Tag: story beginnings

  • Critique Technique Table of Contents

    Here’s a Table of Contents of all of the Critique Technique posts to make it easier to go directly to the post you want to read.

    Introductory Posts

    Part 1: Critique, Technique, and Procedure

    Part 1A: The Critiquer’s Mind

    Part 1B: Life on the Other Side of the Critique

    Part 2: Series Overview

    Reader Response

    Part 3: How Do You Feel?

    Part 3.5: Authorial Intentions and Tracking Your Own Responses

    Beginnings and Endings

    Part 5: Weak or Missing Hook

    Part 6: The Wrong Beginning

    Part 7: Scene and Chapter Endings

    Part 8: Story Endings

    Characterization

    Part 9: Characters and Conflict

    Part 10: Poor Characterization

    Part 11: Lack of Character Development

    Part 12: Showing and Telling in Character Development

    Part 13: Timing the Reveal

    Part 14: Out-of-Character Behavior

    Part 15: Unclear Character Goals

    Part 16: Unclear or Insufficient Obstacles

    Part 17: Dialect, Foreign Languages, and Jargon

    Setting

    Part 18: Lost In Space

    Part 19: Vague Setting

    Part 20: Too Much Setting Detail

    Plot

    Part 21: Unclear Plot

    Part 22: Overly Complex Plot

    Part 23: Confused Storyline

    Flashbacks, Flash-Forwards, and Backstory

    Part 24: Unclear Transitions

    Part 25: Misused Backstory or Flashback

    Part 26: Tangents

    Narrative and Dialogue

    Part 23.5: Read-Out-Loud Tools

    Part 27: Narrative and Dialogue

    Part 28: Awkward Dialog

    Part 29: Writers’ Tics

    Part 30: Too Many Words, or Too Few

    Part 31: The Wrong Words

    Part 32: %*@!$#^!!!! (Swearing)

    Part 33: Contradictions

    Part 34: Imbalance Between Narrative and Dialogue

    Part 35: Name-Calling

    Part 36: As You Know, Bob

    Pace

    Part 37: The Pieces of Pace

    Part 38: Pace: Speed It Up, Whoa It Up, or Change It Up

    Description

    Part 39: The Gray Haze

    Part 40: What Was That Again?

    Part 41: The Dreaded Expository Lump

    Part 42: Too Many Notes

    Part 43: Telling, Not Showing

    General Story-Telling Problems

    Part 44: Pop Goes the Reader!

    Part 45: No Story Arc

    Part 46: Padding

    Part 47: Danglers

    Part 48: Stating the Obvious

    Part 49: Point of View Shifts

    Mechanical Errors

    Part 50: Spelling

    Part 51: Punctuation

    Part 52: Capitalization

    Part 53: Grammar Errors

    Part 54: Manuscript Format

    Positive Reinforcement

    Part 55: Good Job!

    Part 56: Great Start!

    Part 57: Magic Middles

    Part 58: Ending a Scene or Chapter Well

    Other Topics

    Part 59: The End

    Bonus Material: Read-Out-Loud Tools and Techniques

  • Children of the Thunder Review

     

     

     

    Dark, dystopian, and deeply flawed. And yet….

    Author John Brunner’s late 20th century England is a mess: the economy is collapsing, environmental degradation is rampant, the government is corrupt, religious fundamentalists are taking over, and a renegade general is advocating xenophobia and racism at home and nuclear war abroad. Things in the U.S. are similar, minus the general. Meanwhile, Japan and continental Europe are doing fine, or better.

    Peter Levin is a freelance reporter. Few newspapers will buy his work and they are in danger of closing. Claudia Morris is an American sociologist. She made her name with a provocative book, but she now thinks she might have gotten her thesis wrong, and has come to England on sabbatical to do research and write a new book. She and Levin had met previously, and they meet up again.

    Meanwhile, a baker’s dozen of just past puberty children scattered across the British Isles and in Italy have discovered that they have the power to control the people around them, and they’re wielding that power to get everything they want, including the deaths of those who threaten them.

    And here’s where the first flaw shows up. Brunner tells the story of all but one of the children while Levin and Morris meet. Levin fumbles around trying to find paying work while she struggles to keep the funding for her studies coming. There’s little evidence of a connection between the Levin/Morris story line and those of the children for well over half of the book. A science fiction reader will trust the author to eventually bring parallel story lines together, and Brunner eventually does, but even then, the children seem to be of secondary interest Levin and Morris. The early portions of the book are such a disjointed mess that it’s often tempting to put the book down.

    Other flaws: Written in the mid-1980s, the book seems to have been created in haste for the domestic British market, and so was not “translated” into American English for this publication. (My copy of Children is the first of three books collected into one hardback.) For someone like me who’s worked with Britons, this isn’t much of a problem, but for others, even the non-slang terms will cause American readers to stumble.

    Speaking of slang, Brunner chose to create a whole new set of slang and swear words for his characters. It turns out that he did not make up the words he chose, they were terms from previous eras, some quite obscene in their original usage. This wouldn’t be much of a problem except that Levin, the children, and even the American Dr. Morris, who, by the way, is also a Jewish lesbian, swear like sailors. It’s annoying and unnecessary.

    As a writer, I notice dialogue tags. Writers today are taught to use very few: said, asked, thought, maybe one or two others. Brunner, however, resorts to what are called “Tom Swifties,” after the Tom Swift adventure novels, in which each dialogue tag is overdone and accompanied by an adverb to overdo them even more. Brunner’s characters shout angrily, exclaim excitedly, growl menacingly, and so on. It’s annoying tremendously.

    And yet, for all this, I kept reading. The story picks up once Levin and Morris hear about the kids. With the help of Levin’s estranged teenage daughter, who comes to live with him after her mother is killed by a plane crash in her neighborhood, they start to investigate the children. One of the children brings all but two of the others to live with him. He kills the Italian boy because he’s a potential rival. The other child (spoiler alert) is Levin’s daughter, and she’s in cahoots with the rest of them.

    Levin and Morris suspect that these children were all created via artificial insemination (referred to by the British slang term “artinsem”) with sperm from a single donor, so they try to find him. It turns out (more spoilers) that Levin, who was also a sperm donor as a young man, is that man, something that’s only revealed at the end of the book, when the children show him their amoral, power-mad nature and ultimate plans to take over the world, by among other things, making Levin father more of them, including with Morris.

    In true dystopian fashion, the bad guys (the kids) win, and the person we thought was the good guy (Levin) is in fact at fault for the whole mess.

    It’s a tribute to Brunner’s skill as a writer that he was able to keep me interested in such a flawed work all the way to the end, but in the end the flaws drive the rating down, although to a higher score than I first thought I would give it.

  • Revision and Self-Editing for Publication Review

    Small 3-star rating on dark blue background

     

     

    Let’s get this on the table right now: Jim Bell does not write a bad craft-of-writing book. Does NOT.

    In one case, however, the title of his book does not match the contents. That case is Revision and Self-Editing for Publication. As K. M. Weiland noted in her 3-star review of this book on Goodreads, there’s little here about revision or self-editing. That’s too bad because what little there is clearly shows that if Bell had focused on those tasks, rather than writing yet another book about writing a decent first draft, he could have done well.

    Bell divides the book into two sections: “self-editing” and “revision.” The self-editing section is classic Bell writing craft material, full of suggestions and techniques for coming up with ideas, getting over/under/around/through blocks, and making sure each scene has a Lead who has an Objective but is faced with a Confrontation before the scene reaches a Knock-out ending that launches the reader into the next scene—his LOCK method. All of which is great, but where’s the self-editing? It’s found only in the occasional, in-passing reference to the fact that you’ll come back and edit your work. That’s true, but where’s the retrospective, “now that you’ve written a first draft” approach?

    To some extent, it’s in the second section, yet even here there the chapter on “deepening” focuses on techniques for building a good first draft, rather than revising it.

    This is not to say—again—that this is a bad book. The chapters on things to do before you start revising, and on doing the first read-through, and the revision checklist make the book a worthwhile read. But for an author looking for guidance on revision and editing, those are about the only ones he or she needs to read.

    What disappoints me most about this book is that my copy is a second edition. That means that Bell and his editors had the opportunity to realize what they’d done after the first edition and refocus the book for the second, or do a completely new book. They didn’t.

    There are plenty of books on revising and editing out there already—Self-Editing for Fiction Writers by Renni Browne and Dave King stands at the head of the class as far as I’m concerned—but Bell could be right there with them with a book that truly focused on post-draft-one tasks. He can do this, and I hope someday he will.

  • The Art of War for Writers

    Small 4-star rating on dark blue background

     

     

    Put James Scott Bell’s The Art of War for Writers next to Strunk and White’s The Elements of Style on your bookshelf—or better, within easy reach! It’s that good.

    Using famous and long-ago Chinese general Sun Tzu’s The Art of War as his model, Bell presents vital and valuable information for writers in bite-size chunks. These nourishing and digestible non-chicken nuggets add up to a lot of chapters, yet only two are longer than five pages.

    That’s what makes them so useful: you can read a few, set the book aside to ponder them, and then come back without being overwhelmed with information. These chapter titles will give you a sense of what I mean:

    • From Part I, “Reconnaissance”: 21. Put heart into everything you write.
    • From Part II, “Tactics”: 36. Speed is the essence of the opening.
    • From Part III, “Strategy”: 59. Network according to the law of reciprocity.

    So if I think this is such a great book, why give it only four stars? Just one thing. The book was published in 2009, as the independent publishing revolution was just taking hold. Bell’s thoughts about indie publishing reflect the times, so he puts his emphasis on finding a path to what we now call traditional publication. Much has changed in six years, and if Bell were to update the book (let’s hope he will!), I’m sure his tone would change—and there’d be even more chapters to guide writers through the minefields of the indie-publishing world. As the title of chapter 23 says, “The writer of potential greatness settles not for ‘mere fiction.’”

    Highly recommended.

  • Critique Technique, Part 56 — Great Start!

    Young woman reding a book on a lawn
    Photo by lusi/RGBstock photos.

    Experienced writers understand that the most important chapter of a book isn’t the last one, but the first one. And that the first paragraph is the most important paragraph. And that the first sentence is the most important sentence. And that the first word… well, let’s not get carried away here.

    But that understanding about the first sentence, paragraph, and chapter makes sense. The purpose, after all, of each of these firsts is to get the reader to read the one that follows: the second sentence, the second paragraph, the second chapter. Why? Because the writer wants the reader to keep reading, to keep going, sentence after sentence, paragraph after paragraph, chapter after chapter, all the way to the end. In other words, to get lost in the fictive dream, to forget they’re reading a book or a short story—or even a non-fiction article.

    That means a well-turned opening is something to celebrate.

    Hook the Reader

    What makes for a good, if not great, opening? Les Edgerton, in his book Hooked, which I highly recommend, says the first 30 pages of a book need to have three things:

    • The inciting incident: the event that launches the story by changing the characters’ worlds irrevocably.
    • The surface problem: this is likely the inciting incident, or something related to it, but notice the word “surface.” It’s the first thing the characters, especially the protagonist, will have to deal with, but it sure won’t be the last. Or the most important.
    • Hints of the “story-worthy problem”: this is the problem—often psychological, Edgerton says—that will drive the protagonist through the story. Notice the word “hints.” Edgerton says the whole problem likely won’t be revealed until late in the book, maybe at the end.

    Now, Edgerton says those elements have to be present within the first 30 pages. I think it’s more like the first 10. Readers can be such sadists: they want to see the protagonist in trouble right away, and the bigger the trouble, the better. In a YA fantasy novel a friend of mine wrote, her young teen protagonist finds herself in a city in ruins with dragons fighting in the air above her. They’re likely to destroy the entire world in the process and when they do, it’ll be all her fault. One of the bodies she stumbles over as she tries to escape is that of her former torturer. And then she finds a just-hatched baby dragon.

    All of that is in the first five pages! It’s got everything Edgerton asked for:

    • Inciting incident: The destruction of the city.
    • Surface problem: The world’s about to be destroyed.
    • Story-worthy problem: Trina is clearly more than she seems. She must have a big secret, or some kind of power, she needs to keep hidden. Somebody was torturing her, after all. What is it? Can she keep it hidden? Who must she keep it hidden from, and why? Will she?

    Now, not every opening needs to be that big and dramatic but what it has to do is draw the reader in so they can’t stop reading. They have to find out what’s next, and what happens after that, and after that, and….

    Whether we like it or not, the days of the long slow build, full of back-story and character development are over. That material can—and should!—come later, in little bits and pieces, dropped in where each detail adds something vital. It may be part of those first 10 or 30 pages but it can’t be all there is to them.

    So when you as a reviewer find a story opening that draws you inexorably forward, be sure to let the author know that he’s succeeded and how and why he did.

    Questions for You

    How can you do that? For starters, you can identify what you felt were the three elements Edgerton described. You can also ask yourself these questions.

    • What the first thing was that caught your attention in a positive way and made you curious to find out more?
    • What was it about that thing that drew your attention, and why?
    • What was the next thing?
      • Did it build on the first one, or was it something new?
      • Why did it draw your interest?
    • What other elements continued to draw you forward into the story?

    One final note: beginnings are important throughout the story, not just on page one. Each chapter—indeed, each scene—needs to begin in a way that pulls the reader in and sends them onward. Not every chapter or scene beginning will be dramatic, but each one needs to plant another hook that keeps the reader from putting the story down.

    So, what markers of a strong beginning to a story or novel do you look for? Start right now to share your thoughts in the comments box below.

  • Great Stuff for Writers, June 17, 2013

    Quite a collection in today’s Great Stuff. There’s the Hero’s Journey, Niccolo Macchiavelli, who was probably not a hero, Aunt Edna, who might or might not have been one, and a cadaver or two. All in the service of writing. Plus foreign rights agents, dirty talk, and much more. Dive in!

    CRAFT

    Gregory Ciotti’s (@GregoryCiotti) Copyblogger post, What a Notorious 16th-Century Philosopher Can Teach You About Content Marketing Today, might seem to have nothing to do with creative writing, given that its target market is the business blogger. That seeming would be wrong. Niccolo Macchiavelli’s The Prince was controversial, sure, and it’s the book he’s most remembered for, but what’s important to us short story and novel writers is how he used controversy to stir—and maintain—interest in what he had to say. Thought-provoking.

    Katie Weiland (@KMWeiland) on why you want to “show” and not “tell” in your fiction: “If you find yourself summarizing important or potentially juicy scenes, stop and reevaluate what you’re doing. Whatever your reason, it’s not good enough. Readers are reading your book because of these scenes. They want to experience them. They want to see your characters growing and reacting.” (Emphasis hers.) Is Your Story Suffering From the “Montage Effect”?

    When Lisa Cron (@lisacron) asserts, and then explains Why the Hero’s Journey Is a Tourist Trap, she’s not ragging on Joseph Campbell, she’s saying that the Hero’s Journey, and all other story structures, are not what makes for a good story, and especially not a great one. Structure comes from story, not the other way around. By focusing on the problem the protagonist has to confront, and how he or she does that, the story, and hence the structure, will be revealed.

    If you’re writing fiction, do you worry about being sued because one of your characters is based on you batty Aunt Edna? In Write Who You Know (?), Clare Langley-Hawthorne discusses the practical realities—not the legal ramifications—of basing a character on a real person. While it’s important to consider those consequences, the good news is that more than likely, your characters will be composites of many people and anyone you might have chosen as a model will never recognized the traits you chose.

    Jan O’Hara (@jan_ohara) makes a strong case for closely studying well-written works—and provides the technique she used to do so—in The Cadaver Wore Text (aka the Case for Plot Dissection). What makes the case so strong? Without naming the books she studied, she shows how they failed to be perfect while being excellent and what she learned from that.

    BUSINESS

    Who wouldn’t want to see their novel not just sold in foreign countries, but translated into those countries’ native languages in order to reach an even wider audience? Foreign rights agent Marleen Seegers (@2SeasAgency) discusses what she does and how she does it in Foreign Rights Agents: Everything You Need to Know (& Why You May Want One!). While her work specifically relates to traditionally published work, I wouldn’t be surprised to see the translation market keep expanding for indie publishers and ebooks too.

    Having trouble connecting with readers or imagining who your readers will be? Toni Tesori (@duolit) suggests in How to Connect With More Readers in Just 5 Minutes that you focus on just one (ideal) reader. The idea isn’t new but the point behind it is simple: out of the hundreds of millions of potential readers out there, there won’t be just one reader who is like the one you imagine, but many. But imagining one is far easier than trying to imagine a lot, so this technique will help you focus your efforts better.

    THE WRITING LIFE

    While I think—I think—Keith Cronin (@KeithCronin) was writing tongue-in-cheek when he offers a formula for calculating your work’s Potty Mouth Index in Talk Dirty to Me, the piece really isn’t about his, or his characters’ language, or yours, or even about whether strong language is necessary and appropriate in any particular piece, but about how readers react to it and whether or how writers should react to their reactions. It’s a question that has no single right-for-everyone answer, just your own decision and your willingness to live with the negative feedback it’s sure to bring if one of your characters says a naughty word.

    If you’re the kind of person who thinks, Does a bear shit in the woods?, when you’re asked by Katie Weiland (@KMWeiland), Are You Over-Thinking Your First Draft?, then her post is for you. You probably know this intuitively already: thinking too much about a first draft is a sure way to produce a crappy one. Giving yourself permission to produce a less-than-perfect first draft—to NOT think too much about it as you’re writing it—knowing that fixing it is what editing is for, will not only end the pain and make writing fun again, it’ll make the quality of that first draft better too.

    FUN

    I could have split Gabriela Pereira’s (@DIYMFA) Book Expo 2013: Trends and Highlights into two pieces, one up in the Business section and the other down here, but since I like to put these things in just one place, and because the part I want to emphasize is the fun part, it goes here. The fun part is Gabriela’s description of meeting former US Poet Laureate Billy Collins and the links to two of his poems, “Introduction to Poetry” and “Workshop.” “Introduction” is just that, and easy and friendly. “Workshop” is a wry take on one workshopper’s review of a poem that exists only in Collins’ mind. Anyone who’s critiqued poetry—or tried to—will get it, and smile.

  • Great Stuff for Writers, May 8, 2013

    Hey! What happened to Monday? I was traveling, that’s what. And Tuesday? Trying to catch up. And Wednesday? STILL trying to catch up. I’m almost there. So, herewith is an abbreviated and tardy version of Great Stuff: outlining and word choice and beginnings and endings; branding and Goodreads and mastery and saving your work on the cloud.

    CRAFT

    If you’re an outliner, you understand that your outline is a fixed thing, graven in stone. In What Comes After Once Upon a Time, Robert J. Sadler describes how a little item he threw into a story, not thinking it was going to turn out to be important, instead became a key element in getting his latest novel to its conclusion by a path he never intended. But he trusted his storyteller’s instinct and good things happened.

    We all know that we should only use the best words in our writing. See Ernest Hemingway. Poets and their close kin song writers know this better than novelists do. So Joe Moore’s (@JoeMoore_writer) tribute to the just recently passed George Jones, What novelists can learn from song writers, is no surprise but makes the point with economy and clarity.

    Super-agent Donald Maass (@DonMaass) has a brief but excellent piece on Beginning and Ending on Writer Unboxed. The beauty of this piece is its simplicity: the story begins when the protagonist knows something’s changing; it ends when they know that the change is complete and they’ve entered a new world.

    BUSINESS

    Okay, so we’ve all heard about needing to have an “author brand.” What the heck is that? Melissa K. Norris (@MelissaKNorris) explains it in Why Ignoring Your Author Brand is Career Suicide (now that’s a headline that’ll catch your attention!) and goes on to offer a link to a brand development workbook if you subscribe to her and partner Janalynn Voigt’s newsletter.

    SOCIAL MEDIA

    To be honest, Goodreads has been a mystery to me. I have an account but haven’t spent enough time there to understand the site. So along comes Mayor A. Lan (@TheSavvyIndie) to The Creative Penn, where he provides The Ultimate Guide To Goodreads for Authors, and this is a gold mine. Lan lays out the half dozen capabilities Goodreads provides to its registered Goodreads Authors, including the ability for readers to see excerpts of your ebook, buy copies, write reviews, participate in giveaways, and more. I’m marking this post as a favorite to come back to.

    TECHNOLOGY

    Now, this is HUGE. What would happen if your computer crashed? Or was stolen? Or run over by a dump truck? Think it can’t happen? It can and it does to someone every day. EVERY day. So Rachelle Gardner (@RachelleGardner) offers two sets of tools for protecting your work in Never, Never, Never Lose Your Work! First,  use a service like Mozy or Carbonite to do regular (like multiple times a day) backups. Second, use a service like iCloud or Dropbox to hold all of your important files—on the cloud (storage on the web) instead of on your hard drive.

    THE WRITING LIFE

    Here’s a thought that can be both depressing and encouraging, depending on how you want to approach it: “mastery is an asymptote…you can get closer and closer to it, but you can never reach it.” That comes from an interview with Daniel Pink (@DanielPink) done by Ken Coleman and included in Jeff Goins’ (@jeffgoins) Everyone’s an Expert, But Not Everyone Is a Master. I take this as good news: one can always get better if you’re willing to do the work.

  • Critique Technique, Part 6: The Wrong Beginning

    Last time I wrote about how the beginning of a piece is supposed to “hook” the reader, to make them have to keep reading past the first line, the first paragraph, the first page. Now we need to zoom out a little and look at the beginning of the piece as a whole. Specifically, we need to ask, “Is this the right place for the piece to begin?”

    That may seem like an odd question: doesn’t an article, short story, or novel start at the beginning?

    Not necessarily. You’ve probably heard that a story needs to start in medias res, a Latin phrase meaning “in the middle of things.”

    Great. What things?

    Things. You know. The action. The events. Which may, of course, be internal to one of the characters, or external.

    But when there are things, action, events all through a story, which ones should the story start in the middle of?

    What Is the Beginning?

    What is the “beginning” of a story? Let me be more specific. What is the right beginning of a book? That’s a subtle but critical distinction. From this point on I’m going to focus on longer works: novellas, novelettes, and full-length books. Articles and short stories tend to be short enough that there’s less question about exactly where they should start. Not no question, however, so what I’ll discuss here can still apply.

    The problem is, every action, every event that’s part of the story had something happen before it. Lots of somethings, actually. And at least one of those somethings might constitute the beginning. Except that something else happened before it. By this logic, the author would have to go back to the beginning of the universe to find the “real” beginning. That’s not going to work. Well, James Michener could get away with it. Other authors? Not so much.

    As I mentioned last time, new writers tend to want to start with a lot of background information on the characters and their situation. Somewhere in all of that may well be where the story starts, but it’s not where the book should start.

    The beginning of the book has to launch the reader as well as the characters into the piece, even if the events that led to the start of the story happened much earlier. That information, called backstory, can and should be salted into the book later.

    The beginning includes the hook, but it’s more than the hook. The hook is about writing technique; finding the right beginning is about the craft of storytelling. It’s possible to create a hook for a beginning that isn’t the right one. In that case the hook will launch the reader into the piece, only to have her lose interest as the text wanders off into the proverbial woods and gets itself lost.

    The beginning introduces the reader to all or most of the major characters—the protagonist and antagonist for sure, but also key secondary characters—and gives the reader an immediate reason to care about them and their predicament. This is more than just the inciting incident and surface problem of the hook. It’s also the relationships among the key characters, the stakes created by the inciting incident and the surface problem, and the characters’ first response to that problem.

    Example: Ethan Frome

    Is the “inciting incident” the right place for the book to start? Usually yes, but not necessarily. Let me give you an example—Edith Wharton’s Ethan Frome—that seems to contradict what I just wrote, and in so doing illustrates, if not proves, it.

    Ethan and Zeena Frome, desperately poor New England farmers agree, despite their poverty, to take in Zeena’s young cousin Mattie Silver to care for the supposedly sickly Zeena. This agreement is the inciting incident. Mattie is young, beautiful, and vibrant, everything Zeena is not, and Ethan falls in love with her. Zeena notices and sends her away. [Here’s a spoiler alert, if you haven’t read the story.] In a last desperate moment together, Ethan and Mattie go sledding and crash into a tree, forcing Zeena to rise from her sickbed to care for the badly hurt Mattie.

    So, does the novel begin with Ethan and Zeena deciding to take Mattie in? No, it starts with a “frame” in which an unnamed narrator sees the badly crippled, post-accident Ethan, “a ruin of a man,” stagger into the town post office to get his mail. In this extreme case, the novel starts after the story has ended! Why? What was Wharton doing?

    Creating curiosity. Creating the need to know more, to read further—hooking the reader, in other words—to learn the story of Ethan Frome, even though the long preface makes it clear it’s going to come to a terrible end. Frame stories are a kind of special case but they can illustrate beautifully the difference between where a book can start and where the story started.

    Fine. So now you’re the reviewer of someone’s work. How can you tell if they’ve chosen the right—or at least a successful—beginning? It’s easier with an article or short story because you’re likely to have the entire piece in front of you. With a novel, it can be harder, especially if you don’t have the whole manuscript. In this case, you’ll want to wait until you’ve seen more of the book—maybe all of it—before you come to a conclusion.

    And if you’re the author, it’s vital for you to understand that until you have the whole first draft done, you will not really know where the book should start. You will learn things about your story and your characters in the process of writing that first draft that may well cause you to completely replace the beginning you originally wrote. If you do, you will hardly be the first, but your book will be better for it. After I decided I had the wrong beginning for my own first novel, I tried ten other ones; number ten was the right one.

    Review Questions You Can Use

    Here are some questions that can help you decide if the author has selected the right or wrong beginning.

    • Does this beginning take me beyond the hook? Does it amplify and deepen my curiosity about the characters and the story that follows?
    • Does this beginning identify the story’s key characters, their problems, and how significant those problems are? Does it give me a reason to care?
    • Does this beginning consist of action or activities that pull me along? (Note that, as I wrote about the hook, action doesn’t have to be slam-bang shoot-‘em-up stuff. It can be, like Wharton’s, quiet dialog in which the action is psychological, not physical.)
    • Does this beginning focus on the core story, or does it consist of, or wander off into, backstory or tangential material that should come later?
    • Are there other places in the story that would meet these criteria better? If so, what makes them better choices?
    • If nothing in the piece seems right for a beginning, what’s missing? What do you want or need to know to get interested in the characters and their story?

    The beginning is a crucial moment in the relationship between the reader and the story. The wrong beginning, or an ineffective one, will let the reader off the hook (pun fully intended), let her put the book down or flip to the next article or story. Selecting the right place to start isn’t easy but it’s vital and that makes your job as a reviewer that much more important.

    Your Thoughts

    What do you look for when determining whether an article, short story, or novel is starting in the right place? Add your thoughts and suggestions in the Comments box below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 5: Weak or Missing Hook

    Before I begin, remember that for each of the items I’ll discuss from now on, you have four questions to ask:

    • Did it happen?
    • Exactly where did it happen?
    • What exactly is the problem? Or what just worked really well?
    • What can the author do to fix it, if something needs fixing?

    OK, so what is a “hook” and how can it be weak or missing? Whatever you’re writing—fiction or non-fiction, poetry or prose—you need to catch and hold your reader’s interest: you need to hook them. And you need to do it early. How early? Well, in a poem it has to happen right away, in the first few lines, since a poem is likely to be brief. But this is true even in a longer piece. In a book, you have a few pages, in a short story, no more than the first few paragraphs. In Hooked, his excellent book on openings, Les Edgerton says the hook needs to be planted within the first 30 pages. Personally, I think it’s within the first 10, and the earlier within those 10, the better.

    The Hook’s Job

    The hook has a lot of work to do. A weak or missing hook does not do that work, or does not do it well.

    Fish hook in cloth
    Photo by Marco Michelini, via FreeImages.com

    Edgerton says those first pages need to do four things:

    1. Introduce the protagonist and their normal world.
    2. Contain the “inciting incident” that throws the protagonist out of that normal world.
    3. Contain the “surface problem,” the problem they initially think they have to solve.
    4. Introduce the first hints of the “story-worthy problem,” which is what will drive the protagonist through the rest of the book.

    To tell if a hook is present or absent, weak or strong, ask yourself questions like these:

    • Do I know who the important characters are?
      • If the answer is no or you’re not sure, why? Did two or more characters seem to have equal weight, for example? Did no one stand out?
    • Are the characters people I immediately become interested in? Do I care about them right away, even in a negative way? Uninteresting characters are far worse than unsympathetic ones—ones the reader does not like. Writers want their readers to respond to their characters, even if they hate them. But if the reader’s response is “meh,” that’s a problem the author has to fix.
    • Do I know what the protagonist’s problem is? As a reader, you may not know the full scope and extent of the story-worthy problem right away. Indeed, that may not be revealed until the very end, but the reader needs to know there’s a problem—and an important one in the protagonist’s mind—right from the beginning. That’s likely to be the surface problem, but it will begin the revelation of the story-worthy problem. If that is not happening, tell the author.
    • Do I at least have some sense of how big and important this problem is to the characters?
      • What’s at stake for them if they fail to solve it? What do they stand to lose?
      • What’s at stake if they do solve it? What do they stand to gain?
      • If you cannot positively answer at least some of these questions, then the author has not identified the stakes.
    • Do I get bogged down in the character’s history? I’ll discuss backstory in a later article. New authors have a tendency to think they need to provide all sorts of background about the major characters at the beginning of the book. That’s not true, and it buries the hook. If this seems to be happening, be sure to let the writer know, especially if nothing grabs you.

    A True Story

    Here’s an example of what I mean. My friend Debrah Strait was working on her first book and took the latest draft of her first chapter to her writers’ group. They were, shall we say, less than enthusiastic. After the meeting, Debrah went to Safeway and while she was in the store, she met a friend and complained about what the group had said. Her friend asked to see the piece, which Debrah still had in her purse.

    She read the first page. “I don’t care about that,” she said.

    She read the second page. “I don’t care about that.”

    When she finally got to page seven, where pirates began attacking a small settlement on a remote Caribbean island by blowing up a warehouse, she said, “Now I’m interested. Start here.”

    Debrah said, “But but but….”

    “Start. Here.”

    In the final version of The Sweet Trade, the warehouse blows up at the top of page two (and the rest of the village is destroyed and the residents are killed), and young Dirk and his friends, who were playing some distance away, are thrust into the world of piracy that will carry them through the rest of the story. On page one, Debrah introduced the protagonist and his normal world, and on page two, she blew that normal world up. That’s an effective hook.

    Other Components of the Hook

    A hook involves more than plot and characterization. The author’s “tone” or “voice”—how the piece sounds in the reader’s head—is also part of the hook. This might seem to be true primarily in poetry and so-called “literary” fiction, but it applies across genres and forms. Note that there is no “right” tone. Whining and sniveling, done well, can be as attention-catching and –holding as a slam-bang shoot-‘em-up opening scene. Note, too, that “done well” is not the same as what you personally prefer. The question is not whether you liked the opening but whether it grabbed and held your interest. Whether it did or it did not, again, you need to identify why.

    Pace, or lack of it, can also make a hook strong or weak, but it’s not a matter of fast or slow. A scene that goes screaming by may not be a good opening. If it fails at some of the tasks I’ve already discussed, it may not hook the reader. Similarly, a slow scene won’t be boring if it succeeds at those tasks. Again, the questions are:

    • Did it catch and hold my interest?
    • Did it make me want to keep reading?
    • If not, why not, and what can the author do to fix the problem?
    • If so, what was it about the opening that pulled me in?

    The hook also needs to introduce the piece’s setting and mood: when and where it takes place, what the physical, spiritual, and emotional environments are, etc. A weak hook does not establish these.

    That’s a lot to demand of just a line, a sentence, a paragraph, or a few pages, but that’s how important the hook is. If the opening does not hook the reader, he or she will go on to something else, meaning a lost potential fan, or at least a lost sale. On the other hand, a strong hook will launch the reader into the piece. If they have to keep reading past the opening, the hook has done its job.

    Your Thoughts

    In your mind, what makes a hook strong or weak? Do you have any examples you’d like to share? Please put your thoughts or examples in the Comments box below.

  • Great Stuff for Writers, March 19 & 20, 2013

    Holy hotcakes, Batman! Check out the Great Stuff we’ve got today! The first three posts qualify as Extra-Great Stuff in my mind, and the others are none too shabby themselves. Check ‘em out.

    CRAFT

    Chelsea Quinn Yarbro’s excellent Your Story Opening: Shock vs. Seduction on Jane Friedman’s blog opens today’s Great Stuff, and what an opening it is. This excerpt from her book Fine-Tuning Fiction actually starts with a brief discussion of pace and who drives it—antagonist early, protagonist later—then gets into those two types of openings. The shock opening grabs the reader’s interest and attention right away. The seduction opening is harder to do, Yarbro says, because its promises are more subtle, easing the reader into the story, and thus has to draw the reader’s curiosity so strongly, especially in the sentences right after the first one, that he or she can’t help but keep reading (hence the “seduction” description).

    One terrific craft piece deserves another, doesn’t it? Even better, we get to stay with openings. Ray Rhamey (@RayRhamey) “flogs” (critiques) the first page of a pro: The DaVinci Code by Dan Brown on Writer Unboxed. Brown’s writing—indeed his whole series—has been criticized, mostly by people who don’t like his genre (or, let’s be honest, his huge success, which many of them haven’t come close to sharing), but that hasn’t been the kind of evaluation that helps writers. Rhamey’s critique, on the other hand, examines details of Brown’s technique: where he info-dumped or left out important details, overwrote, or was flat inaccurate. This is an evaluation of fewer than two dozen lines, yet there’s a lot new writers (and not so new ones) can learn here. Great Stuff!

    But wait! There’s more! Now we have PJ Parrish Killing Off Good Characters on The Kill Zone (that’s appropriate, isn’t it?). Parrish discusses not only why it’s sometimes necessary to kill off that good character, but why it needs to be done in a way that advances the story. She also addresses a couple of don’ts: to fix a weak plot or to give yourself an opportunity to preach. Readers hate it—hate it!—when we kill off a good character, especially an animal, and they’re not the least bit shy about letting us know about it, but when it’s necessary to move the story forward or force the protagonist to do something they don’t want to do, well, ya gotta do what ya gotta do. Just make sure there’s a payoff for the protagonist—and the reader—in the end.

    My friend and editor Harvey Stanbrough (@h_stanbrough) is anything but shy about expressing his opinions. So there’ll be no question in your mind over what Why Present Tense Is Bad is about. Harvey’s basic points are these: past tense is the natural narrative voice, present tense distances the reader from the story, and it calls attention to the author and away from the story. Yup, no arguments there. And yet… (these are my thoughts, now) there may come the rare occasion when a story demands to be told in the present tense. Or so you think. So I think. I have a story nagging at me to be written that wants to be done in both present tense and first person. Yikes! Double yikes! Can I do it? More important, can I do it well? If this is going to work, it’s going to be damn hard to pull off, and I may ultimately decide it was a really dumb idea and shift back to third person past tense. But I’ll never know until I try.

    Okay, so maybe Katie Weiland (@KMWeiland) doesn’t really tell you How To Figure Out the Worst Thing That Can Happen to Your Character in her video post, but she does explain why you should and why—surprise?—that can turn out to be the best thing after all.

    BUSINESS

    Rachelle Gardner (@RachelleGardner) starts a two-part series on Making a Living as a Writer. Today’s post looks at “volume”—the reality that most writers make their money by having lots of work for sale at any time. Each may sell only a few copies a month but together they add up to solid income. This collection of works making money over time is called “the long tail,” a term you may have heard. If you’ve been following Joe Konrath’s posts—a good example is his recent Exclusivity—you’ll see he’s making serious money on his long tail. It took him years to build that tail but all that work is paying off, big time.