Blog

  • Critique Technique Table of Contents

    Here’s a Table of Contents of all of the Critique Technique posts to make it easier to go directly to the post you want to read.

    Introductory Posts

    Part 1: Critique, Technique, and Procedure

    Part 1A: The Critiquer’s Mind

    Part 1B: Life on the Other Side of the Critique

    Part 2: Series Overview

    Reader Response

    Part 3: How Do You Feel?

    Part 3.5: Authorial Intentions and Tracking Your Own Responses

    Beginnings and Endings

    Part 5: Weak or Missing Hook

    Part 6: The Wrong Beginning

    Part 7: Scene and Chapter Endings

    Part 8: Story Endings

    Characterization

    Part 9: Characters and Conflict

    Part 10: Poor Characterization

    Part 11: Lack of Character Development

    Part 12: Showing and Telling in Character Development

    Part 13: Timing the Reveal

    Part 14: Out-of-Character Behavior

    Part 15: Unclear Character Goals

    Part 16: Unclear or Insufficient Obstacles

    Part 17: Dialect, Foreign Languages, and Jargon

    Setting

    Part 18: Lost In Space

    Part 19: Vague Setting

    Part 20: Too Much Setting Detail

    Plot

    Part 21: Unclear Plot

    Part 22: Overly Complex Plot

    Part 23: Confused Storyline

    Flashbacks, Flash-Forwards, and Backstory

    Part 24: Unclear Transitions

    Part 25: Misused Backstory or Flashback

    Part 26: Tangents

    Narrative and Dialogue

    Part 23.5: Read-Out-Loud Tools

    Part 27: Narrative and Dialogue

    Part 28: Awkward Dialog

    Part 29: Writers’ Tics

    Part 30: Too Many Words, or Too Few

    Part 31: The Wrong Words

    Part 32: %*@!$#^!!!! (Swearing)

    Part 33: Contradictions

    Part 34: Imbalance Between Narrative and Dialogue

    Part 35: Name-Calling

    Part 36: As You Know, Bob

    Pace

    Part 37: The Pieces of Pace

    Part 38: Pace: Speed It Up, Whoa It Up, or Change It Up

    Description

    Part 39: The Gray Haze

    Part 40: What Was That Again?

    Part 41: The Dreaded Expository Lump

    Part 42: Too Many Notes

    Part 43: Telling, Not Showing

    General Story-Telling Problems

    Part 44: Pop Goes the Reader!

    Part 45: No Story Arc

    Part 46: Padding

    Part 47: Danglers

    Part 48: Stating the Obvious

    Part 49: Point of View Shifts

    Mechanical Errors

    Part 50: Spelling

    Part 51: Punctuation

    Part 52: Capitalization

    Part 53: Grammar Errors

    Part 54: Manuscript Format

    Positive Reinforcement

    Part 55: Good Job!

    Part 56: Great Start!

    Part 57: Magic Middles

    Part 58: Ending a Scene or Chapter Well

    Other Topics

    Part 59: The End

    Bonus Material: Read-Out-Loud Tools and Techniques

  • Published!

    The cover image for The Eternity PlagueI am thrilled to announce that The Eternity Plague has been published! Here’s the blurb:

    In 2035, Dr. Janet Hogan makes a stunning discovery: infected by five species of naturally-mutated viruses, every one of earth’s nine billion inhabitants has become immortal.

    Or have they? By the time Janet learns that this immortality is an illusion, it’s too late to change people’s beliefs. Some love her for creating this miracle and the coming paradise they long for. Others hate her for what they see ahead: immoral behavior without consequence, overpopulation, famine, and worse. Zealots demand that she save people’s souls, humanity, the earth… or the viruses. Or else.

    Janet realizes this awful truth: no matter what she does, no matter what anyone else wants, sooner or later, billions will die and she’ll be blamed. Will she live long enough to figure a way out of this trap?

    Meanwhile, the viruses are still mutating.

    The paperback version is available from Amazon.com here for $12.99.

    The ebook is available for $3.99 from these sources:

    I’ll add links to more outlets as the book becomes available there. I expect that these will include the Apple iBook Store, Barnes & Noble (for the Nook), Kobo, Oyster Books (subscription service), and Scribd (subscription service).

     

     

  • “Dragon Plus +” Review

    5-star rating

    Tucson, Arizona, fantasy artist Jessica Feinberg’s little “guide to hybrid creatures” is a visual delight. Each of the over five dozen beings—mostly hybrids of dragons with one or more other life forms—is beautifully and dramatically rendered in vibrant watercolors. OK, maybe the illustrations don’t quite live up to the standards of a John James Audubon, but I doubt that was ever the artist’s intent!

    And I don’t care.

    Each painting is accompanied by a brief note on the creature’s composition, history, habitat, preferred diet, size, and level of danger to curious humans. Good things to know, should you wish to have one as a pet—or avoid them. The habitat information is especially valuable since, while some live in the usual locations—remote caves, deserts, or forests—and some in deep lakes, rivers, or seas, some hang out in more accessible locations. One is particularly dangerous to readers. The Library Sphinx, lurks in—you guessed it—libraries, although fortunately only in occult and mystical ones. Your favorite public library is probably sphinx-free (but be careful in the rare books section).

    Who knew there were so many such hybrids? We can thank Feinberg for revealing them. A must-read for any would-be dragon-rider or -hunter.

  • “Elements of Critique” Review

    3.5 star rating

    (cover image)

    It’s important to understand what David Williamson’s short book is and what it is not. It is not, and readers should not expect it to be, a complete or exhaustive guide to how to effectively critique another writer’s work. It’s clear Williamson never intended it to be that.

    Instead, the book is a collection of 26 slightly revised blog posts, plus three additional articles, that provide brief discussions of some critique topics and techniques. Because the original posts—running in alphabetical order from “Appearance” to “Zaftig”—were short, Williamson could only scratch the surface, touching on a few topics each time.

    In general, he does a reasonable job with the space he has available. There are a few places where his suggestions miss the mark, however. In his chapter on point of view, he seems to be OK with head-hopping, that is, shifting from one point of view character to another within a scene or chapter without any sort of break, like a scene break. This goes against the general guidance for writers that there should be only one viewpoint character per scene.

    In his chapter on verb tenses, he fails to address transitions into and out of flashbacks, where the verb tense must naturally shift.

    Finally, in several chapters, Williamson inserts elements of his faith. This is inappropriate in a book that has nothing to do with religion or faith.

    These problems pull what would have been a 4-star rating for its target audience down a half star (although most places where this review will be posted don’t allow half-star ratings).

    Elements of Critique can serve as a basic introduction to critiquing for a writer who’s just getting started at it, but it is not appropriate for a more experienced critiquer.

  • “The Crucible of Time” Review

    2-star rating

    Give John Brunner credit for trying to do something hard: tell the story of an alien species living on a hostile world as they evolve from near-primitives to space travelers. To do that, Brunner had to create the aliens, their world, its solar and stellar environments, and then put all that into a story spanning thousands of years. In less than 400 pages.

    No easy feat. I wish he’d succeeded.

    His solution to the span-of-years problem was clever enough: write seven 10-chapter novellas, each focusing on the creatures at some point in their scientific and cultural development. Then hit them with a catastrophe of some sort to wrap up that novella and jump ahead hundreds or thousands of years to when the species had mostly recovered. Unfortunately, as the book progressed, those catastrophes became more and more strained, as if Brunner was struggling to come up with the kinds of challenges that would move the story and the species forward.

    The Crucible of Time has so many other flaws that this problem became almost insignificant. For starters, we never got a complete description of what these creatures looked like or what they called themselves. We learned they had a single eye, claws instead of hands, mandibles instead of lips, a mantle of some kind, and a number of legs that wasn’t defined until near the end of the book. In addition, they walked around using some kind of internal hydraulic system in “tubules” instead of muscles. Infants “budded” off of their mother, rather than gestating some other way. They used scents to communicate emotions. And for some, never-explained reason, they used a base-20 counting system. Alien, all right, but hard to picture.

    Even that might not have been so bad had Brunner not resorted to the most awkward and heavy-handed ways of showing how “alien” their language was. He often replaced a single letter in an English word with another letter: shark became sharq, bark and junk (both kinds of boat) became barq and junq, spider became spuder, fungus became funqus, and so on. Colloquial English phrases also got “alienized”: “on the other hand” became “on the other claw,” “knew in her heart” became “knew in her pith,” and so on.

    Writers today are taught to use dialect and specialized terms sparingly, and this book is an object lesson on why. Rather than making these creatures seem alien, the terms call attention to themselves and distract the reader.

    Add to that Brunner’s penchant for long, wordy paragraphs, especially when either the narrator or a character was explaining some particular aspect of the world or their latest scientific advancements, and the book simply became a slog to read. Some of this we might attribute to when the book was written (published in 1982) and where (England) but other British works of the time were far more readable.

    When I first started the book, I thought it was Brunner’s first novel. Imagine my surprise when I learned he’d already been writing and publishing for 30 years when this one came out. That too may help explain its style.

    So call The Crucible of Time a work of good intentions poorly executed. Not a horrible book, but not one readers should spend their time with.

  • ‘The World of M. C. Escher’ Review

    4.5 star rating

    I’ve been fascinated by the work of 20th Century Dutch artist M. C. Escher since I first encountered it in college. His impossible constructions and transformation tilings in particular drew my eye and brain as I tried to figure out how he was able to create them. Somewhere along the way I picked up this book but have only now, years later, gotten around to reading it.

    The essays at the front include one by Escher himself, but the first one, by museum curator J. L. Locher is the most enlightening. It describes how the artist used mathematical principles (without getting deep into the math itself) to structure many of his works, and how he used ambiguous shades of gray to smoothly turn a floor into a wall or a ceiling in a work like “Relativity” or create the closed loop staircase in “Ascending and Descending.”

    If the book falls short anywhere, it’s in the limited attention it gives to Escher’s work in color. Many of his tilings, where he experimented with ways to divide up a flat surface with interlocking figures, were done in watercolor, for example. The book, however, shows only eight works in color, perhaps for cost reasons.

    And while the book reproduces over 250 of his prints, a quick tour through the Escher Foundation web site’s gallery reveals many more.

    The thing about Escher’s art in the latter half of his career is that while it’s mind-bending in so many ways, it’s still approachable. Viewers don’t need seven degrees in art appreciation to be enthralled by the work. While revealing how he did what he did, The World of M. C. Escher only increases that enchantment. Highly recommended.

  • “The Six” Review

    3.5 star rating

    Contrary to author Mark Alpert’s claim in his note at the end of the book, The Six is most definitely science fiction. Its essential premise and technologies are based on the states of science and technology in the mid-2010s, and it relies heavily on projections of the science and tech into the future, making it “hard” SF.

    There are two core story-lines: the ability of doctors to map all of the synaptic connections in a human brain—the “connectome,” although Alpert never uses the term—and artificial intelligence. In this story, technology has advanced enough that it is not only possible to map a person’s connectome, it’s possible to copy it into a vast array of “neuromorphic” computer circuits which, like the brain, can rearrange themselves at will as the computer (or computerized person) learns and experiences new things. That technology is now ready for trial. Unfortunately, the test will kill the person whose brain is scanned and mapped. To get around that major ethical problem, six volunteer teenagers, all suffering from terminal illnesses—mainly cancer or Duchenne muscular dystrophy—are chosen to be the “Pioneers.” If successful, their minds will be recreated inside hulking, 600 pound robots whose shells protect the computer/brain inside.

    At the same time, the father of protagonist Adam Armstrong (no symbolism in that name, is there?) has developed a fully-conscious artificial intelligence. He’s not alone: the Russians are doing it too. Unfortunately (of course), the AI, called “Sigma,” escapes its lab and goes on a rampage against all of humanity, whom it views as its competition. The Pioneers are (of course) the only ones who can defeat Sigma.

    So far, so good. But this is where my reasons for scoring the book down come in. First, Alpert’s use of the technologies involved is heavy-handed. The first several chapters are rife with info-dumps. Then, once the kids’ minds have been successfully transferred into their robots, we’re constantly reminded how long it takes Adam to think a thought, see, analyze, and react to something, etc. Every time he looks at something, we’re reminded that he turns his turret (his head-substitute) and uses his camera eye-replacements to do so. Alpert delivers technical specifications on too many pieces of military hardware (the U.S. Army is, of course, involved), including at one point, the exact designation of a shell being fired at Adam from a Russian tank! Alpert seems intent on not letting any piece of his research go unused.

    Second, Sigma is a one-dimensional villain, intent on nothing but destruction by whatever means is necessary, from torture to nuclear weapons. One can imagine it twirling its electronic mustachios while crying, “Mwaa-haa-haa-haa!” Writing aliens, which a sentient AI would qualify as, is hard enough without resorting to clichés.

    The book is not a total loss, however. Alpert does a good job giving each of the kids a distinct personality and set of motivations. Once we get past the draggy opening chapters, he does a similarly good job of throwing one obstacle or problem after another at the kids, each one worse than the one before. And the pace picks up even more once he starts shifting into the perspective of Shannon, one of the other Pioneers. These positives pull my overall rating up to 3.5 stars, but they’re not enough to raise it to 4 or higher.The Six is by no means a bad book. Science- and tech-loving teens will likely enjoy it and its sequels, The Siege and The Silence.

  • ‘How to Critique Creative Writing’ Review

    2-star rating

    British author Norman Turrell does something difficult for a how-to book: he manages to simultaneously be both too vague to be useful to the would-be critiquer, and too detailed. On the one hand, the “advice” he gives on what a reviewer should look for when critiquing a work is so general the reviewer has nothing to hang his or her critique hat on. Then he suggests the reviewer take so many notes on each read-through of the work that they could end up with more words written than the story or chapter they were reviewing contains. (Those notes being based on the vague guidance he provided.)

    A former mathematician, Turrell recommends the reviewer graph out their impressions, chapter by chapter, for features such as plot, character development, percentage of dialogue contained, and pace: each chapter would get a numerical score based on whatever rating scale the reviewer wanted to give to that feature. His intent is noble—to see how each of these characteristics develops over time—but to be kind, I can only see a few critiquers being willing to apply this technique.

    Finally, Turrell tries another potentially good idea when he applies the topic of each of the very brief analysis chapters to his very first book, Alice in Virtuality. Recognizing that many readers of this critique book will not have read Alice, he encourages them to go purchase a copy, which seems like a pretty cheesy way to generate a few sales. For readers who choose not to buy the book, Turrell’s analyses fall flat because they mean nothing. I ended up skipping most of them. The idea of providing examples was a good one, but the execution left a lot to be desired.

    “Brevity is the soul of wit,” according to Shakespeare’s character Polonius, but this 84 page handbook is too brief to be useful. Not recommended.

  • ‘The Dictionary of Fiction Critique’ Review

    Kate Jonuska’s idea to create a dictionary of critique terms and intermingle them with a bit of discussion seems like a clever technique at first, but the idea quickly loses its luster. First, Jonuska interrupts the flow of the book every time she inserts the definition of a new term and provides an example or two. These interruptions make it very hard to piece together coherent concepts from which a reviewer can build a critique.

    Second, dictionaries are not typically the kind of book one reads in order to try to build a broad understanding of a concept. So between the final third of the book, which is devoted to an A to Z listing of terms, their definitions, and examples, and many of the same terms, definitions, and examples spread through the first two-thirds, maybe a third of the book is devoted to discussions of techniques for providing critique. And as with a standard dictionary, if you don’t know or don’t remember the term you’re trying to get a better understanding of, scrolling through the dictionary, hoping to come across the one you’re looking for is hardly an effective way to learn.

    At times, the author notes that certain concepts are known by several different names. So far, so good, but in the dictionary section, while she does point the reader to the primary term from the secondary one(s), she misses an opportunity to use internal hyperlinks to make the jump to that primary term far easier than scrolling and scrolling and scrolling forward or backward to get to its definition.

    Third, Jonuska spends as much time, if not more, addressing writers as she does reviewers. This is a hard to avoid hazard of any book which means to teach writers how to critique their own or another’s work. Writers have to know the craft in order to be able to meaningfully critique someone’s writing, but a book meant for critiquers needs to address the task of critiquing more clearly and consistently than the author does.

    Finally, the book is rife with spelling and coding errors. Star Wars fans will find it hard to forgive Jonuska’s consistent misspelling of Princess Leia’s name (it’s not Leah). There are also far too many instances—dozens—where the HTML coding for the text of examples is revealed (for example, * <span style=“color: #00000A”>). The failure to catch these errors suggests either simple sloppiness or a rush to publish.

    The book is not completely without merit. I did encounter a few terms and concepts that were new to me, but not enough to overcome the book’s many weaknesses. For an experienced critiquer, this book might have some value when they want to refresh their memory on a particular concept—at least if they use the same terms Jonuska does. But for the new critiquer, this book is going to be far less helpful than it could have been.

    Not recommended.

  • “American Indian Literature, An Anthology” Review

    3.5 star rating

    Alan R. Velie’s 1991 revised edition certainly lives up to it’s anthology subtitle. The book is divided into six sections: Tales, Songs, Oratory, Memoir, Poetry, and Fiction. Each contains what Velie presumably meant to be a representative sampling of these kinds of works.

    A theme that runs through almost all of the works from the Oratory section on is the deep anger, frustration, and heartache of a half-conquered people. Looking beyond the Americas, history is replete with examples of conquering forces invading territories, initially overwhelming the people living there, sometimes quickly, sometimes only after a great struggle, but then never entirely wiping them out and replacing them. (Please note: I am not advocating for this!) What remains is a people struggling to maintain their traditional lives, identities, and ways in the face of ongoing pressure from their conquerors. These struggles can last for centuries, sometimes with the conquered culture finally fading away, sometimes with it returning to power or prominence but vastly changed from what it once was.

    This is the situation American Indian tribes find themselves in the middle of—neither wiped out or assimilated nor able to return to their pre-conquest ways—and the pain of the status is clear in the works Velie chose. For the white reader, that makes for some pretty uncomfortable reading. At the same time, it’s hard not to wonder how much of the stories about life before the white man came are seen through rose-colored glasses, utopian visions of they ways the authors wished life had been, or want readers to believe they were.

    Something else comes through: how little the Indian authors of these works understand white culture, just as so many whites fail to understand the many Indian cultures. A book like this has the potential to help to start bridging that divide, but the authors’ understandable anger and the reader’s likely defensive response to it make the bridge-building difficult.

    Putting together any anthology is unavoidably an exercise in making choices of what to include and what to leave out, but this is where Velie falls down in this reader’s estimation. The tribes of the southern United States, from coast to coast, and of the intermountain west and west coast are almost completely left out. The farthest southwest Velie’s selections come from is Oklahoma. Also, it’s clear that Velie chose poets and novelists he mostly had worked with at the University of Oklahoma and elsewhere and/or knew. This failure to bring in other voices is the reason I’ve taken away a half-star rating where I can.

    A thirty year old book cannot, of course, give any insight into the thinking and writing of Indian authors since its publication, but given the history of those decades, I can’t help but wonder if anything has changed in a meaningful way.

    For the non-Indian reader, and especially for the white reader, this collection gives an insight into the hearts and minds of a people too often ignored and neglected, left in a cultural limbo with no resolution in sight.

  • “The Complete Poems of Emily Dickinson” Review

    4 star rating

    Not long ago I read The Portable Walt Whitman, an edited but complete collection of Whitman’s poetry, fiction, and accounts of his time in Washington, D.C., during the Civil War. What a contrast between him and his contemporary, Dickinson! Where Whitman is voluble, open (perhaps to extremes), and accessible, Dickinson is brief (a few poems are only two lines long), often cryptic, and many times difficult to parse.

    Reading the entire collection of all 1775 poems, plus variations, cover to cover is a task only for the determined. Or the patient. Even at a pace of 25 poems a day, it still took me over two months to get through them all, and “get through” is the right term. At that pace, there’s no real opportunity to try to get far under the surface of many of these poems, but frankly there was only so much of that brain work I was willing to do.

    Reading the entire collection does, however, offer some insights or perceptions a more selective reading would miss. The first is the perception all she wrote about was death is incorrect. Certainly, death, the afterlife, and immortality make up one general category of her work, and a substantial one, but there are at least three others: love, especially lost love; nature and the natural world; and faith and religion.

    Dickinson’s nature poems are her most accessible, at least for this reader. She evidently spent a lot of time in the fields and farms around her home and at the sea shore, in all seasons and all times of the day. Sunrises and sunsets, birds and insects, especially bees, and the characteristics of the seasons and the transitions between them all earn her attention. Like Whitman, she often celebrates these topics.

    While most of her religious poems stay within the canon of Christianity, her faith was sometimes subject to doubt, and those doubts also found expression in her work. For some reason I found this surprising, although I suspect most Christians would not.

    I need to tie her love poems and death poems together. As I read the full body of her work, I got the strong impression there might have been a death of someone close to her, either a female relative, dear friend, or possibly lover that deeply affected her, leaving her to muse about love and loss. I’m not familiar with Dickinson’s biography, so maybe there’s something known about this I’m not aware of. If, however, she had a female lover (or more than one over time), unlike Whitman, any references to them are quite oblique.

    Dickinson’s penchant for using long dashes in place of other punctuation is notorious among students who are required to read her work. It took me some time to train myself to ignore the dashes and let the words and line breaks tell me how to read each poem. Over time, this habit faded and she began using more standard punctuation.

    Editor Thomas H. Johnson assembled this collection into an approximately chronological order based on the year when each poem was thought to have first been written, but every one of these dates is marked “circa.” From poem number 1649 on, a question mark indicates the date couldn’t even be approximately determined.

    For the poetry reader who loves to dig under the surface of a poem to unearth its “true meaning,” a collection like this offers a lifetime of opportunities. For the more casual reader, a smaller collection would certainly be easier to manage. And for the reader who claims they don’t understand poetry, this two inch thick tome is one to stay away from.

  • “Grimm’s Fairy Tales” Review

    4 star rating

    This lavishly illustrated volume, published in 1961 in London, contains only about 50 of the over 200 folktales Jakob and Wilhelm Grimm collected during their lifetimes. It includes, of course, some of the most famous: Cinderella, Hänsel and Grethel (Hansel and Gretel), Rapunzel, Snow-White, and Tom Thumb, among others.

    One of the most interesting aspects of reading these original versions of the stories is how different they are from the Disney-fied versions. Cinderella, for example, had no fairy godmother, no pumpkin-carriage, no clock striking midnight, and no glass slipper, and each of her evil sisters mutilated themselves to try to fit a foot into the shoe she did leave behind.

    Even in their day, some of the Grimms’ stories were so bloody, or included certain topics, that they were not considered suitable for children. None of the stories in this collection go quite that far, but perceptive readers will occasionally notice some “interesting” things going on in the background.

    Many other stories are variations of the theme of the fool or peasant getting the better of the rich man or the king. Often they’re rewarded either with vast riches or the king’s almost-always beautiful daughter and then inherit the kingdom themselves. And of course they live happily ever after, although that phrase never appears in any of the stories in this collection.

    Magic plays a role in some of these stories, but only a few, and fairies, elves, and their kind rarely appear, despite the English name for the collection—the original name was Kinder- und Hausmärchen (Children’s and Household Tales)—and for the title of this book.

    Political correctness was unknown in the Grimms’ day, so some of the stories relate negative stereotypes about residents of certain areas, like the seven Swabians who are so stupid they’re first terrified by a hare, then drown themselves in the Mosel River when they think the first one managed to walk across the bottom because they saw his hat float away. If you’ve never read any of these stories in their original form, this book is a good place to start.