Blog

  • “The Lady of the Lake” Review

    3-star rating

    “The Lady of the Lake” is Sir Walter Scott’s epic poetic tale of two, or possibly three, men who seek the hand of Ellen Douglas, the beautiful daughter of a Scottish nobleman (?). She lives with her father and retainers on a remote island on Loch Katrine, a lake in southwestern Scotland. One of the men, Malcolm Graeme, has been wooing her for a while; the second, James Fitz-James, is presented as a hunter who discovers Ellen and the isle after getting lost while chasing a deer; and the possible third suitor, Roderick Dhu, is the chief of a rebellious Scottish clan.

    Conflict ensues between the men, of course, while at the same time Dhu is making trouble for the English king at Stirling Castle, not far away. The end of the tale is more or less happy (depending on your point of view), with the rebellious clan defeated, the hunter’s true identity revealed, and the long-time suitor winning the fair maiden’s hand.

    I’m not used to reading long-form poetry. The combination of the sing-songy iambic quadrameter of the rhyming paired couplets that make up most of the poem, the turns of phrase needed to make the words fit into the lines, and the archaic and foreign terms, made the story hard for me to follow. For that reason, it’s hard for me to give a fair or complete evaluation of the poem, which is one of Scott’s most popular.

    On top of that, my copy is a 1915 book for students. (That explains the odd cover image above.) The pages are fragile, the binding failing, and many pages at the end, containing explanatory notes and instructions for those students, are missing. I’m not even sure which side of my family originally owned the book. There’s no student name written inside it—although whoever had it certainly scribbled all over many of the pages—and it was printed the year my late mother was born. Perhaps if I’d had a more complete edition that was in better shape, I would have been able to concentrate more on the story.

    “The Lady of the Lake” is considered a classic, so if long-form poetry written in the 1800s is your thing, I suppose this is one you have to check out.

  • “Seven Arrows” Review

    4.5 star rating
    Seven Arrows book cover

    Hyemeyohsts Storm’s 1972 book Seven Arrows is a very unusual work, a cross between historical fiction and an exegesis of the religious beliefs of the Native American people we now think of as being the tribes of the northern high plains of the United States, specifically the Cheyenne, the Sioux, and the Crow. Storm takes pains at the beginning to provide the names these tribes used for themselves: the Painted Arrow, the Brother People, and the Little Black Eagle. (These names may not be in the same order as the first list.) The only book in my experience that similarly combines a historical record with religious philosophy is the Judeo-Christian Bible. However, Seven Arrows weaves the two together, while the Bible’s historical parts are largely in the Old Testament.

    Seven Arrows begins with a series of short pieces which introduce the reader to essential religious concepts: the Medicine Wheel, the Circle, and the Seven Arrows. “Medicine,” in the usage of the Native peoples, means far more than the limited way it’s used among whitepeople, as Storm calls those of European descent. I admit I have not even begun to really grasp the full depth and meaning of the term.

    The circle is a fundamental symbolic figure, also endowed with many deep and varied meanings. The seven arrows point to the four cardinal directions, up, down, and to the individual. The cardinal directions in particular have special and specific religious meanings and associated colors and animals: North—wisdom, white, buffalo; East—illumination, yellow, eagle; South—innocence, green, mouse; and West—introspection, black, and bear. Taken together, these form the philosophical core of these peoples’ beliefs, but to say that only scratches the surface.

    The bulk of the book tells the stories of people of these tribes as they deal with the encroachment of whitepeople, told from the perspective of the Native people themselves. Storm could have taken a polemical approach, especially given when the book was written. Instead he tells the story simply, revealing the conflicts within and among the tribes as they try to understand and deal with this new, powerful, and technologically superior force, which has so upset their previous way of life. Some argue for sticking to their peaceful ways, the Way of the Medicine Wheel and the Sun Dance, while others argue that force must be met by force.

    Storm employs a clever technique when describing conversations between his people and whitemen. It’s the whites whose speech is represented in pidgin dialect, which from the Native point of view, makes sense. It’s the whitemen who are speaking the natives’ languages incorrectly, when they do, and the dialect reflects how the Natives hear what the whites are saying. To take one example, “Jesus” is written as “Geessis.”

    Storm uses the concept of Teachings to introduce the religious elements of the book. While these three tribes spoke different languages, they shared a common sign language, so many times Storm’s protagonist of the moment or teacher will tell a story to other characters by signing it. These stories are always parables, and Storm capitalizes important Words to indicate to the Reader that they have special Meaning, beyond not only what appears on the Surface of the Story but across the Peoples’ entire religion and Teachings. This technique allows him to introduce the philosophical elements of the story without creating jarring interruptions.

    The book is lavishly illustrated, with over a hundred archival black-and-white photographs of the Native people and of the animals that are important at each moment of the story. It also includes well over a dozen color illustrations of various shields. These circular objects were hung on the outside of a family’s lodge and served to identify the residents. They also had deep philosophical meaning, as they represented the man’s “true” name, the one he had learned during his “Spirit Walk,” a kind of solo coming-of-age exploration each boy (and perhaps girl) went on as they approached adulthood. The cynic in me says these photographs and illustrations were publisher Ballantine’s way to pad the length of the book, but they do integrate with the story, so this interpretation may be both wrong and unfair.

    The book ends awkwardly, without truly finishing. That’s fitting, as the story of the Native people and the whitemen is unfinished too. In the final scene, the last protagonist, Green Fire Mouse, now an old man, is taking his grandchildren fishing. He and they now speak English, and he drives a pick-up truck. The children are being taught Christianity, which Green Fire Mouse has not adopted. But he seems to have accommodated himself to his new reality. Accommodated himself, nothing more.

    I originally purchased this book as one of several that were going to be texts for a Native American Literature class. The class was cancelled due to lack of interest—a sad irony given that it was at a university in Oklahoma—but I’m glad I decided to keep the book. Seven Arrows provides a fascinating look inside a culture which is, to the whiteman, foreign, even while being all around us. It is religious without being heavy-handed, and the Teachings often only hint at the deeper meanings they hold under their surfaces.

    Highly recommended.

  • Critique Technique Table of Contents

    Here’s a Table of Contents of all of the Critique Technique posts to make it easier to go directly to the post you want to read.

    Introductory Posts

    Part 1: Critique, Technique, and Procedure

    Part 1A: The Critiquer’s Mind

    Part 1B: Life on the Other Side of the Critique

    Part 2: Series Overview

    Reader Response

    Part 3: How Do You Feel?

    Part 3.5: Authorial Intentions and Tracking Your Own Responses

    Beginnings and Endings

    Part 5: Weak or Missing Hook

    Part 6: The Wrong Beginning

    Part 7: Scene and Chapter Endings

    Part 8: Story Endings

    Characterization

    Part 9: Characters and Conflict

    Part 10: Poor Characterization

    Part 11: Lack of Character Development

    Part 12: Showing and Telling in Character Development

    Part 13: Timing the Reveal

    Part 14: Out-of-Character Behavior

    Part 15: Unclear Character Goals

    Part 16: Unclear or Insufficient Obstacles

    Part 17: Dialect, Foreign Languages, and Jargon

    Setting

    Part 18: Lost In Space

    Part 19: Vague Setting

    Part 20: Too Much Setting Detail

    Plot

    Part 21: Unclear Plot

    Part 22: Overly Complex Plot

    Part 23: Confused Storyline

    Flashbacks, Flash-Forwards, and Backstory

    Part 24: Unclear Transitions

    Part 25: Misused Backstory or Flashback

    Part 26: Tangents

    Narrative and Dialogue

    Part 23.5: Read-Out-Loud Tools

    Part 27: Narrative and Dialogue

    Part 28: Awkward Dialog

    Part 29: Writers’ Tics

    Part 30: Too Many Words, or Too Few

    Part 31: The Wrong Words

    Part 32: %*@!$#^!!!! (Swearing)

    Part 33: Contradictions

    Part 34: Imbalance Between Narrative and Dialogue

    Part 35: Name-Calling

    Part 36: As You Know, Bob

    Pace

    Part 37: The Pieces of Pace

    Part 38: Pace: Speed It Up, Whoa It Up, or Change It Up

    Description

    Part 39: The Gray Haze

    Part 40: What Was That Again?

    Part 41: The Dreaded Expository Lump

    Part 42: Too Many Notes

    Part 43: Telling, Not Showing

    General Story-Telling Problems

    Part 44: Pop Goes the Reader!

    Part 45: No Story Arc

    Part 46: Padding

    Part 47: Danglers

    Part 48: Stating the Obvious

    Part 49: Point of View Shifts

    Mechanical Errors

    Part 50: Spelling

    Part 51: Punctuation

    Part 52: Capitalization

    Part 53: Grammar Errors

    Part 54: Manuscript Format

    Positive Reinforcement

    Part 55: Good Job!

    Part 56: Great Start!

    Part 57: Magic Middles

    Part 58: Ending a Scene or Chapter Well

    Other Topics

    Part 59: The End

    Bonus Material: Read-Out-Loud Tools and Techniques

  • Critique Technique, Part 52 — Capitalization

    A twisted, two-ended red pencil
    Image courtesy FreeDigitalPhotos.net.

    Capitalization is another one of those “mechanical” writing areas where I see a lot of problems. New writers aren’t the only ones who struggle with it either.

    Most writers get the very most basic things right: capitalizing the first word of each sentence, the names of people and places, and so on. Word processors’ grammar checkers will often look for capitalization errors, too, if that functionality is turned on, and there are online tools like Grammarly and web sites where writers can check the rules. A few are the Catalyst capitalization page from McGraw-Hill Higher Education, Grammarly’s blog page on the topic, and “A Little Help with Capitals” from Purdue University’s Online Writing Lab.

    Fiction Flubs

    These resources all do at least a good job with helping to clarify what words should or should not be capitalized but mostly for non-fiction, memoir, or academic writing. What about in fiction? I’ve noticed a couple of trends among the writers I’ve worked with.

    Capitalizing for Emphasis

    Novice writers often engage in “shouting,” that is, using ALL CAPITALS when they want to show that a character is experiencing HIGH EMOTION, especially in their EXCLAMATIONS!!!!!! This technique has a number of problems.

    First, it’s hard to read, especially of the author uses it for a long statement—when a character really is shouting. Second, it’s non-standard. Most fiction writers use italics instead. Third, too often it’s paired with multiple exclamation points, the way I did above. Using all caps this way shows that the writer doesn’t trust the reader to understand, from the words themselves and from the context, that this is a moment of high emotion, or that they don’t trust themselves to convey that emotional content to the reader.

    Sometimes a writer will just capitalize the first letter of words they want to emphasize. I’ve seen this more often among my military friends who’ve served in Germany. Nouns are capitalized in German, so some of my Friends have decided to import this Technique into their Writing. That looks odd to English Speakers and Writers, so rather than emphasizing the Words, they distract the Reader from whatever Point the Author was trying to make.

    Names of Non-Human (Sentient) Species

    Science fiction, fantasy, horror, and even religious fiction can feature non-human characters, or what are sometimes called trans-human or post-human ones. How should an author deal with orcs, elves, goblins, angels, or vampires, not to mention Ewoks, Hutts, Klingons, Tribbles, and Romulans? After all, just in that sentence, the first five species’ names are not capitalized, while the last five are.

    A grammar guide for college students I have recommends not capitalizing a description of an ethnic group or race when it’s used as an adjective, but capitalizing the term when it’s a more formal name for that same group or race. Unfortunately, that doesn’t work well for my list above. If the name of a race or species is tied to the name of its home, whether that’s a planet, country, or region (for example, Romulans from the planet Romulus), and that location name would be capitalized, then capitalizing the species name makes sense.

    Similarly, if the word is a generic identifier, such as orc, then leaving the word in lower case makes sense. However, if the word is used in a specific sense, such as “Grbash the Orc,” or in a species title such as “the Orcs,” then the species name likely should be capitalized.

    In my own books, I have trans- or post-human species I call New People and Gen2s (for second generation New People). While some of the members of my critique group have complained that having these terms capitalized is awkward, I’ve argued that for clarity’s sake, if nothing else, the terms New People or New Person need to be capitalized to distinguish a member of the New Person class from any new person who just shows up in the story.

    Clarity and consistency, especially with regard to the conventions of the genre, are the best guides here.

    Questions for You

    If you find that an author is misusing capital letters, or using them inconsistently, here are some questions you can ask yourself.

    • Is the author using all capitals for emphasis, when she should be using italics?
      • Does she need to be doing anything at all to the printed text, or are the words themselves and their context enough to show that emotion?
    • Is he capitalizing words, like ordinary nouns, that are not typically capitalized in English?
    • Is the author consistent in how she capitalizes her references to non-human sentient species? Is she following the conventions of her genre?

    If you find any of these kinds of capitalization errors, or others, be sure not only to mark them in the text but to discuss the correct form with the author.

    Very few writers will take the path of e. e. cummings and avoid capital letters altogether. That means that Capitalization errors are likely to Crop Up from time to Time. Even if a reader can’t identify exactly why they’re having trouble with a piece, they’ll know Something Is Wrong. Our job as reviewers is to help our authors keep their readers reading without stumbling.

    Do you have any special techniques for spotting capitalization errors? Be a capitol fellow or lady and offer your suggestions in the comments box below.

  • “The Big Schnitzel” Review

    3-star rating

    The Big Schnitzel is the final installment of Steve Smith’s 3-part autobiography of his 22 months “in” the U.S. Army in the late 1950s. I put that first “in” in quotes because, as I’ve noted in my reviews of the first two books, while Smith was in the Army, he was never really a part of it, a reality he wore with more than a little pride.

    But Book 3 is lacking something that Book 1 (Single Striper) and Book 2 (Close Enough for Jazz) had. That something is conflict, specifically conflict that involves Smith.

    Let’s step back for a minute. In Book 1, Smith resists and avoids the Army’s best efforts to turn him into a soldier and then into a radio operator. He and his fellow junior enlistees then face and largely frustrate petty tyrant Staff Sergeant Billie C. Bracie. In Book 2, having escaped Bracie, Smith joins the Kitzingen Area Band (the KAB), known around their home base of Flak Kaserne as “the f***ing band” for their lackadaisical attitude and avoidance of most soldierly duties.

    In Book 3, though, when Smith’s self-admitted wanderlust strikes again and he leaves the band to become a pitcher for the Kitzingen Red Sox baseball team, the fight against the machine of Army bureaucracy evaporates. Military sports activities, particularly in the Army in Europe, was a big deal from the 1950s through my tours in Germany in the 1980s and 1990s. Soldiers, at least in Smith’s time, were relieved of their other duties during their sport’s season to play what amounted to semi-pro baseball, basketball, or football. Sports teams weren’t just tolerated by Service leadership, they were actively supported.

    So instead of first-hand stories of Smith and his mates thumbing their noses at Army structures and strictures, Smith mostly retells second-hand stories of his former band partners, or in one occasion, a baseball teammate who’s kicked off the team after beating up a couple of Military Policemen. The worst potential trouble Smith and his buddies get into is breaking into the basement storage room for the military kitchen next door to steal food.

    Otherwise, we’re given a chapter on the various ways to throw a fastball, backstory of Smith’s pre-Army days when he tried out with various professional baseball clubs and played for west Texas semi-pro teams, and tales of the sexual exploits of some his current teammates.

    A particularly ugly chapter has to do with the philosophizing of that cop-beater, who cherry-picks quotes from Friedrich Nietzsche to disparage the German citizens Smith and the others only interact with in bars and brothels. The wounds of WWII were still raw in the late 1950s, but that’s no excuse for the Ugly Americanism this soldier displays. Smith doesn’t sugar-coat or cover for his ex-teammate, whose opinions we can see in the attitudes of some Americans toward foreigners in our own lands today.

    As an excellent contrast, Smith introduces us to his girlfriend’s/fiancée’s/wife’s Danish family, and a nicer group of people you would not want to meet. This material is a much-needed tonic to the attitudes Smith sees in the soldiers around him.

    At the end of the book, Smith has returned home to El Paso, married (although his wife is still in Denmark with her family) and even a bit more mature than when he left home, preparing for a last-chance series of try-outs with major league baseball teams.

    I have a couple of other quibbles with the book. The titles for Books 1 and 2 had clear connections to their stories: Smith was indeed a “single-striper” (a Private, whose rank insignia was a single chevron) in Book 1; “close enough for jazz” was a quote from one of his bandmates in Book 2. But who or what was “the big schnitzel” in Book 3? The best explanation I can come up with was that because Smith was one of the ace pitchers on his team, instead of being their “big cheese,” he turned the description into “the big schnitzel.”

    Second, the book’s subtitle, “Outflanking the Corps with the Coffee Call Commandos of the KAB” has little or nothing to do with the book. Smith himself never returns to the band, mustering out of the Army right after the baseball season ends, and only parts of the book deal with his ex-bandmates’ exploits.

    In the end, The Big Schnitzel was a disappointment for me. While easy to read, as Smith’s other books have been, it lacked the spark of the first two in the series. Soldiers of that era, or of any since, are less likely to find a connection to their own experiences in this book because so few of them had the opportunity to leave the Army behind in a way, while still drawing an Army paycheck for the privilege of playing a sport. This isn’t anyone’s fault—certainly not the author’s. It’s simply a reflection of the story this one sort-of-soldier had to tell of his time in the Service, but not of it.

  • Russka Review

    3.5 star rating

    I have mixed feelings about this book. Certainly, Edward Rutherfurd’s 760 page doorstop of a novel has its good points, but ultimately I came away unsatisfied.

    “Ambitious” is a good way to describe the effort. After all, in order to tell “The Novel of Russia,” as the book is subtitled, Rutherfurd chose to cover the period from 180 A.D. to 1990. To make this Michener-esque task manageable, he follows generations of the Bobrov family (and a few others) through each major historical period of this vast country. Of course, that means that he also ends up with a vast, Game of Thrones-size cast. Generally, he handles this well: the major characters are all well developed and distinctive, which is no small task. More on the characters later.

    The book starts slowly, and by the end of the first chapter, about a small village located at the edge of the Russian steppe, and the future site of one of two towns named Russka, I almost put the book down. I simply wasn’t interested in the characters or their subsistence farming life. The quality of the writing was just good enough for me to be willing to continue.

    For the next several chapters, Rutherfurd follows the development of Russia through the eras of the fall of the Roman Empire, the Holy Roman Empire, and the rise of Constantinople and the Orthodox Church. He clearly did a lot of research on these eras, and wants to make sure readers see the full result of all of it. I could have done with less. Ivan the Terrible and Peter the Great, who was just as terrible as Ivan in his own ways, get their turns on stage.

    When the book reaches the reign of Catherine the Great, Rutherfurd’s focus shifts from the historical to the personal. Alexander Bobrov, the protagonist at this time, is fairly well-to-do but very ambitious. He has his eyes set on becoming the latest of Catherine’s string of lovers. Unfortunately for him, through a combination of bad luck and insufficient ability, he never achieves his ambitions, and in fact ends up worse off than he was when he started. In this regard, Alexander Bobrov, and indeed the entire Bobrov clan, represent all of Russia: ambitious but never quite competent.

    And that, it seems to me, is the theme for the entire book. Russia, Rutherfurd seems to be saying, is too big to govern, too big to succeed, too religious, too stubbornly backward (he and his characters repeatedly refer to the country as medieval), too inertia-bound, and too ignorant to ever reach its potential. Even as successive governments try to achieve something resembling democracy in the later chapters (covering the late 1800s and early 1900s), they fail every time, largely through incompetence and their inability to overcome inertia. One could even argue that the Bolshevik Revolution—the only one of at least half a dozen attempted revolutions Russia experienced over the centuries—did not succeed. While it was the first to actually change the government and take over the country, it just imposed the same kind of authoritarian rule the country had long been used to, only under a different name. And since the fall of the Soviet Union, not much has really changed except that, once again, the Russian Empire has shrunk.

    I don’t know whether Rutherfurd’s assessment of Russia is one based on the work of many historians, or whether it’s his own view, based on his upbringing in England and life in the United States. I’m no Russophile, but the assessment is harsh, even if it might be accurate. History, after all, always has a political component.

    Finally, the book ends with an epilogue set in 1990, in which the last of the Bobrovs, now an American citizen, returns to Russia and to the northern of the two towns named Russka, where his family had lived for so long. His guide is the scion of the Romanov family, who’d been serfs, and angry ones at that, at the time of the revolution. The meeting seemed contrived, an attempt, perhaps, to provide a sort-of happy ending to what had been, in the classical sense, a tragedy.

    If you like long, historical fiction works, you may find this book appealing. I don’t normally read historical fiction, so the fact that I kept going through all 760 pages speaks well about the quality of Rutherfurd’s writing, but I doubt I will seek out any of his other books.

  • “Close Enough for Jazz” Review

    4 star rating
    "Close Enough for Jazz" cover

    When last we left our hero, author Steve Smith, he had just escaped the fell clutches of a tyrannical Staff Sergeant for the idyllic life of a trumpeter in the Kitzingen Area Band.

    And at first, life was indeed idyllic. The band was, in a word, untouchable. No morning PT (physical training), no onerous details, no inspections. All the band members had to do was practice and play, welcoming the 5th Artillery Division’s Commanding General when he arrived on post each morning, conducting a “rouser march” to get the other soldiers’ day going, and playing gigs off post to keep up good relations with the local community.

    The band had been formed at the General’s insistence, and one of the junior members of the band had grown up next door to then-President Dwight D. Eisenhower’s farm. That caused more than a little excitement at Flak Kaserne when a card from the White House arrived, congratulating the band member on his latest birthday.

    Life was good. Until it wasn’t.

    Like in any military organization, long-time members depart when their tours of duty are up, and new ones come in. The band, being a small unit, was more susceptible than most to the changes in personality those departures and arrivals bring. As the original band members departed without being replaced right away, the band’s performance suffered. After one particularly poor unit parade, the General threatened to disband the band.

    Horrors! Smith and the others might have to return to being actual soldiers! That would never do, yet the band’s “leader,” a Master Sergeant, froze up. It fell to Smith and his fellow junior bandsmen to light a fire under him and bring in new people. The band survived—barely.

    Life went on. Not as idyllic as before, but Smith and the band remained in the Army, but not of it. Even the advent of an Inspector General (IG) visit, did little to change the routine, other than generate the usual panic of cleaning everything in sight, and even things that were out of sight. This thrashing about ended in frustration, as it so often did, when the only time a member of the IG team visited the band’s building, he discovered the unit he was looking for was next door.

    As the book winds down, Smith and some friends take a vacation trip to Copenhagen, Denmark. During the visit, Smith meets a winsome lass and love blooms. Birthe eventually leaves home, work, and family to be close to the author in Bavaria. There is sure to be more to this story in the final book of the trilogy.

    As we reach the end, Smith once again abandons friends and colleagues for grass that appears greener, this time literally so. An opportunity comes along for him to pitch for the Kitzingen Red Socks [sic], an intramural team. Intramural sports have long been a staple of military life, a way for soldiers to blow off steam and keep a competitive attitude. Before he joined the Army, Smith had had a tryout with a professional team, so the chance to get back on the mound was something he couldn’t pass up. Life as a bandsman had lost its luster, apparently, and the green grass of the baseball field beckoned.

    As with Single Striper, the first book of the series, Close Enough for Jazz reads easily, something I should have noted in my previous review. Smith’s penchant for the fancy word remains, but while it’s never a good idea to require the reader to keep a dictionary handy, the tendency does not hurt the pace or flow of the story. The detailed notes he took at the time bring the settings and stories alive. The tension between the draftees like Smith and the “lifers” remains, augmented by the tension between the band and the “real” Army all around them. This tension gives the book much of its forward motion, driving many of the actions of the junior bandsmen.

    As he did with Single Striper, Smith captures a unique look at a special corner of the peacetime Army of the late 1950s. The target market for this book will be small (and getting smaller by the day, sadly) but veterans of that era, and many others will find Close Enough for Jazz an enjoyable read.

  • “The Everything Screenwriting Book” Review

    Of all the books out there on screenwriting, this on one not to waste your money on.

    Because it was published in 2003, it contains a lot of unavoidable “errors.” For example, author Robert Pollock could not have foreseen the death of the video rental store or the rise of video streaming or social media. We can forgive and ignore these and other things and move on to the more serious problems with the book.

    First, it’s easy to wonder why Pollock was hired to write the book in the first place. He has only one screenplay that was turned into a movie to his credit, a generally panned 1981 film called “Loophole.” At the time the book was written, he was a professor at a community college in Connecticut, and while he “had connections” with the Hollywood film industry, they do not appear to have been deep. (In a made-for-Hollywood irony, the book was published eight days after the author’s death.)

    Second, Pollock alternately plays to the novice screenwriter’s dream of writing the surprise blockbuster script and then turns around and tells that novice how many scripts fail to even get a serious reading. The latter fact is likely still true today, so it’s disingenuous at best to then continually dangle the ideas of the big-dollar contract the novice dreams and of having big-name stars headline his or her movie when so few achieve those dreams.

    Third, many of Pollock’s references to movies and directors were dated even when the book came out, going back as far as the 1940s and 1950s, while he barely mentions those from the 1990s and early 2000s. It seems that he was less familiar with the more recent films and directors than those of his youth.

    Fourth, the advice the author gives the reader is often so vague and generic—write a good script, make sure there’s plenty of tension in it, get to know people in Hollywood—that it’s useless. He even encourages the reader to write in the active voice, but most of his own writing is passive and stiff: “one should…,” “it is recommended that….” At other times, Pollock seems to assume the reader knows as much about a topic as he does, which also means leaving out key information.

    Finally—and this may not have been Pollock’s fault—the book contains intrusive little pull-quotes throughout, with headings like “Alert!” or “Essential” or “Fact.” By themselves, these would not have been a problem, and if done well, could have been quite useful. But instead, they seem to have been inserted at random. They often had little to do with the text they were inserted into, and by placing them in the middle of a titled section, they disrupted the flow of the text with their irrelevancy. I suspect this was a characteristic style of the hundreds of books in the “Everything…” series (I’ve seen things like it in other books for novices) but it was so badly done that many times it tempted me to throw the book across the room in frustration.

    Bottom line: don’t waste your money. (I’m glad I got this book for free from a friend. And I know now why he was getting rid of it.)