Blog

  • Critique Technique, Part 51 — Punctuation

    Humanoid image surrounded by question marks
    Image courtesy of David Castillo Dominici / FreeDigitalPhotos.net

    Perhaps as much as spelling, punctuation can be a wonder and a mystery to a lot of novice writers. Schools try to teach their students all sorts of punctuation rules. If you really dig into it, there are hundreds of them—and of course they all have their exceptions and caveats. After a while, many students just give up, and it shows.

    I thought I had a good, workable handle on what to use, when, and how until I went to one of my friend Harvey Stanbrough’s seminars, and then the light bulb really came on. One of the best things you as a reviewer can do is buy yourself a copy of Harvey’s ebook, Punctuation for Writers. It’s available on Amazon for the Kindle, Barnes & Noble for the Nook, and Smashwords for everything else, and it’ll be the best $9.99 you’ve spent in a long time. (I’m not getting paid for that plug. I just believe it.)

    The Purpose of Punctuation

    Harvey’s take on punctuation is simple: punctuation exists to help the reader understand what she’s reading. Try this and you’ll see what I mean:

    I dont understand why punctuation is so important Alice said it just confuses me really I thought is she serious Im serious there are so many rules so you mean you dont want people to understand what youre writing I said

    Whew! It took a lot of extra work to figure that out, didn’t it?

    Punctuation clarifies writing in a number of ways:

    • It tells the reader when to pause and for how long;
    • It clarifies when a character is speaking versus when the narrator is narrating;
    • It can clarify when elements in a list are connected and when they aren’t; and
    • In certain cases it clarifies the emotional tone of a statement.

    That’s it! Let’s take those points in reverse order.

    Emotional tone or content

    Along with italics for emphasis and the content of the text itself, the period, question mark, and exclamation point identify whether a character or the narrator is just delivering information or if there’s something more to their state of mind. The ellipsis, those three dots in a row (…), can show uncertainty because it identifies when a speaker trails off without finishing what they were going to say, or they pause before continuing.

    Novice writers think that when they need to show a character experiencing strong emotion, they need to “pump up the jam” by using multiple exclamation points, an exclamation point plus a question mark, or even the combined symbol, the interrobang ( ‽ ). This is not true. The tone of the writing itself, the words used, and if really necessary, italics are all that’s needed.

    Character versus Narrator

    This one’s easy. Beginning and ending quotation marks distinguish a character’s external speech from the writer’s narration. I’ll have more to say on this in a minute.

    Some writers use italicized text to show a character’s thoughts, some don’t. I prefer to italicize interior monologue because, like quotation marks, it makes clear what’s thought and what’s narrative.

    Lists

    There’s been a never-ending discussion on whether or not writers should use the Oxford or serial comma. This comma follows the next-to-last element in a list, falling just before the conjunction. I personally favor using the Oxford comma because there are cases where confusion can result if you don’t know whether the last two items in a list are separate or belong together. One of the very best examples of this is the title of Lynn Truss’s book on punctuation Eats, Shoots & Leaves. Let’s look closely at it.

    Pauses

    By Harvey’s reckoning, there are three kinds of pauses:

    • Short, created by the comma;
    • Medium, created by the em dash (the long dash: —) and semicolon; and
    • Long, created by the period, question mark, exclamation point, and colon.

    So, whenever the author wants her reader to pause, all she needs to do is decide how long the pause should be and the choice of which mark to use is all but made. (Note that Harvey considers the ellipsis a form of “spelling punctuation,” yet he also acknowledges it as creating a pause in a character’s speech, which means the reader pauses too.)

    Punctuation Around Dialogue

    Punctuating the text in and around dialogue is a task I see a lot of novice writers struggle with. They don’t know what action beats and dialogue tags are, the differences between them, or how to punctuate them and the dialogue they’re connected to.

    Simply stated, a dialogue tag identifies the character and may identify how they said what they said. An action beat identifies the character by describing something they do before, during, or after the words they say or think.

    Action beats are usually complete sentences, so they’re usually separated from the dialogue near them by one of the full-stop punctuation marks: a period, question mark, exclamation point, or em dash.

    Dialogue tags are not complete sentences, so they’re separated by shorter pauses, usually denoted by a comma.

    Unfortunately, it’s not always that simple, so I’ve developed a two-page guide just for punctuating around dialogue. Click here to download a copy for yourself.

    Quotation Marks

    Quotation marks are another kind of spelling punctuation that causes no end of confusion, especially for novice writers. Should a writer put quotes around words or phrases she wants to emphasize? What about around titles of books, articles, pieces of music, etc.? When should a writer use single quotes or double quotes around and within dialogue? What about interior monologue?

    Answering these questions could fill a whole article by itself. I don’t want to do that, or make this one any longer than it already is, so I’ll try to be very concise, using Stanbrough’s book as my reference.

    The Apostrophe

    There’s one other mark that I need to mention here because so many novices use it incorrectly: the apostrophe ( ’ ). The apostrophe has two basic functions:

    • To show when letters have been removed from words to make a contraction: can not or cannot being shortened to can’t, for example, and
    • To show possession: the dog’s chew toy, Alice’s Restaurant.

    Some writers try to use the apostrophe to indicate plurals—like, two apple’s—but that’s just flat wrong unless the apples possess something, in which case the text should have been two apples’ anyway. On rare occasion, though, when needed for clarity, using an apostrophe to show a plural is OK.

    And then there’s it’s (“it is,” contracted) and its (the possessive form of “it”). I don’t see that there’s any way around this one: just memorize the difference and be done with it.

    There are other punctuation marks I haven’t addressed here—the various forms of parentheses and the various kinds of dashes besides the em dash—to name a few.

    Questions for You

    How can you use this information as a reviewer? Here are some questions you can ask yourself as you review a piece.

    • Does the author seem not to have a basic understanding of punctuation’s purpose and how it should be used? If this is the case, unfortunately, they probably need some remedial training that is usually beyond what a critique group does.
    • Does the author know the difference between how the ellipsis and em dash should be used?
    • Does the author use multiple exclamation points or an exclamation point with a question mark?
    • Does the author have trouble with punctuating dialogue, dialogue tags, and action beats?
    • Are they inconsistent or confused about whether to use the Oxford or serial comma?
    • Do they use the apostrophe incorrectly?

    If you adopt the concept of using punctuation to control pauses, then it’s easy to help your authors learn when and why different marks are appropriate. As for the non-pause marks—quotation marks, apostrophes, and some of the others—it’s best to just make the corrections and take the time to explain why you made them. Or refer them to Harvey’s book.

    Writers must master punctuation. It’s a basic skill and one that will always separate the amateurs from the professionals.

    Got any suggestions on how to critique punctuation? Don’t pause… get right to the point and share them in the comments box below!

  • Critique Technique, Part 50 — Spelling

    Spelling, misspelled and corrected

    This article begins a series on mechanical errors in writing, and with it, we’ll finish all the ones on the errors writer make. After that I’ll discuss the kinds of things a reviewer should address when the writer does well. Critique is not criticism, after all, and especially not negative, destructive criticism. It’s important to point out a writer’s successes, too.

    Before I get to that, though, I need to discuss speeling, grammer, puncturation, CapitOlizaTtion—I mean, spelling, grammar, punctuation, capitalization—and other usage problems, and manuscript formatting.

    Spelling words correctly is a basic requirement for every writer. There’s simply no excuse for getting words wrong, unless, like I did in the paragraph above, you’re doing it intentionally. It’s easy to point fingers at teachers who didn’t put enough emphasis on correct spelling in early childhood education, on texting and Twitter, on television, or on some other demon. They may all get some blame but that doesn’t change the fact that a working writer needs to spell well. Period.

    Traps and Problems

    If a writer whose work you’re reviewing didn’t learn to spell before, she needs to learn now. (Of course, this implies that as a reviewer, you know how to spell words correctly and can spot the ones that are wrong.) And not just the complicated or unusual words like circumambulation or phenomenon or phlogiston. The words that trip up too many novice writers are the easy ones, especially the homophones (words that sound alike): their/there/they’re, affect/effect, your/you’re, complement/compliment, and so on. And since using “there” instead of “their” isn’t a case of a word being misspelled, word processor spell-checkers won’t always catch the mistake.

    Now, spelling and grammar checkers have gotten better over the years, so “He went to there house” should get a blue double underline under “there” from MS Word’s spelling checker, and indeed it did when I typed it. But if the writer doesn’t know what’s wrong, he probably won’t fix it.

    There’s another problem with word processors’ spelling and grammar checkers: they’re set up for non-fiction/business/academic writing, and so fiction will make them flag as incorrect all sorts of things the author may have been doing intentionally.

    Helpful Tools

    The web offers some excellent sites for sorting out which word a writer should use when there are two or more that sound alike. Thoughtco.com’s Grammar & Composition section has a page on 200 easily confused words. Vocabulary.com also has a page on homonyms, homographs, and homophones. There’s even a web site dedicated to homophones, www.homophone.com, that features links to the definitions of each word. Online services like Grammarly offer spell-checking and other services, although their free versions do less than the paid ones.

    But you know what? That’s the easy part. The hard part for any author is catching dropped, swapped, or repeated letters. I have a nasty but unintentional habit of dropping the last letter of short words: “not” becomes “no” far too often. And of course, Word’s or Scrivener’s spelling checkers won’t catch that kind of thing. Word’s grammar checker might not either.

    Word does a better job with correcting “associaiton” (the i is on the wrong side of the t) or “associatiion” (two i’s after the t) to “association.” In these cases, though, the incorrect spelling had already been paired with the correct one in Word’s auto-correct function. Any misspellings that aren’t paired up that way will at least get marked as typos.

    This is where your fresh set of reviewer’s eyes can make a big difference. And since it’s already a law of nature that the unwelcome visitor will spot the errors in a work right away, you might as well take advantage of that to be helpful rather than unwelcome!

    Tips and Techniques, but No Questions

    There’s lots of advice for writers on how to catch typos—read the work out loud, read it backwards, etc.—but not a lot about how reviewers can catch these errors. Maybe there doesn’t need to be—those fresh eyes are enough—but fresh eyes in a reader who doesn’t know their own language well enough won’t find the mistakes a knowledgeable reader will. The best advice I can offer is to read a work slowly when you’re reviewing it. Keep one track of your mind looking for spelling and other mechanical errors. If you’re a member of a critique group, listen to the other members’ comments. If they caught things you missed, make a mental note to be on the lookout for those kinds of errors in the future.

    In any case, no author should rely only on others to catch their mistakes. It’s their responsibility, first and foremost, to do most of that work themselves.

    So let me throw it out to you: Do you have any special techniques you use to spot spelling errors in a work you’re reviewing? Are there any tools you use, online or offline, that help with this? Share your ideas and tips in the comments box below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 49 — Point of View Shifts

    Two angry people sitting on a bench

    Let’s be clear from the beginning about what point of view (POV), or viewpoint, is. Simply stated, it means whose eyes and other senses the reader is experiencing the story through. Said another way, if you think of the reader as being the proverbial fly on the wall, where is that fly? That sounds simple enough, but there are four main POV options, and many variations of each.

    Four Main Points of View and Some of Their Variations

    Omniscient

    The word means all-knowing, and in this case, the fly really is on the wall. In this POV, the narrator stands back from the characters and reports on their actions and statements. But it’s also a telepathic fly: the author can tell the reader, as well as show him, what a character is thinking or feeling. However, too much telling can make the omniscient POV impersonal.

    Third Person

    This is the most common POV choice and comes in a variety of forms, depending on how close to the viewpoint character the writer wants the reader to be. In the more distant forms, it’s hard to tell the difference from omniscient. In the more personal forms, the so-called “close third,” the fly is riding right on the shoulder of the POV character and even has telepathic and/or empathic access to his thoughts and emotions.

    In omniscient and third person POVs, the author will refer to the character by name (Alice, Bob), by pronoun (she, he), and by description (the banker, the red head, etc.).

    Second Person

    This POV is used very rarely in part because it’s so hard to do well. In this form, the reader is the POV character, with the author telling her what she’s seeing, feeling, thinking, etc. “You saw Bob coming down the stairs. Your heart beat faster. You smelled his sweat.” This may seem very personal, and it is, but only in a very limited way because, unless the author steps out of this viewpoint in certain scenes, the reader/character can only know what the narrator tells her she knows, what other characters tell her in dialogue, or through actions or events she is aware of.

    It’s possible to do a second person plural POV, but that’s even harder to do, and thus much rarer, than second person singular.

    First Person

    This POV comes in two forms, singular and plural.

    First person singular POV is common in certain genres, like mystery or detective, where the fly is inside the character’s head. The POV character is the narrator, telling the reader what’s happening. Like second person, this viewpoint is very intimate to that character, but it’s also very limiting, again because the reader can only know and experience what the character knows and experiences.

    First person plural is even rarer—and harder to do—than second person because instead there being one POV character, there are several… all at once. The author refers to the POV characters as “we” rather than I, he, she, or you. I’m only aware of one book that’s used this POV, We the Animals by Justin Torres, and even in this case, the author eventually had to switch to another kind of POV to make the story work.

    POV Shifting

    The fact that there are all these different kinds of POV isn’t the problem, however. Authors don’t often intentionally shift from one kind to another within the same work. However, there are a few ways that writers—and not just novices—can shift POV without meaning to.

    Breaking the Fourth Wall

    Writers may sometimes drop into the second person to remind the reader of something they already know. That sounds like it’s intentional but it may not be. The writer is confusing the narrator of the story with a friend of the reader, and so the narrator has a momentary conversation (usually one-sided) with him. This can be OK, but only if the author establishes the technique right from the beginning of the story.

    Head-Hopping

    Head-hopping doesn’t have anything to do with drug-addled frogs (or any kind of frogs, for that matter), mid-twentieth century actress and gossip columnist Hedda Hopper, or some strange horror movie. Instead, the author jumps from one character’s POV to another’s within a scene or even a paragraph. This is an easy trap for new writers to fall into, although more experienced ones can do it too. They’re ripping along, telling a rollicking good tale from the POV of one character, and then, when their attention shifts to another one for a moment, they slip into that character’s POV. As often as not, they slip out again when their focus returns to the first POV character.

    The Slide

    In this kind of shift, the POV just slips from one character to another and stays there to the end of the chapter or scene. This shift can be especially sneaky because it can seem so natural.

    In each case of POV shifting, the essential cause is the same: the writer’s focus—who they’re paying attention to at the moment—shifts, and so they shift into that character’s viewpoint.

    Now, I suppose in “experimental” fiction an author can get away with that, but the standard practice in the industry—the “rule,” if you will—is one POV per scene. Calling a work “experimental” is not an acceptable cover for bad writing technique!

    Fixing POV Shifts

    There are a few different ways to fix POV shifting. The most direct is to just get everything back into the original POV character’s viewpoint. This isn’t always easy, and may require a fair amount of rewriting.

    Another fix is to turn the second character’s perceptions, thoughts, etc., into dialogue. Not interior monologue (thoughts), mind you. External speech. That gets everything right out in the open, but this may not be desirable.

    A third option is to break up the original scene into several. It’s completely acceptable to change POV after a scene or chapter break. In fact, that’s one of the primary reasons for having such a break. Then, once the author has gotten done whatever needed to be done from that different POV, she can insert another break and switch back to the previous viewpoint. This technique can make a work choppy, however, if there are too many such breaks in close succession.

    Questions for You

    As a reviewer, what are you looking for when it comes to shifting POVs, and how can you help fix them? Here are some questions you can ask yourself.

    • What type of POV is the author using at the start of the scene: omniscient, third person, etc.?
    • Who is the POV character at the start of the scene?
    • Do either of these change, even momentarily, during the scene? In other words, do I start experiencing the scene from a different character’s perspective?
    • After the POV shifts the first time, does it shift back to the original POV character, to yet another one, or bounce back and forth?
    • Does the author speak directly to the reader, even momentarily, or describe something to them, that they should already know?
    • Would replacing the shifted POV with dialogue solve the problem?
    • Would breaking the scene where the POV shifts fix it?

    If the answer to any of the middle three questions is yes, you can focus on how the author can keep her focus, and the scene’s POV, locked in on the proper POV character.

    Now it’s your turn. How do you spot point of view shifts, and how do you help writers overcome them? The focus is now on you to share your ideas in the comments box below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 49 — Head-Hopping

    Funny frog
    Image by Zela, from RGBstock.com

    This article doesn’t have anything to do with drug-addled frogs (or any kind of frogs, for that matter), mid-twentieth century actress and gossip columnist Hedda Hopper, or some strange horror movie. Or some even stranger Addams Family-meets-Mitch Miller sing-along show: “Follow the bouncing head and sing along to….” (Man, that’s really weird.)

    No, fortunately, head-hopping in the context of writing is a form of point of view (POV) shifting. What happens is the writer jumps from the viewpoint of one character to another within a scene or even a paragraph. This is an easy trap for new writers to fall into, although more experienced ones can do it too. They’re ripping along, telling a rollicking good tale from the POV of one character, and then, when their attention shifts to another one for a moment, they slip into that character’s POV. As often as not, they slip right back out when their focus returns to the first POV character.

    This trap is easiest to fall into when a story is being told in close third-person POV, because the focus is so much tighter on individual characters’ viewpoints. Omniscient POV can seem to head-hop because the narrator can tell the reader what each character is seeing, thinking, feeling, etc., so it’s important for you as a reviewer to correctly identify each scene’s POV selection.

    Example

    Here’s an example of head-hopping.

    Alice tried to push the gas pedal through the floor, willing the old Chevy to go even faster than it already was down the two-lane State Highway 429. The 50-car freight train on the tracks to her right lumbered along, gaining speed as it cleared Lumberton. Sidesaddle Road crossed the tracks a couple miles ahead. It intersected 429 at an angle and she knew if she could just get there before the train did, she’d lose the sheriff’s deputy who was trailing them. From there it would be clear sailing. But it was going to be close. “C’mon, c’mon, c’mon,” she urged the straining sedan.

    Sitting in the passenger seat, Alice’s partner Bob held the bag of cash they’d gotten from the Bank of Lumberton 20 minutes earlier closer to his stomach. He worried that she was going to take the Sidesaddle Road cutoff and that she’d forgotten about the big dip in the road just before it climbed to the railroad crossing. If they hit it wrong—if she hit it wrong—they’d look like some Fast and Furious movie stunt when the freight train punted them into the next county.

    “We can do this,” Alice said. “I know we can. That big freight’s a girl’s best friend.”

    OK, what’s wrong with that? In the first paragraph, we’re focused on, and in the POV of Alice, the driver. Same for the third paragraph. But in the second, we’re in partner-in-crime Bob’s head. Oops! It’s a natural thing to do, right? The author wants to show us how Bob’s reacting to what he thinks Alice’s plan is. How better to do that than to tell us what he’s thinking?

    The idea’s fine. The execution? Not so much.

    Better

    The fix is pretty straight-forward. All the author needs to do is to have Bob say out loud what she is telling us about. It might go like this:

    Alice tried to push the gas pedal through the floor, willing the old Chevy to go even faster than it already was down the two-lane State Highway 429. The 50-car freight train on the tracks to her right lumbered along, gaining speed as it cleared Lumberton. Sidesaddle Road crossed the tracks a couple miles ahead. From there it would be clear sailing. But it was going to be close. “C’mon, c’mon, c’mon,” she urged the straining sedan.

    Sitting in the passenger seat, Alice’s partner Bob held the bag of cash they’d gotten from the Bank of Lumberton 20 minutes earlier closer to his stomach. “You’re not going to take Sidesaddle Road, are you?”

    She spared a half-second to glance at him. “You got a better idea? We’ve got to shake that deputy.”

    “There’s that big dip right after you leave 429,” he said, his voice rising. “Hit it wrong and we’ll look like some Fast and Furious movie stunt when the train punts us into the next county.”

    Her lips tightened, then parted into a ferocious grin. “We can do this, Bob, I know we can. That dip, and that big freight, are a girl’s best friends.”

    There. The POV stays where it belongs and we stay out of Bob’s head. Or, if the author had wanted to stay in Bob’s POV for a while, she could have inserted a scene break (a blank line) after the first paragraph, spent some time with Bob worrying about Alice’s plans and perhaps wondering why he’d let himself get talked into this crazy scheme in the first place. The author would then follow this with another scene break and pick back up in Alice’s POV.

    So as a reviewer, how do you detect head-hopping? First, keep in mind that it can happen at any time. Follow that up with a continuous awareness of whose eyes and other senses you’re experiencing the story through, whose emotions you’re feeling, and whose thoughts you’re hearing (through interior monologue) or being told about. If you detect that you’re bouncing back and forth from one character to another (and maybe to a third and a fourth), you’ve found a case of head-hopping. Then you can mark it and consider how the author could fix the problem. Scene breaks and dialogue are only two ways. Sometimes changes of description or action can do the trick.

    Questions for You

    Let’s turn those suggestions into questions you can ask yourself as you review a piece.

    • What POV has the author selected: close third, omniscient, or something else?
    • Who is the POV character supposed to be? Usually, this is the character who appears first in the scene.
    • Does the character I’m experiencing the story through change without there being a scene break?
      • If so, how could the author lock down the scene’s point of view?
      • Could they convert some of the narrative to dialogue in order to keep the POV to one character?
      • Would one or more scene breaks work better, or could that make the story too choppy?

    What techniques do you use to detect head-hopping? Hop on down to the comments box below to share your ideas.

  • Critique Technique, Part 48 — Stating the Obvious

    Two people talking
    Photo by Ambro, courtesy FreeDigitalPhotos.net

    When I was studying for my bachelor’s degree in physics, one of the things I hated—HATED—was when a textbook’s author would write “…it is intuitively obvious to the casual observer that…” and then go on to describe something that was anything but obvious, at least to me. I guess I wasn’t a casual observer.

    The topic of this article is not quite the opposite of what those physicists were doing. They assumed what they were about to present was obvious, because it was to them. Fiction writers, on the other hand, just come out and say what really is obvious to the reader, even the casual one.

    Sometimes this takes the form of the “As you know, Bob…” statement, in which one character tells another something the second character (Bob) already knows. I discussed this back in Part 36.

    Examples

    What I want to discuss here is a bit different. It’s also a form of telling versus showing, but in this case, the showing and the telling happen together. Here’s an example:

    Bob ducked and tried to protect his head with his arms as the white Chinette plate Alice threw at him whistled by. Another one followed, then a cup. The cup glanced off his arm, crashed into the wall, and shattered, joining the pile of broken crockery on the floor behind him.

    “You jerk!” Alice shouted. “You lying, two-timing, cheating bastard!” She launched the cup’s saucer at him, then picked up the knife.

    Alice was angry.

    “Alice was angry.” Gosh, really?

    Sometimes the unnecessary, obvious statement leads the showing, rather than following it.

    The town had seen better days. There were more boarded up doors and windows lining Oak Street, the main drag, than ones with the glass exposed. Ted’s Barber Shop and Carol’s Curlz ‘n Cutz were the only shops open on the north side between First and Second Avenues. Across the street, bricks had tumbled from the top of the second story façade of the hardware store, now closed, sometime long in the past, leaving it looking like an old dog’s lower jaw. In fact, an old dog, a stray everyone called Rocky, lolled in the entry, panting in the noon heat.

    “The town had seen better days.” Yeah, we can tell from the rest of the paragraph. The sentence is obvious and unnecessary.

    Not all cases of stating the obvious are going to be so, well, obvious, but you can be sure they won’t be subtle. Usually they happen when a writer wants to make sure the reader “gets” some point he’s trying to make. This isn’t really a lack of trust in the reader so much as the author not trusting himself.

    Just One Question for You

    For you as a reviewer, the task of catching these problems should be pretty simple, although it can be easy to glide right over such statements if you’re not paying really close attention. But if you’ve tuned your reader’s sensitivities so they go ping! when the author tells you something you can clearly see, you can mark it in the text to discuss with her later.

    Are there any special techniques you use to prepare yourself to catch the obvious? Don’t assume they’re obvious to us. Tell us about them in the comments box below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 47 — Danglers

    Shoes hanging from a wire
    Photo by dhannte, via morgueFile.com

    When we think about dangling things—in writing, anyway—we usually think of dangling modifiers, the grammatical fumbles that lead to sentences like, “After spending weeks in the forest, the town was inviting.” So, the town spent weeks in the forest, eh?

    For this article, though, I’m thinking about a different kind of dangler: a story line, event, action, or character the author lavishes some attention on, then forgets. It’s never developed, it’s never finished, it’s just left—you guessed it—dangling.

    This is a continuity problem and it can be hard to catch, for both the author and the reviewer. Why? The author had some reason for putting that character, event, action, subplot, or story line in or she wouldn’t have done it. But then any one of these things happened:

    • She got wrapped up in moving the other characters, plots, and subplots forward and forgot about it.
    • She failed to follow up or follow through on the consequences of that event or action.
    • She had no idea how to finish the plot line or bring the character back in, and so never did, hoping the idea would finally come to her.
    • She thought she had finished that work, but hadn’t.
    • She cut the scene that completed or resolved the plot line, event, action, or character involvement during her editing for other reasons and didn’t realize how that affected earlier scenes.
    • The character or plot line was one of her “darlings” and she couldn’t bear to cut it as she should have.

    Whatever the reason, there the plot, event, action, or character dangles, twisting in the wind.

    It can be hard for a reviewer to spot danglers because, as with padding, he may not have enough material at one time to realize that a particular event or action, story line, or character’s role was never concluded. The reviewer doesn’t have many good ways to overcome this incompletion problem. He needs (a) a really good memory for the details of the story, (b) to have gotten enough of the story in a short enough time to have the chance to catch the dangler, or (c) that stroke of good luck—which usually comes at an inopportune time—in which he suddenly realizes, “Hey, what about…?”

    Catching that Dang Dangler

    So if catching and fixing danglers falls back on the author, what might she do? Probably the best way to do it is to lay out the story in some form so everything is visible. She can do this any number of ways.

    • Timelines or character lines drawn out on sheets of paper or in some electronic format. A character line tracks a particular character and what he or she does or has to deal with. Each character in the story has their own line, and they run parallel to each other. One form of this technique literally shows a solid line when the character is present in a scene, a dashed line when they’re mentioned but not present, and no line when they’re absent.
    • Sticky notes or index cards that track each plot or character line, neatly spread out wherever there’s enough space: on a cork board, wall, or floor… until the cat or 2-year-old finds them. Playtime! Scrivener has a cork board feature but it’s not flexible in the ways you can place each simulated card. It’s possible to color-code each card, which helps some, but it’s still not as helpful as it could be.
    • Get creative with the tools in your productivity software (Microsoft Office, OpenOffice, Libre Office, Apple iWork, etc.). I use an Excel spreadsheet that shows, scene by scene, who does what. Each scene gets its own row and each major character their own column. Sometimes I’ll even give the secondary characters their own columns. This technique is better for tracking character appearances and disappearances but it could be modified to track plot lines. You can also use the table function word processors have but Word’s doesn’t work well for me.
    • Use some other kind of project planning software, if you happen to already have it and know how to use it. These packages can be expensive, though, and they have a lot of other tools that may not apply to story development, so I don’t recommend buying one just for this.

    Questions for You

    These tools are fine for the author, but what about you, the reviewer? Let’s assume that you (a) have reached the end of the work, (b) have the right turn of mind for remembering these kinds of details, (c) were really taken by a character or story line and have kept them or it in mind, or (d) have been taking notes on the work throughout your review. Then you can ask questions like these.

    • Was there a character or story line that seemed important at the time but was never developed, was underdeveloped, or just disappeared from the story without explanation?
    • Was there an event or action in the story that seemed like it was going to be significant but never was, and there was no clear reason why it wasn’t?
    • Could the author combine two (or more) characters—or even story lines—to get rid of a dangler?

    If you can answer “yes” to any of these questions, discuss your discovery with the author. Landing the dangler may be as simple as adding a scene, or even less, at a strategic spot. On the other hand, the author may discover she needs to add or rewrite a lot of material, even remove large portions of the work to solve the problem. That’s not happy news but it’s far better to discover it while the work is still in draft than to have a sharp-eyed reader point it out after it’s published because the author, reviewer(s), and editor(s) didn’t catch it.

    How do you catch danglers? Don’t leave us hanging! Drop on down to the comments box below to share your suggestions.

  • Critique Technique, Part 46 — Padding

    A filled packing box
    Photo by slideshowmom via freeimages.com

    There are times when padding is acceptable, even desirable. When preparing something fragile for shipping, for example. Or filling out a Santa Claus suit. But in writing? Not so much. Not today, anyway.

    Back in the day, that is before Ernest Hemingway, padding was acceptable, even expected. Check out anything written by Henry James, for example. Since writers were paid by the word, “Never say in ten words what can be said in fifty” must have been their motto. No, sorry, more like, “Never say in a mere, miserly ten words, my good man, I exhort you, from the bottom of my soul, not to mention the bottom of my inkwell, what could be said, I have not the slightest doubt, with the greatest of sincerity, depth, and yet extravagance, in not less than fifty words, or indeed more.” There. Fifty-six words in place of eleven.

    Today, especially for the new writer, brevity, to quote Shakespeare’s character Polonius, is the soul of wit. Write tight.

    Sure, sure, the later work of writers like Tom Clancy were padded—filled with material that didn’t contribute to the work—but Clancy’s publisher knew that he had a fan base that would buy anything he wrote (or put his name on), no matter how bloated it was.

    You’re not Tom Clancy. Neither am I.

    Packing on the Pounds Words

    So why and how does a work get padded, how can you as a reviewer recognize padding, and what can an author do to get rid of it?

    Broadly speaking, padding is any material that adds length to a work without adding meaning or depth. A writer can pad her work in a number of ways. One of the most common is with backstory, that background material that explains why and how the hero got into his predicament in the first place; why the antagonist is the way she is, starting back in her deprived childhood; the histories of the remote monastery they now find themselves trapped in and the ascetic monks who first built it, and so on and so on. The reader needs to know all that, right?

    Um, no. That’s padding. (Part 25 discusses backstory in more detail.)

    Another form of padding is excessive description. Beautiful, detailed description is the thing in literary fiction (next to psychological navel-gazing—but I digress) and it can be wonderful. Until it gets in the way of the story. Remember, the more of those details the author provides, the less chance the reader has to be the co-creator of the story, so the less engaged they’ll be. I discussed having too much setting detail in Part 20.

    Speaking of digressions, they’re great examples of padding too. Digressions can be anything from a parenthetical phrase to a full story line that has only tangential connection or relevance to the main plot. They can also spring from secondary or even more minor characters, when the writer spends excessive amounts of time on them. I discussed tangents, which is another term for digressions, in Part 26.

    Travelogues are extensive descriptions of a place, its history, culture, food, people, atmosphere, geography, etc., or just getting a character from Point A to Point B where nothing but the travel happens. When these things aren’t key to the story, they’re padding. James Michener could get away with that. You and I aren’t Michener either.

    Older writers, and people who have worked for government agencies or even private corporations, may have been taught to write in “bureaucratese.” This is a special language that favors verbosity over conciseness, and big words over smaller, clearer ones. For example, rather than writing “to,” these writers will write “in order to” or “for the purpose of.” (I discussed putting too many words into the text in Part 30 and again in Part 42.) This kind of padding doesn’t reach the Henry James level but it was designed to hide meaning rather than reveal it. A motto for today’s writers should be “eschew obfuscation”—I mean, write clearly!

    Diet Time

    So how, as a reviewer, do you decide whether material is padding or not? Aye, there’s the rub. Sometimes it’s clear: Is the writer spending so much time on certain material that you lose track of the main characters and/or plot? Is the text just flat wordy? Do you find yourself getting bored? These are all signs of padding, and they’re places you need to flag for revision.

    If you’re reading only part of a piece, especially a small part, padding can be harder to spot. What seems like a digression now may turn out to be critical later. The only way around this problem, other than asking the author, may be to read larger pieces of the work.

    To help your writer trim the fat, discuss with her why you think the material in question doesn’t contribute to the overall work and how she could improve it by taking out the excess. You both have the same goal: to produce the best possible work. Removing padding is one of the best ways to achieve that.

    Questions for You

    Here are some things you can ask yourself as you review a piece.

    • Has the author provided too much backstory?
      • If so, what is excess, why, and how can he trim it down?
    • Is she spending too much time describing settings, people, or other scene details, or just moving characters from place to place?
      • If so, what did she spend too many words on?
      • Why do you think that was excessive?
      • How can she tighten up her descriptions without losing anything important?
    • Does the work contain material that doesn’t seem relevant to the story?
      • If so, why is it irrelevant? Might there be something you don’t know yet that will make it relevant?
    • Is the writing simply too wordy? Is he using multi-word phrases where a single word would do?
    • Is he using two-bit words where shorter, simpler ones would be better?

    How do you spot padding? How do you help your writers remove it and make their stories better? Set a good example: keep your suggestions short and to the point in the comments box below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 45 — No Story Arc

    Let’s begin by describing what a story arc is, since it’s a good bet new writers in particular won’t know. Story is conflict, and the longer the story, the more conflict there needs to be. Story arcs plot the trajectory of each level and layer of conflict. Just as a map lets you see the layout of the terrain of a place, the story arc lets you see the layout of the conflict in the story.

    An arc is a curved line, perhaps a part of a circle or some other figure, like an ellipse or oval. For our purposes, the best image is part of the outline of an egg, taking in the pointed end and part of the sides leading toward the flatter end. The sides aren’t even and the whole thing is tipped over, something like this (pardon my poor drawing skills).

    The story arc, annotated with key points

    The longest part of the curve represents the “rising action” of the story. Going from left to right, the story begins with some “inciting incident” as Les Edgerton calls it in Hooked. But then things get worse for the protagonist. She wants to overcome the problem the inciting incident created, so she does something in response to it. Maybe it works… sort of. Or maybe it doesn’t work at all. In any case, things get worse.

    So she tries something else.

    Things get worse again.

    That process continues all the way to the climax. The antagonist is usually the reason why the protagonist fails in her efforts, although he doesn’t have to be the reason every time. In fact, he—or she, or it—should not be the reason every time, even if they get blamed every time.

    When it comes right down to it, readers are mean. The love—they want—to see the characters’ lives keep getting worse and worse… until they get better at the end.

    Or they don’t.

    In Scene and Structure, Jack M. Bickham describes this process as the protagonist (and antagonist) trying to reach his goal but continually having obstacles put in his way. Note that each scene has its own protagonist, and the scene protagonist may be the story protagonist, the story antagonist, or an important secondary character. Whoever they are, their goal-seeking behavior creates more and more problems for the characters, and more and more tension in the reader.


    Things get worse and worse as the characters travel from left to right on the arc, and reader tension rises higher and higher, until everyone reaches the climax of the story—the top of the curve—and then things settle to an ending of some kind, maybe happy, maybe not.

    Some writers have described this process not as an arc but a W, like this.

    The W-shaped version of the story arc

    Note that with the W-arc, things might actually get better for a while after the first turning point. But even in a case like this, things are actually getting worse… the characters just don’t know it yet and the reader only suspects it.

    This description of the story arc works too but for this discussion, I’m going to stick with the curved arc.

    Scene and Chapter Arcs

    The reason is this: not only does the whole story have an arc, so does each chapter and even each scene. The scene arcs combine to create the chapter arc, and the chapter arcs combine to create the story arc, something like this:

    Scene arcs overlaid on chapter arcs

    Now, scene arcs aren’t going to be as large and dramatic as chapter arcs, and chapter arcs won’t be as large and dramatic as the whole story arc, but each scene and chapter needs to have a flow of rising tension, leading to a climax of some sort and an ending—which then drives the reader to keep going. Even if there is some kind of resolution—a problem solved or an obstacle overcome—that resolution needs to lead to some new problem or obstacle.

    So, the entire story arc looks something like this (only chapters and the whole story shown). The more of these arcs that are missing, the flatter—and less interesting—the story is going to be.

    Chapter arcs overlaid on the story arc

    Questions for You

    As a reviewer, then, you’re looking for those arcs. If you have only a chapter to look at, look for the arcs in the scenes and the whole chapter.

    • Do things get worse in some way for each scene’s protagonist?
    • Ask the same question for the chapter: do things get worse for all of the characters?

    If you’re able to review a series of chapters all at once, you can look for the broader increase in tension and troubles. If you have the whole book, you should be able to see the entire arc.

    If you don’t find those chapter or scene arcs, the following questions might help you identify what’s missing.

    • What’s happening—or not happening—in the scene, chapter, or story?
    • What goals are the characters trying to achieve? Are there any goals, or are the characters just wandering along? (See Part 15 for more on character goals.)
    • What new obstacles are being put in their way? Are there any obstacles? What could be done to make the characters’ situations worse? (See Part 16 for more on obstacles.)
    • If characters overcome obstacles in the scene or chapter, what new ones have been placed in front of them, or need to be?

    Of course, it’s not your job to write the story for the author, but you can discuss options and possibilities, whether the writer’s a plotter and has an outline laid out or a pantser or puzzler who is feeling their way through the story.

    Now it’s your turn: How do you detect whether a story has an arc, chapter, or scene? And how do you help an author develop story arcs if they seem to be missing? Head straight on down to the comments box below to add your suggestions.

  • Critique Technique, Part 44 — Pop Goes the Reader!

    A toy jack-in-the-box
    By United States Consumer Product Safety Commission [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons

    This article starts a series on general story-telling problems and how to identify and critique them.

    One of the worst things a writer can do is to write something that “pops the reader out of the story,” in other words, write something that so distracts or surprises them that they fall out of the “fictive dream,” the world of the story, and think, Wait… what?

    Pop Starts

    This can happen in many different ways.

    The author can use an unusual term. As I discussed in Part 17, “unusual” can mean several different things.

    • A foreign or slang word or phrase, a jargon term, or writing in dialect, especially if such words have not been part of the story before.
    • A made-up word or phrase. Science fiction and fantasy are notorious for this.
    • A word or phrase that is too high-brow or low-brow for the story. For example, a friend of mine used the word “mephitic” in a mainstream story to describe the odor of a men’s restroom in a hotel. When I hit that word, I was popped out of the story because I did not know what it meant.
    • Any other word or phrase that stops the reader.

    The key characteristic of these unusual terms is that they make the reader stop, even if for just a second. Foreign, slang, jargon, or made-up words are fine if they’re introduced early in the story, their meaning is clear, they’re appropriate to the story or its genre, or if the character who uses them has the right kind of personality to use them. But if the reader gets surprised, they’re a kind of verbal landmine that blows the reader out of the story.

    A sudden and unexplained or unexplainable change in a character’s behavior will also pop the reader out. Behavior changes are fine, even expected, when the story demands them. But when a character suddenly does something out of character, there’d better be a believable explanation coming soon or the reader is going to become confused and suspicious. (See Part 14 for more on this topic.)

    Same for an event that happens for no apparent reason. As soon as the reader wonders, What’s going on here? she’s left the story. New writers will sometimes throw in an event like this because they think they’re adding to the tension and drama of the story with a “plot twist.” They’re not, they’re just sowing confusion.

    Similarly, a too-convenient event can be a reader-ejector. Writers may pull a rabbit out of a hat at the end of a story in order to solve a plot problem or save the hero. As soon as the reader says to himself, Oh, come on now, he’s out of the story.

    Not Surprises

    So it would seem like I could summarize the things that will pop a reader out of the story as surprises. That’s not quite true. Readers love surprises. They love surprises that keep them wondering what’s going to happen next, how the hero or heroine is going to get out of this new predicament, or how this new wrinkle is going to play out. All of these surprises move the story forward.

    What readers don’t love are surprises that don’t make sense within the context of the story. So whether it’s a word or phrase, a character’s behavior, or an event, if it makes them stop to try to understand it, they’re popped out, and that’s what we don’t want.

    Questions for You

    As a reviewer, then, if you get popped out of a story, it’s important to identify what did it and suggest ways the author can fix the problem.

    • Did a word or phrase confuse you?
      • If so, what’s a better alternative? It could be a more common word or one that’s more appropriate to the speaker.
    • Did a character suddenly behave in an unexpected way, and for which an explanation never showed up, or was not believable when it did? Perhaps there’s some information missing that the author needs to provide.
    • Was a plot event confusing?
      • Was it placed in the wrong spot or need some things to happen before it to prepare the reader?
      • Was the reason for it, when it did arrive, not believable?
      • In either case, what can the writer do to fix the problem?
    • Was a plot event too convenient?
      • If it was, why was it?
      • How can the author come up with a better solution to the problem the characters are facing?

    The kinds of corrections discussed here could require significant changes or additions earlier in the story to lay the groundwork for that solution, when it comes, or a rewrite for a totally different solution or outcome. The author may not be happy to hear that news, but a temporarily unhappy writer is better than a disbelieving or distracted reader.

    What kinds of things pop you out of a story? When you find them, how do you help the author fix them? Pop on down to the comments box below to add your suggestions.

  • Critique Technique, Part 43 — Telling, Not Showing

    Hand painting flowers
    Image courtesy of PANPOTE / FreeDigitalPhotos.net

    “Show, don’t tell” is one of the oldest dicta in all of writing, although one prominent writer growled, “I’m a story teller, not a story shower.”

    That, of course, misses the point: we illustrate or exemplify—in other words, show—a character’s emotions or attitudes by telling the reader what they did or how they behaved. Showing applies to inanimate objects as well, by describing the effects the object had on the other objects or the people or animals in the scene.

    Showing, then, is a specialized form of telling.

    Examples

    The best way to explain this, of course, is not to tell you about these differences but to show them to you, starting with a couple examples about people.

    Telling: Alice felt sick.

    Showing: Holding a hand over her mouth, her eyes bugging, Alice dashed into the bathroom and threw up in the sink.

    Telling: Bob was happy.

    Showing: Grinning, Bob pumped his fist in the air and whooped.

    In each case of telling, all we have is a simple declarative sentence. There’s no action, no behavior, no information, really. But in the examples of showing, we can see in our mind’s eye the behavior that illustrates the underlying emotion or physical condition, not that in Alice’s case, we’d really want to.

    The same applies to animals.

    Telling: The tiger wanted to eat the terrified goat.

    Showing: The tiger paced around the goat. The frantic animal bleated, jumping back and forth, pulling against the rope that tied it to the stake in the ground. The tiger’s eyes never left it as it stalked, its nostrils flaring and closing, flaring and closing.

    Poor goat. Kinda gets your heart pounding, doesn’t it? The “telling” example? Not so much.

    Natural phenomena can be shown too.

    Telling: Wind blew the rain hard against the windows.

    Showing: Wind-blown rain roared against the windows, flowing down in sheets that looked like the vertical green wall of a breaker off the coast of Maui, seen from the inside. There was a pause, then another cascade rushed down the pane.

    While some of these examples are negative, showing is by no means limited to bad situations. The reader enjoys happy moments more when they’re shown because she vicariously becomes a part of them. Even moments of motion or quiet gain depth when they’re shown.

    Good Telling, Bad Telling

    Of course, many writers, and not just new ones, will tell when they should show. That’s not to say that telling is all bad, all the time. Sometimes telling is appropriate, such as when the author needs to keep the story moving by glossing over a lot of minor actions or events to get to the good stuff. Summarization telling like that is fine, when used appropriately.

    What matters is telling the right things in the right places and showing the right things in the right places. When there’s too much telling, it’s a good bet you’ll find yourself disengaged, your mind wandering. That’s when, after you force your attention back to the piece, you can flag that spot and consider how the author could do better.

    Questions for You

    So as a reviewer, what should you look for in a piece to determine whether the author is telling or showing? Ask these questions.

    • Does the author make simple, declarative statements about a condition, emotion, behavior, or attitude?
      • If so, what can they do to turn that telling into showing?
    • Does the author use actions or behaviors to illustrate or demonstrate conditions, emotions, or attitudes?
      • If so, they’re showing, but is there some way they might do it better?
    • Did I have any emotional reaction to the author’s description about a character’s condition, emotion, behavior, or attitude, or an environmental condition?
      • If you didn’t, it’s a good chance the author was telling. If you did, the author was probably showing (unless your reaction was boredom!).
      • If he was telling, how could he convert that telling into showing?

    If you find an author telling when they should be showing, discuss with them how they could illustrate whatever it was they told the reader about.

    Showing engages the reader, and an engaged reader is one who’ll keep turning the page. That’s what every writer wants.

    How do you identify when a writer is telling rather than showing? And how do you help them show instead? Do tell! That’s what the comments box below is for.