Tag: critique

  • Critique Technique, Part 13: Timing the Reveal

    In Part 9, I wrote about timing as it related to conflict. But there’s another layer of the writing onion that I need to discuss: timing as it relates to revealing character. I have a feeling this is one of those things that many writers, especially new ones and “pantsers” (writers who don’t plan out their stories in advance, but instead write “by the seat of their pants”), don’t think about. I admit I hadn’t, and I wouldn’t be surprised if experienced writers, whether they outline, stitch together scenes written in random order, or pants-it, do this more subconsciously than consciously, no matter what genre they write in.

    Examining when an author reveals a particular personality trait or characteristic while critiquing a work is worth doing.

    Sometimes it’s obvious: in a murder mystery, for example, there has to be a point at which the act of killing and the identity of the killer are connected. The whys and wherefores might have been revealed earlier—as the FBI profiler builds the psychological sketch of the killer—or may come out later—as the killer himself, the investigator, or the prosecutor explains his motivations. In cases like this, the need for and the timing of at least some of the specific revelations are pretty clear.

    Practical Example

    That’s not always the case, though. Take my own first book, The Eternity Plague. My heroine, a medical researcher, has to decide if she’s going to try to cure a world-wide plague. Seems pretty obvious that the answer would be “yes,” but in this case, it’s not. She has to make the yes-or-no decision and I had to decide when and how to reveal why she makes it. But there were complicating factors I had to consider. (There always are, aren’t there?)

    • At the time she made the decision, would she have a clearly-formed understanding of why she was making it?
    • Events outside her knowledge or control might make her change her mind or her motivations.
    • Her initial reasons for making the decision might be wrong.
    • She might learn things about herself she didn’t know before.
    • Her personality might change: she might mature or retreat into immaturity.

    All of these things could have been true or could have happened. So then I had to decide when and how to reveal them as well as her final decision and its true, or at least final, reasons.

    This kind of analysis is fun. It’s a lot more interesting (to my way of thinking, anyway) than just mechanically creating lists of traits and characteristics for each character and plopping them into the text.

    From the Reviewer’s POV

    So now it’s time to take off the author hat and put on the reviewer hat. You’re reading someone’s piece, either fiction or non-fiction, and you’re watching her reveal her characters’ inner lives and workings. You want to assess whether she’s throwing out these bits of characterization at random, or if there’s a reason for making each revelation at that moment in that way. You want to evaluate whether doing so contributes to the story beyond just telling the reader about this particular aspect of that character.

    A couple other points:

    • Not every revelation will be, or needs to be, so significant. Some details are more important than others. As a reviewer, you’ll need to make that distinction.
    • The author might be planting a false lead. Not every revelation has to be the truth, and won’t be if he’s trying to disguise the character’s true nature, or the character herself is.

    Questions For You

    All right, then, here’s your homework. As you’re reviewing a piece, ask yourself:

    • Does presenting this trait in this way at this time add something important to the story?
      • If not, why not?
      • Could presenting it at a different time or in a different way be more effective? If so, how or where, and why?
    • Does presenting this trait in this way at this time distract or confuse me about the character?
      • Might that have been the author’s intent? If so, why was it effective?
      • If it did distract me and that was not the author’s intent, what can she do to make the revelation clearer or more effective?

    How do you assess whether an author has revealed some aspect of a character’s personality at the right time or in the right way? Add your thoughts in the comments box below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 12: Showing and Telling in Character Development

    “Show, don’t tell.” We writers get told that all the time. ALL the time.

    The thing is, neither telling nor showing are wrong, per se. What’s “wrong” is relying on either one too much, or using one technique where the other would be more effective. This is true in character development and revelation as much as it is in any other aspect of writing. Kristen Lamb discusses this here. As a reviewer, you should be looking for whether a writer is using either of these techniques less well than they could.

    Let’s take a few examples. Carol’s relationship with boyfriend Bob is everything she hoped and dreamed it would be. She gets all tingly and happy whenever she thinks of him. He calls her every day, even when they’ve been together. He gives her little gifts and compliments. She’s thinking he’s “the one.” Then one day, seemingly out of the blue, Bob tells her he thinks they need some time apart; he needs to reevaluate the relationship. How does Carol react?

    If the author writes, “Carol was angry” and stops there, that’s “telling,” but it tells us next to nothing. Although, as blogger Jael McHenry suggested in Writer Unboxed, sometimes those kinds of details don’t matter at the moment, or the writer needs to just move the story along. In those cases, just telling can be all right.

    The author could write, “Carol was angry. Her feelings were hurt. She didn’t understand how Bob could be so loving, then want to dump her. She felt confused and depressed.” That’s all “telling,” too. Yes, it provides more information, but did you notice how much emotional distance there is between you, the reader, and Carol? The writing is clinical, impersonal, analytical. You don’t much care about Carol’s situation. Tough noogies, Carol, you’re thinking. Next story.

    Direct Showing

    “Showing” character means having the character’s personal environment, actions, and behaviors illustrate their mood, personality, etc. Let’s go back to Carol and Bob. This time, the author writes:

    Carol slammed the phone down. “You son of a bitch! You’re not going to do that to me.” She stomped down the hall to her armory, where she wrenched open the display case containing her knife collection and pulled down her favorite machete. Stroking the sharpened edge with her thumb, she crooned, “It’s been a long time since you tasted flesh, hasn’t it, baby?” She slammed the blade home in its scabbard, wrapped the belt around her waist, and yanked the catch tight before turning her attention to her gun safe. Which one? she wondered. The pump-action shotgun or the full-auto AK?

    That’s showing, all right—you can feel the rage—but is it too much showing, or the right kind?

    Now, it’s possible that either of these last two examples could be fine, depending on what the author was trying to do. In the “telling” case, the author may want to create emotional distance as part of her larger plan for how she’s going to present Carol over the course of the story.

    In the admittedly over-the-top “showing” case, maybe Carol really is a psycho who hides it well until something triggers (pun intended) the behavior.

    But if either of these examples represent what the writer does every time she wants to present some aspect of a character’s personality, that’s a problem.

    From Another Character’s POV

    There’s another way of “telling” personality traits that is legitimate and often valuable: when one character describes another’s personality or behavior. There are lots of ways to do this. The character doing the describing can:

    • Tell the character being described what he perceives her to be: Ted snuggled up to Alice. “You’re such a goofball.”
    • Describe the character to himself (and the reader) in his thoughts: Alice is such a goofball.
    • Describe the character to himself (and the reader) in narrative: Ted thought Alice was a goofball.
    • Describe the character to another character: “Alice is such a goofball,” Ted said to Bob.

    Adding an illustrative action by Ted, as I did in the first example above, adds more depth by showing an aspect of the relationship between Ted and Alice, plus one of Ted’s character traits.

    Indirect Showing

    These are all direct methods of showing or telling characterization. There are also more subtle, indirect ways. The author can:

    • Mention something the character owns.
    • Describe the place they live in: not only whether it’s a mansion, say, or a cardboard box, but how that place is furnished and kept.
    • Describe how they dress and keep themselves: clean or dirty, satin or jeans.
    • Identify who they associate with: socialites or gangsters… or both.
    • Describe what they do for a living: run a backhoe or run the company that makes backhoes.
    • Describe the pets they keep—a 2-pound Chihuahua or a 15-foot boa constrictor—or don’t.
    • Describe a habit or tic they have, and so on.

    These methods show the characteristic by telling how it manifests itself in the character’s life.

    To summarize, then, neither “showing” nor “telling” a character’s traits is “right” or “wrong.” What matters is whether such showing or telling is the most effective way to present those traits and whether the author relies too much on one technique or the other.

    Questions For You

    Here are some questions for you to ask as you review a work.

    • Is the author both showing and telling the reader the characters’ traits?
    • Is the author relying too much on one way of presenting character traits?
      • If so, how and where could he use a different technique to better effect?
    • Is the way the author presents a trait or characteristic appropriate to her intent, so far as you can tell, in calling attention to it at this moment in the piece?
      • If not, why not?
    • Is he showing or telling a trait in the most effective way?
      • Would using a different technique be better? If so, what?
    • Is the author “showing” too much? That is, showing character traits when it would simply be better to tell them?

    What cues do you use to evaluate how well the author is presenting a character? Add your comments or suggestions in the comments box below.

     

  • Critique Technique, Part 11: Lack of Character Development

    One of the key things readers want to see in a story (fiction or non-fiction) is some sign of change in the characters over the course of the story—positive, we hope, but that isn’t required. The protagonist may not get what he wants by the end, or even what he deserves, but he should grow or change in some way. The same is true for the secondary characters.

    Even the antagonist needs to change. She doesn’t have to see the light, realize the error of her ways, and become the good person we always knew she could be, and that she always wanted to be deep down inside. That’s awfully cliché, isn’t it? Nor does she have to end up dead, even though she might richly deserve it, but she, too, ought to change in some way.

    A short story or an article doesn’t give the author much room to show that change, so it may be enough for the change to be small. Even so, it needs to be significant in some way. If the character doesn’t change, and in a way that’s clear to the reader, that’s a problem. If there’s no change, usually there’s no story.

    Similarly, a scene in a novel, even a whole chapter, may not provide enough time and space for major change, but any change it reveals needs to be a part of that overall path, that “character arc,” that takes the character from what he was at the beginning to what he is at the end.

    Getting Worse, Getting Better

    Particularly in longer works, negative change can be more interesting than positive. Do we readers want to read about Pollyannas, getting better and better every day in every way? No, we can be evil, mean, and nasty people. Sadists, every one of us. We like it when the protagonist screws up, gets in trouble, or reveals a flaw. The worse, the better, in fact. When Polly really steps in it, when she finds herself in deep doo-doo (think Princess Leia in the giant trash-masher in the first Star Wars movie), especially if it’s all her own doing (or is that doo-doo-ing?), c’mon, admit it, that’s more interesting, isn’t it?

    Of course it is!

    Technically, that’s called “creating tension.” We want to know, How the heck is she going to get out of that mess? And so we keep reading. Maybe we’re trying to assuage our guilt over our latent sadism by wanting to see the protagonist succeed, or at least overcome her latest difficulty—until the next one appears, anyway.

    But wait, there’s more. While Polly’s wiping off the doo-doo, we want her to not just clean up her dress but clean up her act. We want her to learn from that mistake or problem or whatever—to change—and become a different person, even if just a little bit different, so that over the course of the entire piece she becomes someone else, the sum or product of all the plusses and minuses of her journey through the story.

    By the way, if she does not learn the first time, that’s fine. That’ll get her into more trouble. But eventually she needs to learn… or end up dead or a complete failure, if that’s what the author intended.

    But again, if there’s no change, many readers will wonder why they wasted their time on this book.

    “Literary” fiction is more tolerant of this. Consider Forrest Gump. He could be the exception that proves the rule: Given everything that happens around him, we expect him to change but what makes him interesting is that, at his core, he doesn’t.

    With other genres, though, this lack of change can lead to poor reviews and even poorer sales. We critiquers can help authors avoid this fate by showing them how they might change their characters.

    Your Job

    As a critiquer, your job is to keep your eyes open for those changes or—and this is harder—the changes that didn’t happen but should have. Even in a short piece, you need to ask not only if any change occurred at all, but if that change mattered.

    Here’s another wrinkle to consider: Is the character’s revised personality consistent with the changes he’s been going through? Would it make sense, say, for a character to go through a life-threatening experience—an assassination attempt, a natural disaster, even a major traffic accident—and be the same happy-go-lucky guy he was before it happened? Probably not. If he doesn’t change, there’d better be a darn good—and clearly evident—reason why.

    Questions For You

    Here are some questions to ask about character development as you review a story.

    • Have the major characters changed over the course of the piece?
      • If not, were opportunities for change missed? If so, where?
    • Can I see how those changes mattered to the character and to those around her?
    • Can I believe the way he’s changed, given the experiences he’s had?
      • If not, why not? What does the author need to do to make the changes more believable?
    • If the character did not change, is that appropriate to, or even necessary for, the story?
      • How did that failure to change affect the characters around her?

    What do you look for in character development when you’re reviewing a work? Please add your suggestions in the comments box below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 10: Poor Characterization

    Before I begin, a disclaimer: what follows just scratches the surface of characterization. People have written many books on creating believable characters, and I’m smart enough to know I can’t cover everything they do in one post, or even a series of them.

    With that in mind, what do I mean by poor characterization? What makes it poor, and how can you as a reviewer spot it, describe it, and offer help for it to the “guilty” writer?

    Good Characterization

    We readers want the characters of the pieces we read to be:

    • Believable. They can be really bad (a Hannibal Lecter, for example) or really good, but they can’t be so intensely, unremittingly, uniformly bad or good that we lose faith in them. That means they have to also be…
    • ConfusionInteresting. Or quirky. Or flawed. Definitely flawed. They might have some trait that lies outside the norm of the rest of their behavior and yet isn’t so outré that it’s unbelievable. More likely, though, their flaw is what drives the conflict in the story. The author has to make sure we understand why the character has that trait, even if the character herself does not. Good or bad, we also want characters to be…
    • Redeemable. They have the chance and the ability to overcome their flaws. Whether they take that opportunity, and whether they succeed or fail, are other matters. Indeed, how they respond when the opportunity—or demand—presents itself can be very interesting, even the core of the story, but the ability needs to be there. The characters have to be…
    • Committed to something. It doesn’t matter so much if that commitment is to understanding their mother, say, or killing her, but the presence and the intensity of that commitment, that passion, make the character more interesting. This commitment is essential for the protagonist and antagonist, but commitment can really round out secondary characters too. Commitment creates the opportunity for conflict when there’s someone else with a different commitment: the mother who doesn’t want to be “understood,” or who wants to live. This is the central distinction between the protagonist and antagonist. The conflict can be internal, too, which makes the character more interesting. Indeed, an “agonist” is someone who engages in conflict, and “agonist” comes from the same Greek root as “agony” does. Commitment also means characters will be
    • Active. We want characters who do things, not just sit around contemplating their navels, their troubles, their relationships, or their feelings. (See the definition of “agonist” above.) Even in “literary” fiction, where much of the conflict is internal, the characters need to be doing something in response to that conflict, not just sitting around moping. Passive characters are, for the most part, boring. There are exceptions, like Bartleby of Herman Melville’s short story Bartleby, the Scrivener, whose aggression is passive, but nonetheless real. Speaking of feelings, we want characters to…
    • Feel. Not so much that we’re drowned in their emotions, but not so little that they become robots, either. Even Star Trek’s Vulcans had feelings, and not just when “The Seven Year Itch” hit them. Finding something “interesting” is an emotion, too, after all. They had to have feelings, or we wouldn’t have been able to relate to them. Lastly, we want characters to be…
    • Distinct. Many of the things I’ve listed above serve to make each character different from all the others in a piece. As I wrote last time, conflict is a primary requirement of a story, and differences between characters is something that creates conflict. Can you imagine a story in which every character was identical in every respect? Even if they start out that way (a group of clones, for example), differences among and between them have to develop. They can’t all have identical experiences all the time.

     

    In other words, then, we want characters to be people. Wow, what a concept! Piece of cake, right?

    Not so much. At least, not for me. Maybe not for you.

    Poor Characterization

    So what makes for poor characterization? Not having the qualities listed above is part of it, or not having enough of them, but poor characterization can also be revealed by having too much of some trait. Problems will arise if a character is:

    • Too quirky or flawed. When a quirk or flaw becomes a distraction, or disrupts the story, it’s worth asking what the story’s really Also, if a character is…
    • Too committed to something. This can be tricky to judge: how much commitment is too much? That extreme commitment may be their central flaw, the thing that drives the story’s conflict. But if they become a one-trick pony, they become boring, annoying, tiresome, uninteresting. The same is true if they’re…
    • Hyperactive or melodramatic. The hyperactive character wears the reader out while showing no depth. In a later post I’ll write about story pace, but there’s a “pace” for a character, too, and someone who’s “on” all the time doesn’t demonstrate the variety of character pace that makes them interesting. Conversely, melodrama provides too much change of pace. A character who slams from one extreme of emotion to another also becomes boring, or worse. High emotion is fine in the proper time and situation but a character who has no other kind of response will drive readers away. By the same token, the character who…
    • Lacks any emotion will be just as uninteresting. This is true whether they’re the clichéd cold-blooded killer or the dude who’s too cool for everyone and everything. There are exceptions, of course. Bartleby doesn’t lack emotion, actually, but he has only one, extreme diffidence, and Melville uses that lack of variation as the perfect reflector for his first-person narrator’s emotions, bouncing them back without being affected by them, thus creating the story’s conflict.

     

    Judging Characterization

    Judging how well an author has drawn his or her characters can be difficult, especially if you’re reading a work just a chapter or two at a time. You really need a much larger part of a work, perhaps all of it, to be able to put together that complete picture in your mind of each character, and to understand whether he or she comes off the page as a person, to harken back to the Keith Cronin comment I quoted last time, or if he or she remains a character. You can, however, start to build that mental picture of him or her as you read more and more of the work.

    To summarize, then, a well-drawn character has a balanced complexity: they’re a mixture of many traits. Not so many as to be a confused muddle but not so few as to be a cardboard cut-out. Some traits will be more prominent than others, and different traits will be more prominent at different times. Some traits will define the character’s core, others will just decorate their surface. For the story’s protagonist, those core characteristics should be the ones at greatest risk.

    Questions for You

    Here are some questions for you to ask about the characters as you review a piece:

    • Do I see enough different traits in the character to make her interesting? If so, which ones stand out, and why? If not, what seems to be lacking?
    • Are there so many traits that I don’t know who he really is? Which ones could be trimmed out or reduced?
    • Are her responses to the situations she finds herself in appropriate to the story? (Responding inappropriately can be a legitimate character trait.) If they do not make her more whole, why not?
    • Does he have flaws but also the potential to be redeemed from them?
    • Is she committed to something? Is she too committed to something?
    • Does he show a range of emotions that is too wide, too narrow, or appropriate? If too wide or too narrow, what might the author do to make the range more appropriate?
    • And the ultimate questions: Do I believe her and believe in her? Do I want to know more about her?

     

    Your Turn

    What questions to do you ask yourself when evaluating a story’s characters? Please share them in the comments box below.

     

  • Critique Technique, Part 9: Characters and Conflict

    The next eight articles are going to be about characters and characterization. Before we get started, though, I want to point you to another excellent blog post from several years ago, titled The Night the Lights Went Out in Texas, by Keith Cronin, on Writer Unboxed. This paragraph sums up so much about the enterprise of story-telling, whether in fiction or non-fiction:

    “But it really comes down to the people. (I look at the sentence I just typed, and realize I instinctively chose the right word with “people.” It’s hard for me to even refer to them as mere “characters” – that’s how real they’ve become to me.)”

    That says it all, doesn’t it? It’s the fundamental question you’ll be asking about the pieces you read as a reviewer: are the characters in this piece people to me, or just characters? The answer will tell you, and the author, a lot about whether or not the piece is succeeding.

    Essential Ingredients: Characters and Conflict

    There are two things a story can’t live without: characters and conflict. A “story”—fiction or non-fiction—without characters is a technical report. A “story” without conflict isn’t a story at all. Without conflict, characters have nothing at stake, there’s nothing that forces them to do anything at all, much less change or grow.

    Angry couple standing back to back
    Image courtesy of David Castillo Dominici / FreeDigitalPhotos.net

    Now, conflict doesn’t have to mean a character having a gun to his head. Conflict can be internal, too. In fact, that’s the primary form of conflict in much of “literary” fiction. Playwright and author Jeff Helgeson identified five kinds of conflict:

    • Person against self,
    • Person against person,
    • Person against society,
    • Person against nature, and
    • Person against “fate.”

    While four of these are external, each also has an internal component as the character struggles with how these conflicts are affecting her.

    As a reviewer, you may find a piece you’re reading has either too much conflict or too little. The conflict might also be inappropriate or mistimed. Let’s take a look at each.

    Too Much Conflict

    It may seem odd to suggest that a piece can have too much conflict, but here’s an example of what that might look like. A few years ago, a local writer brought her draft novel to my writers’ group for our review. Right from the first chapter, her protagonist and antagonist were having screaming fights with each other. The motivation for their arguments was weak—it didn’t justify the intensity of the conflict—and worse, it gave the characters very few ways to escalate their conflict. As I’ve written in earlier posts, things have to get steadily worse for the characters over the course of the story, but these two were denied that chance.

    Another example of too much conflict is the case where there’s nothing but conflict in the story. Constant conflict might be fine for a first-person-shooter video game but in a written story, the reader needs a break from time to time, a chance to catch his breath. The characters need to do that, too, to lick their wounds (real or figurative), assess their situation, and make new plans (which, of course, will fail, right up to the very end). In his book Scene and Structure, Jack Bickham calls these moments the “sequels” that fall between the “scenes.” These changes of pace, from conflict to peace to conflict again—or more conflict to less to more—keep the reader engaged, not exhausted.

    Too Little Conflict

    Too little conflict, on the other hand, will make the reader lose interest. Writers, especially new ones, who are nice, gentle, kind people, may shy away from creating conflict between and within their characters because they don’t want them to be hurt or stressed. Tough noogies. The writer who’s too nice to her characters will put her readers to sleep. As a reviewer, your job is to help her get over her internal conflict and create conflict on the page. You’ve got to do it.

    Now’s a good time to go back to Helgeson’s list. Conflict should be constantly on the move, from internal to external, from physical to mental, from personal to impersonal, from one source or cause to another. “Constantly” isn’t necessarily the same as “rapidly,” however. The pace of this movement, like the intensity of the conflict, should be changing over time, too.

    Inappropriate Conflict

    That’s a good transition into inappropriate conflict. How can conflict be inappropriate? Let’s take a crazy example. Bob, a mild-mannered private-practice CPA is out on a date at a local Applebee’s with his girlfriend Alice, who’s a sales clerk at a Gap store. The relationship has been fracturing and Bob is struggling to find a way to tell her it’s time for them to go their separate ways. Just as he’s getting ready to say so, a gunfight breaks out among the patrons and Alice whips out a Mac 9 machine pistol from her shoulder bag and joins the fray.

    Uhhh, yeah, sure, that makes sense.

    Now, with more background information, maybe it would make sense, but with only what I’ve given you here, that conflict is completely inappropriate.

    Mistimed Conflict

    Mistimed conflict is a different issue. Getting timing right is difficult—just ask any stand-up comic. That moment’s hesitation before he delivers the punch line can be the difference between howls of laughter and no response at all. Here’s an example of mistiming a conflict in fiction. Another former member of my writers’ group once gave us a chapter from the first draft of his novel. The chapter is pretty early in the story (probably less than a quarter of the way through) and yet the protagonist kills his primary antagonist in it.

    Uh-oh! Now who’s going to chase the good guy around, making trouble for him, putting him in danger, and generating all sorts of conflict, for the next 200 pages? Hmmm, good question. OK, it was a first draft, where problems like this are bound to come up. (It’s also possible this antagonist wasn’t the primary one, but if so, that creates a whole different set of problems.) If that antagonist were to stay around for another 200 pages, the protagonist would find himself in more and more trouble. That’s what we want.

    Mistimed conflict can, of course, be conflict that comes too late, as well, which may be related to there being too little conflict to start with.

    Questions For You

    All right, then. Here are some questions you should be asking yourself as you review a piece.

    • Is there conflict between and within the characters?
    • Is there conflict between the characters and their “environment” (collectively, Helgeson’s society, nature, and fate)?
    • Is there too much conflict, or too little?
      • If too much, which conflicts can be deleted or combined? How would doing so make the story better?
      • If too little, what kinds of appropriate conflict could the author add, and where?
    • Is the conflict appropriate or inappropriate for the situation and characters?
      • If it’s inappropriate, why, and what can the author do to fix that?
    • Is the timing of the conflict off, happening too early or too late?
      • What could the author do to make the timing better?

    Conflict is the heart of “story.” It defines and redefines the story’s characters—it changes them. Getting conflict right is one of an author’s central tasks. Helping him do so is one of your most important tasks as a reviewer.

    Your Turn

    What kinds of problems have you seen in how an author presents conflict within and between her characters? How could, or did, the author change the story to make conflict more effective? Please add your thoughts and suggestions in the comments box below.

     

  • Critique Technique, part 7b: more on scene and chapter endings

    I need to “revise and extend” my last Critique Technique post.

    Last time I wrote that things should be worse for the protagonist at the end of each section (or scene) or chapter of an article, short story, or novel than they were at the beginning. Well, that’s not entirely true. In a longer piece, and particularly in a short part of that piece, that may not be possible, or desirable.

    Letting the scene’s or chapter’s protagonist make a little progress, or seem to make progress, has its benefits:

    1. The reader is encouraged, and so wants to read further.
    2. That progress gives the author more opportunities to make things worse for the protagonist: one step forward makes room for the two steps backward to come. (There we writers go again, being evil and devious!)
    3. If the scene’s protagonist is the story’s antagonist, or even a secondary character, letting him make progress toward his goals can be a direct or indirect way to make things worse for the story’s protagonist. (Oh, what a tangled web we weave!)

    The bottom line, then, is that in every chapter or scene, something has to happen that changes the situation for the characters involved. The change can be large or small. Its size doesn’t have to match the length of the scene or chapter, although a small change over the course of a long chapter or section may not go over so well. As a reviewer, you’re looking for that change and whether the story moved forward because of it.

  • Critique Technique, Part 7: Scene and Chapter Endings

    I’ve written about beginnings in the last couple of posts. For the next couple, I’ll discuss the endings of sections or scenes, chapters, and the entire piece. I’ll look at the first two here.

    Articles and short stories are often divided into sections or scenes, sometimes even into chapters. Books of all kinds are almost always divided into chapters, and those chapters often have scenes within them.

    Why would a chapter, article, or short story be divided into scenes? In fiction, scenes contain the action in a specific time and place, from a particular point of view, or focused on a certain character. In non-fiction, a section or scene may focus on these or on a specific topic that could be one of several within the piece. When the location, time, point of view, key character, or topic changes, the author can use a transition—usually a word, phrase, or sentence to carry the reader across the change (something I’ll cover in a later article)—or she can start a new scene.

    The end of a scene has two purposes. First, like its beginning, it needs to create curiosity in the reader, to make him wonder what’s next and so propel him onward. The second purpose is to make things worse for the central character, or maybe all of the characters, of that scene. Then, if the piece switches to another character or set of characters, that creates even more tension in the reader because his curiosity isn’t satisfied immediately—he has to wait to find out what’s going to happen.

    Obstacles and Frustration

    Black and yellow concrete barriersImage courtesy of FreeDigitalPhotos.net

    So, how can a scene’s ending create that curiosity and tension, and how can you, the reviewer, tell when it hasn’t? Two words: “obstacles” and “frustration.” Obstacles keep the scene’s protagonist from reaching her immediate and long-term (story) objectives. (I’ll write more about objectives later, too.) At the end of every scene, she should have more obstacles in her way than she had when the scene started, or they should have gotten worse. That should increase her frustration, leaving her wondering, “How am I going to overcome this, along with everything else?” The reader should be asking that, too, whether she’s sympathetic to the scene protagonist’s cause or not.

    In fiction, the writer’s job is to keep making things worse for the story’s major characters (protagonist(s) and antagonist(s))—to raise the stakes for them—right up to the climax. In non-fiction, especially creative non-fiction, the author’s job is similar: to relate how things kept getting worse. Even in something as direct as a how-to article, at the end of each section, the author can present an obstacle the do-it-yourselfer could face.

    Now, that new or improved obstacle doesn’t have to be super-dramatic, the famous “cliffhanger.” In fact, in a chapter or short work, cliffhangers at the end of each scene are probably impossible or will make the reader stop believing the story. The new obstacle can be something simple, or it can be an old one made worse, but it still has to be an obstacle.

    Here’s an example. In my own first novel, The Eternity Plague, one chapter has almost 30 scenes as the focus jumps between five different characters. In one scene, my reporter, Lisa, needs to find Sarah, the leader of a rally that has turned into a riot, something Sarah didn’t plan. Unfortunately for Lisa, she’s on a balcony on the old North Carolina State Capitol building, while Sarah was on a stage fifty yards distant, but has now been hustled away. Lisa doesn’t know where Sarah’s gone and has to get through the chaos of the riot to try to find her. Sarah’s disappearance isn’t a huge obstacle for Lisa in the larger scheme of the story, but it does frustrate her immediate desire to get Sarah’s reaction to the violent collapse of her rally. This leaves the reader wondering, “What will Lisa do? Will she find Sarah? What will she do if she does? What will she do if she doesn’t?” (The next scene, of course, shifts to another character, building my reader’s tension as he waits to find out what happens with Lisa and Sarah.)

    Progress as a Problem

    That said, in a longer piece, and particularly in a short part of that piece, making things worse may not be possible, or desirable. Letting the scene’s or chapter’s protagonist make a little progress sometimes, or seem to make progress, has its benefits:

    1. The reader is encouraged, and so wants to read further.
    2. That progress gives the author more opportunities to make things worse for the protagonist: one step forward makes room for the two steps backward to come.
    3. If the scene’s protagonist is the story’s antagonist, or even a secondary character, letting him make progress toward his goals can be a direct or indirect way to make things worse for the story’s protagonist.

    Those are the requirements for the end of a scene. They’re the same for the end of a chapter, only more so. Cliffhangers are appropriate here, but not at the end of every chapter. Still, the author wants the reader biting his fingernails, wondering what’s going to happen next, and having—just having—to turn the page.

    The bottom line, then, is that in every chapter or scene, something has to happen that changes the situation for the characters involved. The change can be large or small. Its size doesn’t have to match the length of the scene or chapter, although a small change over the course of a long chapter or scene may not seem strong or important enough to keep the reader turning pages. As a reviewer, you’re looking for that change and whether the story moved forward because of it.

    Questions You Can Use

    All right. Now you’re the reviewer and your job is to decide whether the end of a scene or chapter has done its job. Here are questions for you to ask:

    • Did the ending of this scene or chapter make things worse for the character(s)?
      • Did it put new obstacles in their way, or make existing ones worse?
      • Did it add frustrations, or make existing ones worse, as the character(s) try to reach their goals?
    • Did the characters make progress at the end of this scene or chapter, making me wonder what new obstacles they’re about to face?
    • Did the ending increase my tension? Did it make me have to know what happens next?

    If the answer to any of these questions is “no,” figure out how the author failed to make things worse for her characters and/or how she failed to increase your need to know more. Then offer suggestions on how to make the piece better.

    Your Thoughts

    What else do you look for in the end of a scene or chapter to decide whether it’s been a success or not? Put your suggestions in the Comments box below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 6: The Wrong Beginning

    Last time I wrote about how the beginning of a piece is supposed to “hook” the reader, to make them have to keep reading past the first line, the first paragraph, the first page. Now we need to zoom out a little and look at the beginning of the piece as a whole. Specifically, we need to ask, “Is this the right place for the piece to begin?”

    That may seem like an odd question: doesn’t an article, short story, or novel start at the beginning?

    Not necessarily. You’ve probably heard that a story needs to start in medias res, a Latin phrase meaning “in the middle of things.”

    Great. What things?

    Things. You know. The action. The events. Which may, of course, be internal to one of the characters, or external.

    But when there are things, action, events all through a story, which ones should the story start in the middle of?

    What Is the Beginning?

    What is the “beginning” of a story? Let me be more specific. What is the right beginning of a book? That’s a subtle but critical distinction. From this point on I’m going to focus on longer works: novellas, novelettes, and full-length books. Articles and short stories tend to be short enough that there’s less question about exactly where they should start. Not no question, however, so what I’ll discuss here can still apply.

    The problem is, every action, every event that’s part of the story had something happen before it. Lots of somethings, actually. And at least one of those somethings might constitute the beginning. Except that something else happened before it. By this logic, the author would have to go back to the beginning of the universe to find the “real” beginning. That’s not going to work. Well, James Michener could get away with it. Other authors? Not so much.

    As I mentioned last time, new writers tend to want to start with a lot of background information on the characters and their situation. Somewhere in all of that may well be where the story starts, but it’s not where the book should start.

    The beginning of the book has to launch the reader as well as the characters into the piece, even if the events that led to the start of the story happened much earlier. That information, called backstory, can and should be salted into the book later.

    The beginning includes the hook, but it’s more than the hook. The hook is about writing technique; finding the right beginning is about the craft of storytelling. It’s possible to create a hook for a beginning that isn’t the right one. In that case the hook will launch the reader into the piece, only to have her lose interest as the text wanders off into the proverbial woods and gets itself lost.

    The beginning introduces the reader to all or most of the major characters—the protagonist and antagonist for sure, but also key secondary characters—and gives the reader an immediate reason to care about them and their predicament. This is more than just the inciting incident and surface problem of the hook. It’s also the relationships among the key characters, the stakes created by the inciting incident and the surface problem, and the characters’ first response to that problem.

    Example: Ethan Frome

    Is the “inciting incident” the right place for the book to start? Usually yes, but not necessarily. Let me give you an example—Edith Wharton’s Ethan Frome—that seems to contradict what I just wrote, and in so doing illustrates, if not proves, it.

    Ethan and Zeena Frome, desperately poor New England farmers agree, despite their poverty, to take in Zeena’s young cousin Mattie Silver to care for the supposedly sickly Zeena. This agreement is the inciting incident. Mattie is young, beautiful, and vibrant, everything Zeena is not, and Ethan falls in love with her. Zeena notices and sends her away. [Here’s a spoiler alert, if you haven’t read the story.] In a last desperate moment together, Ethan and Mattie go sledding and crash into a tree, forcing Zeena to rise from her sickbed to care for the badly hurt Mattie.

    So, does the novel begin with Ethan and Zeena deciding to take Mattie in? No, it starts with a “frame” in which an unnamed narrator sees the badly crippled, post-accident Ethan, “a ruin of a man,” stagger into the town post office to get his mail. In this extreme case, the novel starts after the story has ended! Why? What was Wharton doing?

    Creating curiosity. Creating the need to know more, to read further—hooking the reader, in other words—to learn the story of Ethan Frome, even though the long preface makes it clear it’s going to come to a terrible end. Frame stories are a kind of special case but they can illustrate beautifully the difference between where a book can start and where the story started.

    Fine. So now you’re the reviewer of someone’s work. How can you tell if they’ve chosen the right—or at least a successful—beginning? It’s easier with an article or short story because you’re likely to have the entire piece in front of you. With a novel, it can be harder, especially if you don’t have the whole manuscript. In this case, you’ll want to wait until you’ve seen more of the book—maybe all of it—before you come to a conclusion.

    And if you’re the author, it’s vital for you to understand that until you have the whole first draft done, you will not really know where the book should start. You will learn things about your story and your characters in the process of writing that first draft that may well cause you to completely replace the beginning you originally wrote. If you do, you will hardly be the first, but your book will be better for it. After I decided I had the wrong beginning for my own first novel, I tried ten other ones; number ten was the right one.

    Review Questions You Can Use

    Here are some questions that can help you decide if the author has selected the right or wrong beginning.

    • Does this beginning take me beyond the hook? Does it amplify and deepen my curiosity about the characters and the story that follows?
    • Does this beginning identify the story’s key characters, their problems, and how significant those problems are? Does it give me a reason to care?
    • Does this beginning consist of action or activities that pull me along? (Note that, as I wrote about the hook, action doesn’t have to be slam-bang shoot-‘em-up stuff. It can be, like Wharton’s, quiet dialog in which the action is psychological, not physical.)
    • Does this beginning focus on the core story, or does it consist of, or wander off into, backstory or tangential material that should come later?
    • Are there other places in the story that would meet these criteria better? If so, what makes them better choices?
    • If nothing in the piece seems right for a beginning, what’s missing? What do you want or need to know to get interested in the characters and their story?

    The beginning is a crucial moment in the relationship between the reader and the story. The wrong beginning, or an ineffective one, will let the reader off the hook (pun fully intended), let her put the book down or flip to the next article or story. Selecting the right place to start isn’t easy but it’s vital and that makes your job as a reviewer that much more important.

    Your Thoughts

    What do you look for when determining whether an article, short story, or novel is starting in the right place? Add your thoughts and suggestions in the Comments box below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 5: Weak or Missing Hook

    Before I begin, remember that for each of the items I’ll discuss from now on, you have four questions to ask:

    • Did it happen?
    • Exactly where did it happen?
    • What exactly is the problem? Or what just worked really well?
    • What can the author do to fix it, if something needs fixing?

    OK, so what is a “hook” and how can it be weak or missing? Whatever you’re writing—fiction or non-fiction, poetry or prose—you need to catch and hold your reader’s interest: you need to hook them. And you need to do it early. How early? Well, in a poem it has to happen right away, in the first few lines, since a poem is likely to be brief. But this is true even in a longer piece. In a book, you have a few pages, in a short story, no more than the first few paragraphs. In Hooked, his excellent book on openings, Les Edgerton says the hook needs to be planted within the first 30 pages. Personally, I think it’s within the first 10, and the earlier within those 10, the better.

    The Hook’s Job

    The hook has a lot of work to do. A weak or missing hook does not do that work, or does not do it well.

    Fish hook in cloth
    Photo by Marco Michelini, via FreeImages.com

    Edgerton says those first pages need to do four things:

    1. Introduce the protagonist and their normal world.
    2. Contain the “inciting incident” that throws the protagonist out of that normal world.
    3. Contain the “surface problem,” the problem they initially think they have to solve.
    4. Introduce the first hints of the “story-worthy problem,” which is what will drive the protagonist through the rest of the book.

    To tell if a hook is present or absent, weak or strong, ask yourself questions like these:

    • Do I know who the important characters are?
      • If the answer is no or you’re not sure, why? Did two or more characters seem to have equal weight, for example? Did no one stand out?
    • Are the characters people I immediately become interested in? Do I care about them right away, even in a negative way? Uninteresting characters are far worse than unsympathetic ones—ones the reader does not like. Writers want their readers to respond to their characters, even if they hate them. But if the reader’s response is “meh,” that’s a problem the author has to fix.
    • Do I know what the protagonist’s problem is? As a reader, you may not know the full scope and extent of the story-worthy problem right away. Indeed, that may not be revealed until the very end, but the reader needs to know there’s a problem—and an important one in the protagonist’s mind—right from the beginning. That’s likely to be the surface problem, but it will begin the revelation of the story-worthy problem. If that is not happening, tell the author.
    • Do I at least have some sense of how big and important this problem is to the characters?
      • What’s at stake for them if they fail to solve it? What do they stand to lose?
      • What’s at stake if they do solve it? What do they stand to gain?
      • If you cannot positively answer at least some of these questions, then the author has not identified the stakes.
    • Do I get bogged down in the character’s history? I’ll discuss backstory in a later article. New authors have a tendency to think they need to provide all sorts of background about the major characters at the beginning of the book. That’s not true, and it buries the hook. If this seems to be happening, be sure to let the writer know, especially if nothing grabs you.

    A True Story

    Here’s an example of what I mean. My friend Debrah Strait was working on her first book and took the latest draft of her first chapter to her writers’ group. They were, shall we say, less than enthusiastic. After the meeting, Debrah went to Safeway and while she was in the store, she met a friend and complained about what the group had said. Her friend asked to see the piece, which Debrah still had in her purse.

    She read the first page. “I don’t care about that,” she said.

    She read the second page. “I don’t care about that.”

    When she finally got to page seven, where pirates began attacking a small settlement on a remote Caribbean island by blowing up a warehouse, she said, “Now I’m interested. Start here.”

    Debrah said, “But but but….”

    “Start. Here.”

    In the final version of The Sweet Trade, the warehouse blows up at the top of page two (and the rest of the village is destroyed and the residents are killed), and young Dirk and his friends, who were playing some distance away, are thrust into the world of piracy that will carry them through the rest of the story. On page one, Debrah introduced the protagonist and his normal world, and on page two, she blew that normal world up. That’s an effective hook.

    Other Components of the Hook

    A hook involves more than plot and characterization. The author’s “tone” or “voice”—how the piece sounds in the reader’s head—is also part of the hook. This might seem to be true primarily in poetry and so-called “literary” fiction, but it applies across genres and forms. Note that there is no “right” tone. Whining and sniveling, done well, can be as attention-catching and –holding as a slam-bang shoot-‘em-up opening scene. Note, too, that “done well” is not the same as what you personally prefer. The question is not whether you liked the opening but whether it grabbed and held your interest. Whether it did or it did not, again, you need to identify why.

    Pace, or lack of it, can also make a hook strong or weak, but it’s not a matter of fast or slow. A scene that goes screaming by may not be a good opening. If it fails at some of the tasks I’ve already discussed, it may not hook the reader. Similarly, a slow scene won’t be boring if it succeeds at those tasks. Again, the questions are:

    • Did it catch and hold my interest?
    • Did it make me want to keep reading?
    • If not, why not, and what can the author do to fix the problem?
    • If so, what was it about the opening that pulled me in?

    The hook also needs to introduce the piece’s setting and mood: when and where it takes place, what the physical, spiritual, and emotional environments are, etc. A weak hook does not establish these.

    That’s a lot to demand of just a line, a sentence, a paragraph, or a few pages, but that’s how important the hook is. If the opening does not hook the reader, he or she will go on to something else, meaning a lost potential fan, or at least a lost sale. On the other hand, a strong hook will launch the reader into the piece. If they have to keep reading past the opening, the hook has done its job.

    Your Thoughts

    In your mind, what makes a hook strong or weak? Do you have any examples you’d like to share? Please put your thoughts or examples in the Comments box below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 2: Series Overview

    Before we get down to the nitty-gritty details of what to critique and how to do it, I want to give you a high-level overview of what the rest of this series is going to cover. We’ll look at twelve broad categories:

    • Reader response
    • Beginnings and endings
    • Characters and characterization
    • Setting
    • Plot
    • Flashbacks, flash-forwards, and backstory
    • Narrative and dialogue
    • Pace
    • Description
    • General story-telling problems
    • Mechanical errors
    • Positive reinforcement, and
    • Other topics

    Whew, that’s a lot! “But wait, there’s more!” Much, much more, as you’ll see in a minute.

    Positive reinforcement gets its own section because writers need positive strokes, to hear that something they wrote actually “worked,” that it moved the reader in some way. This is why “critique” is not criticism: its point is NOT to merely find all the ways a work failed, didn’t live up to its potential, etc., but also to identify its successes so the author can, we hope, repeat them.

    Four Overall Questions

    For all of the sections and specific topics that follow, you’ll want to ask and answer the following four questions.

    #1: Did this problem happen?

    I know this seems like an odd question, but since I’ll be discussing 50+ (yes, 50+) different potential problem areas, not all of them will come up in every piece. At least, let’s hope not! You’re going to be on the lookout for all of them, though, and when you find one, your brain should  go ping! (or ah-ha!, or uh-oh!). That’s when you’ll move on to the next question.

    Does this sound hard? Don’t worry, it is, at first. That’s why I’m introducing the problem areas little by little: you only have to absorb one or a few at a time. And with practice, it does get easier.

    #2: Where did it happen?

    Be specific! Identify the spot right on the manuscript. Do more than just underline or circle it, though. In your notes in the margin—you DO write margin notes, don’t you?—answer the next two questions.

    #3: What was the exact nature of the problem?

    Again, be as specific as possible. WARNING: this requires actually thinking about the writing, not just letting it go in one eye and out the other! J Seriously, this is a very writerly task, and it’s a learned skill, not one that comes easily or naturally to a lot of people. If it takes you some time to learn it, that’s OK.

    One technique I use is to read each work twice. The first time, I read fairly quickly, just to get an overall sense of it. The second time is when I really slow down and look for the kinds of things this series will discuss.

    As you learn how to do this kind of review, you’ll find yourself applying it to your own writing as well, and that’s the most powerful benefit of critiquing other people’s work.

    #4: What can the author do to fix it?

    Another tough question! This one’s tricky, too, because it’s not your task to (re)write someone else’s piece to fit your style. Instead of saying, “If I was writing this story, I would have written…,” go back to question #3, try to determine what the writer was trying to accomplish, and then propose a way that he or she might do that.

    This is also a learned skill, so don’t be concerned if you have trouble doing it at first. If you’re a member of a writers’ group, listen to your fellow writers and how they try to accomplish this task. What seems to work? What doesn’t? The author’s verbal and non-verbal responses—and your own—to these suggestions will tell you a lot.

    There’s one last thing that makes this task tricky: the author is free to ignore your suggestions! Even if you think you’re right right RIGHT, if the author thinks you’re wrong wrong WRONG, guess who wins? Not you. At least, not in the near term. Do your best, then tell your ego to sit down and be quiet. Everyone will be happier for it.

    OK, that’s it for this time. Next time we’ll start looking at reader response: what it is and why it’s a good place to start giving critique from.

    A Question for You

    Meanwhile, I’d like to hear from you. When you critique or review a piece, are there any overall techniques you use or questions you keep in mind? I’m looking forward to reading your thoughts and approaches in the comment box below.