Author: Ross Lampert

  • Science Education: Experiential Learning

    With school out across most of the state (except for year-round schools), the Arizona legislature out until next January, and the state school board keeping a tight rein on the superintendent, for now the attacks on science education here have mostly stopped. For that happy reason, I want to talk about a more pleasant topic: experiential learning in STEM (science, technology, engineering, and mathematics) education.

    I am more than a little jealous of today’s students, especially in the STEM fields. They have opportunities today that I could not even dream of when I was their age in the 1960s and ‘70s. While, sadly, these opportunities are not available everywhere, where they do exist, they’re often simply amazing. And we’re not talking about at just the high school or college level, but all the way down to Kindergarten in some cases.

    Hands On, Brains On

    Anybody who’s raised kids, or just watched them, knows that they’re experiential learners. Tell a child not to do something and what are they likely to do? Do it! While this is an ongoing source of frustration for parents—“What were you thinking?”—it’s a reflection of a lot of things, including that kids—and all of us, really—learn some things best when we do them ourselves. Reading about it in a book, watching a video, seeing a demonstration; those are fine. But doing it? That’s something else entirely.

    Call it “hands on, brains on.” Active participation means more involvement, more concentration, more focus… more learning.

    Sure, when I was a kid, we had hands-on stuff in science classes, but we were simply replicating what had been done thousands, if not millions of times before. Maybe that’s OK for establishing basic principles, but there was little hope of discovery: the results were not just expected, they were pre-ordained, even at the college level.

    Today, elementary and middle school kids are participating in programs like FIRST LEGO League. As they progress into high school, they advance to FIRST Robotics. (FIRST is an acronym for “For Inspiration & Recognition of Science & Technology.”) In these programs, the student teams are given a task and a box of supplies and have to build and program a robot to do specific tasks. That’s about all there is in the way of instructions: “Use these bits and pieces to create a device that will do these tasks. Good luck.” Now, of course, the kids don’t go into this project cold; they get lots of training and education along the way, but the programs release their inner creativity and imagination as they figure out how to apply the principles they’ve been introduced to.

    CyberPatriot logoThe Air Force Association (I’m a member) sponsors two programs of its own: CyberPatriot and StellarXplorers. In CyberPatriot, middle- and high-school students learn about computer network security principles and practices, and then have to figure out how to fix simulated networks that have been infected by real-world malware. The Today Show recently did a segment on an all-girls CyberPatriot team.

    In StellarXplorers, high schoolers are tasked to design something like a satellite that has to pass over a certain spot on the earth every X number of days in order to be able to take photos of a certain resolution under specific lighting conditions. That means designing the satellite’s structure, the payload, the booster, and the orbit while staying within weight and cost limits.

    These are tasks that real-world computer scientists and rocket scientists have to do!

    At my alma mater, the University of Colorado-Boulder, students as young as freshmen participate in real research projects. The engineering college has its own “maker space” in which the students design and create devices using 3D printers and other tools. CU-Boulder is by no means unique in this regard: maker spaces exist in schools all the way down to the elementary level.

    Oh, to be a kid again, right?

    The Need and the Payoff

    What’s sad is that not every child has access to these kinds of programs. Maker spaces and the FIRST programs can cost a lot of money. Sponsorships are available but teachers and administrators have to know about them, be able to apply for them, have the support of their districts and communities for them, and perhaps most important of all, be able to spend the time with their students on them, rather than having to concentrate on discipline and even just getting the students into the school building.

    Yet if the kids come to school and get into one of these programs, the changes can be remarkable, even literally life-changing. Participating in these programs and having success teaches girls and kids of color that they, too, along with the white and Asian boys, can succeed in these fields. They, too, have the ability to do the work. And oh, by the way, this stuff can be fun!

    And when the experience of learning is fun, amazing things happen. That’s the added form of experiential learning that needs to get more attention.

    In a nation that is falling farther and farther behind its competitors in the STEM fields, not just in education but in the workforce, this is a change that can’t happen soon enough.

  • Science Education Under Attack: Are Religion and Science Mutually Exclusive?

    There has probably always been tension, if not outright conflict, between science—or what was considered science at the time—and religion. Each offered people some degree of explanation of how the world worked and some feeling of control, or at least influence, over the events in their lives. And there was, of course, a third source of conflict: government, at least when organized religion and organized government were separate entities.

    Religion and government have always sought to control the behaviors of individuals and groups, whereas science generally has not, at least not directly. Governments have sometimes tried to use “scientific” explanations or rationales for certain behaviors or policies, such as eugenics under the Nazis in the early to middle 20th century. I am not aware, however, of any group of scientists who tried to form a government or a religion, the Churches of Scientology, Religious Science, and Christ, Scientist notwithstanding. (None of these actually use science in ways traditional scientists would recognize, and none were founded by practicing or former scientists.)

    While the Catholic Inquisition sought to suppress science, including forcing Galileo to recant his discovery that the earth was one of several planets that revolved around the sun, rather than being the physical center of the universe, the Society of Jesus (the Jesuits) have contributed significantly to a number of scientific fields since the 17th century.

    Science Versus “The Impossible”

    The Renaissance, the Enlightenment, and then the Industrial Revolution certainly added to these tensions as scientists began exploring everything on earth and beyond in systematic ways, and engineers and other technologists turned what the scientists learned into practical devices that could do things that would previously have been considered miraculous or even impossible.

    F/A-18 breaking the sound barrier
    F/A-18 breaking the sound barrier

    To take just one example, consider the statement, “If God had meant man to fly, He would have given him wings.” Yet the aerodynamic property of lift, which the Wright brothers harnessed in their experiments leading to powered flight by heavier-than-air vehicles, traces its lineage back to the founding principles of fluid dynamics, which supposedly started with Daniel Bernoulli watching globs of vomit flow around obstacles in the waters of the canals of Venice. You can’t get much more pedestrian than that for the roots of something “miraculous!”

    The Conflict Today

    So why do science and religion remain in conflict today? And should they be? There are, it seems to me, a number of reasons for the enduring conflict.

    First, religion sees science as a threat to its primacy and power. The more “miraculous” things science can explain, the less mystery there is in the ordinary world and thus the fewer things that can be ascribed to a supreme being or power. While a sunset is no less beautiful when it is explained as light refracting through the water droplets that make up the clouds, it is less miraculous: some god is no longer painting the colors in the sky. The same is true for the colors of a flower petal or a butterfly wing. Mechanical or biological processes produce a different, and to some, a lesser kind of wonder because they provide an explanation for what we term beauty.

    Science, on the other hand, sees religion as so much hand-waving. Modern scientific methods rely on asking questions—often highly specific questions—that can be answered by making measurements and analyzing the results. Whether the increments of the measurements are microns or megaparsecs is irrelevant here; what matters is that the thing or process being studied can be evaluated in numerical terms. Even the most human of sciences, psychology and sociology, rely on group studies to gather reams of data that can then be subjected to statistical analyses.

    But how does one measure God? What questions can one ask, what experiment can one design, to come up with some kind of measurable data points? The problem is not a matter of scale; we can, after all, study galaxies and clusters of galaxies, which are far larger than any human. The problem is first coming up with something to measure, something about which we can gather answers that are quantifiable. The second problem is actually taking those measurements. Scientists have not been able to do either, even if they were interested in doing so.

    I could argue, and religious people may, that this measurability requirement is a fundamental weakness or failing of science, but if so, what is its alternative?

    The problem is also not a matter of complexity. The more deeply scientists study a subject, whether it’s human physiology or the ecology of a rain forest, the more complex it becomes. If scientists fail here—and they often do—it’s because their focus becomes narrower and narrower as they study finer and finer details, rather than looking at how the particular thing they’re studying fits into, affects, and is affected by, the larger environment in which it exists. There are some scientists who look at whole systems, or systems of systems, rather than individual elements, but they’re relatively few.

    Different Starting Points

    As I noted at the beginning, religion and science have the same goal—to understand and explain our world to us—but they approach their task from different starting points. Religion’s approach is top-down, starting with the highest possible power or explanation and working downward to the world in which we live. Religion’s problem has been that as one comes down from that highest level, the explanations become less and less specific—“God willed it so”—and so the world around us becomes a vast collection of “black boxes” whose workings, and the reasons for them, are shrouded in mystery and mysticism.

    Atomic cloud
    An atom is a cloud of probabilities

    Science, on the other hand, takes a bottom-up approach, starting, or trying to start, from the most basic fundamentals and working upward. The problem for science has been that it has yet to find that bottom. At one time, atoms were thought to be the fundamental physical particles. Then physicists discovered that atoms had components, the sub-atomic particles like protons, neutrons, and electrons. Then they discovered that these particles too had components: quarks and gluons, among others. Add to that confusion Einstein’s discovery that mass and energy are interchangeable—one can become the other—and the “fundamental” particle or force becomes even harder to identify with certainty.

    Religion and science both seek to create an orderly structure and rational explanation for how the world works and why it is the way it is. Both are only partially successful because randomness is always present. Religion tries to explain seemingly random events by saying that they’re part of God’s greater plan, which humans are not privy to. Science, on the other hand, simply accepts randomness as part of the nature of the universe: Schrödinger’s cat is both dead and alive, or neither dead nor alive, until someone opens its box and checks. Neither of these approaches is particularly comforting to the person who’s on the receiving end of some unexpected negative event, whether a diagnosis of a serious disease, a home destroyed by a volcano, or simply getting caught in a rainstorm.

    Mutually Exclusive or Mutually Supporting?

    These problems do not automatically mean that science’s view of the world and religion’s are mutually exclusive. Indeed, science can contribute to the wonder ascribed to the world by religion. The more variety, detail, and complexity science discovers, the more amazing and wonderful the world can and should seem. Religions could use this vast complexity, flexibility, and creativity to illustrate the incomprehensibly great powers of whatever supreme being they believe in. Just the variety of environments in which life exists here on earth—from tens of thousands of feet above sea level to tens of thousands of feet below it, from temperatures above the boiling point of water to temperatures below its freezing point, from the oceans to the driest lands—should illustrate this. Yet I have not come across a religion that routinely does this. Scientists do sometimes step back from what they’re studying to contemplate the bigger picture, but not enough and not often enough.

    In the end, science and religion do not have to be, and are not, automatically incompatible. Religion does not have to stand in the way of the teaching of science, seeing it as a threat. Scientists do not need to reject out of hand religion’s attempts to explain the unexplained simply because religion does not follow science’s methods. What’s needed is more and better communication between religion and science to bridge the gaps and seek to build understanding and respect.

     

  • Science Education Under Attack—Politics

    So far I’ve stayed away from discussing politics in these posts because, like religion, it’s a kind of “third rail,” something that if you touch, it’s going to hurt you. But on the other hand, it’s the elephant in the room. Between the federal Department of Education and state legislatures and education departments or boards, education funding, and the politics that comes with it, is bound to have a role. It’s simply unavoidable.

    It’s also nearly impossible to take a politically neutral stance on the issue, and although I’m going to try to thread that needle I don’t expect to fully succeed. The hole in the needle gets even narrower when the role religion plays in some politicians’ beliefs gets factored in.

    History and Politics

    A twisted, two-ended red pencil
    Image courtesy FreeDigitalPhotos.net.

    According to a Wikipedia article, the federal government has had an office or department with a specific interest in education since 1867, although until the creation of the Department of Health, Education, and Welfare (HEW) in 1953, it rarely and only briefly had cabinet-level status. In 1979, HEW was split into the Department of Health and Human Services and the Department of Education. Then and since, Republican federal legislators and even presidents have opposed the federal department and have repeatedly tried but failed to eliminate it.

    Programs and laws like “Common Core” and the No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB) initially started with bipartisan support. The Common Core set of math and English language educational standards was developed in 2010 under the auspices of the National Governors Association, a bipartisan group of state governors.

    Some conservative federal and state legislators who believed strongly in local control saw Common Core as a federal intrusion into what local school districts should be deciding, including what to teach and how to teach it, even though, as a set of standards, Common Core only established what skill levels students should reach by certain grades, not how schools and teachers would help them get there.

    Similarly, after the Obama Administration tried to tie federal education funding to school performance under some NCLB requirements, conservatives objected to what they saw as another example of federal overreach and intrusion into local decision-making. NCLB was eventually scrapped.

    I’m not here to argue how much or how little influence or control the federal government should have in local decisions. It is interesting to note, however, that some of the same state legislators and regulators who argue against federal intrusion, as they see it, have no problem imposing their own rules, standards, and beliefs on their state’s school districts. Attempts to end, directly or by stealth, the teaching of evolution, for example, happen this way. It’s also how state funding for schools gets cut, as conservative legislators seek to curtail or completely block what they see as the teaching of “Liberal values” that they don’t share. The hypocrisy is as depressing as it is obvious.

    Political Action

    The poorly-paid teachers in some states, Arizona among them, finally decided they’d had enough this year and have forced governors and state legislatures to substantially increase school funding. But how long will this effort, and its effects last? The #RedforEd movement had a moment in the sun this spring, in a few states, but there’s little sign so far that it will have any far-reaching effects.

    Some teachers have decided to run for office in their state legislatures, almost always as Democrats, in states where the legislatures are Republican controlled. Single-issue candidates have a hard time winning general elections, even if they succeed in the primaries. And if they are elected, they have to deal with the whole range of issues a legislature faces, including the political and budget trade-offs that have to be made. Or aren’t made, and then nothing gets done. Or, if it’s large enough, the majority party runs roughshod over the powerless minority. These teachers run that risk and could end up doing little more than shouting into the wind.

    Running as Republicans might seem at first to be an alternative strategy. The challenge of winning the primary vote is even greater, though, given who votes in the primaries and state rules that often limit who can vote in them.

    There’s another factor at work here. Partisans of every stripe see every issue through the lens of their political leanings. The responses to information about global climate change are the most obvious example. The farther right one goes on the political spectrum, the more likely it is that a person, whether a legislator, think-tanker, or ordinary citizen, will see climate change as a Nancy Pelosi/Hillary Clinton/Bernie Sanders/pick-your-most-hated-Democrat-created pseudo-crisis whose only purpose is to increase government intrusion into the lives of individual citizens. Or that scientists are making it all up for their own purposes. The facts and the science get lost in the arguments over who believes what and what their motives are.

    The impact of this kind of attitude should be clear. If science doesn’t matter, if scientists are seen to be political hacks who bend their conclusions to fit their politics, then kids can be discouraged from studying science, or may not even be able to study it in full due to politically-imposed restrictions, and thus may be discouraged from exploring science as their adult vocation.

    What’s Next?

    So what’s the solution? Is there one?

    There’s no silver bullet, no single approach that’s going to solve everything. There are, however, certain things that can help. For one, the #RedforEd movement needs to continue through the fall election season and into next year, when state legislatures meet to build their states’ budgets. And it needs to continue far beyond the spring of 2019. Science teachers need to stand up not only for decent pay and adequate resources, but for the ability to teach real science, not pseudo-science.

    For another, scientists need to get out of their labs, come in from their field studies, and talk with ordinary people, in terms and time-frames they can understand, about how science directly affects their lives every day. For some fields, like cosmology, particle physics, and fundamental mathematics, this is tough, but it needs to be done.

    In both of these cases, the educators and scientists need to recognize that, especially when they’re speaking with some politicians (and they need to know in advance who these people are), the scientific facts don’t matter much, if at all. What matters is that politician’s world view: how they see the world, what factors are important to them, including perhaps what their religion tells them is true. Do these politicians, deep down, believe that science is bad because it intrudes into God’s realm? Does it explore things that man should not know? Or does it simply contradict what the Bible says, or what they think it says?

    Addressing those kinds of attitudes and beliefs will be an even greater challenge than explaining cosmology to a shoe salesman. But it must be done if science education is going to not only survive, but thrive, in America’s schools.

    Your Thoughts

    I may be taking a risk by asking for your thoughts, but I can’t hide that Comments box below. What do you think? Is politics, particularly “conservative” politics, naturally inimical to science education?

  • “A Chain of Events” Review

    4 star rating

     

     

    I’ve known, since even before I reluctantly purchased this book in the early 2000s, that it would be a difficult read. That’s why it sat, unopened, on a bookshelf in three different houses, until now. In part, the reason might be obvious from author Joan Piper’s subtitle: “The Government Cover-up of the Black Hawk Incident and the Friendly-Fire Death of Lt. Laura Piper.” The other reasons require some up-front disclosure.

    • I am a retired Air Force officer.
    • I was a Mission Crew Commander (MCC) on the E-3 Airborne Warning and Control System (AWACS) aircraft.
    • On the date of the shoot-down of the two Black Hawk helicopters over northern Iraq—April 14, 1994—I was deployed to Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, to fly missions enforcing the southern no-fly zone over Iraq for Operation Southern Watch/Desert Calm, the counterpart to Operation Provide Comfort (OPC).
    • In July 1994, when the first investigation report was released, I was deployed to Incirlik Air Base, Turkey, to fly OPC missions. I was in the audience at the base theater when the report was briefed to the aircrews there the evening before it was released to the public.
    • I knew slightly both of the MCCs who were on the AWACS crew the day of the shoot-down, and have since gotten to know one of the senior officers involved in the decisions on who to prosecute or not. I did not know the one AWACS officer who was ultimately court-martialed but declared innocent by the jury.

    In other words, this is personal, although nowhere near as personal as it was for Piper and the other Black Hawk families.

    A Chain of Events should not be seen as a definitive history of the shoot-down and subsequent investigations and the events surrounding them. It is appropriately categorized as a memoir, a personal history of the Piper family’s struggles to understand what happened to their daughter Laura and to seek “accountability” for her death. The Pipers’ fully-understandable pain over their loss (and the deaths of the other 25 people, from three other nations plus ethnic Kurds, who were on the two helicopters), which never should have happened, comes through loud and clear. The Pipers’ anger and frustration over how the various investigations into the shoot-down were handled, in particular how information was allegedly kept out of the reports or away from the investigators, decision-makers, and court-martial jury, and how other investigations were allegedly stymied by the Air Force leadership and Washington politics, also comes through.

    Sometimes that anger takes an ugly turn. During Piper’s relating of the events surrounding the court-martial of Captain Jim Wang, she cites medical information revealed during the trial to suggest that he was mentally unstable. Elsewhere in this same chapter, she suggests, on the basis of flimsy evidence, that Captain Eric Wickson, the lead F-15 pilot that day and the individual likely most responsible for the 26 deaths, had Tourette Syndrome, something she was not qualified to diagnose. [My attempts to get more information from my local flight surgeon’s office on whether Tourette’s would disqualify someone from flight duties were ignored.] While such allegations reflect the depths of her anger and pain, the ad hominem attacks hurt her case, for which she has plenty of other evidence.

    That aside, Piper is to be commended for having the courage to write this account. She was willing to be the public face of the American Black Hawk families, to be interviewed repeatedly by the press, and to ultimately write the book. She was uniquely placed, perhaps, to do so. Her husband Danny had key connections to people on the inside of several of the investigations, and so the Pipers were able to get access to information that others could not have gotten, and possibly to even have influence on the direction of at least the investigation led by Senator William Roth. As such, she was able to shine a light into places that might not have been revealed otherwise. But it is only a spotlight, because she did not have total access to the decision-makers. She at times speculates without proof on their motives and the forces driving them. A complete historical account would have included that information, but that was not the purpose of this book.

    At several places in the book, Piper states that she did not want anyone involved in the shoot-down to go to jail; all she wanted was “accountability.” This makes me wonder what her real desires were. In other cases of undeserved death, surviving family members talk about wanting accountability or “justice.” What do those terms really mean? Are these people afraid to actually say that they want the perpetrators punished? If so, why?

    Late in the book, Piper quotes Fyodor Dostoevsky in The Brothers Karamazov: “Above all, don’t lie to yourself. The man who lies to himself and listens to his own lie comes to such a pass that he cannot distinguish the truth within him, or around him, and so loses all respect for himself and for others.” The target of the quote is the leadership of the Air Force at the time. However, it is hard but fair to ask, in the context of “accountability,” if the quote does not also apply to her.

    At the end of the book, Piper says she’d achieved “closure,” another popular but vague term, regarding her daughter’s death. I wonder if, almost 25 years after the incident, she still feels that way, or what “closure” means to her now.

    Not only is there no happy ending to this story, there’s really no ending at all. I know of one other book on the shoot down, Army Lieutenant Colonel Scott Snook’s Friendly Fire, which I have not yet read. A quick scan suggests it is an organizational psychology evaluation of the actions and decision-making around the actual shoot-down but does not address the larger issues Piper raises. My own experiences, and the story told in this book, make one thing clear: while there was a “chain of events” that led to this unnecessary tragedy, there was an even larger chain of failures—of skill, of professionalism, of integrity—at many levels and over a longer timeline than Piper discusses, which pervades and drives the entire story.

    The full story has yet to be told, and it may never be, which would be a loss not only for the families of the victims but also for the United States Air Force as a whole.

    In the end, despite its flaws, A Chain of Events does a service to the victims, the U.S. Air Force, and America at large for revealing what it does.

     

  • Science Education Under Attack—The Language Barrier

    In my first article in this series, I wrote about how certain groups were attacking evolution and the “big bang” as “only” theories and how the word theory means something different to scientists than to everyone else. But this isn’t the only case where words have different meanings within and outside of science. This time the fault lies within the scientific community, rather than with those who oppose teaching legitimate science to children for allowing the confusion to continue, or for making it worse.

    There are two related problems here: technical jargon and unique meanings for common words.

    Technical Jargon

    Confusion Jargon is a problem in every line of work. In every instance, the jargon term was selected or came into use either because it was the most accurate way to describe something, or because it was handed down through the generations from a time when its original meaning was well understood.

    A common example of the first case comes from medicine. One doesn’t have a “heart attack,” one has a myocardial infarction. Myo- refers to muscle and cardial refers to the heart. Dictionary.com defines an infarct as “a localized area of tissue, as in the heart or kidney, that is dying or dead, having been deprived of its blood supply because of an obstruction by embolism or thrombosis,” so an infarction is the death or killing of that tissue. But what the heck is a thrombosis—some kind of weird musical instrument? No, it’s a blood clot… sorry, an “intravascular coagulation of the blood.” The deeper we dig, the more jargon we uncover.

    Medicine is by no means alone in this. Botany has its phyla and genera and species. Genetics has it genomes and proteomes and regulomes. Physics its quarks and WIMPs. And on and on.

    One Word, Many Meanings

    Those terms are bad enough, but what about when a common word has a special meaning that doesn’t connect with any in common usage? In construction, a cricket is a kind of sloped structure on an otherwise flat roof that guides water toward some way off of the roof. In literary analysis, formal has nothing to do will ball gowns or tuxedos, but with the form of a piece of writing: poetry or prose, fiction or non-fiction.

    This is where “theory” runs into trouble. Similarly for mole, solution, and basic in chemistry, respectively a unit of measure, a mixture of two or more substances where none are chemically changed, and the opposite of acidic. The opportunities for confusion are endless.

    Say What?

    George Bernard Shaw (not Sir Winston Churchill) famously described England and America as “two countries separated by the same language.” That’s what’s happening here. All of these words are used to express something very specific within their context, but to the lay person who doesn’t understand the context, they confuse rather than clarify. This is where scientists too often fail. They forget, when speaking to the general public, that they’re speaking in what amounts to a foreign tongue. The terms they use are so natural—to them—and their meanings are so clear—to them—that they forget that their audience doesn’t share their knowledge and understanding. (This is not, of course, a problem just for scientists. A civilian talking to a military person will soon be lost in the forest of acronyms and special terms that are unique not just to the military or even that branch of service, but to the speaker’s specialty.)

    But once that barrier is unwittingly erected, hostility and rejection are not far behind. So when scientists, or science educators, lapse into jargon with a member of the general public, they shouldn’t be surprised by the glazed-over eyes and the refusal to support whatever the scientist or educator is proposing, like, say, evolution or teaching evolution.

    Oh, I Get It!

    The solution to this problem is easy enough to describe, but harder to do: speakers need to be aware of their own jargon, of who they’re speaking to, and of the fact that they may not share the same set of definitions, then make an effort to use the terms both share. While this won’t solve all of the conflicts between those who support teaching science to children, it will help, at least a little.

     

  • Critique Technique, Part 3: How Do You Feel?

    New members of a critique or writers’ group will often say, “I don’t know how to critique.” The tendency, I suspect, is to think they have to do what they did in high school or college English classes: identify and explain the symbolism in a passage, say, or compare and contrast the use of metaphor with onomatopoeia.

    Nope! Nope, nope, nope. That’s not what critique or writers’ group feedback is about. It’s about helping the author get better by identifying what worked, what didn’t, and why.

    How Do You Feel?

    Let’s start with the easiest thing: how did the piece make you feel? Did it:

    • excite you
    • anger you
    • make you happy
    • make you sad
    • confuse you
    • fascinate you
    • annoy you
    • thrill you
    • bore you
    • make you giggle
    • make you swear
    • make you stay up all night thinking about it
    • make you throw it across the room
    • make you want to bang your head against the wall
    • something else entirely
    • all of the above
    • some of the above
    • none of the above?

    Note that it could have done many of these things. Even a four line poem can do this—and a really good one will.

    Whatever it might have done, capture that emotion—write it down in your comments: “This piece made me feel X” (and maybe Y and Z and A and…).

    A Two-Track Mind

    This requires a bit of self-awareness, a kind of second track running in your mind as you’re reading that’s taking note of your responses to the story. It can take some practice to develop, but doing so will pay big dividends because everything else in this series will also depend on that second train of thought running on that parallel track, taking notes, as it were.

    So, once you’ve noticed those emotional responses to the piece, the next question to ask is, “Why did it make me feel that way?”

    Ah, now the fun begins. Now you get to start really analyzing the work.

    WAIT! Come back! This isn’t scary! Really it’s not. But to let your heart rate get back down to normal, we’ll save that topic for next time.

    Your Thoughts

    Meanwhile, do have any suggestions on how a new critiquer can develop or improve their awareness of their response to a piece while they’re reading it? If so, please put them in the Comments box at the end of the post.

  • Children of the Thunder Review

     

     

     

    Dark, dystopian, and deeply flawed. And yet….

    Author John Brunner’s late 20th century England is a mess: the economy is collapsing, environmental degradation is rampant, the government is corrupt, religious fundamentalists are taking over, and a renegade general is advocating xenophobia and racism at home and nuclear war abroad. Things in the U.S. are similar, minus the general. Meanwhile, Japan and continental Europe are doing fine, or better.

    Peter Levin is a freelance reporter. Few newspapers will buy his work and they are in danger of closing. Claudia Morris is an American sociologist. She made her name with a provocative book, but she now thinks she might have gotten her thesis wrong, and has come to England on sabbatical to do research and write a new book. She and Levin had met previously, and they meet up again.

    Meanwhile, a baker’s dozen of just past puberty children scattered across the British Isles and in Italy have discovered that they have the power to control the people around them, and they’re wielding that power to get everything they want, including the deaths of those who threaten them.

    And here’s where the first flaw shows up. Brunner tells the story of all but one of the children while Levin and Morris meet. Levin fumbles around trying to find paying work while she struggles to keep the funding for her studies coming. There’s little evidence of a connection between the Levin/Morris story line and those of the children for well over half of the book. A science fiction reader will trust the author to eventually bring parallel story lines together, and Brunner eventually does, but even then, the children seem to be of secondary interest Levin and Morris. The early portions of the book are such a disjointed mess that it’s often tempting to put the book down.

    Other flaws: Written in the mid-1980s, the book seems to have been created in haste for the domestic British market, and so was not “translated” into American English for this publication. (My copy of Children is the first of three books collected into one hardback.) For someone like me who’s worked with Britons, this isn’t much of a problem, but for others, even the non-slang terms will cause American readers to stumble.

    Speaking of slang, Brunner chose to create a whole new set of slang and swear words for his characters. It turns out that he did not make up the words he chose, they were terms from previous eras, some quite obscene in their original usage. This wouldn’t be much of a problem except that Levin, the children, and even the American Dr. Morris, who, by the way, is also a Jewish lesbian, swear like sailors. It’s annoying and unnecessary.

    As a writer, I notice dialogue tags. Writers today are taught to use very few: said, asked, thought, maybe one or two others. Brunner, however, resorts to what are called “Tom Swifties,” after the Tom Swift adventure novels, in which each dialogue tag is overdone and accompanied by an adverb to overdo them even more. Brunner’s characters shout angrily, exclaim excitedly, growl menacingly, and so on. It’s annoying tremendously.

    And yet, for all this, I kept reading. The story picks up once Levin and Morris hear about the kids. With the help of Levin’s estranged teenage daughter, who comes to live with him after her mother is killed by a plane crash in her neighborhood, they start to investigate the children. One of the children brings all but two of the others to live with him. He kills the Italian boy because he’s a potential rival. The other child (spoiler alert) is Levin’s daughter, and she’s in cahoots with the rest of them.

    Levin and Morris suspect that these children were all created via artificial insemination (referred to by the British slang term “artinsem”) with sperm from a single donor, so they try to find him. It turns out (more spoilers) that Levin, who was also a sperm donor as a young man, is that man, something that’s only revealed at the end of the book, when the children show him their amoral, power-mad nature and ultimate plans to take over the world, by among other things, making Levin father more of them, including with Morris.

    In true dystopian fashion, the bad guys (the kids) win, and the person we thought was the good guy (Levin) is in fact at fault for the whole mess.

    It’s a tribute to Brunner’s skill as a writer that he was able to keep me interested in such a flawed work all the way to the end, but in the end the flaws drive the rating down, although to a higher score than I first thought I would give it.

  • Fancies and Goodnights Review

    3-star rating

     

     

    I had been looking forward to reading this collection of short stories for literally over ten years. I was first introduced to it via one of its stories, “Are You Too Late or Was I Too Early,” while taking classes for my Master’s Degree in the mid-2000s. That brief story, with its never-saw-it-coming twist ending, enchanted me. And Ray Bradbury, my all-time favorite author, wrote the introduction. How could I not enjoy the other 49 stories?

    Well, it turns out that the book in total, and the individual stories, were less than I had hoped. To be clear, John Collier was a very skilled writer. Even though the stories were all written in the 1930s and 1940s (the book was first published in 1951), each one is tight and clean, not a word wasted. But they are uniformly dark, which became tiring. Virtually all of the characters are scoundrels, and if the protagonists were not done in by their own weaknesses and failings, they were defeated by antagonists who were even worse scoundrels than the protagonists.

    Almost all of the stories have a twist ending, and not an O. Henry kind of twist. It became a kind of game to try to guess the actual ending. Once I realized that virtually every story was going to have that twist, I started picking out the clues Collier would leave that presaged the end. But there was little satisfaction in guessing right, or nearly so. Few endings provided a real surprise.

    Oddly, there was one set of stories that did not have twist endings, and even showed a wry sense of humor missing from the others. These stories all included the Devil, and in each case, the protagonist triumphed, unlike the other stories, and Old Scratch got his comeuppance.

    The stories reflect the attitudes and beliefs of the time when they were written. Racism is casual and common. Women are either harpies and dangerous, or stereotypical housewives, naïve and ignorant servants of their husbands.

    And then there’s the cover (not Collier’s fault), a bizarre, bilious green dreamscape of men wearing ice skates, overcoats, and fedoras, and carrying overlong hockey sticks, that has nothing to do with any of the stories behind it. I got really tired of looking at it. What was the publisher thinking in selecting it?

    I imagine that if I’d read just one or two of these stories, then had a long break from them, as if I was reading them in some magazine, I would have enjoyed them more, but 50 in a row became wearing, even when spread out over the course of several months.

    John Collier was no doubt a skilled story-teller, but his work is also an acquired taste, and one that, after this full multi-course meal of it, I am not inclined to acquire.

  • Invasion! Review

     

     

    The premise of Invasion! The Forgotten Adventures of Dolley Madison, Book One is clever enough. Dolley Madison, wife of America’s fourth President, James Madison, had another life during the War of 1812: a turbaned crusader, along with her trusty sidekick and servant girl Sukey, harrying and perplexing the invading British Army at every turn, rallying and leading American troops, turning the tide of battle after battle. Unbeknownst to historians everywhere, or forgotten by them, she was America’s secret weapon.

    A clever premise, yes. In execution, not quite so much.

    In his end notes, author Neil Garra reports that at one time he built war games for a certain government agency located in Maryland (likely the National Security Agency), and that around that same time he’d become fascinated with Dolley Madison and the history of the War of 1812. The Forgotten Adventures was the result. This is both good news and bad news.

    The bad news is that Invasion! reads much like a video game, and has many of such games’ weaknesses. There is little in the way of character development. Dolley and Sukey spend 60 of the first 90 pages learning how to become Rangers after they fought off an attack by robbers while traveling to Fort Lafayette, near Pittsburgh. But that’s about it. From that point forward, Dolley and Sukey become the female Batman and Robin of the early 19th Century. They win every battle they enter. If they’re ever in any real danger, they emerge from the battle unscathed. If they’re captured, they’ll escape. After the first encounter or two, the reader has no reason to worry: he or she knows they’ll survive. The only question becomes where they’ll go and who they’ll defeat next.

    Garra tries to add some depth to Dolley by giving her and her husband a sex life, but every episode (each no more than PG rated) feels tacked on, as if someone had told Garra that adding sex scenes would make Dolley more of a real person. They don’t. They contribute nothing important to the larger story.

    The same is true for the religious elements. Like Dolley, Garra was raised a Quaker but later left the denomination. Through roughly the first half of the book, Dolley takes part in religious activities—attending a church service at Fort Lafayette, teaching or quoting long passages from the Bible, praying for forgiveness before or after killing an enemy (or many of them)—and then they largely fade from the story. As with the sex scenes, these events feel tacked on, and for a reader who doesn’t share those beliefs, they can also feel like the author is rubbing the reader’s face in them.

    The book is not a complete loss, however. Garra clearly did a lot of research on the early part of the War (Invasion! ends with the attack on Fort McHenry in September of 1814), both armies, their weapons, and their leaders, the politics of the fledgling United States, and the topography and geography of the area around Washington City and Baltimore. He even uses the fact that Dolley was sometimes called the “Presidentress” rather than the “First Lady.” Garra uses these details so well that the reader can feel as if they’re in the location, watching events unfold.

    Garra’s character’s dialogue is also comfortable and realistic, although this reader got tired of every character exclaiming “Huzzah!” Surely the people of the time used other exclamations too. Certain other expressions, like “gotta” and “gonna,” seemed out of place for the time as well.

    In sum, Invasion! seems to be more a history of the early part of the War of 1812, with an action/adventure story featuring an unlikely pair of heroines laid over the top, than an action/adventure story featuring an unlikely pair of heroines set in the War of 1812. The difference is significant, and it left this reader disappointed.

     

  • Light of the Dragon review

    Marielena is a young and extremely powerful witch, Sinnie a just-hatched baby dragon. No, wait. Let me let author Susan Trombley introduce them to you.

    “Marielena ran as the world shattered around her. The ground cracked and crumbled beneath her feet. The roar of dragons and gods rent the air. It was the end of times, and it was Marielena’s fault. … It was Marielena’s magic that had built the gruesome portal, powered the gate, and provided the key. She’d done as they’d demanded, and she had doomed them all. …

    “Then Marielena saw it, a small glow like a shard of sunlight trapped within the rubble. … The glow belonged to the burgeoning aura of a tiny dragon, uncurling its round body and serpentine tail from the remains of an eggshell held within a broken box. It looked up at her and blinked its violet eyes. It mewled again. Marielena sank to the ground, and the baby dragon climbed into her lap.”

    All this, and much more in the first two pages of Chapter 1.

    For years, Marielena wanders, determined to protect Sinnie from other dragons and from any members of the Cult of Solendar who might have survived the catastrophe Marielena caused. Desperate to know more about dragons so she can raise Sinnie properly, the two journey to the Academy of Magic, where Marielena meets two other young misfits, Jayce, a powerful talent who can’t control is own powers, and Katreen, whose true skills lie undetected by the mages of the Academy. Together, they end up having to battle forces far stronger than they are, individually or together, even after Jayce and Katreen discover and learn a little of how to use their powers. Help comes from unlikely sources, including Lord Valon, a centuries-dead battle mage whom the Archmage of the Academy had resurrected and then lost control of, and Valon’s mechanical golem. Valon, too, is not what he seems.

    Trombley weaves together multiple storylines as the three teens, Valon, Sinnie, and others, are thrown together, then torn apart, then thrown together again. Each character is distinct and well-rounded. Even Valon turns out not to be the villain the historical documents at the Academy make him out to be, and he discovers a softer side he never knew he had. (Being dead for a thousand years will do that for you, I guess.)

    In the end, all of these characters, and a few others, work together, at extreme peril, to triumph over the destroyer-god Solendar. Or do they? Light of the Dragon is billed as the first book in a series, and Trombley certainly left the hooks in place for more stories to follow.

    If I have a quibble, it’s with the prologue. The opening scene of Chapter 1 absolutely rocks, but it’s buried behind a prologue that I feel didn’t add anything, and in fact might take away from the end of the book. At the very least, it has little connection to the first 250 pages, and what connection there is is confusing at best.

    Some readers may also stumble over a few of the terms Trombley uses: “rota” for day, “cycle” for year, “sunbirth” and “sundeath” for sunrise and sunset, respectively, but she’s consistent about using them and they give this story world a special twist that distinguishes it from similar ones.

    Light of the Dragon is a Young Adult book that will appeal to young and not-quite-so-young adults alike. An engaging and enjoyable read. Where I can give it 4.5 stars, I do. Where I can’t, that’s a shame because this book deserves more than four.