Tag: critique

  • Critique Technique, Part 4: Authorial Intentions and Tracking Your Own Responses

    I wrote in the previous article about keeping track of how a piece of writing makes you feel when you’re reviewing it. In this post, I was going to explore identifying why it made you feel that way, but I discovered I should introduce another topic first: “Is that what the author wanted me to feel?” Both questions—that one and “How did this piece make me feel?”—need to be followed by the questions, “Why did the piece make me feel this way?” and “Why did the author want me to feel that way?”

    Now, of course, you can’t have perfect knowledge of the author’s intent if you’re not the author  (and sometimes not even when you are) but some elements of common sense can apply. For example, if a scene seems like it’s supposed to be sad but it’s making you giggle, that’s a problem. Or, if the scene is supposed to be funny and you’re not getting even the slightest hint of a chuckle out of it, that’s a problem, too. On the other hand, a scene that’s doing what it was meant to do—and doing it well—is, from a writer’s perspective, a joy to read, even if it’s making you bawl your eyes out or scream in fright. Especially then.

    You will always have some kind of emotional response to a piece of writing. Always. “Emotional” doesn’t mean extreme emotion: uncontrollable sobbing or rolling on the floor laughing. Boredom is also an emotional response. So are frustration, confusion, delight, even sexual arousal. “Emotional” covers the full range of reactions.

    Driving Factors

    What factors drive or create your emotional response? First and foremost, character behavior. Ask yourself how you are responding to these factors.

    • What are the characters doing, thinking, saying, and feeling?
    • How are they interacting with each other, their environment, and their situation?
    • Are their behaviors consistent with or contrary to their situation or environment?
    • Are their behaviors what you expected, or did they surprise you?
    • How emotionally engaged are you with the characters? How much or how little do you care about them and what is happening to them?

    Other things will affect your emotional response, too. Setting comes to mind, as do the story’s structure, its tone and style, even its pace, but the primary driver will be the characters.

    Capture Your Response

    Woman reading a book
    Image courtesy of Marin / FreeDigitalPhotos.net

    Your job as a reviewer is to capture for the author where he or she:

    • Got it right—where the writing, the intent, and your response all came together;
    • Got it wrong—where what the author apparently wanted you to feel isn’t what you felt; or,
    • Left you confused or not knowing what to feel. Perhaps the intent was unclear, or the intention and the writing didn’t quite match.

    Then, you need to identify why you responded that way. This requires that awareness—“right now I’m feeling [emotion] because [the characters are doing/saying/feeling/thinking X, for example]”—and the ability to capture that awareness and write it down.

    Finally, when the writing isn’t successful, try to suggest to the author how he or she might achieve what you think they meant to.

    In later posts, we’ll get into the details of characterization, structure, setting, pace, tone, dialog, and narrative that will help you explain your response in more detail. As a new reviewer, however, this much is enough for you to be helpful to your fellow author.

    Your Thoughts

    What techniques do you use to track your emotional response to a piece of writing? Share them in the Comments below.

     

  • Hacking and Cutting

    A couple of events conspired recently to turn into an important revelation.

    The first event was getting the feedback from my beta readers. One told me a certain chapter stopped her cold and it took her a couple weeks to pick the manuscript up again. Uh-oh! Another told me she struggled through the same chapter. Double uh-oh!

    Then, about two weeks ago, as I was reading through a chapter of a novel by a member of my writers’ group, I experienced a similar problem. Half-way through I just had to put it down. Uh-oh again! As I thought about why that was, I realized that while his chapter was well written in many ways, its major flaw was how much backstory it contained.

    That’s when the 25 Watt light bulb over my head began to flicker.

    My problematic chapter had a similar problem: too much backstory in the process of introducing a bunch of new characters. Which, interestingly enough, my professional editor didn’t catch or see as a problem. Hmmm. Who’s right? After all, the other two beta readers didn’t have a problem with that chapter either.

    What to do? What to do?

    Experiment: that’s what to do! I’ve created a fresh draft—number 6K for those of you keeping score at home—in which I’m chopping out most of that chapter and transferring only the key elements to other places in the text. Then I’ll compare and contrast.

    The version that works better will be the one that goes to my copy editor.

    …And the beat goes on.

     

  • Critique Technique, Part 2–How Do You Feel?

    [This is a reposting of a piece that was originally published on the Cochise Writers blog on September 10, 2011.]

    Before I get to the first real topic in this series, I need to give a shout-out to local writer/poet/editor Harvey Stambrough for a blog post that he put up yesterday, “A Dozen Ways to Make Your Critique Group Work.” Good stuff there. Well worth your time to follow the link and give it a look.

    New members of a critique/writers’ group will say, “I don’t know how to do this [provide feedback].” The tendency, I suspect, is to think they have to replicate what they had to do in high school and/or college English classes: things like identify and explain the symbolism in a passage, say, or compare and contrast the use of metaphor with onomatopoeia.

    Nope! Nope, nope, nope. That’s not what critique/writers’ group feedback is about. It’s about helping the author get better by identifying what worked, what didn’t, and why.

    Let’s start with the easiest thing: how did the chapter/story/poem/article/whatever–let’s make that easier: the piece–how did the piece make you feel? Did it:

    • excite you
    • anger you
    • make you happy
    • make you sad
    • confuse you
    • fascinate you
    • annoy you
    • thrill you
    • make you giggle
    • make you swear
    • make you stay up all night thinking about it
    • make you throw it across the room
    • make you want to bang your head against the wall
    • bore you
    • something else entirely
    • all of the above
    • some of the above
    • none of the above?

    Note that it could have done many of these things at once or sequentially. Even a four line poem can do this–and a really good one will.

    Whatever it might have done, capture that emotion–write it down in your comments: “This piece made me feel X (and maybe Y and Z and A and…).” This requires a bit of self-awareness, a kind of second track running in your mind as you’re reading that’s taking note of your responses to the story. That can take some practice to develop, but doing so will pay big dividends because everything else in this series will also depend on that second train of thought running on that parallel track, taking notes, as it were.

    So, once you’ve noticed those emotional responses to the piece, the next question to ask is, “Why did it make me feel that way?”

    Ah, now the fun begins. Now you get to start really analyzing the work.

    WAIT! Come back! This isn’t scary! Really it’s not. But to let your heart rate get back down to normal, we’ll save the topic for next time.

  • Great Stuff for Writers, March 19 & 20, 2013

    Holy hotcakes, Batman! Check out the Great Stuff we’ve got today! The first three posts qualify as Extra-Great Stuff in my mind, and the others are none too shabby themselves. Check ‘em out.

    CRAFT

    Chelsea Quinn Yarbro’s excellent Your Story Opening: Shock vs. Seduction on Jane Friedman’s blog opens today’s Great Stuff, and what an opening it is. This excerpt from her book Fine-Tuning Fiction actually starts with a brief discussion of pace and who drives it—antagonist early, protagonist later—then gets into those two types of openings. The shock opening grabs the reader’s interest and attention right away. The seduction opening is harder to do, Yarbro says, because its promises are more subtle, easing the reader into the story, and thus has to draw the reader’s curiosity so strongly, especially in the sentences right after the first one, that he or she can’t help but keep reading (hence the “seduction” description).

    One terrific craft piece deserves another, doesn’t it? Even better, we get to stay with openings. Ray Rhamey (@RayRhamey) “flogs” (critiques) the first page of a pro: The DaVinci Code by Dan Brown on Writer Unboxed. Brown’s writing—indeed his whole series—has been criticized, mostly by people who don’t like his genre (or, let’s be honest, his huge success, which many of them haven’t come close to sharing), but that hasn’t been the kind of evaluation that helps writers. Rhamey’s critique, on the other hand, examines details of Brown’s technique: where he info-dumped or left out important details, overwrote, or was flat inaccurate. This is an evaluation of fewer than two dozen lines, yet there’s a lot new writers (and not so new ones) can learn here. Great Stuff!

    But wait! There’s more! Now we have PJ Parrish Killing Off Good Characters on The Kill Zone (that’s appropriate, isn’t it?). Parrish discusses not only why it’s sometimes necessary to kill off that good character, but why it needs to be done in a way that advances the story. She also addresses a couple of don’ts: to fix a weak plot or to give yourself an opportunity to preach. Readers hate it—hate it!—when we kill off a good character, especially an animal, and they’re not the least bit shy about letting us know about it, but when it’s necessary to move the story forward or force the protagonist to do something they don’t want to do, well, ya gotta do what ya gotta do. Just make sure there’s a payoff for the protagonist—and the reader—in the end.

    My friend and editor Harvey Stanbrough (@h_stanbrough) is anything but shy about expressing his opinions. So there’ll be no question in your mind over what Why Present Tense Is Bad is about. Harvey’s basic points are these: past tense is the natural narrative voice, present tense distances the reader from the story, and it calls attention to the author and away from the story. Yup, no arguments there. And yet… (these are my thoughts, now) there may come the rare occasion when a story demands to be told in the present tense. Or so you think. So I think. I have a story nagging at me to be written that wants to be done in both present tense and first person. Yikes! Double yikes! Can I do it? More important, can I do it well? If this is going to work, it’s going to be damn hard to pull off, and I may ultimately decide it was a really dumb idea and shift back to third person past tense. But I’ll never know until I try.

    Okay, so maybe Katie Weiland (@KMWeiland) doesn’t really tell you How To Figure Out the Worst Thing That Can Happen to Your Character in her video post, but she does explain why you should and why—surprise?—that can turn out to be the best thing after all.

    BUSINESS

    Rachelle Gardner (@RachelleGardner) starts a two-part series on Making a Living as a Writer. Today’s post looks at “volume”—the reality that most writers make their money by having lots of work for sale at any time. Each may sell only a few copies a month but together they add up to solid income. This collection of works making money over time is called “the long tail,” a term you may have heard. If you’ve been following Joe Konrath’s posts—a good example is his recent Exclusivity—you’ll see he’s making serious money on his long tail. It took him years to build that tail but all that work is paying off, big time.

  • Critique Technique, Part 1: Critique, Technique, and Procedure

    A while back several members of my critique group, the Cochise Writers’ Group, and I came up with a list of questions we could and should ask ourselves as we were reading each other’s work. We’ve shared it with other people but why keep the good stuff to ourselves?

    So, without further ado, here’s an introduction to critique, “technique,” and “procedure.”

    Read books, magazines, blogs, web sites, you-name-it on writing and you’ll be inundated, absolutely overwhelmed, with tips, tricks, hints, suggestions, ideas, and more on how to write everything from a poem to the Great American Novel, how to overcome writer’s block, how to spur your creativity, how to… well, do just about anything and everything writing-related. Some writers, agents, and publishers even suggest that you MUST follow their advice.

    Bunk.

    Even the hard-and-fast rules on such things as grammar, spelling, and punctuation have their caveats and exceptions. They’re rules until they aren’t. And even when the rule would ordinarily apply, you might have a good reason for breaking it.

    When I was in the Air Force, for a while I was an instructor in my aircrew position on the E-3 Airborne Warning and Control System aircraft. Part of my training included learning the difference between “procedure” and “technique.” “Procedure” was what was written down in our Technical Orders, manuals, and checklists. These were things we had to follow exactly as written for a variety of reasons, including the possibility that if we didn’t, we could break expensive equipment or hurt somebody. There was one right way of doing things. (For those of you who have never been in the military, there are fewer of those “procedures” than the stereotypes would have you believe.) As an instructor, I could grade my students on how well they followed and performed these “procedures.”

    “Technique,” on the other hand, was everything else. Emphasis on everything. If there was more than one way to accomplish a task safely, on time, and without violating any established rules, regulations, or procedures, then any of those alternative ways was acceptable. As an instructor, I could critique my student on their technique and suggest alternatives, but I could not grade them on their performance, so long as the job got done as needed, when needed.

    That’s the way writing is, only more so: 99.9% technique.

    The same is true for critiquing. If there’s one thing that is a rule, a “procedure,” it’s this: evaluate the writing, do not criticize the writer. Said another way, evaluate the work, not the worker. As a critiquer, it’s your job to help the writer being critiqued get better or make their work better. There are lots of ways to do this, and they are all technique, too.

    One good technique for providing feedback goes by a number of names. I’ll call it “soft-hard-soft.” In this technique, the reviewer first says something positive about the work. It might be something major or something minor. It should not be something silly, a sign that you’re struggling to come up with something good to say, like, “Your margins were wonderful.” Your purpose is to not only compliment the writer for something well done but to make them more receptive to what you’re about to tell them.

    Then you go to the “hard” stuff, the things that did not work, or did not work well. Be sure to explain why they did not, as best you can, and offer suggestions on how to improve them, if you can. Be tactful about it: you want the author to at least consider your suggestions.

    On the other hand, three unacceptable techniques need to be called out right now.

    #1: The ego-crusher. In this terrible technique, the reviewer does everything in his or her power to crush the soul of the writer. Here’s an example. I think it comes from a Marx Brothers movie, but since I haven’t been able to confirm it, I’ll make the characters generic and make no claims that the dialog is exactly correct:

    Patient: “Doctor, have you decided what’s wrong with me?”
    Doctor: “Indeed I have, Madam: you’re ugly.”
    Patient [gasps]: “Doctor! I want a second opinion!”
    Doctor: “OK, you’re stupid.”

    In the context of writing, telling an author, especially a new one that they or their work are terrible is cruel and unhelpful. It’s a sign of the reviewer’s insecurity rather than the writer’s ineptitude. Do not do anything like this.

    #2: The fog. In this technique, the reviewer says nothing meaningful for fear of crushing the writer’s fragile ego. For example: “Oh, it was fine.” Or, “Gee, I wouldn’t, you know….” This kind of response provides no meaningful information, and so is a waste of everyone’s time. Writers need to learn how to take both critique and criticism. It’s better to get critiqued by their friends, long before a piece is published, than to get nuked in one-star reviews afterwards. Empty words do not help the writer develop the rhino skin they’re going to need. Critique needs to be honest, but delivered with tact and respect.

    #3: The liar. Related to #2, the reviewer lies rather than say anything that might be construed as being even the slightest bit critical: “It’s perfect. Don’t change a thing.” In a group setting, the lie will be revealed for what it is—and the liar for what they are—in short order. Sucking up to another writer, even an experienced one, is not what they need and, we hope, what they want. Don’t do it.

    Starting with the next post, I’ll offer a series of questions you can ask yourself as you read a work in order to provide the author with useful feedback. Every one of them describes a technique, but each one will give you insights into how to review a particular aspect of a work.

    Last thing: giving good critique is not natural for most people. It’s a learned skill. It takes time and practice. Besides applying what you learn from these posts, listen carefully to how the other members of your group do it. Learn from what they do well—and not so well. There’s one more benefit: learning how to critique others’ work will also help you evaluate and edit your own. You’ll be come a better writer while you’re helping other writers improve.