Tag: critique

  • “Elements of Critique” Review

    3.5 star rating

    (cover image)

    It’s important to understand what David Williamson’s short book is and what it is not. It is not, and readers should not expect it to be, a complete or exhaustive guide to how to effectively critique another writer’s work. It’s clear Williamson never intended it to be that.

    Instead, the book is a collection of 26 slightly revised blog posts, plus three additional articles, that provide brief discussions of some critique topics and techniques. Because the original posts—running in alphabetical order from “Appearance” to “Zaftig”—were short, Williamson could only scratch the surface, touching on a few topics each time.

    In general, he does a reasonable job with the space he has available. There are a few places where his suggestions miss the mark, however. In his chapter on point of view, he seems to be OK with head-hopping, that is, shifting from one point of view character to another within a scene or chapter without any sort of break, like a scene break. This goes against the general guidance for writers that there should be only one viewpoint character per scene.

    In his chapter on verb tenses, he fails to address transitions into and out of flashbacks, where the verb tense must naturally shift.

    Finally, in several chapters, Williamson inserts elements of his faith. This is inappropriate in a book that has nothing to do with religion or faith.

    These problems pull what would have been a 4-star rating for its target audience down a half star (although most places where this review will be posted don’t allow half-star ratings).

    Elements of Critique can serve as a basic introduction to critiquing for a writer who’s just getting started at it, but it is not appropriate for a more experienced critiquer.

  • ‘The Dictionary of Fiction Critique’ Review

    Kate Jonuska’s idea to create a dictionary of critique terms and intermingle them with a bit of discussion seems like a clever technique at first, but the idea quickly loses its luster. First, Jonuska interrupts the flow of the book every time she inserts the definition of a new term and provides an example or two. These interruptions make it very hard to piece together coherent concepts from which a reviewer can build a critique.

    Second, dictionaries are not typically the kind of book one reads in order to try to build a broad understanding of a concept. So between the final third of the book, which is devoted to an A to Z listing of terms, their definitions, and examples, and many of the same terms, definitions, and examples spread through the first two-thirds, maybe a third of the book is devoted to discussions of techniques for providing critique. And as with a standard dictionary, if you don’t know or don’t remember the term you’re trying to get a better understanding of, scrolling through the dictionary, hoping to come across the one you’re looking for is hardly an effective way to learn.

    At times, the author notes that certain concepts are known by several different names. So far, so good, but in the dictionary section, while she does point the reader to the primary term from the secondary one(s), she misses an opportunity to use internal hyperlinks to make the jump to that primary term far easier than scrolling and scrolling and scrolling forward or backward to get to its definition.

    Third, Jonuska spends as much time, if not more, addressing writers as she does reviewers. This is a hard to avoid hazard of any book which means to teach writers how to critique their own or another’s work. Writers have to know the craft in order to be able to meaningfully critique someone’s writing, but a book meant for critiquers needs to address the task of critiquing more clearly and consistently than the author does.

    Finally, the book is rife with spelling and coding errors. Star Wars fans will find it hard to forgive Jonuska’s consistent misspelling of Princess Leia’s name (it’s not Leah). There are also far too many instances—dozens—where the HTML coding for the text of examples is revealed (for example, * <span style=“color: #00000A”>). The failure to catch these errors suggests either simple sloppiness or a rush to publish.

    The book is not completely without merit. I did encounter a few terms and concepts that were new to me, but not enough to overcome the book’s many weaknesses. For an experienced critiquer, this book might have some value when they want to refresh their memory on a particular concept—at least if they use the same terms Jonuska does. But for the new critiquer, this book is going to be far less helpful than it could have been.

    Not recommended.

  • Critique Technique Table of Contents

    Here’s a Table of Contents of all of the Critique Technique posts to make it easier to go directly to the post you want to read.

    Introductory Posts

    Part 1: Critique, Technique, and Procedure

    Part 1A: The Critiquer’s Mind

    Part 1B: Life on the Other Side of the Critique

    Part 2: Series Overview

    Reader Response

    Part 3: How Do You Feel?

    Part 3.5: Authorial Intentions and Tracking Your Own Responses

    Beginnings and Endings

    Part 5: Weak or Missing Hook

    Part 6: The Wrong Beginning

    Part 7: Scene and Chapter Endings

    Part 8: Story Endings

    Characterization

    Part 9: Characters and Conflict

    Part 10: Poor Characterization

    Part 11: Lack of Character Development

    Part 12: Showing and Telling in Character Development

    Part 13: Timing the Reveal

    Part 14: Out-of-Character Behavior

    Part 15: Unclear Character Goals

    Part 16: Unclear or Insufficient Obstacles

    Part 17: Dialect, Foreign Languages, and Jargon

    Setting

    Part 18: Lost In Space

    Part 19: Vague Setting

    Part 20: Too Much Setting Detail

    Plot

    Part 21: Unclear Plot

    Part 22: Overly Complex Plot

    Part 23: Confused Storyline

    Flashbacks, Flash-Forwards, and Backstory

    Part 24: Unclear Transitions

    Part 25: Misused Backstory or Flashback

    Part 26: Tangents

    Narrative and Dialogue

    Part 23.5: Read-Out-Loud Tools

    Part 27: Narrative and Dialogue

    Part 28: Awkward Dialog

    Part 29: Writers’ Tics

    Part 30: Too Many Words, or Too Few

    Part 31: The Wrong Words

    Part 32: %*@!$#^!!!! (Swearing)

    Part 33: Contradictions

    Part 34: Imbalance Between Narrative and Dialogue

    Part 35: Name-Calling

    Part 36: As You Know, Bob

    Pace

    Part 37: The Pieces of Pace

    Part 38: Pace: Speed It Up, Whoa It Up, or Change It Up

    Description

    Part 39: The Gray Haze

    Part 40: What Was That Again?

    Part 41: The Dreaded Expository Lump

    Part 42: Too Many Notes

    Part 43: Telling, Not Showing

    General Story-Telling Problems

    Part 44: Pop Goes the Reader!

    Part 45: No Story Arc

    Part 46: Padding

    Part 47: Danglers

    Part 48: Stating the Obvious

    Part 49: Point of View Shifts

    Mechanical Errors

    Part 50: Spelling

    Part 51: Punctuation

    Part 52: Capitalization

    Part 53: Grammar Errors

    Part 54: Manuscript Format

    Positive Reinforcement

    Part 55: Good Job!

    Part 56: Great Start!

    Part 57: Magic Middles

    Part 58: Ending a Scene or Chapter Well

    Other Topics

    Part 59: The End

    Bonus Material: Read-Out-Loud Tools and Techniques

  • Critique Technique, Part 17: Dialect, Foreign Languages, and Jargon

    This is the last post in the series on characterization. Next time we’ll move on to setting.

    Confused person
    Photo by Jeroen van Oostrom, via FreeDigitalPhotos.net

    If you’ve traveled around the country, or watched TV or the movies, or done just about anything other than live under a rock, you know that people speak differently in different places. They have different accents, different slang terms, and different styles of speaking. Compare the laconic Mainer or cowboy to the fast-talking New Yorker. And that’s just in the United States! Canadians, Britons, Scots, Irish, New Zealanders, Australians, and some Indians and Kenyans (to name just a few) speak English, too.

    And they all do it differently.

    England’s WWII Prime Minister Sir Winston Churchill famously described America and England as “two nations separated by a common tongue.” Love that line.

    The differences aren’t just geographic, either. There are differences between racial and ethnic groups, economic classes, age groups, education levels, and more.

    And we writers want to capture them. After all, the way a character speaks says a lot about them.

    But aye, there’s the rub. Several rubs, in fact.

    Hard to Replicate

    Dialect is hard to write and even harder to read and understand, especially in large quantities. Have you ever tried to write out a Bostonian’s accent? We all know “pahk the cah in Hahvahd Yahd, Roberter,” right? Or that of someone from the Deep South? Y’all sho’ kin trah. Or someone from The Bronx? Fuhgeddaboudit. You end up doing all sorts of alphabetic gymnastics trying to capture sounds that are hard, if not impossible to represent just with English’s 26 letters and a few punctuation marks. And try to use all those special characters you find in dictionaries, the ones that are supposed to help you understand how to pronounce a word? That’s asking a reader to work way too hard. A writer might get away with that once. More than that and the reader is likely to put the book down.

    There are better approaches. I’ll have suggestions on them later.

    Disrespectful?

    The second rub is that some writers, teachers, and critics think writing in dialect shows disrespect for characters, that it belittles them. There may be some merit to this argument. Think about it: How many characters have you read, who were supposed to have high cultural or economic standing, but spoke with a deep southern accent or a slow western drawl if the story wasn’t set in one of those locations? Not many, I’ll bet. That mismatch between how a reader expects a character to sound and how they actually do could make a character more interesting, but it could also be used to mark them in a negative way.

    If a writer is creating this mismatch intentionally, they need to make that clear as early as they can. Note, however, that this might not be early at all if the author intends to misdirect the reader, the other characters, or both.

    Foreign languages are also things to be careful with. If a character comes from a foreign country, it’s OK in some circumstances for an author to drop in an occasional foreign word:

    • If it’s the right word, or the only word, she can use to express a certain idea or concept;
    • If it’s a common-to-him word that he would naturally use in place of the English one; or
    • Just to establish the character as being foreign.

    It can also be OK for an author to throw into a character’s dialogue enough foreign words to show her putting on airs or otherwise trying to be someone she is not.

    Better ways to show that a character is speaking English as a foreign language are to use English words that are technically correct, or almost right, but are not the ones a native speaker would use, or to rearrange the structure of their sentences. Think about how Yoda spoke in the Star Wars movies, with his verbs at the end of his sentences.

    Cover Other Weaknesses

    A third rub is an author using dialect, foreign words, or jargon to cover up other weaknesses in the piece, particularly in characterization, or to show off their own vocabulary. A friend of mine once used the word mephitic to describe the smell of a men’s restroom. Sending readers to the dictionary is a good way to ensure they never pick up the book or story again.

    When Jargon is Acceptable

    If a character works in a field that has its own specialized jargon, which all do, then it’s appropriate for him to use that language. Of course, the author needs to use that jargon correctly, and in ways that would be natural for the character. People often forget that others don’t understand their jargon, which can lead to confusion and misunderstanding. Authors can and should take advantage of that, so long as only the other characters are confused and not the reader—at least not for long.

    There’s a special proviso here for non-fiction works: If the piece is being written for a specialized audience (say for hunters and sport shooters in Guns and Ammo) or for a field’s professional magazine (for example, Cell in biology), then the jargon needs to be there. It adds clarity and accuracy rather than reducing it.

    The general rule of thumb is that authors should use dialect, foreign words, and jargon sparingly, only enough to establish what they need to about the character. Once the character’s background, social standing, culture, heritage, profession, etc., have been established, the author should minimize how much they use those special words and phrases. If a character has been off-stage for a while, using a little dialect or jargon when they come back into the story is appropriate.

    Questions for You

    All right, then, time to put on your reviewer’s hat. Here are some questions to ask regarding dialect, foreign languages, and jargon as you review a work.

    • Is the dialect, foreign language, or jargon necessary and appropriate to the piece?
      • If it isn’t necessary, appropriate, or both, what should the author do to fix the problem?
    • Does the amount of dialect, foreign language, or jargon, or the way it’s being written, make the piece hard to read? Does it confuse rather than clarify?
      • If so, what should the author change or remove?
    • Does the author seem to be using dialect, foreign language, or jargon to belittle a character?
      • Is that appropriate for the story? For example, does he want the reader to not respect that character?
      • Could that be accomplished some other way, such as through the character’s behavior? Is that being done already?
      • If none of these are the case, what should the author do to fix the problem?
    • Does the author seem to be using dialect, foreign language, or jargon to cover up other weaknesses or over-impress with her vocabulary?

    Used properly, dialect, foreign words, or jargon can add to a piece, giving it the flavor of a particular environment, giving a character an added or necessary dimension, or adding a degree of authenticity or authority to the story. That’s what you, as a reviewer, should be trying to help the author achieve.

    What do you look for, and look out for, when reviewing how an author uses dialect, foreign terms, or jargon? Y’all kin ‘splain yore thinkin’ in that comment box down yonder.

  • Critique Technique, part 14: Out-of-Character Behavior

    Comedy has been defined as “ordinary people in extraordinary situations, or extraordinary people in ordinary situations.” But what if the piece you’re critiquing isn’t comedy—or isn’t meant to be comedy? When a character you’ve come to know suddenly acts in a way that makes you stop, scratch your head, and say “huh?”, maybe there’s a problem.

    Maybe. That’s an important word. What does the story’s context tell you about this new behavior? If Alice suddenly starts screaming, which she’s never done before, but it’s because the car she’s riding in just went off a cliff, that’s reasonable. If, on the other hand, as the car begins its graceful, 1,000 foot descent, she calmly takes out her .357 Magnum and blows away the driver, well, maybe not so much. OK, I can understand her being pissed at him, but really, what good does shooting him now do? [Oh, right. Next, she unbuckles her seat belt, pulls her parachute from the back seat, wrestles it on—how convenient that all the straps are already adjusted to her size—opens the door, steps out, and— SPLAT! Oops, too late! Dang. Well, BASE jumping [1] was never her forte, anyway.]

    What’s the Reason?

    There are lots of stories in which someone’s personality changes suddenly and dramatically, but the good ones (and some of the not-so-good ones) justify the change. You know why. And if the change makes sense, all’s well.

    It is possible for an author to have a character’s behavior change significantly, or have some new and very different-from-the-norm trait appear, without explaining it or setting the context for it before or at the moment of change. If he does, though, he’s asking the reader to trust that all will be made clear in good time. That’s fine, so long as he keeps that implicit promise.

    Sometimes it can be hard to tell if the promise is kept, however. If you’re reading a long piece like a novella or full-length novel, but you’re only seeing it a few chapters at a time, the explanation for the new behavior may not show up in the material you’re reading. In that case, you need to ask about it. If it’s a mistake, it’s possible the author didn’t realize she’d made it.

    Questions For You

    Your task as a reviewer, then, is to do a kind of sanity check on any sudden change or new behavior. Here are a few questions to ask.

    • Have the character’s circumstances changed suddenly, requiring a behavior she hasn’t demonstrated before?
    • If there was not a sudden change, but a more gradual one, has the author prepared me for this character’s new behavior by establishing the circumstances that warrant it?
      • Has the author hinted that there might be more going on with this character than meets the eye?
      • If she did, how? Why did this effort work?
      • If the answer to any of these questions was no, what was missing?
    • Whether the circumstances changed slowly or suddenly, does the new behavior make sense?
      • If not, why not?
      • Do you need more information for the behavior to make sense? If so, what?
    • Has the character demonstrated the ability to change in the past, or is this change forced on them?
      • If it was forced, what is the effect of that?

    If you’re not clear on why the character’s behavior has changed, you’ll want to bookmark the moment the new behavior appears and watch for the explanation to be revealed. If it isn’t, this is something you’ll want to flag for the author.

    What else do you look for when watching for out-of-character behavior? Please add your suggestions in the comment box below.


    [1] BASE jumping is an extreme form of sport parachuting. BASE stands for Buildings, Aerials (or Antennas but definitely NOT Automobiles, falling or otherwise), Spans (e.g. bridges), and Earth (e.g. cliffs).

  • Critique Groups: Saying Good-Bye

    The Cochise Writers’ Group, which I co-founded with Cappy Hanson, has gone through phases of growth and contraction, as every group does. We’ve been as small as four members, and as large as 17! We hit that number about a year ago and it became obvious very quickly that if we didn’t do something, the group was going to be unmanageable. The first thing we did was close the group to new members.

    Our only saving grace was that not everyone in the group was submitting work. A lot of the new members did initially, in that burst of enthusiasm that comes with being new at something, but that tapered off over the months. Now we’ve got about half a dozen members who submit work more or less regularly, and that makes things easier to handle, both from a critique standpoint and from a management one.

    But as the months went by, it became clear to us that some of our longer-term members weren’t actually contributing much. Their attendance was spotty, they only provided critiques once in a while, and they weren’t submitting work. Something had to change.

    Now, we’d been pretty tolerant with these folks. Some had been regulars at our every-two-weeks meetings, and had contributed work in the past. But now they were dealing with medical issues, either their own or their aging parents’, or there were work issues, or other things, and for the sake of keeping them engaged in the writing process, at least a little, we’d let them remain members. That was fine while those problems were active, but as they resolved themselves, these “writers” now weren’t living up to the expectations document we’d put together over the summer.

    So Cappy and I looked over our membership list just after Christmas and picked out half a dozen people whom we felt we needed to say, “Time to fish or cut bait.” We each took three and either talked to them in person or over the phone. No e-mails; this all had to be personal.

    The message was this: You have until the end of March to do the following, or we’re going to have to ask you to leave. (1) Start attending regularly, even if that’s only at one of our two locations. (We meet in two different towns, Sierra Vista and Bisbee, which are about 30 road miles apart. Some of us drive 60 miles or more, round trip, to get to our meetings. This wouldn’t be acceptable, or even necessary, in a big city. In a rural area, it’s just the way things are.)The end of a dream

    (2) Start critiquing everything the other members send out. If you have to send your critiques back via e-mail, that’s fine. If you have to give them to one of the members who goes to all meetings so they can deliver them in person two weeks later, that’s fine. But do the work.

    (3) Start submitting, or at least participate in the Google Docs spreadsheet one of us created to record your daily word count, how much time you spent working, or whatever. In other words, we’re a working writers’ group: prove to us that you’re writing.

    That got some of the people to step up.  Some took that necessary deep breath and made their first submission. Others, however, did little or nothing.

    And so, on Tuesday night, Cappy and I took the first of those people aside and gave her the news: we were asking her to leave the group.

    This is never easy. We’ve only had to do it once before. The truth is, though, that besides actual writers, critique groups attract other people: wannabes, dreamers, procrastinators, lookie-loos, groupies, people looking for some kind of social contact. Dead weight, in other words, for a working group. Those people have to be identified, given a chance to change, and if they fail or refuse, let go.

    It’s not easy. It’s never fun.

    And it’s absolutely necessary.

  • Writers’/Critique Groups: Right for Every Writer?

    My writers’/critique group, the Cochise Writers’ Group, has been going through some changes lately and that’s gotten me thinking about critique groups in general: their puCritique grouprpose, size, makeup, and so on. This post starts an occasional series as I collect my thoughts and observations about them.

    One of the most argued about questions in writer-dom is whether writers should join critique groups or not. There are some people who are absolutely certain they know what the right answer is for everyone. Multi-published author Dean Wesley Smith is death on writers’ groups. I guess he had a bad experience with one once, but if he did, that’s not a sufficient reason–not a reason at all, really–to declare all groups bad all the time for all writers.

    Here’s the thing. (Check out this blinding grasp of the obvious.) Every writer is different: different personality, different needs, different skill level, different… well, different everything.

    So is every critique group. Some are big, some are small, some in-between. Some are made up of advanced writers, some of newbies, some a mix. Some focus on one genre, some will critique anything. Some are egalitarian, with everyone contributing to the best of their ability; some are dominated by a single individual. Some (often those dominated by one person) can be destructive; some–the best–work hard to help each other get better. Some meet weekly, some biweekly, some every month. Some meet in person, others are online.

    And that’s what makes finding the right group a challenge for writers, presuming, of course, that they think they want and need such a group–by no means a given. How many groups are there close–whatever that might mean–to a given writer? Do they meet at a convenient time? How do they work? How much work can a writer submit? How quickly will it get reviewed?

    Very important: What’s the personality of the group: welcoming or not, helpful or critical, constructive or destructive?

    Most important: What does the writer want to get out of being a part of the group? And what do they hope to contribute to it?

    There’s no “right” answer for all writers, just a “right-for-now” answer for each writer, and each writer has to figure that out for themselves.

     

  • Critique Technique, Part 8: Story Endings

    To quote from Ogden Nash’s puckish poetry accompanying Camille Saint-Saëns’ Carnival of the Animals, “Now we reach the grand finale / Animale Carnivale….”

    The story you’ve been reviewing has reached and passed its climax, its moment of greatest tension and conflict. The good guys have won… or not. The protagonist has survived, achieved whatever she set out to achieve (or maybe something different), or gained some new understanding… or not. Now it’s time for the author to tie everything up in a shiny bow, or leather straps, or bands of steel… or not, so you, the reader feel that satisfying sense of completion… or not.

    Or not?

    Or not. We’ll get to that shortly.

    What Makes a Great Ending?

    Way back in 2011, award-winning thriller writer Joe Moore wrote an excellent post on The Kill Zone blog in which he talked about the makings of a great ending. I won’t try to reproduce the whole piece here—you should go read it for yourself—but he says a great ending should:

    1.   Resolve anything that wasn’t taken care of in the climax. Tie up the loose ends, in other words.
    2.   Answer the “story question”—that is, what the story was about, what changes the protagonist went through as a result of the situation he faced, and whether, as noted above, he achieved his objectives… or not.
    3.   Establish a new sense of normalcy. Things have been topsy-turvy for the protagonist throughout the story. Now she can get on with her life, even if that life is totally different from what it was at the beginning.
    4.   Reinforce the story’s message, theme, or moral, if there was one.

    That third point deserves a bit more discussion. The “new normal” doesn’t have to be a good state of affairs. The protagonist might be dead… which could be bad for him, or good. Or enslaved. Or wealthy. Or married. Or divorced. Or back at home (except, of course, that you can never go home again). There may be hints that there’s more chaos or turmoil yet to come, but at least the chaos and turmoil of this story are over… or not.

    Exceptions

    There are several exceptions to this “rule,” of course. First, some genres tolerate unhappy or ambiguous endings that leave things unsettled. They’re acceptable in “literary” or science fiction but anathema in romance. For example, John Steinbeck’s The Grapes of Wrath ends with a scene of amazing humanity and giving, yet we never know the result of Rose of Sharon’s act or what happens to the entire Joad family.

    Woman reading a book
    Image courtesy of Marin / FreeDigitalPhotos.net

    Second, if the piece is part of a continuing-story series—and this is true for non-fiction as well as fiction—there needs to be something left unresolved. In this case, just as with the end of a scene or chapter, this is where the writer leaves the reader with that, “But wait, what about…?” itch, that hint of something left undone, unfinished, or still to come that makes him want to read the next installment, even if it’ll be a year or more before it appears. This incompleteness can appear in the form of just a word, a phrase, or a sentence, or even in something left not said or not done.

    Third, there’s the series in which the protagonist and some of his or her associated secondary characters continue from book to book, but each story more or less stands alone. Many mystery series fall into this category. In this case, the resolution of one book may not necessarily lead the reader to the next one. Character is critical in these kinds of books: if the reader isn’t interested enough in the protagonist, she won’t seek out another book in that series. In each book, while the story (such as the murder to be solved) is different, what carries the series is the nature of the protagonist and the personal problem (what Les Edgerton calls “the story-worthy problem”) he or she must face because of the story problem. J. A. Konrath’s Jacqueline “Jack” Daniels mystery thriller series is an example of this. The conclusion of one book may or may not suggest what the protagonist’s next challenge will be, although there might be hints of it buried in the text. For you as a reviewer, this is going to be hard, if not impossible, to ferret out, so in this respect, this kind of book is similar to a stand-alone one.

    Fourth, a variation of this latter series is one in which the environment, setting, or wider story remains more or less constant but different characters become the protagonist in subsequent books. Think The Hobbit followed by The Lord of the Rings (setting aside the arguments about whether Lord of the Rings is one book or three). In this case, the author has a couple of choices: they can elevate a previously secondary character to protagonist, while demoting the protagonist of a previous book to a secondary role, or they can introduce a totally new protagonist in each book. For the purpose of evaluating the ending, in the first case, you’ll want to see if that secondary character was interesting enough and had a large enough role to make you want to read more about them. In the second case, the environment, setting, or story has to be interesting enough to make you want to return to it.

    Note that in both of these last two cases, the author has to be up-front with you about their intentions. In a critique group setting, writers will tend to want to not reveal future elements of the story (that is, “spoilers”), but writers should be discouraged from doing this because it hinders the group’s ability to fully evaluate the work and how well it will function as part of a series.

    In the end (pun fully intended), no matter how a piece concludes, your job as the reviewer is to decide whether it succeeded in its mission to complete the story… or not.

    Questions You Can Use

    Here are questions for you to ask as you make your evaluation:

    • If the piece ends a series or is meant to stand alone:
      • Have all the threads of the story been tied up?
        • Do I know what happened to all the major characters and why?
        • Has a new state of normalcy been established?
      • If the author meant the piece to have a message, moral, or theme, is there a concluding restatement of it? Note that this statement can be implicit or explicit. The Grapes of Wrath has one: the human spirit will triumph, no matter how many degrading and demoralizing obstacles are put in the way. Rose of Sharon’s action says it better than any blunt statement even Steinbeck could have ever made.
      • Do I feel the story is complete, or is something still lacking? If something is lacking, what is it?
      • If the piece ends ambiguously:
        • Is the piece written in a genre that accepts or allows this kind of ending?
        • Is this what the author intended (as best you can tell)?
        • Did she prepare me for this?
        • Is it a fitting ending for the story?
        • If the piece is any part of a series except the last, add:
      • Do I have an idea of where the larger story is headed next, what’s in store for the protagonist (and possibly the antagonist)?
        • Is the “new normal” still unsettled?
        • Does the protagonist know there’s still something more to do or resolve? He may not, but you, the reader, have to sense it.
      • Am I excited by the possibility of spending more time with these characters? Do I want to know more about them? Do I want to find out how they deal with their next adventure, or the danger I see lurking around the corner?
    • If the book is a part of a continuing-character series, add:
      • Is the protagonist compelling enough that I would want to read more about him or her?
    • If the book is part of a continuing-setting series, add:
      • Are there secondary characters who are interesting enough that I would like to know more about them, or see one of them become the protagonist of their own story within this world?
      • Does the story-world provide enough opportunities for new stories and new characters that I would be interested in reading more books set in it?

    Your Thoughts

    What else do you look for in the end of a piece to decide whether that ending is successful or not? Add your suggestions or ideas in the Comments box below.

     

    And with that, we’ve reached the conclusion of this series on beginnings and endings. Next time we’ll begin looking at characters and characterization.

    The End on dice
    Photo by hisks via RGBStock.com

     

  • Critique Technique, Part 59 — The End

    The End on dice
    Photo by hisks via RGBStock.com

    This article marks the formal end of the Critique Technique series, at least for now. But like a good ending to a short story or novel, it should feel like it wraps up the series well.

    For writers, there are only three parts of a story that are hard to write: the beginning, the middle, and the end. A successful ending is something worth celebrating.

    Happily Ever After… or Not

    Endings can take many forms—happy or sad, satisfying or unsatisfying, completing or dangling—as the author chooses. There’s no single “right” kind of ending except the one that’s right (appropriate) for its story. A romance is likely to end up happy, satisfying, and complete—the lovers fall into each other’s arms and all is right in their world. At least for now.

    A tragedy can end up sad, dangling, and unsatisfying (yet perhaps in some strange way, still satisfying). Take Shakespeare’s King Lear. At the end, Lear has returned to madness and died, his beloved and only loyal daughter Cordelia has been murdered, and none of the survivors wants to take the English throne. And yet, if you’ve read or seen the play, you know: wow, what an ending! It’s my favorite ending ever.

    The “Right” End

    So if there is no single kind of right ending, are there some general characteristics we can look for to determine whether an ending has done its job or not—and what that job was supposed to be? I think there are. Let’s try these on for size. A good ending should:

    • Be consistent with the rest of the story in tone and style. An essentially happy story shouldn’t end on a down note. Conversely, and tragic story shouldn’t be forced into a happy ending, á la P.D.Q. Bach’s “half-act” opera, “The Stoned Guest,” in which the entire cast sings, “Happy ending, happy ending, happy ending….” After they’d all died in the previous scene.
    • Wrap up only what needs to be wrapped up and leave dangling what needs to be left dangling.

    A former member of my writers’ group took too much to heart the idea that a story needed to end on an up-note with all loose ends tied up. Every one of his characters—from the hapless British ex-pat who’d gotten himself wrapped up in a gold theft and smuggling scheme, to the down-on-their-luck Nigerian family who’d hatched the plot, to the ruthless Mafia boss who wanted the gold for himself—all ended up living happily ever after, with their storylines tied up in pretty bows.

    Um, no.

    The ex-pat, sure. He was the hero of the story and managed by pluck and luck to get himself out of a bad bind. The family, maybe. At least their story as the antagonists needed to be completed, although not necessarily with unicorns and rainbows. And the Mafia boss’s story didn’t even need to be wrapped up. His part wasn’t major enough to deserve it.

    Conversely, my novels The Eternity Plague and Chrysalis end with some serious dangling threads (no spoilers here) because they’re part of a trilogy and the dangling threads are meant to carry the reader into the next book.

    A good ending should also:

    • Not resort to desperate, deus ex machina kinds of devices to wrap up story lines and achieve an undeserved happy ending. The story should reach its end naturally, not be forced to end in any particular way. This is true even if the ending is shocking or surprising: it should make sense given everything that has gone before.
    • Leave the reader satisfied. Now what the heck does that mean? Let’s try this. Say you’ve got a story about a search for justice, an attempt to right a wrong. If the story ends with justice done, that’s likely to be satisfying. However, if it ends with justice not done, but it’s clear why it wasn’t, and why the ending was understandable, even inevitable, then while the reader might not be happy about the ending, she can still be satisfied by it. In other words, the ending needs to make sense, to be fitting, in the context of the overall story.
    • Stays with the reader after he has closed the book or turned the page. Not every short story or novel will reach this level, nor should they. Not every piece is meant to do that, and whether it does or not depends in large part on the reader. But if the reader is still thinking about the story, the issues it raised, and the conclusions it came to days after he finished it, if he’s telling his friends about it, that’s a story with a great ending. In fact, it was probably a great story, period.

    Questions for You

    So as a critiquer, these are the kinds of things you’re looking for: consistency, the right degree of completion, naturalness, satisfaction, and resonance. If you find them, be sure to congratulate the author on them.

    One last time, let’s put those items into questions you can ask yourself as you read the end of a story or book.

    • Was the ending consistent in tone and style with the rest of the story?
    • What gave it its feeling that it was the natural and logical conclusion, even if it was shocking or surprising?
    • How did that consistency provide the sense of completion you felt the story needed?
    • How was the ending satisfying, even if it was not happy?
    • Did you feel, even if the piece is an early draft, that this was a story that could have readers thinking and talking about it for a long time?
      • If so, what was it about the entire story, not just the ending, that makes you feel that way?

    Your author has worked long and hard to reach this point, whether its her first draft or a later one. Being told, “This ending worked!” can make all of the blood, sweat, and tears she’s shed in getting you and it to this point worthwhile. Even if there are more drafts ahead. Don’t be shy about giving that praise, so long as it was legitimately earned.

    All right, then. Here’s your last chance: What do you look for to call the ending of a book or story a success? The comments box at the end is just waiting for your suggestions.

    Thanks for reading.

    The Beatles' The End lyrics
    photo credit: B Rosen via photopin cc
  • Critique Technique, Part 58 — Ending a Scene or Chapter Well

    saying on shirt
    photo credit: Harpersbizarre via photopin cc

    When a writer ends a scene or chapter, he wants to do two things. He wants to leave the scene’s or chapter’s protagonist worse off than they were before. (Except, perhaps, at the very end of the story or book. More on that in the next article.) And because of that, he wants to leave the reader wanting to read more. No, needing to read more.

    The end of every scene or chapter should in some way launch the reader into the next one. That launch doesn’t have to be the equivalent of a giant rocket blasting off for deep space. It could be a gentle shove, or a subtle but irresistible suction that pulls them onward. But gentle or gigantic, push or pull, it needs to be undeniable: the reader can’t say no to it.

    Launch Controls

    There are lots of ways to do this, of course. The writer can:

    • Employ the classic “cliffhanger,” in which the protagonist or another key character is left dangling over some kind of abyss: physical, emotional, psychological, or personal. The term comes from the old book and movie serials that ended each episode with the hero hanging by his or her fingernails from a rock ledge or tree root above a long drop to certain death, with a steam locomotive bearing down on them, the bad guy’s gun pointed right at their chest, or whatever. In every case, the reader or viewer was left having to wait on pins and needles for the next installment, which of course they just had to read or go see.
    • Leave the scene or chapter before the action is complete. This can be dramatic or subtle, but the incompleteness will drive the reader to turn the page.
    • Switch point of view (POV), time, or location in the transition to the next scene or chapter. Especially when combined with ending the scene or chapter before the action ends, this technique pulls the reader onward.

    In my book The Eternity Plague, a riot takes place in one of the chapters. In order to show the chaos and confusion of the riot, I switched from POV to POV and place to place very quickly. (That’s called “jump-cutting” in television and the movies.) No one character’s actions were done before I moved on to the next one… and the next… and the next. The result was that the reader raced through the chapter, which ended with the next technique.

    • Complete the action but leave the characters in a worse position than they were before. The cliffhanger is the extreme example of this, but this technique can be used very quietly, too, particularly if the text leaves the reader only sensing that things have just gotten worse. Then they have to turn the page.
    • Complete the action, leaving the characters seemingly in a better place, but leave hints that that peace and tranquility isn’t going to last for long. Those hints will push the reader onward: they have to know what’s going to happen when the other shoe drops.

    As a reviewer, these are the kinds of things you’re looking for as you finish each chapter or scene. If you find them, that’s great news, and it’s something you want to point out to the author. Specifically, you want to note what she did that kept you reading (or wanting the next batch of chapters), and why it worked. Even better, if she used different techniques at the ends of different scenes or chapters, that’s worth calling special attention to because it’s a sign of even more skill at work.

    Questions for You

    Let’s wrap this article up with some questions that codify the techniques I listed above.

    • If the author used the classic brink-of-disaster cliffhanger, why did it work?
      • How had she built up to it to make it so suspenseful (pun fully intended)?
    • If he ended the scene or chapter before the action wrapped up, why was leaving at that specific moment so effective?
      • Did he combine this technique with changing to a different POV, time, or place in the next scene or chapter?
      • If so, why was that effective?
    • If, at the end of a scene or chapter, the action had wrapped up but her characters’ situation was worse than before, what was it about their new situation that made you want to know what would happen next?
    • Similarly, if his characters seemed to be better off, but you knew they weren’t, what was it about the hints he planted that kept you reading?
      • What hints did he plant?
      • Was there any hint that was particularly important or well-placed?

    What do you look for to identify an effective ending to a scene or chapter? The comments box is, of course, at the end of this article, but you can keep me reading my putting your suggestions and ideas about effective scene and chapter endings there.