Blog

  • Critique Technique, Part 8: Story Endings

    To quote from Ogden Nash’s puckish poetry accompanying Camille Saint-Saëns’ Carnival of the Animals, “Now we reach the grand finale / Animale Carnivale….”

    The story you’ve been reviewing has reached and passed its climax, its moment of greatest tension and conflict. The good guys have won… or not. The protagonist has survived, achieved whatever she set out to achieve (or maybe something different), or gained some new understanding… or not. Now it’s time for the author to tie everything up in a shiny bow, or leather straps, or bands of steel… or not, so you, the reader feel that satisfying sense of completion… or not.

    Or not?

    Or not. We’ll get to that shortly.

    What Makes a Great Ending?

    Way back in 2011, award-winning thriller writer Joe Moore wrote an excellent post on The Kill Zone blog in which he talked about the makings of a great ending. I won’t try to reproduce the whole piece here—you should go read it for yourself—but he says a great ending should:

    1.   Resolve anything that wasn’t taken care of in the climax. Tie up the loose ends, in other words.
    2.   Answer the “story question”—that is, what the story was about, what changes the protagonist went through as a result of the situation he faced, and whether, as noted above, he achieved his objectives… or not.
    3.   Establish a new sense of normalcy. Things have been topsy-turvy for the protagonist throughout the story. Now she can get on with her life, even if that life is totally different from what it was at the beginning.
    4.   Reinforce the story’s message, theme, or moral, if there was one.

    That third point deserves a bit more discussion. The “new normal” doesn’t have to be a good state of affairs. The protagonist might be dead… which could be bad for him, or good. Or enslaved. Or wealthy. Or married. Or divorced. Or back at home (except, of course, that you can never go home again). There may be hints that there’s more chaos or turmoil yet to come, but at least the chaos and turmoil of this story are over… or not.

    Exceptions

    There are several exceptions to this “rule,” of course. First, some genres tolerate unhappy or ambiguous endings that leave things unsettled. They’re acceptable in “literary” or science fiction but anathema in romance. For example, John Steinbeck’s The Grapes of Wrath ends with a scene of amazing humanity and giving, yet we never know the result of Rose of Sharon’s act or what happens to the entire Joad family.

    Woman reading a book
    Image courtesy of Marin / FreeDigitalPhotos.net

    Second, if the piece is part of a continuing-story series—and this is true for non-fiction as well as fiction—there needs to be something left unresolved. In this case, just as with the end of a scene or chapter, this is where the writer leaves the reader with that, “But wait, what about…?” itch, that hint of something left undone, unfinished, or still to come that makes him want to read the next installment, even if it’ll be a year or more before it appears. This incompleteness can appear in the form of just a word, a phrase, or a sentence, or even in something left not said or not done.

    Third, there’s the series in which the protagonist and some of his or her associated secondary characters continue from book to book, but each story more or less stands alone. Many mystery series fall into this category. In this case, the resolution of one book may not necessarily lead the reader to the next one. Character is critical in these kinds of books: if the reader isn’t interested enough in the protagonist, she won’t seek out another book in that series. In each book, while the story (such as the murder to be solved) is different, what carries the series is the nature of the protagonist and the personal problem (what Les Edgerton calls “the story-worthy problem”) he or she must face because of the story problem. J. A. Konrath’s Jacqueline “Jack” Daniels mystery thriller series is an example of this. The conclusion of one book may or may not suggest what the protagonist’s next challenge will be, although there might be hints of it buried in the text. For you as a reviewer, this is going to be hard, if not impossible, to ferret out, so in this respect, this kind of book is similar to a stand-alone one.

    Fourth, a variation of this latter series is one in which the environment, setting, or wider story remains more or less constant but different characters become the protagonist in subsequent books. Think The Hobbit followed by The Lord of the Rings (setting aside the arguments about whether Lord of the Rings is one book or three). In this case, the author has a couple of choices: they can elevate a previously secondary character to protagonist, while demoting the protagonist of a previous book to a secondary role, or they can introduce a totally new protagonist in each book. For the purpose of evaluating the ending, in the first case, you’ll want to see if that secondary character was interesting enough and had a large enough role to make you want to read more about them. In the second case, the environment, setting, or story has to be interesting enough to make you want to return to it.

    Note that in both of these last two cases, the author has to be up-front with you about their intentions. In a critique group setting, writers will tend to want to not reveal future elements of the story (that is, “spoilers”), but writers should be discouraged from doing this because it hinders the group’s ability to fully evaluate the work and how well it will function as part of a series.

    In the end (pun fully intended), no matter how a piece concludes, your job as the reviewer is to decide whether it succeeded in its mission to complete the story… or not.

    Questions You Can Use

    Here are questions for you to ask as you make your evaluation:

    • If the piece ends a series or is meant to stand alone:
      • Have all the threads of the story been tied up?
        • Do I know what happened to all the major characters and why?
        • Has a new state of normalcy been established?
      • If the author meant the piece to have a message, moral, or theme, is there a concluding restatement of it? Note that this statement can be implicit or explicit. The Grapes of Wrath has one: the human spirit will triumph, no matter how many degrading and demoralizing obstacles are put in the way. Rose of Sharon’s action says it better than any blunt statement even Steinbeck could have ever made.
      • Do I feel the story is complete, or is something still lacking? If something is lacking, what is it?
      • If the piece ends ambiguously:
        • Is the piece written in a genre that accepts or allows this kind of ending?
        • Is this what the author intended (as best you can tell)?
        • Did she prepare me for this?
        • Is it a fitting ending for the story?
        • If the piece is any part of a series except the last, add:
      • Do I have an idea of where the larger story is headed next, what’s in store for the protagonist (and possibly the antagonist)?
        • Is the “new normal” still unsettled?
        • Does the protagonist know there’s still something more to do or resolve? He may not, but you, the reader, have to sense it.
      • Am I excited by the possibility of spending more time with these characters? Do I want to know more about them? Do I want to find out how they deal with their next adventure, or the danger I see lurking around the corner?
    • If the book is a part of a continuing-character series, add:
      • Is the protagonist compelling enough that I would want to read more about him or her?
    • If the book is part of a continuing-setting series, add:
      • Are there secondary characters who are interesting enough that I would like to know more about them, or see one of them become the protagonist of their own story within this world?
      • Does the story-world provide enough opportunities for new stories and new characters that I would be interested in reading more books set in it?

    Your Thoughts

    What else do you look for in the end of a piece to decide whether that ending is successful or not? Add your suggestions or ideas in the Comments box below.

     

    And with that, we’ve reached the conclusion of this series on beginnings and endings. Next time we’ll begin looking at characters and characterization.

    The End on dice
    Photo by hisks via RGBStock.com

     

  • The Dragon’s Gold Review

    By Ross B. Lampert

    Small 4-star rating on dark blue background

     

     

    Debrah Strait applies some unique twists to classic Young Adult story tropes in The Dragon’s Gold. While fire-breathing dragons, damsels in distress, and bumbling knights are nothing new, the same dragon with a bad cough and a damsel who doesn’t want to be rescued are new, at least in my limited YA reading.

    The Tisbees, Sitwells, and Neales are three small but noble clans who occupy the eastern two-thirds of the Isle of Zuber. Before Queen Wiltrude passed away without an heir, the three clans were prosperous, trading with each other and the Sadirrans on the west side of the mountains, and with the peoples across the ocean. But since the queen died, the clans have been reduced to sloth, lethargy, and kidnapping members of the other families for ransom. Before she died, the queen had promised that whichever clan became “great,” which to the clans means “rich,” could become “royal” and rule the island. But since none of the clans have much gold, they don’t think they’re rich enough to become royal. The only solution they can see is to get the dragon who lives in the mountains to give them his gold.

    Problem is, they’re too lazy and cowardly to go get it.

    The task falls to Sir Gilford, the unwilling and unwanted adoptee of the Sitwell clan, and the last of Queen Wiltrude’s line. Unfortunately, the gangly, awkward Gilford makes a mess of everything he tries, and is mocked and bullied by the rest of his adoptive family. His at-first unwilling partner is the Lady Brianna, an adoptee too, who is smart as a whip but also has as much tact as one.

    Sir Gilford is sent to win the gold after he fails to keep Brianna from being kidnapped by some of the knights of the Neale clan. The Sitwells would actually be happy to let the Neales keep the harridan Brianna, who quickly come to regret having taken her. While the Neales’ ransom demand is more than the Sitwells can afford, they can’t abandon her, and the Neales cannot break with tradition by sending her back unpaid-for.

    The dragon turns out to be a rather friendly sort but before he’ll part with any of his gold, he sends Gilford off on one mission after another to prove he deserves the gold. Every time, Gilford botches the task, but the dragon sends him back out to try again.

    Eventually, with a little help from the dragon, he accidentally frees Brianna and they form a reluctant friendship. They begin to work together and finally get the clans to do the same for the benefit of everyone on Zuber.

    Does anyone ever get the gold? I’ll just say that they all get something more precious than precious metal. It’s not what they wished for; it’s definitely better.

    The dragon has a secret wish, too, and while he doesn’t get his wish either, what he does get provides a satisfying if bittersweet ending to the story.

    Strait handles her cast and story deftly. The clans are all silly but in distinctly different ways, with sweet little subplots woven throughout their relations. Gilford tries hard but finds new and creative ways to fail at each task he’s given. Brianna’s intelligence and good heart shine through despite her sharp tongue. And the dragon provides the moral center and compass they all need.

    Young readers—middle graders as well as young adults—and those young at heart, will find plenty of situations to giggle over and characters to identify with and root for. Well recommended.

     

  • Revision and Self-Editing for Publication Review

    Small 3-star rating on dark blue background

     

     

    Let’s get this on the table right now: Jim Bell does not write a bad craft-of-writing book. Does NOT.

    In one case, however, the title of his book does not match the contents. That case is Revision and Self-Editing for Publication. As K. M. Weiland noted in her 3-star review of this book on Goodreads, there’s little here about revision or self-editing. That’s too bad because what little there is clearly shows that if Bell had focused on those tasks, rather than writing yet another book about writing a decent first draft, he could have done well.

    Bell divides the book into two sections: “self-editing” and “revision.” The self-editing section is classic Bell writing craft material, full of suggestions and techniques for coming up with ideas, getting over/under/around/through blocks, and making sure each scene has a Lead who has an Objective but is faced with a Confrontation before the scene reaches a Knock-out ending that launches the reader into the next scene—his LOCK method. All of which is great, but where’s the self-editing? It’s found only in the occasional, in-passing reference to the fact that you’ll come back and edit your work. That’s true, but where’s the retrospective, “now that you’ve written a first draft” approach?

    To some extent, it’s in the second section, yet even here there the chapter on “deepening” focuses on techniques for building a good first draft, rather than revising it.

    This is not to say—again—that this is a bad book. The chapters on things to do before you start revising, and on doing the first read-through, and the revision checklist make the book a worthwhile read. But for an author looking for guidance on revision and editing, those are about the only ones he or she needs to read.

    What disappoints me most about this book is that my copy is a second edition. That means that Bell and his editors had the opportunity to realize what they’d done after the first edition and refocus the book for the second, or do a completely new book. They didn’t.

    There are plenty of books on revising and editing out there already—Self-Editing for Fiction Writers by Renni Browne and Dave King stands at the head of the class as far as I’m concerned—but Bell could be right there with them with a book that truly focused on post-draft-one tasks. He can do this, and I hope someday he will.

  • Wool Review

    By Ross B. Lampert

    4.5-star rating dark blue background

     

     

     

    Wool is the title of both the first novella and the first five stories in the Silo series, and the book which rocketed Hugh Howey to science fiction stardom. Deservedly so.

    WARNING: There are spoilers in this review. I’ll put them in a different font so you can spot and skip them if you wish.

    Wool is the story of a large, thoroughly developed community of people (hundreds if not a few thousand) who have lived for a long time in a 144 story deep underground silo. One of many, as it turns out, but the residents of Silo 18 don’t know that there are other silos until late in the story. Until then, only a select few even know that they’re “Silo 18.”

    The silo culture is divided into dozens of functional groups: the Mechanicals live in the “down deep,” the lowest levels of the silo and keep the power, water, and air-conditioning flowing; Supply lives in “the mids,” and does what you’d think a supply organization does; the IT department lives in the lower portion of the “up top” levels and provides an early 1990s-era level of technology. There are porters, farmers, doctors, priests, and others, all overseen by an elected mayor and a tiny police force: one sheriff and three deputies, one in each of the vertical thirds of the silo. Why everyone lives in the silo is a closely-guarded secret, however, but everyone knows that the outside is deadly. They can see it, thanks to four camera lenses mounted on a tower that bring in a panoramic view of desolation in to the cafeteria on the top level.

    Those lenses need cleaning every now and then, but cleaning is not a job: it’s a death sentence. The silo’s Supply and IT departments have the ability to create environmental suits that allow someone to survive outside—but they can’t be allowed back in. Most residents don’t know why, they just know they can’t be. So when someone is convicted of a particularly heinous crime, which does not necessarily include murder, they’re sentenced to clean the lenses, and then die when their oxygen runs out.

    So you’d think the condemned would fight being sent out, yet they never do. For one thing, the air lock to the outside is cleansed by fire after the outer door is opened and closed. For another, when they get their first look outside from the airlock, what they see is nothing like what they saw through the other lenses. The world is green and lush. The buildings in the far distance are gleaming skyscrapers, not skeletons. And so the condemned people get to work, scrubbing furiously at the lenses with their wool cleaning pads, trying to show the people inside what’s really there.

    Except it’s not. And when they take off their helmets, thinking they can survive, well, you can guess what happens. Until one person learns the truth. And then another truth. And another.

    Wool is a story of deception and a desperate attempt to keep the people of the silo compliant with the rules as enforced by the mayor and sheriff, in part because there have been uprisings from time to time in the past—whose history was then (supposedly) erased from the archives—and anyone who dared to mention them sent to cleaning.

    For writers, Wool is an excellent story for studying world-building and character development. You’ll care about Sheriff Holston, and then your heart will break for him. You’ll care about Juliette, his successor and the protagonist of the story, and desperately want her to survive and succeed. And you’ll come to understand why Bernard, the head of the IT department, does what he does. He is the hero of his own story, and his story is rational in its own way.

    One final note. A reviewer on Amazon or Goodreads, I can’t remember which, took Howey to task because there was no wool in Wool. Alas, the young lady was wrong. There are two kinds: the wool of the cleaning pads, and the more horrific, suffocating wool that’s pulled over the eyes of almost all the residents. There is one problem however: while there is wool in the cleaning pads, there’s no mention of sheep in the story. But this one oversight is easy to miss and almost as easy to forgive.

    Very highly recommended.

  • The Most Brilliant Thoughts of All Time Review

    By Ross B. Lampert

    Small 1-star rating on dark blue background

     

     

    A high school buddy gave me this book a long, long time ago. Now that I’ve read it, I have to wonder why. In the spirit of its “(In Two Lines or Less)” subtitle, here are my thoughts.

    Cynical: But Ambrose Bierce’s The Devil’s Dictionary did that better.

    Repetitive: Go ahead and use the same quote in different chapters. No one will notice.

    Egotistical: Never trust an editor who considers more of his own thoughts “brilliant” than those in all of the great religious works ever written… combined.

    Repetitive: Go ahead and use nearly-identical quotes in the same chapter. No one will notice.

    Disorganized: Organizing quotes like these along themes within a given chapter is a great idea. It’s just not required.

    At least I learned the full or true names of various famous people: F. Scott Fitzgerald (Francis Scott Key Fitzgerald), Voltaire (François Marie Arouet), George Orwell (Eric Blair), Anatole France (Jacques Anatole François Thibault), George Eliot (Marian Evans Cross), and Leon Trotsky (Lev Davidovich Bronstein), among others. That’s not enough to recommend this book, however.

  • The Portable American Realism Reader Review

    By Ross B. Lampert

    Small 4-star rating on dark blue background

     

     

    I was introduced to this collection of short stories about ten years ago, when it was one of the assigned books in one of my master’s degree classes. The 47 stories were published between 1865 and 1918 and were written by both famous authors—Mark Twain, Kate Chopin, Ambrose Bierce, Stephen Crane, and Jack London, to name a few—to writers not known outside of literary circles, like Sioux author Zitkala-Sä and Chinese immigrant Sui Sin Far.

    The stories are divided into three general categories whose time-frames overlap: regionalism and local color (1865 and after), realism (1890 and after), and naturalism (also 1890 and after). As the names of the categories and their periods suggest, they illustrate the changing tenors and interests of the times. In the post-Civil War years, there was increasing interest among readers and writers in the interests and stories from all parts of the still-expanding—and still-recovering—United States. As time passed, that fascination changed as people became more aware of the realities and challenges of life, whether in the more settled areas along the East Coast or in the wilder lands in the west.

    For writers, there’s one particular lesson to draw from many of these stories. Today, writers are taught to avoid using regional dialect, or trying to recreate the way people speak—the accents, the rhythms and patterns of a particular place or time—because doing so is often unsuccessful and it’s hard to read. That wasn’t the case for these authors, and many worked hard to translate the spoken word onto the page. Their attempts show why modern writers are warned away.

    Most of these stories are excellent (although I’m not a fan of the verbose and plodding Henry James) and certainly deserve their places here. Selecting which stories to include is always a challenge for the people who assemble collections like these, but in the case of editors James Nagel and Tom Quirk, their rationales are clear in their introductory notes to each story. Many of the –isms of academic life—feminism, environmentalism, egalitarianism—had their influence on Nagel’s and Quirk’s choices. While I don’t have any problem with some of these philosophies, I can’t help but wonder what stories were left out of the collection because they didn’t fit with the editors’ prejudices.

    Politics is never far from the surface of these stories. Many of the earlier ones deal with slavery and the after-effects of the Civil War. In the naturalist stories, poverty and the wide gaps between the rich and poor become central themes in some authors’ works, while the cruelty and unforgiving nature of Nature herself figure in others. Many of the stories also have a moralizing tone, sometimes blatant, sometimes subtle, but almost always there.

    This illustrates how academics can influence, even transform, the attitudes and opinions of the naïve college undergraduate, simply by selecting what to present to them, and how—which stories to place in an anthology like this one, which ones to teach, and how to teach them—and what to quietly put aside. Too often, the student is unarmed, or under-armed, to defend themselves against an academic’s well-planned and long-rehearsed positions (whether liberal or conservative); they (the students) simply don’t have the breadth and depth of knowledge or life experience to know they’re being manipulated, much less to stop or counteract that manipulation.

    This complaint has little to do with the stories in the American Realism Reader themselves, however, and anyone who wants to read quality works from this time period could do worse than to pick up this volume. Recommended.

  • Get Known Before the Book Deal Review

    Small 3-star rating on dark blue background  (Non-fiction)

     

      (Fiction)

     

    You’re a member of “writer mama” Christina Katz’s target audience if you’re (1) a female (2) non-fiction writer who’s (3) looking to traditionally publish (4) in around 2010 and (5) have plenty of time on your hands. The fewer of those categories you fall into, however, the less this book is for you. So for me as a male, indie-published, fiction author with precious little spare time in the middle of 2015, this book had limited value.

    That’s not to say Get Known is a bad book. It’s not.

    Katz, whom I discovered through one of many writers’ blogs I used to have time to read, treats the topic of “platform”—the base on which you establish your credibility and from which you grow your list of followers and readers—quite thoroughly. Before the indie-publishing revolution hit, establishing your platform was particularly critical for non-fiction authors, male or female. It still is today for authors who want that “validation” of being accepted by an agent and then by a New York publishing house. And it can certainly separate from the herd the non-fiction author who wants to publish independently in a world where anyone can publish and many people do.

    To be fair, three of the factors that limit Get Known’s value today are things whose impact Katz, like many other authors at the time, did not anticipate: the rise of indie-publishing, which was in its infancy when this book was published in 2008; social media, which was also just getting going in a serious way then; and web site development, which has become vastly easier since 2008. As a result, both indie publishing, which is a legitimate option, and social media, now an important component of platform, are mentioned only in passing. Katz’s suggestions regarding the technologies for building a web site are simply outdated.

    Katz describes in detail all the ways an author can build her platform: through making connections, volunteering, teaching, guest speaking, hosting an event, publishing articles, and/or offering a service. She emphasizes—as she should—that authors should not try to do all of these things, especially not all at once, and that some will just be a bad fit of some people. Still, it’s more than a little overwhelming to have all of these things thrown at you. And the busier you are with the rest of your life, the more overwhelming it is to see that you’re supposed to do some of these things too. A discussion of prioritizing would have been welcome.

    The decision whether to give this book a try should be based on how well you fit into Katz’s target audience and with the understanding that important parts of the book are now outdated. Unfortunately, there does not appear to be an ebook version that might be more up-to-date.

     

  • Love Life, with Parrots Review

    Small 4-star rating on dark blue background

     

     

    I don’t normally read memoirs but Love Life, with Parrots came highly recommended by a friend, so I thought I’d give it a try for something different.

    The book covers the period between the end of Hanson’s first marriage and the early years of her second. Unfortunately, we never know for sure how many years that is.

    What we do learn, in quite some detail, is that these are not easy years. Hanson struggles from one bad relationship to another, with each man having his own failings, some of them severe. While Hanson is never physically abused, she suffers a lot of emotional abuse which, combined with her low self-esteem (a legacy of her childhood), makes her struggles that much greater. On top of this, a car crash leaves her unable to work for over a year, suffering from both physical injuries and what today would be called post-traumatic stress.

    At this point, you’d be forgiven for thinking this must be an awfully depressing book, but what saves it—and Hanson—are her conures. These small (four ounce) parrots—first one, then two, eventually four—provide the unconditional love and affection that grounds her, and often frustrates, amazes, and entertains her and the reader. A perfect illustration is the story of the day 12-week-old Maggie, parrot #2, walked into the middle of a bowl to eat some of Hanson’s food. When Hanson told Maggie it’s customary in her household for parrots to perch on the edge of the bowl to eat, Maggie not only appeared to understand completely, she walked to the edge and never makes that mistake again!

    Love Life has a happy ending. Hanson reconnects with Dennis, a friend from many years in the past, and they discover they’re right and ready for each other. Even better, not only does Hanson’s three-parrot flock accept him, they accept a new baby bird he picks out to join the family.

    Hanson chose an unusual structure for her book: it has no chapters. Instead, it is broken up into many shorter, titled sections. While this certainly could invite the reader to put the book down for good, they sometimes provide a place to stop when the emotional intensity requires a bit of a break. Hanson’s personable writing style helps, too, especially in the more intense spots.

    Memoir readers, especially those who like memoirs involving pets, will find this story challenging but engaging. And the happy ending doesn’t hurt a bit.

    Recommended.

  • House Made of Dawn Review

    Small 3-star rating on dark blue background

     

     

    If you’re looking for a book with a linear narrative, a clear and present protagonist, and a consistent point of view, N. Scott Momaday’s House Made of Dawn is not the book you’re looking for. If, on the other hand, you’re looking for occasionally beautiful writing, and an unusual style of story-telling, this 1969 Pulitzer Prize winner may be just the thing.

    House Made of Dawn is the story of Abel (an obviously symbolic name), a young Native American from somewhere in southern California. The story proceeds in jumps from 1949 to 1952, during which Abel leaves the grandfather who raised him, has a brief affair with a white woman living outside of town, kills a “white man” who is an albino, not an Anglo, spends time in jail for the murder, spends more time lost in Los Angeles, and finally, returns home, the prodigal, just before his grandfather dies.

    Simple enough, yet Abel is rarely on stage, and even more rarely the point of view character. More often he’s someone who exists in another character’s world, and maybe the character spends time talking directly to the reader about his (the character’s life) and Abel, making it often difficult to determine who Abel really is, why he’s in that particular place, and where he’s headed. If this was Momaday’s way of showing the dislocation of the modern Native American trying to make his way through both his ancestral world and the modern one, he succeeds by repeatedly dislocating the reader.

    The land is almost as important a character to Momaday as Abel is. The author spends pages and pages in description of the land and the weather, and it’s here that I found some of Momaday’s most beautiful work. His three-page description of the canyon outside of the town he grew up near is among the best I’ve read in a very long time.

    And so the book makes its slow, inexorable, yet indefinite way to the uncertain end of Abel’s journey there and back. It’s perhaps not surprising that the Pulitzer Committee chose this highly “literary” work of a man who considered himself primarily a poet for its prize. Whether any given reader will enjoy it is another matter entirely.