Author: Ross Lampert

  • Critique Technique, Part 28 — Awkward Dialogue

    Woman talking on pay phone
    Image courtesy of Sira Anamwong / FreeDigitalPhotos.net

    Ah, dialogue. It’s hard for many writers to do well. When it works, it crackles, sings, inspires, enrages, chills, thrills. But when it doesn’t, it might do that too, but for the wrong reasons! It may be stiff and stilted, choppy or verbose, confused or confusing, or have other problems. Any or all of those characteristics can be acceptable, even necessary, when they reflect the character of the speaker. When they don’t, there’s trouble.

    Natural Dialogue vs. Written Dialogue

    There are many reasons for this. First off, dialogue in writing—all writing: fiction, memoir, and non-fiction—is not natural, but has to sound natural when read, especially out loud. Real dialogue includes pauses, repetitions, false starts, bad grammar, slang and jargon, incomplete sentences, and other problems.

    Fictional dialogue is “better” than natural speech without seeming to be constructed, even though it is. If any of the problems I listed above appear there, the author should have put them there intentionally.

    Perhaps even more than in narrative, every word must be the right word. Sentence structure must be just right to convey the proper degree of tension—from raving rage to the gentlest soothing. Every speaker must say just the right thing, especially when that’s just the wrong thing.

    The good news for you as a reviewer is that bad dialogue calls attention to itself. You feel the problem as you read it. You find yourself saying, “Huh?” or “Get on with it, will you?” or even throwing the story across the room in frustration.

    But let’s get a bit more specific about a few ways dialogue can be awkward. We’ll start with dialogue that is stiff or stilted.

    Stiff and Stilted

    First off, what do I mean by “stiff” and “stilted”? They’re very similar, so I need to be clear about how they’re different. Stiff dialogue has these characteristics.

    • It is often too grammatically correct. Sentences are complete, with an explicit subject, verb, and object. Real, and real-sounding, dialogue on the other hand is full of sentence fragments.
    • Sentences may be long and rambling (there’s an example below) or short and choppy, like this: “Bob went to the store. He bought a loaf of bread and a half-gallon of milk. He paid for them in cash.” Both kinds of sentences can be effective when they’re used properly. The problem occurs when the style does not match the character or the situation.
    • The speakers avoid using contractions, saying “I will” rather than “I’ll,” for example.
    • It’s emotionally flat, even when trying to express strong emotion, by avoiding the strong language that high emotion requires, or by using sentence structures that don’t match with or create the high emotion the author intended.
    • The pace never changes and often plods. The pace and flow of real, and real-sounding, dialogue ebbs and flows.

    In short, stiff dialogue sounds the way a robot in a bad science fiction movie from the 1950s would speak.

    Stilted dialogue is stiff, and then some. It adds extra degrees of formality, “expert” or erudite language (like that), and emotional distance between the speakers. Sentences in stilted dialogue or narrative tend to be longer and more complex than they need to be and to use many words where a few would do. The result can be something like this: “As you can see, madam, by virtue—or lack thereof—of your behavior, it shall be necessary for me to make inquiries into the nature and number of your previous liaisons with potential suitors in order that I may be better informed as to their, and your, morality and any potential indications of turpitude or depravity.”

    As opposed to, “So, Alice, who’ve you been screwing lately?”

    There are other ways writing can be awkward.

    • Unclear personal pronoun references can be a real problem. When there are two or more characters of the same gender in a sentence or paragraph, referring to them with pronouns (he/him/his, she/her/hers) can leave the reader confused over which pronoun refers to which character.
    • Similarly, using the characters’ names over and over can be just as awkward. There’s no confusion over who the author or speaker is referring to but repeating names does not reflect natural speech patterns.
    • “Talking around” a topic, that is, using euphemisms or indirect language rather than coming out and naming the person or thing can lead to real confusion for the reader, whether it’s the narrator or a character speaking.
    • Abnormal word order is a technique writers will use when they’re trying to make a character seem “foreign”—Yoda from the Star Wars movies, for example—or uneducated. Used sparingly and in character, this technique can be fine. If the author uses it too much, though, the reader will struggle.

    While I’ve concentrated on dialogue here, awkward narrative shares all of these faults. The only difference is that it’s the narrator “speaking” directly or indirectly to the reader, rather than the reader listening in on a character’s thoughts or to a conversation between characters.

    A Powerful Technique

    What can you do to help repair awkward dialogue or narrative? One of the best things you can do is encourage the author to read her work out loud before she submits it. Or, she can use the read-aloud capabilities that some word processors and document handling programs like Adobe Reader have. If she resists, read the unedited work out loud to her so she can hear just how awkward it is. In many cases, the awkwardness will speak for itself and you won’t have to exaggerate the problems. If she still doesn’t understand that there’s a problem, you may need to ask her to explain why she chose to write the dialogue the way she did. Maybe you’re the one who doesn’t understand.

     Reading a work out loud is such a powerful technique because we process the words we hear differently than when we read them with our eyes. Problems our eyes and brain glide right over will jump out to the listener when the work is read aloud. This technique works for narrative as well as dialogue.

    Questions for You

    Now here are some questions you can ask yourself as you review a work.

    • Is every sentence of the author’s dialogue grammatically correct?
    • Is every sentence complete, or does he use fragments?
    • Are her sentences consistently the same length, or do they vary?
    • Do her characters fail to use contractions?
    • Do his characters expresses emotion through their dialogue effectively?
    • Is his characters’ dialogue consistent or inconsistent with the kind of person they’re supposed to be?

    If you spot any of these problems, suggest ways the author could fix them.

    Awkward dialogue or narrative will undermine a reader’s confidence in a writer perhaps faster than just about anything else. It’s immediately obvious. It’s also generally easy to fix, and as a reviewer, you’ll do your writer-friend a huge favor by helping them do so.

    What kinds of things stand out to you as awkward dialogue? Be sure to be clear about it when you put your thoughts in the Comments box below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 27— Narrative and Dialog

     

    Two men talking
    Image by photostock, courtesy FreeDigitalPhotos.net

    This post begins a series on narrative and dialog. Stated most simply, narrative and dialog are the tools writers use to tell their stories. They take different forms and serve complementary functions, but with plenty of overlap.

    Writers use narrative to:

    • Describe—to show—action (“Bob ran down the street after Alice’s car”) or emotion;
    • Describe a person (“Alice’s hair was dyed souvenir-shop-coral red”), a place, or a thing;
    • Make connections between people, places, actions, emotions, or things; and
    • Provide the reader with whatever other information she might need.

    It is the words not placed inside quotation marks or used for internal monolog (sometimes shown in italics).

    While it’s true that dialog can do many of these same things, and often does, narrative is the better choice in many cases. Consider how awkward it would be to have characters discussing the details of every setting in order to present that information to the reader:

    “Oh, look, Alice. This room has windows through which the sun is shining on a round oak table with two chairs set opposite each other.”

    “Yes, Bob, and the far wall is nothing but bookcases filled with leather-bound volumes and the occasional knick-knack.”

    Oy.

    On the other hand, while it’s possible to write a story that contains little or no dialog—I published one that had only internal monolog; none of the characters ever said a word to each other—it’s rare and unless done well, hard for readers to stay engaged with.

    One reason is that we engage in dialog every day: we talk to each other. Characters need to do that, too. Dialog:

    • Allows characters to interact with each other: to support each other, provide information or direction, deceive each other, etc.
    • Illustrates character. What a character says reveals what he knows, how she’s feeling, what he thinks about a situation, how she perceives another character, and so on.
    • Can build or relieve tension and conflict.
    • Lubricates the plot and the narrative and keeps them moving forward.

    In short, dialog is all but essential to a story.

    Much of what I wrote about in earlier Critique Technique articles dealt with problems in narrative. This next series will, too, because many problems in dialog appear in narrative, too, and vice versa. But there are also some problems that are unique to dialog, so this is where I’ll address them. Specifically, we’ll be looking at:

    • Awkward, choppy, and stiff or stilted writing;
    • Overused words, phrases, or text patterns;
    • Writing that is verbose or cryptic;
    • Inappropriate language, including but not limited to obscenities and vulgarities;
    • Unintentionally contradictory language and statements;
    • Imbalance between narrative and dialog;
    • Name-calling within dialog; and
    • Using dialog to blatantly convey information to the reader, including the “As you know, Bob” problem.

    I may add other items to the list as we go along, but this is where we’ll start. What other problems would you like me to discuss in this section? Add your suggestions in the Comments below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 26 — Tangents

    Lines tangent to circles and ellipses
    Image courtesy Wikimedia

    If you look up “tangent” in the dictionary, it takes a while to get to a definition like this one from Webster’s Universal College Dictionary: “digressing suddenly from one course of action or thought and turning to another.”

    Tangents share a characteristic with excessive backstory and flashbacks: they start from the current story moment and then shift in time, place, point of view, or topic. As with a flashback, the author may mean to provide some kind of amplifying information, but then he forgets to stop after providing it and wanders not only off the beaten path, but off any path at all.

    Sometimes that can be intentional, for example if she’s trying to produce a piece of stream-of-consciousness writing. The sneaky truth, though, is that while stream-of-consciousness writing seems to be unstructured and uncontrolled, when done well it’s actually very tightly controlled. A tangent, on the other hand, if unplanned is a sign the author has lost control of her work.

    Back in Part 20, I put in a long and rambling monologue as an example of too much setting detail, but it overflows with tangents, too. I stopped counting at a dozen of them and I know there were more.

    Now, in the right context, a long sentence like that one could be just fine, a clear if exhausting illustration of a manic and scatter-brained personality. Even without a larger context, it’s easy to see how each tangent in that example splits off from the previous line of thought, only to have another tangent split off from it.

    Problems with Tangents

    The main problem with tangents is that their material has little to do with the story at the moment the tangent departed. If one of the lines in the diagram at the top of this article represents the main storyline, then when one of the circles, representing a tangent, touches it, the story loops of in a completely unrelated direction as it follows the edge of that circle. With luck, the loop will finally return to the original line.

    If not, each additional divergence takes the reader farther away from the original storyline, until, as with excess backstory, he loses track of it entirely. The circles in the diagram above are all on different planes, which illustrates that separation.

    Tangents also disrupt a story’s flow. Even when the events of a story are chaotic, a tangent can swirl the reader off into a whirlpool of confusion. At best, it may take a forced and awkward transition to bring her back to the main storyline.

    A tangent can be a clear sign that the author doesn’t know what’s important in his story. As with backstory or flashback, he may be trying to force in information. Or the tangent can be a sign that he’s losing control of the story: he doesn’t know where it’s supposed to be going.

    Uses for Tangents

    Not all tangents are bad, however, at least so long as the author has firm control on them. As I noted above, one positive use for a tangent is to illustrate a character’s personality. Tangents like these need to be used with caution, however, because in addition to the problems I listed above, too many of them can exhaust the reader as she tries to keep track of or make sense of the character’s personality.

    A tangent can also be used to plant a false lead or a false clue. Done with care and intention, this can really catch the reader’s attention and keep him wondering how that clue is going to matter. That false clue can be used to distract or misdirect a character too. “Red herrings” are a key tool for mystery writers, and tangents can be used to slip them into a story.

    In every case, however, tangents like these need to be used with care. The author needs to know exactly what she’s doing in order to maintain control of the tangent and her story.

    As a reviewer, then, a key problem you can face, especially when reading something for the first time, is determining the author’s intent. You might have to get through the entire piece and then look back on it before you can decide.

    Questions for You

    To wrap up, then, here are some questions you can ask yourself when you come across material that seems like a tangent.

    • If the author uses tangents repeatedly, is this a stylistic choice that supports the story? Does the tangential material do that in a clear and definable way?
      • If not, how is it failing?
    • Is the author illustrating something about a character or a chaotic situation?
      • If so, does he do it just enough to make the point? In other words, is he using the tangent in a controlled and purposeful way?
      • If not, what about it is not working?
    • Does the tangent begin and end cleanly, with clear transitions into and out of it?
      • If not, what’s wrong with the transitions and how could the author fix them?
      • Did the transition come back to the main storyline soon enough that I didn’t forget what the main story was?
    • Could the author use the material in the tangent somewhere else?
      • If so, where and how, or does it just need to be deleted?

    How do you identify tangents and how do you help authors avoid them? I know you’ll stick to the point in your suggestions in the comments box below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 25 — Misused Backstory or Flashback

    A twisted, two-ended red pencil
    Image courtesy FreeDigitalPhotos.net.

    Backstory and its kissing cousin flashback are techniques authors use to provide amplifying information about a situation, a location, or a character. Flashbacks and backstory differ from “front story” in that the author jumps away from the story’s current timeline to relate them, then returns to the story’s present to continue.

    Jumping forward in time—a “flash forward”—can have the same purpose, and everything below also applies to it.

    Good Backstory Technique

    Flashing back is just a technique for relating backstory. A brief interruption of the story’s flow, it can be:

    • Initiated by the narrator to provide information not available to the characters or which would be unnatural for the characters to provide;
    • A character’s recollection; or
    • A conversation between two or more characters (“You remember when…?”), to name just three.

    The words “flash” and “brief” are important here: flashbacks are over and done with quickly.

    Backstory can be told more leisurely, as a stand-alone scene for example, but generally should not be. Any relating of backstory that takes long enough to derail the narrative flow of the story is known as an info-dump. I’ll say more about this a little later.

    Backstory can take the form of just a single, telling detail. For example, there’s this line in a Robert Reed novella, “Murder Born,” which centers around a couple trying to bring back their murdered daughter: “But that didn’t stop [Lauren] from…curling up on the mattress cover that was washed every two weeks, the same as always.” That last phrase, “the same as always,” is the droplet of backstory that tells us so much about Lauren’s grief, expressed in her continuing care for her dead daughter’s bedclothes.

    Sprinkling in nuggets of backstory like that is a highly effective technique. It gives the reader a piece of important information just at the moment it’s most needed and has the most impact, but doesn’t interrupt the flow of the story. In fact, the reader might not notice it consciously, even though they’ve just learned something important.

    Poor Backstory Technique

    So while “backstory” encompasses all the background information that doesn’t fit into a story’s or article’s primary timeline, here are four improper or ineffective techniques for presenting it.

    • Starting with backstory;
    • Using backstory too often;
    • Spending too much time in backstory; and
    • Using backstory as front story.

    Starting With Backstory

    We’ve all run into stories—maybe even written them ourselves—in which the author starts by explaining everything she feels the reader will need to know in order to “get” the story once it begins. I did that with the first drafts of my first book, The Eternity Plague, and ended up cutting out or drastically rewriting the first 100 pages.

    You know, of course, to start in medias res and filter the backstory in later.

    The next three techniques have an important element in common: they cause the reader to lose track of the primary story line. You don’t want a confused reader, unless you’re doing that just enough to keep pulling her through to the end, but that’s a pretty advanced technique and needs to be done with care. For our purposes here, confusing the reader is a bad thing.

    Using Backstory Too Often

    Using backstory too often is another case of the author wanting the reader to know everything she knows about the story, characters, setting, situation, etc. This time, the desire gets manifested as flashbacks or backstory details being inserted at every opportunity, whether they’re necessary or not. “Necessary” is the key word here. You, as the independent reviewer, aren’t emotionally invested in the story, so you have the ability to look at a detail, a flashback, even a whole chapter, and ask, “Do I need to know that?” The more often you find yourself asking that, the more likely it is the author is using backstory too much.

    Too Much Backstory

    Using backstory as front story and spending too much time in backstory mean the author isn’t clear on what information needs to be doled out in little pieces to deepen and enrich the story at key moments. Instead, he delivers info-dumps, which can take the form of lectures by the narrator, or speeches by characters, among others. I’ll discuss info-dumps, also known as expository lumps, in more detail in Part 42.

    Yes, deciding how much is too much can be subjective but again, if you lose track of the main story line, the author is guilty of this error.

    If the author is suffering from either of these problems, the flow of the story will come to a grinding halt as it wanders off into material that isn’t relevant to the story’s current moment. These aren’t quite the same things as tangents, which I’ll discuss in more detail in Part 26.

    Questions for You

    Here, then, are some questions you can ask yourself as you review someone’s work.

    • If you’re reading the beginning of a story or article, did the author start with background information that could have waited?
      • If so, where should the piece actually start?
      • What material could be removed? Where should it be moved to?
    • Is the author peppering me with so many background details that I get confused or lose track of the story line?
      • If so, what could be removed?
      • Can it be relocated, or should it be deleted entirely?
    • Later in the piece, is the author dumping information, either through the narrative or via her characters, and causing me to lose track of the storyline?
      • As before, what could be moved or removed?
      • Besides improving the story’s flow, how else would doing so improve the story?
    • Is the author spending so much time in backstory that I can’t tell what’s backstory and what’s front story anymore? In other words, has he lost track of his story?
      • What seems to be the main story, or what has he told you it’s supposed to be?
      • How can he return his and the reader’s focus to it?

    What other things do you look for when determining if backstory and/or flashbacks are being misused? You don’t need to repeat what I’ve discussed when you put your suggestions in the comments box below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 24—Unclear Transitions

    Blank directional signs
    Image courtesy of artur84 / FreeDigitalPhotos.net

    This article begins a series on flashbacks, flash-forwards, and backstory: that ancillary material that fills out a story and its characters by introducing information that doesn’t fit into the piece’s main flow. As with so many of the other subjects I’ve discussed, this topic applies to non-fiction as well as fiction.

    Before I get to flashbacks, etc., though, I need a transition: this post on transitions.

    What Is A Transition?

    A transition is a bridge, a connection between two pieces of a story, such as when the story changes:

    • Time, that is, moves into the future or past relative to the current moment;
    • Location;
    • Point-of-view or focus character, in other words, whose perspective the story is being told through or whom it is focused on;
    • Mood or tone;
    • Topic (particularly in non-fiction); or
    • Any combination of the above.

    This is not a complete list but focuses on the kinds of transitions you’ll see most often in fiction. Non-fiction transitions may be needed around such things as addition, comparison, effect, clarification, cause, and purpose, among many others.

    Transition Types, Words, and Phrases

    Transitions come in two types: hard or soft. Hard transitions are marked by a scene or chapter break. The presence of that break announces that a transition of some sort is about to happen.

    A soft transition occurs within a chapter or scene. Instead of having a physical marker, it’s denoted by either a verb tense change, an identifying word or phrase, or both.

    Verb tense changes depend on what tense the story is being told in.

    • If in past tense, a flashback or backstory usually shifts into past perfect tense: from “Bob went to the store” to “Bob had gone to the store.”
    • A present tense story would shift into past tense: from “Bob is going [or goes] to the store” to “Bob went to the store.”
    • Flash-forwards can shift into the future tense, the present tense, or even stay in the past tense but at a time ahead of where the flash-forward started. That could be really confusing, though, and would need to be marked by a transitional word or phrase as well.

    “Meanwhile, back at the ranch…” is probably one of the most famous examples of the transitional phrase—and one of the most clichéd—but notice how it marks both a clear shift in location and a subtle shift in time. “Meanwhile” indicates that something is happening at the same time as what the reader just read, but there may be a slight shift back in time to catch him up to the moment he just left.

    Some other transitional words or phrases are: earlier, at (as in “at the same time” or “at [another location]”), after or afterwards, once, and before. You can find lots of other examples of transitional words and phrases in articles on the University of Wisconsin and Brigham Young University web sites.

    There’s another important point here: backstory or a flashback or flash-forward needs two transitions: one into it and one back out of it.

    So what makes a transition unclear? Usually it’s failing to do one of the things I’ve been discussing: not inserting a scene or chapter break or transitional words or phrases, or not changing verb tense. As a reviewer, you’ll know the author messed up a transition when you find yourself confused by an unexpected shift. It’s a good bet this happened because the author knew what had changed but forgot to signal the reader.

    Questions for You

    When you have one of those “Wait… what?” moments, ask yourself these questions.

    • Where did the story change time, place, point of view, focus character, mood, tone, or topic without warning?
    • Did the author introduce backstory or a flashback or flash forward?
      • If so, where did that occur?
    • Where does that diversion end or where should it end? Is a transition missing there, too?
    • What kind of transitional device(s) should the author have used?

    Transitions ought to be easy to get right but they can catch even skilled writers from time to time.

    What else do you look for to spot unclear transitions? After you’ve arrived at the comment box below, you’ll be ready to type your answer.

  • Critique Technique Bonus Material — Read-Out-Loud Tools and Techniques

    We may not think of reading a work out loud as being a useful technique for critiquing a work, but it can be. Before a piece ever reaches a critiquer’s hands, though, authors can use the technique too. This article, then, is more for authors than critiquers, but both can benefit from it.

    If you’ve been writing for any time at all, you’ve heard the advice that you should read your work out loud, or have it read to you. The reason is, you’ll hear things go bump or clank in the text that you might not have discovered otherwise. Your brain processes information through different channels when it comes in through your ears as opposed to when it comes in through your eyes. That can be truly eye- (or should that be “ear-”?) opening.

    Like a lot of authors, I used to think I had a good mental ear for my writing, especially my dialogue. Then I read some of my work out loud. One reading was enough to tell me I was wrong. I’ve been a read-it-out-loud evangelist ever since. Nothing I write for publication—nothing—is “final” until I’ve read it out loud. It always changes. It’s taken some doing to get some of the members of my critique group to get the message, but when they do, they really do.

    The Tools

    There are many different ways to do this, some high-tech, some low-tech, some no-tech.

    • No-tech: Find a place where you can talk to yourself without getting funny looks, and then, go to it. I know some authors who even act out some of what’s in the text, although not the murder and mayhem. You’ll need a reduced sense of self-consciousness for this, no matter where you do it, even at home.
    • No-tech: Have an understanding or—even better—helpful spouse, significant other, or cat to listen to the work or read it to you. (OK, maybe not the cat. They’re too critical, if they’ll listen at all, and their diction isn’t so great if you want them to read the work to you. Not a dog, either—they’ll love anything you do.)
    • Low-tech to high-tech: A voice recorder of some kind: tape, digital, smart phone, etc. These can be awkward as you try to juggle manuscript pages, microphone, recorder, red pen, adult beverage (just kidding—maybe), and so on. I’ve used the free program Audacity, which is available for PCs, Macs, and Linux machines, to record all of these articles.

    The down-side of these techniques is that, even if they work—and they will—you still have to listen to the piece after you’ve recorded it, making for double work. And hearing your voice the way other people hear it takes some getting used to.

    Our voices sound different to ourselves because we not only hear the sound through our ears but through our bones. Recording software only “hears” what comes through the air to its microphone. The quality of the microphone and the acoustics of the room will have effects too.

    But while it may feel weird to hear your own voice this way, the more you do it, the more comfortable you’ll be with it, especially as you discover all the things you need to fix.

    • High-tech: Have your computer read the work to you. Both Windows and macOS have text-to-speech software built in.

    For many years, Microsoft and Apple word processing programs have had a read-aloud function. Today, many apps based on either Windows or macOS can take advantage of the operating systems’ convert-to-audio functions. This had to have been a huge savings in time and effort for the developers of free programs like OpenOffice, Libre Office, and others, since they no longer had to invest in developing the software to do it themselves. All they had to do was create the hooks that would connect their software to the operating system’s tool.

    Apps like Adobe Reader and the Kindle desktop do this too. The Kindle app lets you upload a PDF document, which it can then read to you.

    I don’t have the space to show you where to find this tool in whatever program or app you use—there are too many of them, and the location may change over time—so feel free to poke around in the software, use its Help function, or ask a friend or online.

    Word and Pages Speak

    To be honest, neither the Windows nor the Apple implementation is all that good. Both have trouble deciding how to pronounce words that can be spoken different ways. Should “live” be pronounced “liv” or “lyve,” for example? Or “read”: is it “reed” or “red?” Sometimes the software will get it right, sometimes it won’t. Pauses at commas are longer than they need to be, and some punctuation marks may be read aloud: the software may say “slash” when it encounters one. Inflections can be hit-or-miss; a question may not sound like a question. The default reading speed can be faster than normal speech (unless you’re from New York, maybe), although sometimes you can control the speed to some degree.

    Here are a couple samples, using Microsoft Word and Apple Pages to read the opening paragraphs of the Gettysburg Address.

    Here’s Word, using a voice named “Microsoft Mark.”

    And here’s Pages, using a voice named “Alex.”

    Did you notice that Apple even adds the sound of the narrator inhaling?

    Thanks to my friend Tina for sending me the Pages audio.

    All things considered, it’s pretty remarkable that computers can do this at all. At least it is to some of us. And as Dan Aykroyd said in his Elwood Blues persona, “Waddaya want for nothin’?”

    Do What Works Best for You

    For my money, reading the work aloud myself is still the best option. I can read it straight off the computer screen, make edits as I go, and check how well they flow and sound right away.

    It really doesn’t matter how you do it. Whether you take the DIY approach and read the work yourself, have someone read it to you, or turn the work over to your computer, reading a work out loud is a very powerful technique. If you’re an author, it’ll improve your work immeasurably. If you’re a critiquer, it can reveal both flaws and excellent work in ways reading it silently wouldn’t or didn’t.

    What’s your take on reading your work out loud? Do you do it yourself? If so, how? Do you have a favorite program or tool to read it for you? I don’t know if you can put an audio recording in the comments box below, so you may have to write it. Whichever you do, I’m looking forward to hearing from you, figuratively or literally.

  • Critique Technique, Part 23—Confused Storyline

    Green die with past, present, and future on faces
    Photo credit: Stuart Miles via freedigitalphotos.net

    I was originally going to title this article “Confused Timeline” but as I put my notes together I realized time isn’t the problem (other than me not having enough of it). Of course it’s important that a story flow in a logical sequence of events from its beginning to its end (with some exceptions I’ll get to in a moment), but that sequence doesn’t have to follow a time-linear order.

    In fact, more than likely, it won’t. Consider:

    • If there’s even one flashback, flash-forward, or instance of a character remembering something, the perfect time sequence is broken. This is true even if the story is written in the present tense.
    • Same thing if there are multiple plot lines or point of view characters. A story in which every POV shift also moved forward in time would be unusual because these storylines or characters’ lives run in parallel through the larger story. Jumping forward with each storyline or POV change necessarily leaves out things that happened.
    • Authors will skip events in order to conceal information from the reader or the characters, which builds tension.

    There’s also the special case of “experimental” fiction, where the author intentionally disregards time sequencing or other forms of logical flow for “artistic” purposes. These stories are not only a challenge to read, but to critique.

    But if time isn’t the organizing factor underlying a story’s plot, what is?

    It’s the logical development of the story, the piece-by-piece revelation of the major characters’ problems and responses, the way they take one step forward, one step sideways, two steps back, another step sideways, as they try to reach their goals. Yes, time is a factor—and an important one—in creating a “logical” sequence and structure in a story, but it may be necessary to jump around in time, rather than sticking to a strictly linear flow, to best tell the story.

    • Flashbacks, backstory, and memories can only happen by stepping back in time, then returning to the story’s present.
    • “Frame” stories start in a present time, step back for the core story, then step forward again for the concluding frame.
    • Flash-forwards step ahead in time, then drop back.
    • Multiple plot-line stories will jump back and forth to follow each line until they converge.

    Transitions and Scene Order

    It’s not the to-ing and fro-ing, then, that can be the problem, but how it’s all handled. Two interrelated factors—transitions and scene order—come into play here. The author may not realize that these factors are confused or confusing because she’s too close to the story and understands all the connections. Your job as the reviewer is to help her see what she didn’t before.

    Scene order is just what the term implies: a logical, but not necessarily time-driven, ordering of the scenes. I don’t want you to get too wrapped up in the meaning of the word “logical.” I’m not talking about formal, syllogistic logic here. What I mean is simply that the order in which the scenes appear neither leaves the reader confused about when and where the scene is taking place nor fails to build on the scenes that have preceded it. “Preceded” doesn’t have to mean “immediately before” for either multiple- or single-plot-line stories, just on some earlier page.  This is where transitions come in, if necessary, to connect the reader to that new time and place.

    Scene order can also refer to the placement of a device such as a flashback. While there may not be a formal scene or chapter break in the text when this kind of device starts and ends, there still needs to be some sort of transition at each end to signal those shift points.

    Transitions take several forms:

    • Chapter or scene headings, which can identify a specific date, time, and/or location;
    • Time-related words or phrases such as “meanwhile,” “two weeks earlier,” “on October 21st, 1933,” etc.;
    • Location-related words or phrases such as “in Paris,” “at the ballpark,” “in another room,” and so on;
    • Scene breaks;
    • Changes in verb tense; or
    • Combinations of these.

    Questions For You

    What questions should you be asking yourself as you evaluate a piece’s storyline? Try these.

    • When each scene starts, do I know where and when it’s taking place, both in absolute terms and relative to what I’ve read before?
      • If not, what information is missing? How could it be added?
    • Do the scenes appear in a sequence that allows the story to develop smoothly, or do I find myself being jerked back and forth for no apparent reason?
      • Remember that certain types of fiction will disregard this requirement. If this seems to be the case, you’ll need to determine if this was the author’s intent or if he did not understand the concept of dramatic development.
    • If the author uses some other device, like a flashback, memory, or frame, or introduces backstory, am I oriented to this new time and/or place when the device starts and when it ends and returns me to current story time?
      • Again, if not, what information is missing? How could it be added?
    • Does the author use transition devices effectively? Does she use them at all?
      • If not, where could she use them, or use better ones? What information do I need that I don’t have now?

    Now it’s your turn. What do you look for when evaluating the flow of a storyline? Be sure to get straight to the point in the comments box below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 22—Overly-Complex Plot

    Knotted ropes
    Photo credit: Boaz Yiftach via freedigitalphotos.net

    In a way it’s hard to say that a story’s plot is overly complex. Many stories have multiple plot lines, each with their own subplots, and yet the story “works”: the reader can understand what’s going on, the plot lines all make sense (eventually, anyway), and things come together at the end. Maybe the conclusion doesn’t tie everything together in a pretty bow—if the book is part of a series, it shouldn’t unless it’s the last one—but the story doesn’t end in a Gordian knot, either.

    So the question isn’t whether a story’s plot is too complex, but whether it’s too complex for the space allotted to it. Is there time for the various plot elements to be explored in enough depth and detail for them to all make sense? Or, did the author, in trying to craft a complex plot, simply try to do too much? Too many plot points or plot lines, too many characters, or any combination of these can turn what should have been a fascinating puzzle into a complete muddle.

    If You Can See It All

    If you’re reviewing a stand-alone piece—a short story or non-fiction article, for example—and you’ve got the whole thing in front of you, it’s easy enough to evaluate the plot. If it’s too complex, the piece may:

    • Feel rushed, as if the author is hurrying to cram everything in before the end; and/or
    • Not have a clear protagonist (or antagonist), or the characters who are supposed to fill these roles appear infrequently while the author chases other plot lines; and/or
    • Make you wonder why certain events or characters are included. Events may happen but then are never followed up on, or a character appears, and seems important, but then disappears; and/or
    • Contain other details that seem important but are never followed up on, or are contradicted later without reason; and/or
    • Leave you wanting to know more, with the sense that the author knew things she didn’t tell but should have; and/or
    • Leave you confused, not having gotten the information you needed to make sense of what you had, or overwhelmed you with too much information.

    Some of these points—such as leaving out key details which the reader is then supposed to pull out of the subtext or context—are techniques literary-fiction writers sometimes use, but that’s not what I’m talking about here. Creative non-fiction can use these techniques, too, but only with caution.

    Of course, you need to know what genre a story is a part of, whether fiction or non-fiction because different genres are more or less receptive to complex plots.

    If You Can Only See a Part of a Piece

    If you’re reviewing a part of a longer piece, such as one or several chapters of a novel, judging whether a plot is too complex for the space allotted to it is much more difficult. Each chapter and each story line has its own plot elements, of course, but they won’t necessarily be linked together yet. If you have an outline or synopsis of the entire book, you have a tool to evaluate a chapter’s complexity. If you’ve seen—and can remember the details of—previous chapters, that can also help.

    If not, you’re going to have to fall back on your own writer’s sense of what works. You can:

    • Discuss the story with the author;
    • Make notes to help keep track of the various plot lines; or
    • Flag events and details that don’t make sense or seem out of place to see if they’re justified, explained, or resolved later.

    There’s one other factor to consider, irrespective of story length or type: whether one or more plot lines are necessary to the story at all. This is a question that can generate a lot of angst and consternation in the writer because he may well consider every piece critical.

    Tough. You’re doing the author a big favor if you can demonstrate that the story will be better—tighter, clearer, more focused—if certain material is taken out. The thing is, you’ll need to be able to see the whole story, more than likely, to be able to make a strong case for this position. If you don’t have that information, you can at least discuss it with the author. (NOTE: “Spoilers” are not relevant in a critique setting. If you need the author to reveal how a story ends so that you can understand why a plot line or event is important, she needs to do that.)

    Questions For You

    Here are some questions to ask as you consider a piece’s plot complexity.

    • Can I see how each plot line and subplot contribute to the overall story?
      • If not, why not? What’s missing?
      • Can the author explain how this event or plot line will be important later?
    • Does the story, or the part I can see, feel rushed, as if too much is happening at once or without sufficient development or explanation?
    • Does the author seem to be trying too hard to create a complex plot?
      • If so, what can be removed or simplified to improve the story, and why?
    • If you can see the whole story:
      • Can a plot line or subplot be removed from the story without damage? Might doing so make the story better?
        • If so, how or why would that improve the story?
      • Are the relationships and connections among the plot lines clear, or made clear at appropriate times?
      • By the end of the story, did I feel I knew enough to make sense of it and its plot lines? Was information left out that left me confused when that was not the author’s intent?

    What do you use to evaluate whether a story’s plot is too complex or not? No need to get real complicated with your suggestions, but do put them in the comments box below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 21–Unclear Plot

    This is the first of a 3-part series on critiquing a story’s plot.

    Signpost: puzzled, unsure, confused, etc.
    Image courtesy of Stuart Miles / FreeDigitalPhotos.net.

    The basic concept of plot is simple: it’s the series of events that the characters experience and are involved in that builds in intensity, leading to the story’s climax and resolution. Every story—fiction or non-fiction—has one. In a so-called “literary” story, most of the “action” may be internal to the characters (emotional and/or psychological) rather than external. It may seem like there isn’t much plot, but there has to be some. At the other extreme, pick up any Tom Clancy novel and there’s tons of external activity—chases, explosions, spycraft, you name it—as well as internal action.

    The point of this post isn’t to examine ​how much​ plot there is, or how little, but whether what is going on makes sense. Plot events build on each other, doing those things I’ve written about before, such as providing conflict, creating tension, and putting obstacles in the characters’ ways. Every scene has its own set of plot points (the very briefest may have just one) that, if done right, build to a high point, then fall away to leave the reader wanting to know more. The same is true of each chapter, and of course of the entire story. These are the scene, chapter, and story arcs.

    Building Blocks That Don’t Build

    An unclear plot will fail to build that arc in one or more ways. Plot and characters are inseparable, so if the plot events seem unrelated to the characters’ goals, needs, desires, or conflicts, that may be a problem. Even in experimental fiction, events don’t happen truly at random or for no reason, they just may not happen in a linear sequence. The connection between a plot event and a character’s motivations may not be apparent right away, especially early in the story, but the author must eventually make that connection. Unfortunately, it may be hard, even impossible, for you to see it if the motivation isn’t revealed in the part of a longer piece you’re reading. As Les Edgerton notes in Hooked, the final pieces of the “story-worthy problem” may not be revealed until the very end. In that case, your discussion with the author about the plot events should reveal the link.

    Similarly, there might be no clear connection between individual events. Now, if the story contains several plot lines, some events on the different lines may never be connected, or the connection may not be apparent until later in the story. That’s fine. But within a plot line, unconnected, disjointed events will just confuse the reader. In a case like this, the author may know what the connection is but has failed or chosen not to show it on the page. Sometimes this is a good thing, because the way it surprises the reader can increase her tension and curiosity about the story. Again, this is something you’ll want to discuss with the author.

    Irrelevant events fall into the same category. If, for example, in the middle of a spy thriller, the protagonist waxes poetic about his Aunt Tillie’s prize-winning mac-and-cheese recipe, there’d better be a darn good reason for that. If there isn’t (and the excuse is likely to be, “it’s character development”), you need to flag it.

    In an early draft, especially if the author is a “pantser” (that is, someone who writes “by the seat of their pants”), they may be throwing literary mud against the wall to see what will stick. This kind of writing can be hard to evaluate productively because the author herself may not have any idea what the story’s overall structure will be or how the pieces will fit together. This is a good argument for not critiquing a story’s first draft.

    Also, plot events need to fall in some kind of logical order, but I’m going to save that discussion for Part 23.

    An unclear plot doesn’t build tension or move the story forward. Flashbacks and backstory can do that if they add a new wrinkle to the story or demonstrate a bit of a character’s motivation, but anything that stops or retards that forward motion, takes the story off on a tangent, or leaves it wandering is something you need to call to the author’s attention.

    Questions for You

    Here are some questions for you to ask about the plot as you read a piece.

    • Do the plot events relate to the characters’ goals, needs, desires, motivations, or conflicts?
      • If not, what’s missing? Will this be revealed later?
    • As best I can tell, are the plot events relevant to the overall story?
      • If not, why don’t they seem relevant? What don’t I understand?
    • Can I see the connections between the plot’s events?
      • If not, can the author explain their connections to me, or how those connections will be revealed later?
    • Do the plot events continue to make life more difficult for the characters in believable ways?
      • If not, what’s the problem? Are the characters’ situations not getting worse, or are they getting worse in unbelievable ways?
      • What does the author need to fix?
      • If a plot event solves a problem, does it create new ones?
    • Do the plot events make sense, or do they leave me wondering, in a bad way, what’s going on?
      • If I’m confused, what am I confused about?
    • Do the plot events continue to pique my interest and keep me reading?
      • If not, why not? What about these events caused me to lose interest, and why?

    A poorly constructed plot leaves the reader at sea without a paddle or sail. Writers don’t let writers plot badly. What do you look for when evaluating a plot for clarity? Plot out your clear suggestions in the comments box below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 20—Too Much Setting Detail

    Cluttered bedroom
    Image courtesy of Bill Longshaw / FreeDigitalPhotos.net

    The flip side of providing vague or insufficient setting detail is providing too much. Drowning the reader in the minutia of a setting not only kills the momentum of the story, it causes readers to lose track of the story. When they do that, they lose interest. For the lucky author, the reader will just skip ahead—a few times.

    Brace Yourself

    But for the unlucky author, or the one who insists on writing a description like this—deep breath—“the three green sateen ribbons on the head of the second Pekinese from the left, the one with the ghost-grey patch of fur on its back that looks just like a giraffe if you look at it from the right rear, which is hard to do because the dog insists on spinning around—always clockwise, never counterclockwise—to face you, but is now asleep in the brown wicker basket with the braided handle that Rosalee bought for just 50 cents at the neighborhood garage sale over in Johnsonville from that nice lady wearing the darling sundress with the purple and gold iris flower pattern that went so well with her blond hair, that was now sitting on the linoleum with the orange and white pattern of squares and triangles and the 6 inch diameter water stain reaching out from the far wall, in front of the oak veneer bookcase that Rosalee bought on sale for just half price at the dollar store because it was a display sample and they wanted to get rid of it, especially because the middle shelf was missing a couple of screws and so it sagged toward the back and she—Rosalee, not Janetta, the sales clerk with the gold teeth who always wears those big silver hoop earrings—hadn’t had time to go to Lowe’s to pick up the nickel-plated #10 by 1½” hex head screws that would be hanging in the rack down toward the end of aisle 13, up where she’d have to stand on her tippy-toes to reach them, in the dark blue plastic pouch that she found so convenient if hard to open, meaning she’d have to find those Fiskars scissors with the pretty pink plastic handles her Gramma Gemma had given her when she was just six and working on her Kindergarten Christmas card project—the one where she spilled Elmer’s glue and silver sparkles all over the sort-of-brand-new kitchen table—and still had and they were still sharp after all these years, but even after she fixed the shelf the bookcase would still be wobbly and she doubted she’d be able to get her collection of The Great Books with their wonderful brown leather covers embossed with real gold and that still smelled real good, like an old saddle maybe, or Aunt Barbara’s fancy coat with the long sleeves that she wouldn’t wear in the winter because it would get wet, if you put your nose up real close, to stay in it because it would probably collapse in a heap”—that author is going to have the reader throwing the book across the room.

    If they don’t fall asleep first.

    And that wasn’t even a good bad example!

    Over-describing anything—the setting; a character’s features, personality, motivations, or clothing; the past events that led up to the current moment (a.k.a. backstory); etc.—is a sign that the author doesn’t trust the reader to be able to fill in these details, or trust herself to tell the story clearly enough. Unfortunately, over-compensating does not solve the problem.

    The point, of course, is that somewhere between that 423-word mass of details and “the bookcase,” there’s a balance point at which the author has given the reader enough information to build the rest of the scene in his head. The fact that the scene he sees with his mind’s eye won’t be—can’t be—exactly the same scene the author saw with hers doesn’t matter, so long as he knows what’s important about the setting.

    Your Challenge

    The challenge for you as a reviewer is to determine whether or not a particular setting detail—or a whole bunch of them—is important or even necessary. The author may be planting that detail now even though its importance won’t be evident until later. That’s a favorite technique in mystery stories. Or, lots of details may be important for establishing the environment, beyond the immediate moment of the story. Pick up an early Tom Clancy novel, for example, and you’ll find a story rich in details, such as of the close confines, the equipment, the displays, the sounds, and the men in the sonar room of a submarine.

    Questions For You

    Here are a few questions you can ask yourself as you review someone’s work.

    • Are there so many details that they kill the story’s forward progress?
    • Do the details provide information but not knowledge? That is, do they tell me things, but I don’t understand why I’m being told them?
    • Are there so many setting details that I lose track of the story?
    • Are there so many details that I stop caring about the story and its characters?

    If the answer to any of these questions is yes, be sure to tell the author about what you’ve seen and suggest ways they might remove or compress details to make the story better.

    What other things cue you to the fact that the author is providing too much setting information? Go ahead and provide all the details you want in the comments box below.