Tag: science

  • Science Education Under Attack—The Problem of Really Large Numbers

    Before I get into today’s post, three updates to last week’s. First, Arizona Governor Doug Ducey has come out publicly in favor of teaching evolution and cosmology, specifically the “Big Bang” theory, which Superintendent of Public Instruction Diane Douglas wants to eliminate, in the public schools. Second, it’s important to note that Superintendent Douglas does not have the last word on this issue, the state Board of Education does, and Douglas is only one member. She does, however, control what is presented to the Board, so this is not entirely good news. Third, the comment period on the proposed science standards revision was supposed to end on Monday, but when word of Douglas’s proposals got out, so many people commented—mostly in opposition, according to news reports—that the system crashed. It’s back up today and the comment period was extended to Friday. And yes, I put in my two cents.

    Too Big to Grasp

    On to today’s topic: big numbers. Really big numbers. I’m not talking tens or hundreds or even thousands. I mean millions and billions and trillions. Numbers like these get thrown around all the time: a $4 trillion US federal budget, the human body is made up of 100 trillion cells, the universe is an estimated 13 billion years old. Problem is, the poor old human brain can’t comprehend these numbers. A hundred years we can grasp. We know of people who have lived that long. A thousand years, or two thousand, maybe. After all, this is the year two-thousand-eighteen. Beyond that, though, if we try to think about these numbers, our minds, like pinball machines played a little too hard, go TILT!

    This has been a known problem since at least Biblical times. “Such knowledge is too wonderful for me; it is high, I cannot attain unto it.” (Psalm 139:6)

    The same is true for really small numbers: millionths and billionths and trillionths of an inch or an ounce, a centimeter or a gram.

    Archbishop James Ussher
    Archbishop Ussher

    It’s easy, then, to see why religiously-inspired concepts like “intelligent design” gain a foothold: they’re simpler, and they don’t ask people to deal with numbers that are incomprehensible. Seventeenth century Anglican Archbishop James Ussher, using numbers where they were available in the Bible (Methuselah lived “900 years”) and assumptions where they were not, calculated that the universe was created on October 23, 4004 BCE, or 6,022 years ago, an almost comprehensible number. (I sometimes wonder why some Biblical literalist hasn’t suggested that October 25th, not April 22nd, should be the “real” Earth Day, since according to Genesis 1:10, it was on the third day of creation that God made the land and the waters.)

    One Two Three… Infinity!

    But back to the really big and really small numbers. Even today, some primitive tribes only have one, two, three, and many for their numbering/counting system. They don’t have ten fingers, they have many. Our hunter-gatherer ancestors didn’t need to know millions, or even hundreds, either. “Many” was good enough for most circumstances. It’s only in the last 200 years or so that millions, millionths, and beyond have become necessary. So while poet Walt Whitman’s mind might have been able to “contain multitudes,” the rest of ours can’t.

    What can be done about this? Universal, quality science education in all schools—public, private, parochial, etc.—is a start. This is where we can start to build the case that really large and really small numbers, though hard or impossible to truly grasp, are nonetheless real and the science that needs to use them is legitimate. These numbers and the concepts using them don’t need to be taken on faith; there’s a logical, comprehensible, step-by-step process that leads to them. It’s even possible to make a case that science and religion are not necessarily and automatically in conflict. I’ll write about that in a later post.

    For adults, scientists need to get out in public more, to communicate more, to show the step-wise development that leads to those very large and very small numbers, to make them a little less intimidating. Very large and very small numbers are not part of the daily lives of most citizens, and generally there’s no reason for them to be. This is why politicians and the press can make big deals out of a few million dollars of waste in a government program. When the total budget for the problem program is in the billions, that number is beyond people’s grasp, but a few million dollars is an average professional athlete’s annual salary, and that’s something the public can relate to. Maybe this is the key: tying those big and small science numbers to ones people are more used to seeing, where possible. It won’t work in every case, but it’s a start.

    Next time I’ll pick up on a concept I hinted at here: simplicity versus complexity.

    Your Thoughts

    What do you think about the big numbers problem? I’d like to see your thoughts in the comments below.

     

  • Science Education Under Attack: Evolution as “Just a Theory”

    Portrait of Charles DarwinArizona Superintendent of Public Instruction Diane Douglas, the state’s top education official, is once again on the attack against teaching evolution in public schools. Douglas has learned that she can’t just delete it from the curriculum, especially in favor of so-called “intelligent design,” because federal courts have ruled that that’s a violation of the U.S. Constitution’s “establishment clause,” which establishes the clear separation between church and state. So she’s trying to do it through the back door, by replacing the word “evolution” with phrases that sound similar to the layman but are not.

    For example, according to a recent Capitol Media Services report, instead of the requirement that students be able to evaluate how inherited traits in a population can lead to evolution, they would now have to evaluate how those traits would lead to “biological diversity,” which says nothing about how the population changes over time in response to changing conditions.

    Similarly, a reference to “the mechanism of biological evolution,” in other words, how evolution happens, would be replaced with “change in genetic composition of a population over successive generations,” which says nothing about how or why such changes occur.

    This is nothing new. Religious conservatives have been trying for a long time to drive these kinds of changes, with the ultimate goal of ending the teaching of evolution, on the grounds that evolution is “just a theory.” This phrase takes advantage of the average citizen’s lack of understanding that the word theory means something different to scientists than it does to the general public. Specifically, to the ordinary citizen, a theory is an idea, a guess, a supposition. It could be right, it could be wrong. To the scientist, however, this is a hypothesis, something to be tested.

    A theory is something far different. Back in 2005, as part of a presentation in one of my Master’s Degree classes, I put together this list of things that a proposal must do in order to be accepted by the scientific community as a theory. It must:

    • Acknowledge and account for its assumptions
    • Be the most accurate and comprehensive explanation of the known facts about its subject
    • Make non-obvious predictions
    • Be testable, and have survived attempts to disprove it
    • Be able to evolve (yes, I chose that word intentionally) to accommodate new facts—or be discarded if it can’t, and
    • Not be accepted merely on the say-so of a single individual or small group.

    There’s one other thing about real scientific theories: they draw on the knowledge generated by other theories. One example: paleontologists can date dinosaurs back to the Cretaceous Era because they use radiocarbon dating technologies to determine how much of a radioactive form of carbon remains in the fossilized bones. The carbon decays to another, non-radioactive form at a set rate, known as its half-life, so how much of the radioactive form there is allows the age of the fossil to be calculated. Radioactivity and half-life are concepts that come from atomic theory. So far, opponents of evolution have not attacked atomic theory and “just a theory,” for which I’m grateful.

    Finally, one could ask why, if evolution is so good, it’s still a theory, not on the highest step of science’s hierarchy, a law? It’s because it has not been proven to be universal—true everywhere, all the time—the way, say, the law of gravitational attraction has been. Until we find life elsewhere in the universe, we won’t be able to test evolution for universality.

    Unfortunately, too few scientists have spoken up to explain these basic requirements in public forums, and as a result, in the minds of too many people, evolution remains “just a theory,” and as such, stands on equal ground with any other such “theory” anyone else might propose, whether it’s based in fact or not.

  • Here Come Da (Science Fair) Judge!

    One of the things I do outside of my writing life is to be a judge at a local science fair. The Youth Engineering and Science (YES) Fair is sponsored by the local electrical co-op and the Armed Forces Communications and Electronics Association, or AFCEA. Each spring, students in grades 5-12, from schools in the co-op’s service area, compete first in fairs at their schools, unless they’re home-schooled, and the top projects come to the YES Fair.

    The judges are all volunteers from the area. Some are active scientists or engineers, some are retirees, and then there are the oddballs like me who have never been a practicing scientist or engineer, but we’re interested in the fields and can talk a good game. (Or as Kristine Kathryn Rusch says, “we play one on TV.”) I’ve been doing this for the last seven or eight years, I guess. Last year was the only one I missed, and that was due to another commitment.

    The YES Fair breaks the students into three grade groups: 5th and 6th, 7th and 8th, and high school. My first year, I judged the 5th and 6th grade projects. The next year I stepped up to 7th and 8th, and since then I’ve judged the high school projects. Some of the projects are amazingly good, even at the lower grade levels. Some of the others? Well, not so much. Some–but not all–of the best ones are projects the students have been working on for years, bringing an updated and expanded version of the previous year’s project back for another go.

    The worst are thrown together at the last minute… and it shows.

    One of the best parts of being a judge is getting to talk with the students. In the morning we just look at the projects, review the workbooks, etc. But in the afternoon, the students are there to discuss what they did, why and how they did it, and what they learned.

    Too often we see, hear, and read stories about out of control, abusive, drug-using kids, and it’s all too easy to project that image onto all of them. Talk to the students at the science fair and you’ll learn that there are some amazing young people out there, capable of doing great things.

    Image courtesy of Chaiwat / FreeDigitalPhotos.net
    Image courtesy of Chaiwat / FreeDigitalPhotos.net

    This year, we had a young lady who did a study of the challenges of building a quantum computer. Another–a freshman!–is in the beginning stages of designing a system that would detect when an infant, pet, or disabled adult has been left alone in a hot or cold car and is in danger. She still has a lot of work to do, as she freely admitted, but the project has so much potential! She wasn’t one of our Grand Prize winners this year, but I wouldn’t be surprised if she is in the future.

    One of our two Grand Prize winners–both of whom will go on to compete in the International Science and Engineering Fair (ISEF) in Phoenix–developed a way to fight fires… with sound! She still has a lot of development work to do to make it practical, but it works already: she had the videos to prove it.

    The other tried to develop a device that would distill water, making it safe to drink, using only focused sunlight and simple, inexpensive materials. His idea is that it could be used in underdeveloped countries where fancy, complicated systems are too expensive and couldn’t be maintained. His project didn’t work well but he has ideas on how to fix it so it will.

    Am I bragging on these kids? Absolutely! Will they go on to win big prizes at ISEF? Probably not. That’s not the point. The point is that we’re keeping them interested in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics, and as a science fiction writer, and as a citizen, I’m all for that. One day they might even read my books… and tell me all the things I got wrong!