Blog

  • May I?

    One of the things I need to be concerned about that most SF writers don’t with most of their stories is that The Eternity Plague takes place in real places on a real planet–earth. Can I use the names of these real places–not just cities, they’re okay, but institutions–specifically the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center in  Dallas.

    Another potential problem is that one of my characters quotes song lyrics that are still under copyright. Can I use them under the “fair use” principle, or are the lengths of the quotes too long by some standard I don’t know. “Fair use” doesn’t have a hard-and-fast standard by which it’s measured, which makes sense in a lot of ways. But that also makes it difficult to know when you’ve crossed the line when the line is vague and blurry, not bright.

    And when there’s the potential for lawyers to get involved….

    So one of my tasks this week is to contact UT-Southwestern. So far, my phone calls and e-mails haven’t been returned, or even acknowledged. Worse comes to worse, I can always change the center’s name and sidestep that problem.

    The fair use question is bigger and is probably going to require talking to an intellectual property attorney to get a (written) opinion. Or I could change the lyrics from real ones to made-up ones, but that’s an option I don’t like.

    So for now I play mother-may-I.

  • Great Stuff for Writers, April 29, 2013

    Frantically trying to get caught up after spending the last 3 days volunteering with the Oklahoma City Memorial Marathon, something I do every year to honor the memory of a friend of mine who was killed in the bombing of the Murrah Federal Building here. I’ve been a part of the event every year, as a volunteer, runner, or both, and this year was even honored with a profile interview in The Oklahoman, the city’s newspaper, even if the writer did misspell my name.

    But enough of that! This is a writing blog! There’s lots of Great Stuff included this week: foreshadowing, characters who pop, pitching, the benefits of writing short fiction, book marketing, the value of reviews, burnout, learning from writing, and even some fun: one 2-year-old’s takes on books based on their covers. All that and more is waiting for you below.

    CRAFT

    We all want our characters, especially our protagonist and antagonist, to stand out. But how to do it without going over the top or descending into cliché? Katie Weiland (@KMWeiland) offers A Simple Trick for Making Your Characters Pop: add one or two details that contrast with the rest of his or her personality. They don’t have to be huge but so long as you can show that they make sense in the context of the character’s overall life and personality, you’ve just made them memorable.

    We all want feedback that helps us get better, and that’s what Kathleen Pooler (@kathypooler) got, from perhaps the best but most intimidating sources: real agents, editors, and publishers. Still, How Practicing My Pitch Helped Me Write a Better Book on DIY MFA illustrates how the right attitude can turn a not-ready-for-prime-time draft into something that just might make it.

    “The biggest thing I’ve learned from writing short stories,” writes Suzanna Windsor Freeman (@Writeitsideways) in What Novelists Should Know About Short Fiction on Writer Unboxed, “is the art of subtlety: how to be less obvious with symbolism or themes, how to choose subtle titles, and when it’s better to leave things unsaid.” She says more, but that’s enough.

    Before you can know How to Use Foreshadowing, you have to know what it is, what its component pieces are, and how it differs from telegraphing an event and from foreboding. Katie Weiland (@KMWeiland) takes care of all of that in this post, which, by the way, is an example of telegraphing.

    Yikes! Michael Swanwick isn’t kidding when he calls the following A Brutal Test for Your Fiction. It comes straight from early 20th Century humorist Stephen Leacock, who was, as best I can tell, dead serious when he wrote this: “Remove a page from the middle of your work.  Set it aside.  Then read the page before it and the page after.  Can you reconstruct what happened in that page?  Then your work is mediocre at best.” (Italics Swanwick’s.)

    BUSINESS

    Think book reviews don’t matter… or don’t matter much? Angela Ackerman (@AngelaAckerman) traces how they influence future purchases in Book Reviews Matter: Thank You For Taking the Time. Long story short: they matter—a lot.

    We haven’t talked about press kits much here, at least not recently, so Nigerian-born British author Tolulope Popoola’s (@TolulopePopoola) Book Marketing: Creating Your Author Press Kit on The Creative Penn provides a handy summary of the four parts of a good kit. One note: Popoola says the press release should be “brief and sucking”! Must be a British-ism. I presume that means attention-getting or informative.

    With the success and influence of Guy Kawasaki’s book Author, Publisher, Entrepreneur, you’d think Gabriela Pereira (@DIYMFA) was being a crazy woman when she writes Why You Don’t Need to Be an Author Entrepreneur. She’s not. She’s acknowledging that complete entrepreneurship isn’t for everyone, but at the same time, we all do need to be entrepreneurial, that is, looking for—and taking advantage of—opportunities to get our work in front of more people through partnerships, new business models, and new technologies.

    THE WRITING LIFE

    I hope this never happens to you, but Barbara O’Neal’s (@barabaraoneal) Boundaries and Burnout hit really close to home. I’ve been feeling that burn and not in a good way. Fortunately, some tasks I’ve been working on are now done but others await. And there will come a point where, like Barbara, I have to say no or stop doing certain things or save them for later.

    In Here’s What I’m Learning From This One, John Vorhaus (@TrueFactBarFact) announces he’s conquered his fear of writing, and encourages you to do the same. A few truths stand out: “The more words I write, the better I get at writing more words” and “To be a writer is to be emotionally authentic on the page.”

    FUN

    In Robert Bruce’s (@robertbruce76) My 2-Year-Old Judges Books By Their Covers, that’s exactly what we get… but that’s not all. Of course, a 2-year-old isn’t going to get all the symbolism and summary and meaning that a cover artist tries to fit into a cover and still have it make sense; this piece isn’t about that. It’s about the cute things kids will say when given an unusual prompt. But it does also make the point that a puzzling, unclear cover doesn’t help a prospective reader decide to read the book.

  • Critique Technique, Part 5: Weak or Missing Hook

    Before I begin, remember that for each of the items I’ll discuss from now on, you have four questions to ask:

    • Did it happen?
    • Exactly where did it happen?
    • What exactly is the problem? Or what just worked really well?
    • What can the author do to fix it, if something needs fixing?

    OK, so what is a “hook” and how can it be weak or missing? Whatever you’re writing—fiction or non-fiction, poetry or prose—you need to catch and hold your reader’s interest: you need to hook them. And you need to do it early. How early? Well, in a poem it has to happen right away, in the first few lines, since a poem is likely to be brief. But this is true even in a longer piece. In a book, you have a few pages, in a short story, no more than the first few paragraphs. In Hooked, his excellent book on openings, Les Edgerton says the hook needs to be planted within the first 30 pages. Personally, I think it’s within the first 10, and the earlier within those 10, the better.

    The Hook’s Job

    The hook has a lot of work to do. A weak or missing hook does not do that work, or does not do it well.

    Fish hook in cloth
    Photo by Marco Michelini, via FreeImages.com

    Edgerton says those first pages need to do four things:

    1. Introduce the protagonist and their normal world.
    2. Contain the “inciting incident” that throws the protagonist out of that normal world.
    3. Contain the “surface problem,” the problem they initially think they have to solve.
    4. Introduce the first hints of the “story-worthy problem,” which is what will drive the protagonist through the rest of the book.

    To tell if a hook is present or absent, weak or strong, ask yourself questions like these:

    • Do I know who the important characters are?
      • If the answer is no or you’re not sure, why? Did two or more characters seem to have equal weight, for example? Did no one stand out?
    • Are the characters people I immediately become interested in? Do I care about them right away, even in a negative way? Uninteresting characters are far worse than unsympathetic ones—ones the reader does not like. Writers want their readers to respond to their characters, even if they hate them. But if the reader’s response is “meh,” that’s a problem the author has to fix.
    • Do I know what the protagonist’s problem is? As a reader, you may not know the full scope and extent of the story-worthy problem right away. Indeed, that may not be revealed until the very end, but the reader needs to know there’s a problem—and an important one in the protagonist’s mind—right from the beginning. That’s likely to be the surface problem, but it will begin the revelation of the story-worthy problem. If that is not happening, tell the author.
    • Do I at least have some sense of how big and important this problem is to the characters?
      • What’s at stake for them if they fail to solve it? What do they stand to lose?
      • What’s at stake if they do solve it? What do they stand to gain?
      • If you cannot positively answer at least some of these questions, then the author has not identified the stakes.
    • Do I get bogged down in the character’s history? I’ll discuss backstory in a later article. New authors have a tendency to think they need to provide all sorts of background about the major characters at the beginning of the book. That’s not true, and it buries the hook. If this seems to be happening, be sure to let the writer know, especially if nothing grabs you.

    A True Story

    Here’s an example of what I mean. My friend Debrah Strait was working on her first book and took the latest draft of her first chapter to her writers’ group. They were, shall we say, less than enthusiastic. After the meeting, Debrah went to Safeway and while she was in the store, she met a friend and complained about what the group had said. Her friend asked to see the piece, which Debrah still had in her purse.

    She read the first page. “I don’t care about that,” she said.

    She read the second page. “I don’t care about that.”

    When she finally got to page seven, where pirates began attacking a small settlement on a remote Caribbean island by blowing up a warehouse, she said, “Now I’m interested. Start here.”

    Debrah said, “But but but….”

    “Start. Here.”

    In the final version of The Sweet Trade, the warehouse blows up at the top of page two (and the rest of the village is destroyed and the residents are killed), and young Dirk and his friends, who were playing some distance away, are thrust into the world of piracy that will carry them through the rest of the story. On page one, Debrah introduced the protagonist and his normal world, and on page two, she blew that normal world up. That’s an effective hook.

    Other Components of the Hook

    A hook involves more than plot and characterization. The author’s “tone” or “voice”—how the piece sounds in the reader’s head—is also part of the hook. This might seem to be true primarily in poetry and so-called “literary” fiction, but it applies across genres and forms. Note that there is no “right” tone. Whining and sniveling, done well, can be as attention-catching and –holding as a slam-bang shoot-‘em-up opening scene. Note, too, that “done well” is not the same as what you personally prefer. The question is not whether you liked the opening but whether it grabbed and held your interest. Whether it did or it did not, again, you need to identify why.

    Pace, or lack of it, can also make a hook strong or weak, but it’s not a matter of fast or slow. A scene that goes screaming by may not be a good opening. If it fails at some of the tasks I’ve already discussed, it may not hook the reader. Similarly, a slow scene won’t be boring if it succeeds at those tasks. Again, the questions are:

    • Did it catch and hold my interest?
    • Did it make me want to keep reading?
    • If not, why not, and what can the author do to fix the problem?
    • If so, what was it about the opening that pulled me in?

    The hook also needs to introduce the piece’s setting and mood: when and where it takes place, what the physical, spiritual, and emotional environments are, etc. A weak hook does not establish these.

    That’s a lot to demand of just a line, a sentence, a paragraph, or a few pages, but that’s how important the hook is. If the opening does not hook the reader, he or she will go on to something else, meaning a lost potential fan, or at least a lost sale. On the other hand, a strong hook will launch the reader into the piece. If they have to keep reading past the opening, the hook has done its job.

    Your Thoughts

    In your mind, what makes a hook strong or weak? Do you have any examples you’d like to share? Please put your thoughts or examples in the Comments box below.

  • Another Step

    This morning I took another important step on the road to publication: I sent the manuscript off to a proofreader/copy editor. Whew. Little by little, The Eternity Plague is turning into a “real” book, as opposed to a manuscript.

    There are still a few loose ends to tie up: either getting permission from the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center to use the Center’s name in the story, or changing the name to something else; and getting a reading on whether the song lyrics my reporter character, Lisa Lange, quotes from time to time can be considered “fair use” or if I have to get permission to use them too.

    If UT-Southwestern says no, that’s an easy fix: global find-and-replace is a wonderful thing. Getting permission for the song lyrics could take longer, if I have to. I sure hope I don’t.

    Meanwhile, this has turned into a kind of overwhelming month, with too many things to do. But I’ve got a solution: I’m getting away for a couple weeks. Over the weekend I’ll be volunteering with the Oklahoma City Memorial Marathon, something I do every year to honor the memory of a friend who was killed in the bombing of the Murrah Federal Building. The following weekend, I’ll be attending the Oklahoma Writers Federation’s annual conference. In between and afterwards I’ll be visiting friends and relatives. A much-needed break, except that some work is going to follow me. SIGH.

    But no whining–better this than being bored, at least so long as I don’t lose my mind.

  • Great Stuff for Writers, April 22, 2013

    If you read nothing else this week, read Joel Friedlander’s piece on the destruction of the writing web site Publetariat down in the Technology section. Protecting your blog or web site needs to be high on your priority list because there are slimeballs out there who will destroy web sites just for the pleasure of destroying them. If you have a WordPress.org-based site, I point you to a resource that will help you keep your site safe.

    In addition we have posts on picking titles, getting everything right in a story, ending it well, ebook publishing options and resources, going to writers’ conferences, writer’s courage, and the differences between Microsoft Word formats and why that matters to you.

    CRAFT

    Kris Montee, one of the sisters who write as PJ Parrish, has plenty of great advice about picking the title for your work. Sounds easy, right? It’s not. And When Titles Go Bad, sales tend to follow, if there are even sales in the first place. So while at the end of the piece she lists 10 things to do, I like this one (#10) best: write 20 candidate titles and let them sit for a week. When you come back, one will pop.

    It must be titles week, because here’s another piece on Finding a Good Title, this one by Sophie Masson (@SophieMasson1). She provides only 4 tips, compared to Kris Montee’s 10, but they’re also good: titles can be simple but complex, poetic, or mysterious can work as well. Theme, atmosphere, setting, or characters can also provide the keys. Bottom line: keep your mind and mental ear open for that magic phrase.

    Giving your story a satisfactory ending is one of the surest ways to bring your reader back for more. So how do you play The End Game well? Joe Moore (@JoeMoore_writer) provides a number of ideas: the protagonist gets what he wants, or doesn’t, or gets something different but better (or worse), or has done to him what he was trying to do to others. Or something entirely unexpected happens. Or something else entirely. Whatever you do, leave the reader satisfied.

    Before the reader can be satisfied, the writer needs to be, but as Boyd Morrison (@boydmorrison) points out, Getting Everything Right Is Wrong. When it comes to self-satisfaction, there’s a time to let go of tweaking the micro-details that don’t improve the story.

    BUSINESS

    We all know—or we should know—that going to writers’ conferences can be valuable. But what about other kinds? In Get Thee to a Conference, Writer!, Jan Dunlap describes why she goes to what she calls “pre-writing conferences”—conferences that have to do with the interests and topics that form the backgrounds of her stories. These meetings provide not only the latest information on what’s happening in these fields but are also new marketing opportunities. Wins all around.

    Last week James Scott Bell (@jamesscottbell) wrote about publishing options. One of the responses got him thinking about How to Make Money Self-Publishing Fiction. Using Earle Stanley Gardner as an example (although, of course, Gardner didn’t self-publish), Bell suggests writers treat their writing as (1) a job, (2) a craft, (3) a sacrifice, (4) a mad passion, (5) an adventure. Aren’t those contradictory? Not really: they’re components. And even if they were, isn’t contradiction what we writers deal in?

    Looking for a one-stop shop for information on How to Publish an E-Book? Jane Friedman (@JaneFriedman) has assembled a compendium of literally dozens of resources on getting started, marketing and promotion, tools, major retailers and distributors, and e-book bloggers. Keep in mind, as Jane notes, that the e-book world is changing constantly and what’s true today may not be six months from now.

    TECHNOLOGY

    This one’s for the geeks among us. In X Hits the Spot: Why .DOCX is Better than .DOC for Authors Using Word, Tracy R. Atkins (@TracyRAtkins) explains the important differences between Microsoft Word’s .docx format and the .doc format that preceded it. The short version: it’s FAR more than just one letter added to the end of the filename extension. And there are a lot more and better reasons than Microsoft wanting to make money by forcing us to buy a new software package.

    If you have a web site, or even a blog, you MUST read the first section of Joel Friedlander’s (@JFBookman) News: Publetariat, New York Times, BookDesignTemplates.com.  That first section deals with the web site Publetariat, which Writer’s Digest just named one of its 101 Best Sites for Writers, and as one of the Best of the Best. A week later, it was hacked and all but destroyed. Joel tells the story in brief. The lesson to be learned is this: Do everything you can to protect your site. WordPress is the best-known (and probably therefore most-attacked) Content Management System in its WordPress.org incarnation, but Publetariat was based on Drupal, another CMS, and still got whacked. If you have a WordPress.org-based web site, I strongly recommend checking out The WordPress Security Checklist, available either in free ebook form here or in its online form here. NOTE: the authors of the checklist say it’s written for the non-technical user, but that’s not entirely true. Even so, if you know how to install plug-ins, you’ll be able to do much of what the Checklist recommends (and if you don’t, it’s easy to learn how).

    THE WRITING LIFE

    Rachelle Gardner (@RachelleGardner) asks a challenging and important question: What Would You Do If You Weren’t Afraid? Naturally, she focuses the question on work and writing (hers and ours), and of course that’s legitimate, but it could also be extended to the rest of our lives. And the answers could be very revealing. Scary, no? But valuable? Yes!

  • Critique Technique, Part 2: Series Overview

    Before we get down to the nitty-gritty details of what to critique and how to do it, I want to give you a high-level overview of what the rest of this series is going to cover. We’ll look at twelve broad categories:

    • Reader response
    • Beginnings and endings
    • Characters and characterization
    • Setting
    • Plot
    • Flashbacks, flash-forwards, and backstory
    • Narrative and dialogue
    • Pace
    • Description
    • General story-telling problems
    • Mechanical errors
    • Positive reinforcement, and
    • Other topics

    Whew, that’s a lot! “But wait, there’s more!” Much, much more, as you’ll see in a minute.

    Positive reinforcement gets its own section because writers need positive strokes, to hear that something they wrote actually “worked,” that it moved the reader in some way. This is why “critique” is not criticism: its point is NOT to merely find all the ways a work failed, didn’t live up to its potential, etc., but also to identify its successes so the author can, we hope, repeat them.

    Four Overall Questions

    For all of the sections and specific topics that follow, you’ll want to ask and answer the following four questions.

    #1: Did this problem happen?

    I know this seems like an odd question, but since I’ll be discussing 50+ (yes, 50+) different potential problem areas, not all of them will come up in every piece. At least, let’s hope not! You’re going to be on the lookout for all of them, though, and when you find one, your brain should  go ping! (or ah-ha!, or uh-oh!). That’s when you’ll move on to the next question.

    Does this sound hard? Don’t worry, it is, at first. That’s why I’m introducing the problem areas little by little: you only have to absorb one or a few at a time. And with practice, it does get easier.

    #2: Where did it happen?

    Be specific! Identify the spot right on the manuscript. Do more than just underline or circle it, though. In your notes in the margin—you DO write margin notes, don’t you?—answer the next two questions.

    #3: What was the exact nature of the problem?

    Again, be as specific as possible. WARNING: this requires actually thinking about the writing, not just letting it go in one eye and out the other! J Seriously, this is a very writerly task, and it’s a learned skill, not one that comes easily or naturally to a lot of people. If it takes you some time to learn it, that’s OK.

    One technique I use is to read each work twice. The first time, I read fairly quickly, just to get an overall sense of it. The second time is when I really slow down and look for the kinds of things this series will discuss.

    As you learn how to do this kind of review, you’ll find yourself applying it to your own writing as well, and that’s the most powerful benefit of critiquing other people’s work.

    #4: What can the author do to fix it?

    Another tough question! This one’s tricky, too, because it’s not your task to (re)write someone else’s piece to fit your style. Instead of saying, “If I was writing this story, I would have written…,” go back to question #3, try to determine what the writer was trying to accomplish, and then propose a way that he or she might do that.

    This is also a learned skill, so don’t be concerned if you have trouble doing it at first. If you’re a member of a writers’ group, listen to your fellow writers and how they try to accomplish this task. What seems to work? What doesn’t? The author’s verbal and non-verbal responses—and your own—to these suggestions will tell you a lot.

    There’s one last thing that makes this task tricky: the author is free to ignore your suggestions! Even if you think you’re right right RIGHT, if the author thinks you’re wrong wrong WRONG, guess who wins? Not you. At least, not in the near term. Do your best, then tell your ego to sit down and be quiet. Everyone will be happier for it.

    OK, that’s it for this time. Next time we’ll start looking at reader response: what it is and why it’s a good place to start giving critique from.

    A Question for You

    Meanwhile, I’d like to hear from you. When you critique or review a piece, are there any overall techniques you use or questions you keep in mind? I’m looking forward to reading your thoughts and approaches in the comment box below.

     

  • Late to start, late to finish

    It’s been a crazy week ’round here and things that should be getting done either aren’t, or are, but late. Like this post.

    The good news is that one important task, finishing my last edits, including deleting an entire chapter, got done today. So, all that’ s let to do is write the Acknowledgements and front matter (at least in rough draft form) and the manuscript of The Eternity Plague will be ready to head off to my copy editor. And just in time, as other tasks await.

    Meanwhile, in virus news, the latest strain of avian (bird) flu in Asia, an H7N9 strain, is once again killing a large percentage of the people it infects–while infecting very few people. A detail that is not keeping the press from being all a-twitter (pun fully intended) over the latest potential pandemic–subtext: how excited they are at the prospect of covering yet another disaster, which they’ll hype before and during, and have theme music and special graphics for.

    Oh, sorry. Got a little carried away there. But that press hype was one of the behaviors motivating the original idea for the book, even though it never really came out in the completed story. Well, that’s not entirely true. One of the secondary characters, Antonio Corolli, is a self-aggrandizing, self-promoting reporter, but for the most part in today’s media environment, it’s not the reporters who do they hyping, its their networks, and that just wasn’t going to fit in the story.

    That’s all for this late-started, late-finished installment. Other tasks await.

  • Great Stuff for Writers, April 15, 2013

    It’s Tax Day in America, which is anything but a holiday, with millions of people frantically trying to do what they could have done any time in the last 10 weeks, but then, who LIKES paying taxes? So this week we have one post on that very subject, plus pieces on blogging, storytelling, characterization, publishing, “tweetables,” and making time for writing. Enjoy!

    CRAFT

    I know for some people there never seems to be enough time to write, so adding one more writing task seems counterproductive if not impossible. But Dan Blank (@danblank) makes the case for 4 Ways Blogging Will Make You a Better Writer on DIY MFA. He argues that blogging (1) makes you publish, (2) focuses you on writing and getting read, (3) adds new ways to connect to readers, and (4) builds the habit of writing (I’d put that at #1, actually). Nothing really new here, but good reinforcement.

    Lisa Cron (@lisacron) doesn’t have to ask, What is a Natural Storyteller? because she already knows. You do too. But she uses that question to make the distinction between what we do when we tell a story—verbally—and what we do when we write a story and why we too often let that distinction block us. Check out the four things we can learn from natural storytelling and the 12 questions you can ask yourself to become better at it.

    Yes, David Corbett (@DavidCorbett_CA) does list what he considers to be The Five Cornerstones of Dramatic Characterization in his guest post on The Creative Penn—several times, in fact, and they’re good ones—but the part that jumped out at me was this statement: “Characterization requires a constant back-and-forth between the exterior events of the story and the inner life of the character.” It’s that back-and-forth that develops the character’s depth.

    BUSINESS

    Some of us (increasingly more, it seems) who have been fortunate enough to have been traditionally published are suddenly finding ourselves shut out. What to do? In Help! I’m Published and I Can’t Get Up!, James Scott Bell (@jamesscottbell) advises taking a step back and doing some self assessing: what kind of writer/publisher are you—he suggests four types, from “hands off” to “arms around”—and then that thing we’ve all heard before, but based on step 1: never give up.

    Today being Tax Day in the U.S., it’s a bit of a surprise to see only one post on taxes. But Rachelle Gardner (@RachelleGardner) does provide some practical advice for writers in Taxes and Writers, with the important caveat that she’s not a CPA or a tax attorney. It can be hard to remember but having to pay taxes on your writing income is a good thing: it means you’re making money from your writing!

    SOCIAL MEDIA

    You may have noticed items popping up in blogs labeled “Tweetable” or “Click to tweet.” Wonder what that’s about? They’re called Tweetables and they’re a new way to get the best pieces of your latest post out into the Twitterverse right away. Jordyn Redwood (@JordynRedwood) provides a quick how-to and the link to clicktotweet.com to make it happen.

    THE WRITING LIFE

    It seems to me I’ve written about excerpts from Sage Cohen’s (@sagecohen) book The Productive Writer before, even on this topic: Make More Time for Your Writing. Nonetheless, this post from the Writer’s Digest There Are No Rules blog had one little piece that really jumped out at me. By way of several references, Cohen notes that the Chinese ideogram for “busy” is composed of two others: the one for heart and the one for killing. Hmmm.

    If today’s tax day for you, how are you dealing with it?

  • Critique Technique, Part 4: Authorial Intentions and Tracking Your Own Responses

    I wrote in the previous article about keeping track of how a piece of writing makes you feel when you’re reviewing it. In this post, I was going to explore identifying why it made you feel that way, but I discovered I should introduce another topic first: “Is that what the author wanted me to feel?” Both questions—that one and “How did this piece make me feel?”—need to be followed by the questions, “Why did the piece make me feel this way?” and “Why did the author want me to feel that way?”

    Now, of course, you can’t have perfect knowledge of the author’s intent if you’re not the author  (and sometimes not even when you are) but some elements of common sense can apply. For example, if a scene seems like it’s supposed to be sad but it’s making you giggle, that’s a problem. Or, if the scene is supposed to be funny and you’re not getting even the slightest hint of a chuckle out of it, that’s a problem, too. On the other hand, a scene that’s doing what it was meant to do—and doing it well—is, from a writer’s perspective, a joy to read, even if it’s making you bawl your eyes out or scream in fright. Especially then.

    You will always have some kind of emotional response to a piece of writing. Always. “Emotional” doesn’t mean extreme emotion: uncontrollable sobbing or rolling on the floor laughing. Boredom is also an emotional response. So are frustration, confusion, delight, even sexual arousal. “Emotional” covers the full range of reactions.

    Driving Factors

    What factors drive or create your emotional response? First and foremost, character behavior. Ask yourself how you are responding to these factors.

    • What are the characters doing, thinking, saying, and feeling?
    • How are they interacting with each other, their environment, and their situation?
    • Are their behaviors consistent with or contrary to their situation or environment?
    • Are their behaviors what you expected, or did they surprise you?
    • How emotionally engaged are you with the characters? How much or how little do you care about them and what is happening to them?

    Other things will affect your emotional response, too. Setting comes to mind, as do the story’s structure, its tone and style, even its pace, but the primary driver will be the characters.

    Capture Your Response

    Woman reading a book
    Image courtesy of Marin / FreeDigitalPhotos.net

    Your job as a reviewer is to capture for the author where he or she:

    • Got it right—where the writing, the intent, and your response all came together;
    • Got it wrong—where what the author apparently wanted you to feel isn’t what you felt; or,
    • Left you confused or not knowing what to feel. Perhaps the intent was unclear, or the intention and the writing didn’t quite match.

    Then, you need to identify why you responded that way. This requires that awareness—“right now I’m feeling [emotion] because [the characters are doing/saying/feeling/thinking X, for example]”—and the ability to capture that awareness and write it down.

    Finally, when the writing isn’t successful, try to suggest to the author how he or she might achieve what you think they meant to.

    In later posts, we’ll get into the details of characterization, structure, setting, pace, tone, dialog, and narrative that will help you explain your response in more detail. As a new reviewer, however, this much is enough for you to be helpful to your fellow author.

    Your Thoughts

    What techniques do you use to track your emotional response to a piece of writing? Share them in the Comments below.

     

  • Hacking and Cutting

    A couple of events conspired recently to turn into an important revelation.

    The first event was getting the feedback from my beta readers. One told me a certain chapter stopped her cold and it took her a couple weeks to pick the manuscript up again. Uh-oh! Another told me she struggled through the same chapter. Double uh-oh!

    Then, about two weeks ago, as I was reading through a chapter of a novel by a member of my writers’ group, I experienced a similar problem. Half-way through I just had to put it down. Uh-oh again! As I thought about why that was, I realized that while his chapter was well written in many ways, its major flaw was how much backstory it contained.

    That’s when the 25 Watt light bulb over my head began to flicker.

    My problematic chapter had a similar problem: too much backstory in the process of introducing a bunch of new characters. Which, interestingly enough, my professional editor didn’t catch or see as a problem. Hmmm. Who’s right? After all, the other two beta readers didn’t have a problem with that chapter either.

    What to do? What to do?

    Experiment: that’s what to do! I’ve created a fresh draft—number 6K for those of you keeping score at home—in which I’m chopping out most of that chapter and transferring only the key elements to other places in the text. Then I’ll compare and contrast.

    The version that works better will be the one that goes to my copy editor.

    …And the beat goes on.