Blog

  • Critique Technique, Part 9: Characters and Conflict

    The next eight articles are going to be about characters and characterization. Before we get started, though, I want to point you to another excellent blog post from several years ago, titled The Night the Lights Went Out in Texas, by Keith Cronin, on Writer Unboxed. This paragraph sums up so much about the enterprise of story-telling, whether in fiction or non-fiction:

    “But it really comes down to the people. (I look at the sentence I just typed, and realize I instinctively chose the right word with “people.” It’s hard for me to even refer to them as mere “characters” – that’s how real they’ve become to me.)”

    That says it all, doesn’t it? It’s the fundamental question you’ll be asking about the pieces you read as a reviewer: are the characters in this piece people to me, or just characters? The answer will tell you, and the author, a lot about whether or not the piece is succeeding.

    Essential Ingredients: Characters and Conflict

    There are two things a story can’t live without: characters and conflict. A “story”—fiction or non-fiction—without characters is a technical report. A “story” without conflict isn’t a story at all. Without conflict, characters have nothing at stake, there’s nothing that forces them to do anything at all, much less change or grow.

    Angry couple standing back to back
    Image courtesy of David Castillo Dominici / FreeDigitalPhotos.net

    Now, conflict doesn’t have to mean a character having a gun to his head. Conflict can be internal, too. In fact, that’s the primary form of conflict in much of “literary” fiction. Playwright and author Jeff Helgeson identified five kinds of conflict:

    • Person against self,
    • Person against person,
    • Person against society,
    • Person against nature, and
    • Person against “fate.”

    While four of these are external, each also has an internal component as the character struggles with how these conflicts are affecting her.

    As a reviewer, you may find a piece you’re reading has either too much conflict or too little. The conflict might also be inappropriate or mistimed. Let’s take a look at each.

    Too Much Conflict

    It may seem odd to suggest that a piece can have too much conflict, but here’s an example of what that might look like. A few years ago, a local writer brought her draft novel to my writers’ group for our review. Right from the first chapter, her protagonist and antagonist were having screaming fights with each other. The motivation for their arguments was weak—it didn’t justify the intensity of the conflict—and worse, it gave the characters very few ways to escalate their conflict. As I’ve written in earlier posts, things have to get steadily worse for the characters over the course of the story, but these two were denied that chance.

    Another example of too much conflict is the case where there’s nothing but conflict in the story. Constant conflict might be fine for a first-person-shooter video game but in a written story, the reader needs a break from time to time, a chance to catch his breath. The characters need to do that, too, to lick their wounds (real or figurative), assess their situation, and make new plans (which, of course, will fail, right up to the very end). In his book Scene and Structure, Jack Bickham calls these moments the “sequels” that fall between the “scenes.” These changes of pace, from conflict to peace to conflict again—or more conflict to less to more—keep the reader engaged, not exhausted.

    Too Little Conflict

    Too little conflict, on the other hand, will make the reader lose interest. Writers, especially new ones, who are nice, gentle, kind people, may shy away from creating conflict between and within their characters because they don’t want them to be hurt or stressed. Tough noogies. The writer who’s too nice to her characters will put her readers to sleep. As a reviewer, your job is to help her get over her internal conflict and create conflict on the page. You’ve got to do it.

    Now’s a good time to go back to Helgeson’s list. Conflict should be constantly on the move, from internal to external, from physical to mental, from personal to impersonal, from one source or cause to another. “Constantly” isn’t necessarily the same as “rapidly,” however. The pace of this movement, like the intensity of the conflict, should be changing over time, too.

    Inappropriate Conflict

    That’s a good transition into inappropriate conflict. How can conflict be inappropriate? Let’s take a crazy example. Bob, a mild-mannered private-practice CPA is out on a date at a local Applebee’s with his girlfriend Alice, who’s a sales clerk at a Gap store. The relationship has been fracturing and Bob is struggling to find a way to tell her it’s time for them to go their separate ways. Just as he’s getting ready to say so, a gunfight breaks out among the patrons and Alice whips out a Mac 9 machine pistol from her shoulder bag and joins the fray.

    Uhhh, yeah, sure, that makes sense.

    Now, with more background information, maybe it would make sense, but with only what I’ve given you here, that conflict is completely inappropriate.

    Mistimed Conflict

    Mistimed conflict is a different issue. Getting timing right is difficult—just ask any stand-up comic. That moment’s hesitation before he delivers the punch line can be the difference between howls of laughter and no response at all. Here’s an example of mistiming a conflict in fiction. Another former member of my writers’ group once gave us a chapter from the first draft of his novel. The chapter is pretty early in the story (probably less than a quarter of the way through) and yet the protagonist kills his primary antagonist in it.

    Uh-oh! Now who’s going to chase the good guy around, making trouble for him, putting him in danger, and generating all sorts of conflict, for the next 200 pages? Hmmm, good question. OK, it was a first draft, where problems like this are bound to come up. (It’s also possible this antagonist wasn’t the primary one, but if so, that creates a whole different set of problems.) If that antagonist were to stay around for another 200 pages, the protagonist would find himself in more and more trouble. That’s what we want.

    Mistimed conflict can, of course, be conflict that comes too late, as well, which may be related to there being too little conflict to start with.

    Questions For You

    All right, then. Here are some questions you should be asking yourself as you review a piece.

    • Is there conflict between and within the characters?
    • Is there conflict between the characters and their “environment” (collectively, Helgeson’s society, nature, and fate)?
    • Is there too much conflict, or too little?
      • If too much, which conflicts can be deleted or combined? How would doing so make the story better?
      • If too little, what kinds of appropriate conflict could the author add, and where?
    • Is the conflict appropriate or inappropriate for the situation and characters?
      • If it’s inappropriate, why, and what can the author do to fix that?
    • Is the timing of the conflict off, happening too early or too late?
      • What could the author do to make the timing better?

    Conflict is the heart of “story.” It defines and redefines the story’s characters—it changes them. Getting conflict right is one of an author’s central tasks. Helping him do so is one of your most important tasks as a reviewer.

    Your Turn

    What kinds of problems have you seen in how an author presents conflict within and between her characters? How could, or did, the author change the story to make conflict more effective? Please add your thoughts and suggestions in the comments box below.

     

  • Great Stuff for Writers, May 27, 2013

    Today is Memorial Day in the United States, one of the two holidays (two!) in which we honor and remember our military personnel, those serving today and those who have served in the past, especially those who were injured or killed in combat. As a veteran myself, I’ll be participating in a ceremony this evening. Courage in the face of mortal danger and sacrifice to it have long been—and should be!—staples of literature. James Scott Bell’s (@jamesscottbell) Of Miracles, Sacrifice and Story speak to this better than I can, so that’s where we’ll start this week’s Great Stuff.

    And to my brothers and sisters in arms, thank you.

    CRAFT

    Nancy J. Cohen (@nancyjcohen) offers a veritable plethora of tips on how to make On-Site Research trips worth your time and expense. She has specific examples of how to engage each of your—make that your character’s—senses and what tools to bring to make sure you capture what you detect.

    Katie Weiland’s (@KMWeiland) Are Your Multiple POVs Killing Your Story’s Suspense? was an uh-oh moment for me, because my WIP has six! Certainly, too many POVs can kill the suspense—or it can maintain or increase it. It all depends on the story. Her point is a good one: beware of the trap and be willing to revise if necessary. Some of those darlings may just have to go.

    Grammar Girl Mignon Fogarty excerpts a section of Marcia Reifer Johnston’s (@MarciaRJohnston) new book Word Up! for a discussion of How to Use Hyphens—including when to use them, when not to, and why (or why not) as well has how to. The main purpose of a hyphen, like much other punctuation, is to make meaning clearer, and this piece, though long, should help you get a clearer idea of how to use hyphens for just that purpose.

    Repetition can be a tricky technique: used well, it can drive a point home in surprising and subtle ways. Used poorly, it can drive a reader away. Elizabeth Craig (@elizabethscraig) describes 3 Ways to Add Repetition That Pleases Readers in a guest post for Katie Weiland’s WORDplay blog.

    BUSINESS

    What to put into a query letter is something new writers always wonder about. Chuck Sambuchino (@ChuckSambuchino) covers the do’s and don’ts of one piece of the query in What to Write in the “Bio” Section of Your Query Letter. If this is something you’re looking for guidance on, check out this article.

    FUN

    John Vorhaus’s (@TrueFactBarFact) The Kings’ English Dethorned is absolutely writers’ humor. You might—might—share it with new-writer friends, but only if they’re sharp enough to catch all of John’s intentional (I think) misteaks. For your non-writer friends who can’t spel or puncturate so good, consider sharing only if they’re a friend you’re not intent on keeping.

  • Uncovering the Cover

    The Great Cover Artist Search continues. Or resumes, to be more accurate about it.

    I started a month or more ago and then other tasks took priority, but now, getting the cover designed is one of the last things I need to do. I guess I shouldn’t be surprised but this task is harder, or at least more time-consuming, than it might seem.

    First off, where do you find cover artists in the first place? I’ve found four good sources:

    1. Joel Friedlander’s The Book Designer web site. Every month, Joel shows all the ebook covers submitted to him for review, and critiques some. That’s a big help in a lot of ways.
    2. Other authors’ web sites. J. A. Konrath and Joanna Penn have named the cover artists they’ve used, for example.
    3. Mark Coker’s list of book designers and cover artists on Smashwords.
    4. The “Look Inside” feature on Amazon.com. Sometimes the authors will name their cover artist in the front matter of their e-books.

    Some people have recommended fiverr.com but that seems like a starving-artists hangout. This is too important to go cheap.

    So, that gets me a list to start from, but it’s not complete because often all I have is a name, not a web site–or blog, or Flickr page–address. So I have to look that up.

    Once I’ve got a place to look at, there’s the artist’s portfolio to look through. You’d think that would be easy. The smart ones have a portfolio page. Sometimes they even sort their work by genre. That’s helpful. If nothing else, it reveals how big the market for Romance covers is! This step alone weeds out easily two-thirds of the candidates.

    Next:Do I like their work? Joel’s critiques have been really valuable here, teaching me what to look for, like an artist that uses a variety of type faces rather than the same ones over and over. Is the type readable against the background? Some are, some aren’t. What about color contrasts? Red type against a black background is often hard to read. Small type will disappear in a thumbnail image. Does the artist seem to know that? This, too, cuts out a lot of candidates.

    Fourth, how can I contact the artist? What? No contact information? That cuts out a few more.

    Now I can look at prices and other factors.

    • How many revisions will the artist do? Some allow just a few, some “unlimited.”
    • What’s their turn-around time? Most say a few days to a week.
    • Will they get the image(s) to be used or do I have to provide it/them? Is that included in the price or is it an additional fee?
    • Do they do POD covers as well as ebooks?
    • And of course, what do they charge and how and when do they want to be paid?

    So, that process has gotten me from 53 candidates down to 10. Now I’m into the lather-rinse-repeat cycle of looking at portfolios, services, and prices.

    Decisions, decisions.

    Got any recommendations?

  • Great Stuff for Writers, May 20, 2013

    Wow! TONS of Great Stuff this week, in just about all categories. Titles, critique groups, emotions, made-up words, publishing paths, “scarcity thinking,” and dogs reading books! Even a traditional/self-publishing poll. Something for everyone.

    CRAFT

    Right up there with a great cover, a great title is critical to getting a potential reader to consider your book. That’s why Katie Weiland (@KMWeiland) provides 17 Steps to a Reader-Grabbing Title. Seventeen sounds like a lot, but she breaks them into 5 elements, 7 questions to ask, and 5 brainstorming tips, to make them easy to digest.

    There are writers out there who hate critique groups. HATE ‘em. Sometimes there’s plenty of reason to. But sometimes not. Kris Montee, one of the sister pair who write as PJ Parrish, discusses this in Getting pecked to death: Are critique groups worth it? Her answer, not surprisingly, is “it depends” but she does a good job describing how to select a group that will meet your needs and how to get value out of it. Definitely worth checking out if you’re considering looking for some help and support.

    To Be Great, Strive to Be Ordinary. Really? Elizabeth Sims’s (@ESimsAuthor) guest post for Jane Friedman isn’t as counterintuitive as it might seem. Her point is that trying too hard to be great is a sure way to be awful, to stifle your natural writer’s voice, or at least to end up with writer’s block. Relax and be you, especially in the first draft, and you’re on the road to something special.

    If you’re really a writer, you just can’t get upset by a post like Demian Farnworth’s (@demianfarnworth) 11 Compound Word Errors that Might Make You Look like a Numbskull (and the three other posts it links to on similar topics) on Copyblogger. These are basics every writer needs to know—cold.

    Super-agent Donald Maass (@DonMaass) knows a thing or two about writing, so Angela Ackerman’s (@AngelaAckerman) notes from a workshop he led, Donald Maass Wisdom: Cultivate Reader Interest Through Unexpected Emotions, is something I’m going to pay attention to. The exercise he had attendees do was to have a character from a scene in their work feel an emotion that they would never dare to voice or show.

    Here’s an interesting question: Are Your Bad Guys Dying in the Right Order? That’s the question Katie Weiland (@KMWeiland) answers in this week’s vlog. So what’s the right order? The one in which the most important antagonist—the one the hero has the largest personal investment in—dies last. Makes sense, doesn’t it?

    Speaking of dying, Joanna Penn (@thecreativepenn) thinks Dan Brown’s enthusiasm for his work is dying in Inferno. Her spoiler-free review in What Writers Can Learn from Dan Brown’s Inferno discusses not the plot or characters but what happens when (1) an author isn’t writing what he or she loves, (2) the resulting book’s title, marketing, and theme don’t work together, and (3) the writing confuses the reader (which means, my opinion, the author didn’t get well edited—or edited at all). Joanna’s still a fan, but….

    It takes a while to get to the point (to say nothing of the title!) of Jan O’Hara’s (@jan_ohara) Linguistic Quirks: What Wordbirthing & Name-Nicking Can Do for Fiction, but that point is an excellent one. Namely: the unique twists of language characters use, especially couples with each other, reveal lots about them, their culture, and their relationships, in ways that are both economical and effective.

    BUSINESS

    Nathan Bransford (@NathanBransford) has an interesting poll question in How Do You Plan to Publish Your Work-in-Progress? After a week of polling, almost half (45%) of the 721 respondents consider traditional publishing their first preference. Almost quarter each consider self-publishing their first choice or will ignore it completely. Less than 10% intend to ignore traditional publishing. What about you?

    One of the on-going problems with indie publishing is that it’s been all but impossible to get print copies of your book into bricks-and-mortar bookstores. That appears to finally be changing. Kristine Kathryn Rusch (@kriswrites) reports in The Business Rusch: Shifting Sands that the two major book distributors, Baker & Taylor and Ingrams, have now put together processes for getting print-on-demand books into stores. Unfortunately, to get to the key news, you have to wade through a lot of other stuff first. To save time, search for “Createspace” [sic] and read the four paragraphs starting at the first hit. Then search down for “Earlier this year” and start reading there. This is great news!

    Casey Demchak’s (@caseydemchak) guest post on The Book Designer, 7 Secrets to Writing Persuasive Back Cover Sales Copy, might seem to apply only to print authors—ebooks don’t have back covers, after all—but it doesn’t. Think about the book summary on Amazon.com or bn.com. Same thing, same purpose, different location. After the cover, this is what makes the reader look inside and maybe, just maybe, make the decision to buy.

    Jane Friedman (@JaneFriedman) has created an Infographic: 5 Key Book Publishing Paths that nicely consolidates a lot of information on methods of publishing and their characteristics, values, and risks and then adds a few special cases. You can download it directly here but reading the post will provide a lot of additional information and depth.

    TECHNOLOGY

    Thanks to Copyblogger, we jump over to The Orbiter to find Andy Crestodina’s (@crestodina) Email Signup Forms: 4 Things That Lead to Huge Success or Total Failure. Those four things are: prominence (visibility on the page), promise (of what will be delivered), proof (how many follower/subscribers you already have), and privacy (you’ll protect it). The examples illustrate each point, and the last example—of a really bad form—shows how not to do it.

    THE WRITING LIFE

    This post could have gone in the Business section, but it’s really about you, not business. Orna Ross (@OrnaRoss) asks Should You Self-Publish? 15 Questions on Jane Friedman’s blog. For starters: are you brave, hard-working, entrepreneurial? Have you made plans for all the things that go into self-publishing? Plus nearly a dozen more. Self-publishing isn’t for everyone. What about you?

    What? STOP writing? Yes, sometimes it’s necessary—for your craft, for your sanity, or just because life demands it. That’s why Katie Weiland (@KMWeiland) and written 5 Reasons You Should Stop Writing—to let you know that it’s okay, even necessary. And that, as she says, just because you have to stop for a while doesn’t mean you’re not a writer.

    “There isn’t enough (whatever).” That “scarcity mentality” is what Rachelle Gardner (@RachelleGardner) says is a hurtful falsehood in Letting Go of Scarcity Thinking. There is enough time to get things done, there are enough readers for your book to find its place, there is enough room in the market for it. If we believe there is enough (not too much, but just enough), we’ll do fine.

    FUN

    Definitely just for fun: Robert Bruce’s (@robertbruce76) 12 Photos of Dogs Who Love to Read.

  • Critique Technique, part 7b: more on scene and chapter endings

    I need to “revise and extend” my last Critique Technique post.

    Last time I wrote that things should be worse for the protagonist at the end of each section (or scene) or chapter of an article, short story, or novel than they were at the beginning. Well, that’s not entirely true. In a longer piece, and particularly in a short part of that piece, that may not be possible, or desirable.

    Letting the scene’s or chapter’s protagonist make a little progress, or seem to make progress, has its benefits:

    1. The reader is encouraged, and so wants to read further.
    2. That progress gives the author more opportunities to make things worse for the protagonist: one step forward makes room for the two steps backward to come. (There we writers go again, being evil and devious!)
    3. If the scene’s protagonist is the story’s antagonist, or even a secondary character, letting him make progress toward his goals can be a direct or indirect way to make things worse for the story’s protagonist. (Oh, what a tangled web we weave!)

    The bottom line, then, is that in every chapter or scene, something has to happen that changes the situation for the characters involved. The change can be large or small. Its size doesn’t have to match the length of the scene or chapter, although a small change over the course of a long chapter or section may not go over so well. As a reviewer, you’re looking for that change and whether the story moved forward because of it.

  • Another step closer, but more yet to go

    Man climbing steps
    Making progress, step by step

    Step by step, The Eternity Plague gets closer to becoming a published reality. Earlier this week I finished reviewing the work of a local copy editor. That’s an important step.

    There’s still important work to do, however. When I began writing the book, lo those many years ago (2004!), I chose to set parts of the story at a medical research center I visited early in my research: the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center near downtown Dallas. Why? Well, it was–and still is–a highly regarded research center and a cousin of mine who works there was able to arrange for me to spend some time in the lab of one of its scientists. Very cool! AND, it wasn’t in Oklahoma, which was where I was living at the time.

    Now, don’t get me wrong: there’s nothing wrong with Oklahoma. OK, OK, there are tornadoes. But the point is, all of my fellow students were placing their stories in Oklahoma and I didn’t want to do that. So that’s how UT-Southwestern, Raleigh, North Carolina, and Portland, Oregon, ended up as settings instead.

    BUT! Until just recently, I never really thought about whether UT-Southwestern, and several other real institutions, would be happy to be featured in a science fiction novel, even if favorably. So now I’ve got to get that sorted out. I’ve got a plan if they say no, or want some cut of the profits. So we’ll see.

    Then there’s this matter of “fair use.” You see, a couple of my characters quote song lyrics a few times. Copyrighted lyrics, of course. Not a lot of them, and the characters identify who wrote or recorded the songs, but do those snippets fall within the legal concept of “fair use?” That’s a tough one, and it’s probably going to take an intellectual property lawyer to give me an assessment. Or I could just take them out. Or replace them with made-up ones. But I’d rather not.

    And then there’s cover art to get done. And text formatting to do. And publicity.

    I’m not complaining, mind you, just looking ahead. Looking forward too! After all, as each of those steps gets done, I’m one more step closer to that magic day when the book goes up for sale.

    Soon.

  • Great Stuff for Writers, May 13, 2013

    A double-13 day today, but you should feel lucky because there’s so much Great Stuff waiting below. Techniques for getting started or keeping going, for pulling in the reader, setting mood, and more. News about Smashwords and indie publishing. Making better use of social media generally and Goodreads and Twitter in particular. Even a link to an old video game based on The Great Gatsby! Check it out.

    CRAFT

    Just in case you don’t already have enough to read, or you’re looking for something specific that you haven’t found yet, Katie Weiland (@KMWeiland) lists 10 of My Favorite Writing-Craft Sites. Two you see mentioned a lot here—Writer Unboxed and The Creative Penn—are on the list, plus others I hadn’t heard of.

    Not only is James Scott Bell (@jamesscottbell) an excellent writer, he’s an excellent teacher. In 11 Keys to Making a Novel a Page Turner, he examines, of all things, a 1953 novel by John McPartland (Never heard of him? Neither had I. Or Bell) titled Big Red’s Daughter and uses what he learned by doing so to show how McPartland used basic techniques to suck Bell so deeply into the story he forgot he was reading. Isn’t that what we all want to happen to our readers?

    Katie’s back with the next installment of her Most Common Mistakes series, this time on The Do’s and Don’ts of Dialect. More than just a list of do’s and don’ts, Katie explains why each is what it is, and following those thoughts will keep your reader engaged in the story, rather than in trying to translate the gibberish of phonetically spelled out dialect.

    Despite the title, Jan Drexler’s (@JanDrexler) Are You In the Mood? has nothing to do with either sex or waiting for the muse. It’s about setting the mood for a particular scene in a story through the use of both word choice and sentence length. Simple but effective advice.

    Most of Boyd Morrison’s (@boydmorrison) Hunting Down the Muse would fit better down in Writing Life but there’s a little technique called The List of Twenty for generating story ideas near the end of the piece that’s very crafty—in more ways than one—and that’s why I’ve put the post here. Ella Mei Yon (@EllaMeiYon) takes a similar list-based approach in Finding a Way In in Glimmer Train, via Jane Friedman’s blog.

    Professional editor Dave King introduces some much needed sanity into the craft with Rules and Tools on Writer Unboxed. His core point is that guidelines followed too closely—as iron-clad rules, in other words—are more likely to hurt than help your writing. Treat those guidelines as tools, and use the right one for the job at the right time, and they will help.

    In Zest + Small Things = Great Writing, Elizabeth Sims (@ESimsAuthor) discusses how focusing on small pieces of your overall story—one detail that isn’t yet fully developed—can be the door to greater or continuing enthusiasm (zest) for the enterprise of writing: for not only getting the writing done, but getting it done well.

    BUSINESS

    If you’re an ebook author, you either know about Smashwords, the free ebook formatter/distributor, or should know about it. One of the service’s best features is that it allows you to create reduced-price coupons for your books when they’re sold through the Smashwords site (but only there, unfortunately). K.S. Brooks shows how to set this up in Getting the Most Out of Smashwords on Indies Unlimited, courtesy Joel Friedlander.

    Also courtesy of Joel is Mark Coker’s (@markcoker) New Smashwords Survey Helps Authors Sell More Books, the blog version of a presentation he’s made recently at the RT Booklovers convention in Kansas City and the Oklahoma Writers’ Federation conference in the Oklahoma City area. Bottom lines (pun fully intended): a $2.99 price points for indie-published books sells better than others (except free) but $3.99 produces more income, certain book lengths (~110,000 words) sell better than others, and there’s a power-law distribution of ebooks, just as there is of traditionally published. This is a long piece, and the slide show on Slideshare is 74 slides, but it’s well worth your time if you’re considering indie publishing.

    SOCIAL MEDIA

    Martina Boone’s (@MartinaABoone) Four Questions to Define Your Social Media Presence on DIY MFA should probably be required reading for anyone who’s just beginning to dip their toes into the social media waters or anyone who’s dissatisfied with their social media presence. He four questions center around goals, inspiration, viability, and enjoyment. Those things aren’t new but deserve repeating and refreshing. I’m marking this as a favorite.

    Last time I mentioned an article by Mayor Lan on making the most of Goodreads. Unfortunately, it assumed you already had an account and knew the basics. Along comes Kimberley Grabas (@KimberleyGrabas) to the rescue with How to Market a Book and Strengthen Your Author Platform with Goodreads on Your Writer Platform, courtesy Joel Friedlander. This long but thorough article takes you through the basics of getting set up and working on this important site. Another definite keeper.

    If you’re not totally down with Twitter, you may not know the etiquette for retweeting someone else’s tweets. Annie Neugebauer (@AnnieNeugebauer) to the rescue with Everything You Need to Know About the Retweet on Writer Unboxed. For just one example, did you know that there are proper and improper ways of adding your own comment to a retweet? To learn the whole panoply of do’s and don’ts, check out her post.

    THE WRITING LIFE

    Nathan Bransford’s (@NathanBransford) wry How to Do Your Chores in 12 Easy Steps begins with “Start a novel.” Enough said. *grin*

    FUN

    There aren’t many video games based on great literature but Robert Bruce (@robertbruce76) has found one for Nintendo that dates back to the 1980s! Yet there’s a playable version of it available on line. Check it out via Gatsby for Nintendo, Old Sport!

  • Critique Technique, Part 7: Scene and Chapter Endings

    I’ve written about beginnings in the last couple of posts. For the next couple, I’ll discuss the endings of sections or scenes, chapters, and the entire piece. I’ll look at the first two here.

    Articles and short stories are often divided into sections or scenes, sometimes even into chapters. Books of all kinds are almost always divided into chapters, and those chapters often have scenes within them.

    Why would a chapter, article, or short story be divided into scenes? In fiction, scenes contain the action in a specific time and place, from a particular point of view, or focused on a certain character. In non-fiction, a section or scene may focus on these or on a specific topic that could be one of several within the piece. When the location, time, point of view, key character, or topic changes, the author can use a transition—usually a word, phrase, or sentence to carry the reader across the change (something I’ll cover in a later article)—or she can start a new scene.

    The end of a scene has two purposes. First, like its beginning, it needs to create curiosity in the reader, to make him wonder what’s next and so propel him onward. The second purpose is to make things worse for the central character, or maybe all of the characters, of that scene. Then, if the piece switches to another character or set of characters, that creates even more tension in the reader because his curiosity isn’t satisfied immediately—he has to wait to find out what’s going to happen.

    Obstacles and Frustration

    Black and yellow concrete barriersImage courtesy of FreeDigitalPhotos.net

    So, how can a scene’s ending create that curiosity and tension, and how can you, the reviewer, tell when it hasn’t? Two words: “obstacles” and “frustration.” Obstacles keep the scene’s protagonist from reaching her immediate and long-term (story) objectives. (I’ll write more about objectives later, too.) At the end of every scene, she should have more obstacles in her way than she had when the scene started, or they should have gotten worse. That should increase her frustration, leaving her wondering, “How am I going to overcome this, along with everything else?” The reader should be asking that, too, whether she’s sympathetic to the scene protagonist’s cause or not.

    In fiction, the writer’s job is to keep making things worse for the story’s major characters (protagonist(s) and antagonist(s))—to raise the stakes for them—right up to the climax. In non-fiction, especially creative non-fiction, the author’s job is similar: to relate how things kept getting worse. Even in something as direct as a how-to article, at the end of each section, the author can present an obstacle the do-it-yourselfer could face.

    Now, that new or improved obstacle doesn’t have to be super-dramatic, the famous “cliffhanger.” In fact, in a chapter or short work, cliffhangers at the end of each scene are probably impossible or will make the reader stop believing the story. The new obstacle can be something simple, or it can be an old one made worse, but it still has to be an obstacle.

    Here’s an example. In my own first novel, The Eternity Plague, one chapter has almost 30 scenes as the focus jumps between five different characters. In one scene, my reporter, Lisa, needs to find Sarah, the leader of a rally that has turned into a riot, something Sarah didn’t plan. Unfortunately for Lisa, she’s on a balcony on the old North Carolina State Capitol building, while Sarah was on a stage fifty yards distant, but has now been hustled away. Lisa doesn’t know where Sarah’s gone and has to get through the chaos of the riot to try to find her. Sarah’s disappearance isn’t a huge obstacle for Lisa in the larger scheme of the story, but it does frustrate her immediate desire to get Sarah’s reaction to the violent collapse of her rally. This leaves the reader wondering, “What will Lisa do? Will she find Sarah? What will she do if she does? What will she do if she doesn’t?” (The next scene, of course, shifts to another character, building my reader’s tension as he waits to find out what happens with Lisa and Sarah.)

    Progress as a Problem

    That said, in a longer piece, and particularly in a short part of that piece, making things worse may not be possible, or desirable. Letting the scene’s or chapter’s protagonist make a little progress sometimes, or seem to make progress, has its benefits:

    1. The reader is encouraged, and so wants to read further.
    2. That progress gives the author more opportunities to make things worse for the protagonist: one step forward makes room for the two steps backward to come.
    3. If the scene’s protagonist is the story’s antagonist, or even a secondary character, letting him make progress toward his goals can be a direct or indirect way to make things worse for the story’s protagonist.

    Those are the requirements for the end of a scene. They’re the same for the end of a chapter, only more so. Cliffhangers are appropriate here, but not at the end of every chapter. Still, the author wants the reader biting his fingernails, wondering what’s going to happen next, and having—just having—to turn the page.

    The bottom line, then, is that in every chapter or scene, something has to happen that changes the situation for the characters involved. The change can be large or small. Its size doesn’t have to match the length of the scene or chapter, although a small change over the course of a long chapter or scene may not seem strong or important enough to keep the reader turning pages. As a reviewer, you’re looking for that change and whether the story moved forward because of it.

    Questions You Can Use

    All right. Now you’re the reviewer and your job is to decide whether the end of a scene or chapter has done its job. Here are questions for you to ask:

    • Did the ending of this scene or chapter make things worse for the character(s)?
      • Did it put new obstacles in their way, or make existing ones worse?
      • Did it add frustrations, or make existing ones worse, as the character(s) try to reach their goals?
    • Did the characters make progress at the end of this scene or chapter, making me wonder what new obstacles they’re about to face?
    • Did the ending increase my tension? Did it make me have to know what happens next?

    If the answer to any of these questions is “no,” figure out how the author failed to make things worse for her characters and/or how she failed to increase your need to know more. Then offer suggestions on how to make the piece better.

    Your Thoughts

    What else do you look for in the end of a scene or chapter to decide whether it’s been a success or not? Put your suggestions in the Comments box below.

  • Great Stuff for Writers, May 8, 2013

    Hey! What happened to Monday? I was traveling, that’s what. And Tuesday? Trying to catch up. And Wednesday? STILL trying to catch up. I’m almost there. So, herewith is an abbreviated and tardy version of Great Stuff: outlining and word choice and beginnings and endings; branding and Goodreads and mastery and saving your work on the cloud.

    CRAFT

    If you’re an outliner, you understand that your outline is a fixed thing, graven in stone. In What Comes After Once Upon a Time, Robert J. Sadler describes how a little item he threw into a story, not thinking it was going to turn out to be important, instead became a key element in getting his latest novel to its conclusion by a path he never intended. But he trusted his storyteller’s instinct and good things happened.

    We all know that we should only use the best words in our writing. See Ernest Hemingway. Poets and their close kin song writers know this better than novelists do. So Joe Moore’s (@JoeMoore_writer) tribute to the just recently passed George Jones, What novelists can learn from song writers, is no surprise but makes the point with economy and clarity.

    Super-agent Donald Maass (@DonMaass) has a brief but excellent piece on Beginning and Ending on Writer Unboxed. The beauty of this piece is its simplicity: the story begins when the protagonist knows something’s changing; it ends when they know that the change is complete and they’ve entered a new world.

    BUSINESS

    Okay, so we’ve all heard about needing to have an “author brand.” What the heck is that? Melissa K. Norris (@MelissaKNorris) explains it in Why Ignoring Your Author Brand is Career Suicide (now that’s a headline that’ll catch your attention!) and goes on to offer a link to a brand development workbook if you subscribe to her and partner Janalynn Voigt’s newsletter.

    SOCIAL MEDIA

    To be honest, Goodreads has been a mystery to me. I have an account but haven’t spent enough time there to understand the site. So along comes Mayor A. Lan (@TheSavvyIndie) to The Creative Penn, where he provides The Ultimate Guide To Goodreads for Authors, and this is a gold mine. Lan lays out the half dozen capabilities Goodreads provides to its registered Goodreads Authors, including the ability for readers to see excerpts of your ebook, buy copies, write reviews, participate in giveaways, and more. I’m marking this post as a favorite to come back to.

    TECHNOLOGY

    Now, this is HUGE. What would happen if your computer crashed? Or was stolen? Or run over by a dump truck? Think it can’t happen? It can and it does to someone every day. EVERY day. So Rachelle Gardner (@RachelleGardner) offers two sets of tools for protecting your work in Never, Never, Never Lose Your Work! First,  use a service like Mozy or Carbonite to do regular (like multiple times a day) backups. Second, use a service like iCloud or Dropbox to hold all of your important files—on the cloud (storage on the web) instead of on your hard drive.

    THE WRITING LIFE

    Here’s a thought that can be both depressing and encouraging, depending on how you want to approach it: “mastery is an asymptote…you can get closer and closer to it, but you can never reach it.” That comes from an interview with Daniel Pink (@DanielPink) done by Ken Coleman and included in Jeff Goins’ (@jeffgoins) Everyone’s an Expert, But Not Everyone Is a Master. I take this as good news: one can always get better if you’re willing to do the work.

  • Critique Technique, Part 6: The Wrong Beginning

    Last time I wrote about how the beginning of a piece is supposed to “hook” the reader, to make them have to keep reading past the first line, the first paragraph, the first page. Now we need to zoom out a little and look at the beginning of the piece as a whole. Specifically, we need to ask, “Is this the right place for the piece to begin?”

    That may seem like an odd question: doesn’t an article, short story, or novel start at the beginning?

    Not necessarily. You’ve probably heard that a story needs to start in medias res, a Latin phrase meaning “in the middle of things.”

    Great. What things?

    Things. You know. The action. The events. Which may, of course, be internal to one of the characters, or external.

    But when there are things, action, events all through a story, which ones should the story start in the middle of?

    What Is the Beginning?

    What is the “beginning” of a story? Let me be more specific. What is the right beginning of a book? That’s a subtle but critical distinction. From this point on I’m going to focus on longer works: novellas, novelettes, and full-length books. Articles and short stories tend to be short enough that there’s less question about exactly where they should start. Not no question, however, so what I’ll discuss here can still apply.

    The problem is, every action, every event that’s part of the story had something happen before it. Lots of somethings, actually. And at least one of those somethings might constitute the beginning. Except that something else happened before it. By this logic, the author would have to go back to the beginning of the universe to find the “real” beginning. That’s not going to work. Well, James Michener could get away with it. Other authors? Not so much.

    As I mentioned last time, new writers tend to want to start with a lot of background information on the characters and their situation. Somewhere in all of that may well be where the story starts, but it’s not where the book should start.

    The beginning of the book has to launch the reader as well as the characters into the piece, even if the events that led to the start of the story happened much earlier. That information, called backstory, can and should be salted into the book later.

    The beginning includes the hook, but it’s more than the hook. The hook is about writing technique; finding the right beginning is about the craft of storytelling. It’s possible to create a hook for a beginning that isn’t the right one. In that case the hook will launch the reader into the piece, only to have her lose interest as the text wanders off into the proverbial woods and gets itself lost.

    The beginning introduces the reader to all or most of the major characters—the protagonist and antagonist for sure, but also key secondary characters—and gives the reader an immediate reason to care about them and their predicament. This is more than just the inciting incident and surface problem of the hook. It’s also the relationships among the key characters, the stakes created by the inciting incident and the surface problem, and the characters’ first response to that problem.

    Example: Ethan Frome

    Is the “inciting incident” the right place for the book to start? Usually yes, but not necessarily. Let me give you an example—Edith Wharton’s Ethan Frome—that seems to contradict what I just wrote, and in so doing illustrates, if not proves, it.

    Ethan and Zeena Frome, desperately poor New England farmers agree, despite their poverty, to take in Zeena’s young cousin Mattie Silver to care for the supposedly sickly Zeena. This agreement is the inciting incident. Mattie is young, beautiful, and vibrant, everything Zeena is not, and Ethan falls in love with her. Zeena notices and sends her away. [Here’s a spoiler alert, if you haven’t read the story.] In a last desperate moment together, Ethan and Mattie go sledding and crash into a tree, forcing Zeena to rise from her sickbed to care for the badly hurt Mattie.

    So, does the novel begin with Ethan and Zeena deciding to take Mattie in? No, it starts with a “frame” in which an unnamed narrator sees the badly crippled, post-accident Ethan, “a ruin of a man,” stagger into the town post office to get his mail. In this extreme case, the novel starts after the story has ended! Why? What was Wharton doing?

    Creating curiosity. Creating the need to know more, to read further—hooking the reader, in other words—to learn the story of Ethan Frome, even though the long preface makes it clear it’s going to come to a terrible end. Frame stories are a kind of special case but they can illustrate beautifully the difference between where a book can start and where the story started.

    Fine. So now you’re the reviewer of someone’s work. How can you tell if they’ve chosen the right—or at least a successful—beginning? It’s easier with an article or short story because you’re likely to have the entire piece in front of you. With a novel, it can be harder, especially if you don’t have the whole manuscript. In this case, you’ll want to wait until you’ve seen more of the book—maybe all of it—before you come to a conclusion.

    And if you’re the author, it’s vital for you to understand that until you have the whole first draft done, you will not really know where the book should start. You will learn things about your story and your characters in the process of writing that first draft that may well cause you to completely replace the beginning you originally wrote. If you do, you will hardly be the first, but your book will be better for it. After I decided I had the wrong beginning for my own first novel, I tried ten other ones; number ten was the right one.

    Review Questions You Can Use

    Here are some questions that can help you decide if the author has selected the right or wrong beginning.

    • Does this beginning take me beyond the hook? Does it amplify and deepen my curiosity about the characters and the story that follows?
    • Does this beginning identify the story’s key characters, their problems, and how significant those problems are? Does it give me a reason to care?
    • Does this beginning consist of action or activities that pull me along? (Note that, as I wrote about the hook, action doesn’t have to be slam-bang shoot-‘em-up stuff. It can be, like Wharton’s, quiet dialog in which the action is psychological, not physical.)
    • Does this beginning focus on the core story, or does it consist of, or wander off into, backstory or tangential material that should come later?
    • Are there other places in the story that would meet these criteria better? If so, what makes them better choices?
    • If nothing in the piece seems right for a beginning, what’s missing? What do you want or need to know to get interested in the characters and their story?

    The beginning is a crucial moment in the relationship between the reader and the story. The wrong beginning, or an ineffective one, will let the reader off the hook (pun fully intended), let her put the book down or flip to the next article or story. Selecting the right place to start isn’t easy but it’s vital and that makes your job as a reviewer that much more important.

    Your Thoughts

    What do you look for when determining whether an article, short story, or novel is starting in the right place? Add your thoughts and suggestions in the Comments box below.