Tag: suspense

  • Spirit Walk Review

     

     

     

    Best novel I’ve read in quite a while. And a debut novel at that.

    Jay Treiber is a rare individual: a college English literature professor who can also write it, and write it well.

    College English professor Kevin McNally has been struggling for decades with his guilt over an incident that happened when he was a teenager. This is the kind of subject that could lead the author and reader down a rat hole of angst, self-loathing, and neurotic navel-gazing but  Treiber avoids this trap. Instead, he chooses to have McNally seek resolution of that guilt, and forgiveness for what happened, through a skillfully interwoven series of story lines that mix McNally’s present and past.

    By itself, that’s not unusual, but the story’s location and characters are. McNally comes from a line of southeastern Arizona ranch families, with friends and acquaintances on both sides of the border with Mexico, but perhaps as a way to escape his past, he left the small border town of Douglas to teach in Tucson—away, but not that far away. In telling the parallel stories of McNally’s return and of the original incident, Treiber takes the reader on journeys into worlds many have never experienced: the rugged high-desert canyons and mountains of far southeastern Arizona, far southwestern New Mexico, and the bordering lands of northern Mexico; the lives of the people who ranch and hunt on that land; and the drug smugglers who cross it.

    The story revolves around McNally and Amanda Monahan, the 15 year old daughter of an area rancher. Raised in the ranch life, Mandi is no girly-girl. She’s a skilled hunter, and also the secret heart-throb of 17 year old Kevin. While the two families and other friends are out on a deer hunt, the party splits up. Mandi, hunting with Kevin and his friend Armando “Mondy” Luna, takes down a buck. Kevin wants to offer to help her field dress the animal and take it back to the family truck but she seems so well able to handle the tasks that he and Mondy leave her to chase after a crippled black jaguar known as “Old Pete,” which they’d spotted. When the hunting parties return to their parked trucks sometime later, the deer’s head and carcass are there, but Amanda is not. Neither are Kevin and Mondy. The families wait for them for a while, then start searching, not knowing that the kids are not together. No one, as it turns out, knows that Amanda has been captured by a group of drug-runners, who now face the problem of what to do with her.

    The “young Kevin” story splits again and again as it follows Amanda, the druggies, the boys, and the different pieces growing search party. The “old Kevin” story line stays focused on McNally as he searches for the truth about a past he doesn’t clearly remember. Treiber weaves in and out of these bifurcating story lines like Old Pete weaving in and out of the bushes, trees, and rocky terrain, sometimes spotted but rarely seen clearly or for long.

    The story lines all come together in a climactic shootout between the searchers and the druggies, but it would be a spoiler to reveal who dies. It does, however, finally clarify the real reason for McNally’s guilt, which Treiber skillfully misdirects our attention from throughout the book.

    All this said, there were a few things about the book I found disappointing. Toward the end, the adult McNally goes on a peyote-fueled trip to the site of the search, led there by an old Indian friend. This was too much of a southwestern search-for-meaning-story cliché and is the least well done part of the entire book. It doesn’t even contribute much to the final resolution.

    As I neared the climax of the story, I realized that the names of two of the key characters, Amanda and Armando, sounded suspiciously alike. After reaching the end, I couldn’t help but wonder if Treiber, English lit professor that he is, hadn’t tried to be oh-so-clever with these names, creating the symbolic parallelism that those professors love. The meanings of the two names are relevant: Amanda means “lovable” or “worthy of love,” and Armando means “soldier.” Both names are appropriate to their roles, so I wouldn’t be surprised if Treiber consciously chose them. Or maybe he didn’t, and their meanings and the similarities of their sounds just slipped by author and editor alike.

    Finally, Treiber mixes in Spanish dialogue, which is appropriate for some of the characters, but he does not always provide a translation, and context is not always helpful. For those of us who don’t speak Spanish, this adds verisimilitude but is also a stumbling block.

    In the end, these faults matter little. Treiber’s characters are finely drawn. Even the struggling adult McNally is sympathetic enough to keep the reader following him. Treiber clearly knows and loves the portion of the desert southwest the story is set in, and he places the reader right there with the characters. And no dilettante professor, he doesn’t shy away from the details of the weapons the hunters, sheriff’s deputies, and druggies use, or from the hunting—for people or game animals—that is so much a part of this area and of the story. By the end, the adult McNally’s spirit walk has led him to a place at which his spirit is recovering, if not yet fully healed.

    Highly recommended.

  • Wool Review

    By Ross B. Lampert

    4.5-star rating dark blue background

     

     

     

    Wool is the title of both the first novella and the first five stories in the Silo series, and the book which rocketed Hugh Howey to science fiction stardom. Deservedly so.

    WARNING: There are spoilers in this review. I’ll put them in a different font so you can spot and skip them if you wish.

    Wool is the story of a large, thoroughly developed community of people (hundreds if not a few thousand) who have lived for a long time in a 144 story deep underground silo. One of many, as it turns out, but the residents of Silo 18 don’t know that there are other silos until late in the story. Until then, only a select few even know that they’re “Silo 18.”

    The silo culture is divided into dozens of functional groups: the Mechanicals live in the “down deep,” the lowest levels of the silo and keep the power, water, and air-conditioning flowing; Supply lives in “the mids,” and does what you’d think a supply organization does; the IT department lives in the lower portion of the “up top” levels and provides an early 1990s-era level of technology. There are porters, farmers, doctors, priests, and others, all overseen by an elected mayor and a tiny police force: one sheriff and three deputies, one in each of the vertical thirds of the silo. Why everyone lives in the silo is a closely-guarded secret, however, but everyone knows that the outside is deadly. They can see it, thanks to four camera lenses mounted on a tower that bring in a panoramic view of desolation in to the cafeteria on the top level.

    Those lenses need cleaning every now and then, but cleaning is not a job: it’s a death sentence. The silo’s Supply and IT departments have the ability to create environmental suits that allow someone to survive outside—but they can’t be allowed back in. Most residents don’t know why, they just know they can’t be. So when someone is convicted of a particularly heinous crime, which does not necessarily include murder, they’re sentenced to clean the lenses, and then die when their oxygen runs out.

    So you’d think the condemned would fight being sent out, yet they never do. For one thing, the air lock to the outside is cleansed by fire after the outer door is opened and closed. For another, when they get their first look outside from the airlock, what they see is nothing like what they saw through the other lenses. The world is green and lush. The buildings in the far distance are gleaming skyscrapers, not skeletons. And so the condemned people get to work, scrubbing furiously at the lenses with their wool cleaning pads, trying to show the people inside what’s really there.

    Except it’s not. And when they take off their helmets, thinking they can survive, well, you can guess what happens. Until one person learns the truth. And then another truth. And another.

    Wool is a story of deception and a desperate attempt to keep the people of the silo compliant with the rules as enforced by the mayor and sheriff, in part because there have been uprisings from time to time in the past—whose history was then (supposedly) erased from the archives—and anyone who dared to mention them sent to cleaning.

    For writers, Wool is an excellent story for studying world-building and character development. You’ll care about Sheriff Holston, and then your heart will break for him. You’ll care about Juliette, his successor and the protagonist of the story, and desperately want her to survive and succeed. And you’ll come to understand why Bernard, the head of the IT department, does what he does. He is the hero of his own story, and his story is rational in its own way.

    One final note. A reviewer on Amazon or Goodreads, I can’t remember which, took Howey to task because there was no wool in Wool. Alas, the young lady was wrong. There are two kinds: the wool of the cleaning pads, and the more horrific, suffocating wool that’s pulled over the eyes of almost all the residents. There is one problem however: while there is wool in the cleaning pads, there’s no mention of sheep in the story. But this one oversight is easy to miss and almost as easy to forgive.

    Very highly recommended.

  • Critique Technique, Part 33 — Contradictions

    Contradictions are the stuff of conflict. Contradictions between

    Angry couple standing back to back
    Image courtesy of David Castillo Dominici / FreeDigitalPhotos.net
    • characters’ words and actions,
    • what characters say to different people and/or at different times,
    • what characters do at different times or in different circumstances, or
    • the responses of different characters to the same stimulus

    all increase a reader’s tension and interest in the story.

    At least so long as the contradictions are intentional on the author’s part.

    If they’re not, that could be a problem. Or an unintended or unexpected opportunity. Your job as a reviewer is to not only spot the contradictions, but to evaluate them for effect, motivation, and intent.

    Intentional or Unintentional

    The first thing you need to assess is whether the author placed a contradiction in the story intentionally or not. If you’re new to the story or author, this can be difficult, at least until you have a better understanding of the story and the way the author works. But even before that, you can ask yourself whether the contradiction seems to have a purpose. Writers should always put contradictory actions or statements into a piece for a specific reason. They can:

    • indicate a change in the character’s situation, beliefs, or intentions;
    • be an attempt to deceive or mislead another character;
    • show confusion on the part of the character, perhaps due to a declining mental state, being overwhelmed by their situation or how much information is coming their way, or the conflicting demands of other characters or the situation in the story; or
    • simply be an unintentional (on the character’s part) misstatement or mistaken action that is going to have consequences later.

    Your job is to assess whether the author intended to insert that contradiction or he just made a mistake. The author’s “failure” could be intentional: he might be withholding information to increase your tension and your need to know what happens next. That’s why it’s important to keep reading, as much as possible, to see if that was, in fact, the author’s intent. If you critique what appears to be a mistake too soon, you might have to go back and delete or revise that comment.

    Assessing Contradictions

    OK, so how do you assess a contradiction? It’s relatively easy when the contrary words or acts are close together. Unfortunately, that doesn’t always happen. That’s when this kind of assessment can be difficult, especially if you’re not reading an entire piece at once.

    Here’s an example. Let’s say that in chapter three Bob says he respects Alice. He’s impressed with her knowledge and determination. Now supposed Bob and Alice go their separate ways in chapters four to six, but in chapter seven, Bob calls Alice lazy and stupid. That’s a pretty sharp contrast, and if it seems to come out of the blue, you’re likely to remember Bob’s earlier statements and wonder what’s up now. But if Bob’s later comment is diffident, that Alice’s work is okay, will you catch the conflict? You should, but it’s harder to do.

    In my article on the reviewer’s mind, I discuss how to remember details across large parts of a text or over long periods of time. You might want to review that article soon.

    Let’s say you’ve spotted some kind of contradiction. What’s next?

    Effects

    The first thing to look for is its effect: how it affects the characters involved.

    • Does it create new and interesting problems for one or more characters?
    • Does it make matters worse for them?
    • Do those problems change the direction of the story, especially in interesting and/or unexpected ways? And does the author follow up on that new direction?

    Contradictory behavior in a character reveals something about her. This is good. Or at least, it can be.

    Preparation

    Next, you want to assess whether the author prepared the reader for the contradiction. It’s important for the author to have set up the behavior before it happens. This is a place where a lot of writers fall down.

    The author can set up the contradiction in a number of ways, and any of them can be blatant or subtle. For example:

    • Circumstances in the character’s life and environment can force a change that leads to the contradiction. Being forced out of his home by a natural catastrophe is a blatant set-up. A slow build-up of conflict leading to a divorce or separation from his partner could be subtle.
    • The character herself might have been evolving due to an accumulation of small changes.
    • What the character said or did originally may have been dishonest, misleading, or just incorrect. Or what he’s saying or doing now may be.
    • The character is responding to what another character says or does that she didn’t expect.
    • The character’s statement or action is unintentional, compared to what he’s said and done before.

    Motivation

    A third factor is the character’s motivation for saying or doing something that contradicts what he said or did in the past, even if that past was just seconds ago in story time. You’ll want to assess not only if the reader can see or sense what the motivation is but also if it’s credible, given what you know about the story and the characters.

    If the author set up the contradiction, and the character’s motivation for it and its effect are clear, that’s great. But if she’s missed on any one, that’s a sign there’s a problem. You as the reviewer need to identify what went wrong.

    Questions for You

    Here are some questions you can ask when you’re evaluating something that a character in a piece has done or said that seems to contradict his earlier statements or behavior.

    • Did the author place this contradiction with a purpose?
      • Does it reveal something about a change in the character or her situation?
      • Might it be setting up something that will happen later in the story?
      • If not, what exactly is the problem and how can the author fix it?
    • Does this contradictory statement or behavior change things for the character, those around him, or the overall story? Especially, does it make things worse?
    • If the change doesn’t happen right away, do it and its effects show up at all, or did the author seem to forget that she set up a change that hasn’t happened?
      • If the change hasn’t shown up, why?
    • Was the reader prepared for the contradiction?
      • If he was, was that good, or was it perhaps telegraphed (he could see it coming)?
      • If he wasn’t, was that good? Does it create new interest and tension in the reader?
    • Can you see why the character said or did the contradictory thing? Was her motivation clear?
      • If not, why not? Was that intentional on the author’s part?

    Well-placed contradictions make stories more interesting and keep the reader engaged. Be sure to compliment the author when they do them well.

    What do you look for and what do you consider when you run across a contradiction in a story? It’s no contradiction to say that the best place for your suggestions is in the comments box below.

  • Great Stuff for Writers, April 29, 2013

    Frantically trying to get caught up after spending the last 3 days volunteering with the Oklahoma City Memorial Marathon, something I do every year to honor the memory of a friend of mine who was killed in the bombing of the Murrah Federal Building here. I’ve been a part of the event every year, as a volunteer, runner, or both, and this year was even honored with a profile interview in The Oklahoman, the city’s newspaper, even if the writer did misspell my name.

    But enough of that! This is a writing blog! There’s lots of Great Stuff included this week: foreshadowing, characters who pop, pitching, the benefits of writing short fiction, book marketing, the value of reviews, burnout, learning from writing, and even some fun: one 2-year-old’s takes on books based on their covers. All that and more is waiting for you below.

    CRAFT

    We all want our characters, especially our protagonist and antagonist, to stand out. But how to do it without going over the top or descending into cliché? Katie Weiland (@KMWeiland) offers A Simple Trick for Making Your Characters Pop: add one or two details that contrast with the rest of his or her personality. They don’t have to be huge but so long as you can show that they make sense in the context of the character’s overall life and personality, you’ve just made them memorable.

    We all want feedback that helps us get better, and that’s what Kathleen Pooler (@kathypooler) got, from perhaps the best but most intimidating sources: real agents, editors, and publishers. Still, How Practicing My Pitch Helped Me Write a Better Book on DIY MFA illustrates how the right attitude can turn a not-ready-for-prime-time draft into something that just might make it.

    “The biggest thing I’ve learned from writing short stories,” writes Suzanna Windsor Freeman (@Writeitsideways) in What Novelists Should Know About Short Fiction on Writer Unboxed, “is the art of subtlety: how to be less obvious with symbolism or themes, how to choose subtle titles, and when it’s better to leave things unsaid.” She says more, but that’s enough.

    Before you can know How to Use Foreshadowing, you have to know what it is, what its component pieces are, and how it differs from telegraphing an event and from foreboding. Katie Weiland (@KMWeiland) takes care of all of that in this post, which, by the way, is an example of telegraphing.

    Yikes! Michael Swanwick isn’t kidding when he calls the following A Brutal Test for Your Fiction. It comes straight from early 20th Century humorist Stephen Leacock, who was, as best I can tell, dead serious when he wrote this: “Remove a page from the middle of your work.  Set it aside.  Then read the page before it and the page after.  Can you reconstruct what happened in that page?  Then your work is mediocre at best.” (Italics Swanwick’s.)

    BUSINESS

    Think book reviews don’t matter… or don’t matter much? Angela Ackerman (@AngelaAckerman) traces how they influence future purchases in Book Reviews Matter: Thank You For Taking the Time. Long story short: they matter—a lot.

    We haven’t talked about press kits much here, at least not recently, so Nigerian-born British author Tolulope Popoola’s (@TolulopePopoola) Book Marketing: Creating Your Author Press Kit on The Creative Penn provides a handy summary of the four parts of a good kit. One note: Popoola says the press release should be “brief and sucking”! Must be a British-ism. I presume that means attention-getting or informative.

    With the success and influence of Guy Kawasaki’s book Author, Publisher, Entrepreneur, you’d think Gabriela Pereira (@DIYMFA) was being a crazy woman when she writes Why You Don’t Need to Be an Author Entrepreneur. She’s not. She’s acknowledging that complete entrepreneurship isn’t for everyone, but at the same time, we all do need to be entrepreneurial, that is, looking for—and taking advantage of—opportunities to get our work in front of more people through partnerships, new business models, and new technologies.

    THE WRITING LIFE

    I hope this never happens to you, but Barbara O’Neal’s (@barabaraoneal) Boundaries and Burnout hit really close to home. I’ve been feeling that burn and not in a good way. Fortunately, some tasks I’ve been working on are now done but others await. And there will come a point where, like Barbara, I have to say no or stop doing certain things or save them for later.

    In Here’s What I’m Learning From This One, John Vorhaus (@TrueFactBarFact) announces he’s conquered his fear of writing, and encourages you to do the same. A few truths stand out: “The more words I write, the better I get at writing more words” and “To be a writer is to be emotionally authentic on the page.”

    FUN

    In Robert Bruce’s (@robertbruce76) My 2-Year-Old Judges Books By Their Covers, that’s exactly what we get… but that’s not all. Of course, a 2-year-old isn’t going to get all the symbolism and summary and meaning that a cover artist tries to fit into a cover and still have it make sense; this piece isn’t about that. It’s about the cute things kids will say when given an unusual prompt. But it does also make the point that a puzzling, unclear cover doesn’t help a prospective reader decide to read the book.

  • Great Stuff for Writers, March 7 & 8, 2013

    Happy Friday, everyone. The Tucson Festival of Books is this weekend and I’m psyched. This is always a great event. Maybe I’ll see you there. Meanwhile, there’s a big kerfuffle afoot over some new ebook contracts from Random House. See below for much more on that, plus other, far less controversial Great Stuff.

    CRAFT

    Jordan Dane (@JordanDane) offers terrific advice in 8 Key Ways to Edit Suspense & Pace into Your Finished Manuscript. If that title isn’t enough to make you want to go read it, I’ll tease a few of her suggestions: figure out if you’ve started at the best point; is the setting the right one; does the protagonist’s “black moment” occur at the best possible place? Valuable stuff here.

    Rachelle Gardner (@RachelleGardner) injects a moment of sanity in what other might be a crazy-making time in a writer’s life in Calling Your Manuscript Finished (For Now). The idea is simple to say, hard for some of us to do: once you’ve submitted it somewhere—and especially once an agent has accepted it!—let it go. Don’t worry about the little stuff: the occasional typo, the margins that might be 1/10th of an inch off. Those things can be fixed later, if necessary. In the meantime, relax.

    BUSINESS

    My original headline for this article was going to be “John Scalzi Nukes New Random House eBook Imprint Contracts,” but upon further review, I’m going to tone down my own rhetoric and let others speak for themselves. Victoria Strauss (@victoriastrauss) over at Writer Beware® Blogs broke the story of the new contract boilerplate from the SF/Fantasy imprint Hydra. Then Dean Wesley Smith (@DeanWesleySmith) reported that Scalzi (@scalzi), the President of the Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America (SFWA), went into much more detail about these contracts. The first of his two posts, Note to SF/F Writers: Random House’s Hydra Imprint Has Appallingly Bad Contract Terms, relies largely on Strauss’s reporting, but his second post, also put up on March 6th, A Contract from Alibi (the mystery/thriller story imprint), is based on an actual copy of the contract. Random House has also launched two other imprints, Flirt for “New Adult,” and Loveswept for romance, and given that two of the four are using the same boilerplate, it’s reasonable to assume these latter two will do the same. Why did Scalzi go ballistic? He lists seven reasons; I’ll mention just four:

    • The author gets no advance.
    • The imprint takes all rights, all over the world, for the life of the copyright.
    • The author gets billed for part of the costs of things the publisher used to pay for itself, possibly without having any way of knowing what they were charged or whether that amount was accurate and reasonable.
    • The rights-reversion clause does not define when a book has gone “out of print,” allowing the publisher to never revert rights back to the author so long as the book is available from just one obscure source anywhere in the world.

    The SFWA subsequently announced that it will not consider Hydra a membership-qualifying publisher. (SF/F writers have to have published three works with “qualifying” publishers/publications to be eligible for SFWA membership.) Strauss finds some of these parts of the contract less objectionable than Scalzi does in SFWA De-Lists Hydra; Random House Responds.  My friend Dawn pointed me to this post on The Passive Voice blog (@PassiveVoiceBlg): Random House Responds to SFWA Slamming Its Hydra Imprint, which contains the full text of the RH letter. This morning, SFWA wrote back, saying in essence, “sorry, we don’t buy your arguments, we’re standing by our delisting, and if this sort of contract spreads to other imprints besides Alibi or to the wider company, we just might delist Random House altogether.”

    There’s an important caveat here: no one in this argument besides Scalzi and the SFWA board and the folks at Random House has seen a copy of an actual contract. Strauss has not, so far as I can tell, only an offer sheet. So until and unless a copy of the contract is made public—and how likely is that?—we’re all working on second-hand information. As I type this, neither the mystery nor romance writers associations have commented on their web sites.

    What should you do? Read these posts—carefully—including Scalzi’s CYA disclaimers in the first comment to each of his posts.

    If you write in any of the genres listed above and already have an agent, you might want to tell them not to pitch to these imprints at least until the dust settles. If you’re pitching on your own, same thing: hold off. If you’ve already signed one of these contracts, that’s another matter entirely. Scalzi says nothing about the contracts’ escape/cancellation clauses, but that doesn’t mean they’re okay.

    Now, take a deep breath. This is Chapter The First of this story, not Chapter The Last, and it’s important not to get too caught up in the emotions of the moment. Random House has a chance to change its mind and rewrite these contracts. Maybe they will, maybe they won’t; maybe a revision will make things better, maybe worse. Time will tell.

    Whew! Let’s get away from that mess for a while. Joel Friedlander invited lawyer Sara Hawkins (@Saving4Someday) to do a post on the 5 Top Legal Issues for Authors and Self-Publishers. She discusses matters of potential copyright infringement by the author of images, graphics, text, and music lyrics, copyright registration, misuse of brand names and trademarks, and what you might do if it’s your copyrighted work that’s misused. The discussion is necessarily general but should give you a good sense of where the sometimes gray lines are.

    THE WRITING LIFE

    There are a couple of posts today on the general subject of children and writing but Rochelle Melander’s (@WriteNowCoach) 5 Things Children Teach Us About Writing on the WORDplay blog resonated better with me. In summary, Melander’s 5 things are: dedicate space and time to writing, accept what shows up, honor your passion, prewrite, and look for “the golden sentence” in each day’s work. These are all things she does with the kids she teaches and has learned to apply them to her own writing life too.

    FUN

    Okay, time to get your word-geek on. Mignon Fogarty (@GrammarGirl) discusses a couple sets of Crazy English Idioms: those surrounding the word “whole”—first “the whole ball of wax,” and then others including “the whole enchilada”—and then the pair “go pound sand” and “go pound salt.” Every language has its expressions that leave foreigners scratching their heads, and English in all its many variations has its share, which was partly why Sir Winston Churchill once described Americans and Britons as “two peoples separated by a common tongue.”

    This last item has nothing to do with writing but it’s just amazing. Michael Swanwick reports on two videos from an Austrian university (their equivalent of MIT) in which pairs of small four-rotor autonomous drones called quadrotors bounce a ball back and forth to each other while in flight or toss a pole from one to the other. The link to the first video in Teaching Quadrotors to Juggle worked fine but the second one didn’t. You can, however, see that two-minute video here.

    What do you think? What’s going to happen with those Random House contracts? How bad do you think they are?