Tag: critique

  • Critique Technique, Part 34 — Imbalance Between Narrative and Dialogue

    Old woman falling down
    Image courtesy of Ambro / FreeDigitalPhotos.net

    OK, I admit it: saying there’s an imbalance between narrative and dialogue in a piece of writing is like saying there’s an imbalance between the ice cream and the banana in a banana split. For some people’s tastes, it’s not possible to have too much ice cream. Or too much banana.

    But for most of us, there’s a sweet spot—pun fully intended—around which a little bit more ice cream or banana, or a little bit less, would still be OK.

    The same is true of the balance between narrative and dialogue. Except that the range is wider. Much wider.

    It’s possible to write and publish a story that has no dialogue whatsoever. I’ve done it. James Michener, I’m told, wrote hundreds of dialogue-free pages at the beginning of Hawaii.

    The opposite—no narrative at all—could be done too, I suppose, but not easily. At some point, the speakers are going to have to be identified within the conversation. After all, even one “Bob said” or “Alice said” dialogue tag is narrative. Trying to avoid dialogue tags entirely runs the author into the name-calling and “as you know, Bob” problems I’ll discuss in later posts.

    So what we’re really dealing with here is not a 100% of one or the other situation, or even 50% + 1%, which is way too mathematical, anyway. It’s a much more subjective but nevertheless real question: What is the balance between narrative and dialogue that tells the story effectively? How can you as a reviewer spot when the relative proportions result in a story that is not told well?

    It’s also important to note here that this imbalance can show up almost down to the paragraph level. There’s nothing wrong with a single paragraph being all narrative or all dialogue, but problems can start to show up within just a few paragraphs, far below the level of a scene.

    The central question is whether you remain engaged with the story. Does your mind start to wander? Do you start skipping material? Do you get confused and have to go back to reread a passage? If the answer to any of these questions is yes, that could be a sign that the balance between narrative and dialogue is out of whack. (It could be a sign of other problems, of course, but for now we’ll ignore those possibilities.)

    “Too Much” Narrative

    Especially in fiction, when a piece has a section that’s nothing but narrative, the author may be info-dumping or lecturing the reader. When that happens, the pace will drag or even come to a complete stop. Readers will skip ahead to where the action picks up again.

    Similarly, large blocks of narrative can be signs the author is “telling” the story, rather than “showing” it. If he describes what a character thought or felt, rather than letting the reader experience those feelings or hear those thoughts, he’ll do it through narrative.

    These are both examples of the dreaded “expository lump,” that carcinoma of words which, if allowed to spread, will suck the life out of a story. When you find one, it’s time to put on your best Lady Macbeth and with a cry of, “Out, damned spot! Out, I say!” wield your reviewer’s pen.

    The key, again, is engagement: if a piece is filled with page after page of nothing but narrative but you can’t put it down, it’s working, and imbalance is not an issue.

    “Too Much” Dialogue

    Too much dialogue reveals itself in some ways that are similar and some that are different.

    Dialogue can be an expository lump in disguise. In this case, a character does the lecturing instead of the author or narrator, by either making a long speech to another character or ruminating in interior monologue.

    “Long” can be subjective, by the way. Just a few lines can feel long if they make the reader lose interest. On the other hand, if the reader has forgotten that she’s reading and is totally engrossed in the story, it won’t matter if a paragraph is more than a page long.

    Dialogue can also get out of balance if the contents of the conversation are boring. Dialogue can be boring if:

    • it fails to move the story forward,
    • its relevance is not clear,
    • it deals with insignificant matters,
    • the characters are just exchanging information, or
    • the characters show no emotion or interest in what they’re discussing.

    The common thread here is the lack of conflict. Effective dialogue has a spark, an energy that keeps the reader intensely inside the scene.

    Dialogue-as-info-dump suffers from a similar problem but in this case there’s no opportunity for conflict because the speaker just won’t shut up.

    Another way dialogue can be out of balance is if the author is using it, intentionally or otherwise, to avoid providing the kinds of details that narrative provides best. There are times when just a brief bit of narrative—describing a gesture that reveals a contradictory emotion, for example—can show what dialogue alone cannot, or cannot show well.

    Relevant setting details are another example of good use of narrative rather than dialogue. If an author tries to have a character describe something verbally, it will likely sound stilted and awkward. She’s using the wrong tool for the job.

    Finally, dialogue gets out of balance when the reader loses track of who’s speaking. Even if two characters are speaking with highly distinctive voices, after a while a reader needs a cue in the form of a dialogue tag to keep him on track. This is especially true when there are more than two characters in the scene.

    Dialogue’s different and shorter sentence structure results in space on the page with no printing on it. This “white space” lets the reader rest a bit. Narrative can provide something similar. Small insertions of narrative—the dialogue tag, the descriptive detail—or just a one-line paragraph, also provide a restful break, however brief, that keeps the reader engaged.

    Questions For You

    How can you tell if a piece’s narrative and dialogue are getting out of balance? Ask yourself these questions.

    • Is the author lecturing or info-dumping, in either dialogue or narrative?
    • Is the author providing too much detail, too little, or via the wrong method?
    • Is the author telling what should be shown, or showing what should be told?
    • Are the characters discussing things that make the story drag or otherwise make you lose interest?
    • Is the author failing to mix the dialogue and narrative in ways that allow you to rest, even while you stay interested?
    • Does the author let you lose track of who’s speaking?

    If you find any of these situations, be sure to let the author know and suggest alternatives.

    What signals you that a piece’s narrative and dialogue are out of balance? I’m sure you’ll find the right balance when you put your suggestions in the comments box below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 33 — Contradictions

    Contradictions are the stuff of conflict. Contradictions between

    Angry couple standing back to back
    Image courtesy of David Castillo Dominici / FreeDigitalPhotos.net
    • characters’ words and actions,
    • what characters say to different people and/or at different times,
    • what characters do at different times or in different circumstances, or
    • the responses of different characters to the same stimulus

    all increase a reader’s tension and interest in the story.

    At least so long as the contradictions are intentional on the author’s part.

    If they’re not, that could be a problem. Or an unintended or unexpected opportunity. Your job as a reviewer is to not only spot the contradictions, but to evaluate them for effect, motivation, and intent.

    Intentional or Unintentional

    The first thing you need to assess is whether the author placed a contradiction in the story intentionally or not. If you’re new to the story or author, this can be difficult, at least until you have a better understanding of the story and the way the author works. But even before that, you can ask yourself whether the contradiction seems to have a purpose. Writers should always put contradictory actions or statements into a piece for a specific reason. They can:

    • indicate a change in the character’s situation, beliefs, or intentions;
    • be an attempt to deceive or mislead another character;
    • show confusion on the part of the character, perhaps due to a declining mental state, being overwhelmed by their situation or how much information is coming their way, or the conflicting demands of other characters or the situation in the story; or
    • simply be an unintentional (on the character’s part) misstatement or mistaken action that is going to have consequences later.

    Your job is to assess whether the author intended to insert that contradiction or he just made a mistake. The author’s “failure” could be intentional: he might be withholding information to increase your tension and your need to know what happens next. That’s why it’s important to keep reading, as much as possible, to see if that was, in fact, the author’s intent. If you critique what appears to be a mistake too soon, you might have to go back and delete or revise that comment.

    Assessing Contradictions

    OK, so how do you assess a contradiction? It’s relatively easy when the contrary words or acts are close together. Unfortunately, that doesn’t always happen. That’s when this kind of assessment can be difficult, especially if you’re not reading an entire piece at once.

    Here’s an example. Let’s say that in chapter three Bob says he respects Alice. He’s impressed with her knowledge and determination. Now supposed Bob and Alice go their separate ways in chapters four to six, but in chapter seven, Bob calls Alice lazy and stupid. That’s a pretty sharp contrast, and if it seems to come out of the blue, you’re likely to remember Bob’s earlier statements and wonder what’s up now. But if Bob’s later comment is diffident, that Alice’s work is okay, will you catch the conflict? You should, but it’s harder to do.

    In my article on the reviewer’s mind, I discuss how to remember details across large parts of a text or over long periods of time. You might want to review that article soon.

    Let’s say you’ve spotted some kind of contradiction. What’s next?

    Effects

    The first thing to look for is its effect: how it affects the characters involved.

    • Does it create new and interesting problems for one or more characters?
    • Does it make matters worse for them?
    • Do those problems change the direction of the story, especially in interesting and/or unexpected ways? And does the author follow up on that new direction?

    Contradictory behavior in a character reveals something about her. This is good. Or at least, it can be.

    Preparation

    Next, you want to assess whether the author prepared the reader for the contradiction. It’s important for the author to have set up the behavior before it happens. This is a place where a lot of writers fall down.

    The author can set up the contradiction in a number of ways, and any of them can be blatant or subtle. For example:

    • Circumstances in the character’s life and environment can force a change that leads to the contradiction. Being forced out of his home by a natural catastrophe is a blatant set-up. A slow build-up of conflict leading to a divorce or separation from his partner could be subtle.
    • The character herself might have been evolving due to an accumulation of small changes.
    • What the character said or did originally may have been dishonest, misleading, or just incorrect. Or what he’s saying or doing now may be.
    • The character is responding to what another character says or does that she didn’t expect.
    • The character’s statement or action is unintentional, compared to what he’s said and done before.

    Motivation

    A third factor is the character’s motivation for saying or doing something that contradicts what he said or did in the past, even if that past was just seconds ago in story time. You’ll want to assess not only if the reader can see or sense what the motivation is but also if it’s credible, given what you know about the story and the characters.

    If the author set up the contradiction, and the character’s motivation for it and its effect are clear, that’s great. But if she’s missed on any one, that’s a sign there’s a problem. You as the reviewer need to identify what went wrong.

    Questions for You

    Here are some questions you can ask when you’re evaluating something that a character in a piece has done or said that seems to contradict his earlier statements or behavior.

    • Did the author place this contradiction with a purpose?
      • Does it reveal something about a change in the character or her situation?
      • Might it be setting up something that will happen later in the story?
      • If not, what exactly is the problem and how can the author fix it?
    • Does this contradictory statement or behavior change things for the character, those around him, or the overall story? Especially, does it make things worse?
    • If the change doesn’t happen right away, do it and its effects show up at all, or did the author seem to forget that she set up a change that hasn’t happened?
      • If the change hasn’t shown up, why?
    • Was the reader prepared for the contradiction?
      • If he was, was that good, or was it perhaps telegraphed (he could see it coming)?
      • If he wasn’t, was that good? Does it create new interest and tension in the reader?
    • Can you see why the character said or did the contradictory thing? Was her motivation clear?
      • If not, why not? Was that intentional on the author’s part?

    Well-placed contradictions make stories more interesting and keep the reader engaged. Be sure to compliment the author when they do them well.

    What do you look for and what do you consider when you run across a contradiction in a story? It’s no contradiction to say that the best place for your suggestions is in the comments box below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 32 — %*@!$#^!!!!

    Let’s get this out of the way right up front. This post is about the “f-bomb” and various other phrases and four- through fourteen-letter words that are generally not used in polite company: swear words, curse words, obscenities, vulgarities, the whole lot, and the words we sometimes substitute for them. As a matter of convenience, I’ll call everything swearing.

    A simulated swear word

    I know you’ve all heard the usual advice to writers and their reviewers: if swear words are natural parts of a character’s way of speaking, don’t be shy about using them, even if that’s not the way you speak.

    But that’s not really enough advice for a writer, nor is it enough for a critiquer trying to determine if such language is being used as it should. That’s what I want to get into now.

    Uses of Swearing

    Writers should use swearing, like every other kind of language, with intent. Swearing in dialog can:

    • Show extreme emotion;
    • Show a character’s response to great physical pain[1] or a sudden, often unpleasant surprise;
    • Describe, reveal an attitude about, or add emphasis to the (usually negative) description of another character, an action, an idea, etc.; or
    • Add emphasis to irony or sarcasm. Note that using even very mild epithets, like golly-gee, can do this, too, particularly from a character who normally uses rougher terms.

    Even when swearing is part of a character’s persona, swearing at random or too much is a problem. If a character swears all the time, it won’t take long before the reader feels like she’s being beaten over the head with it. Once the author has established that a character swears a lot, he doesn’t need to show every instance.

    If swearing is not part of a character’s normal persona, when they do swear, there must be a good reason for it. I’m not referring here to a character using some mild term like, “oh, sugar,” but using a phrase like “oh, shit,” instead of what they would normally use. When this happens, it should reveal something about the person or her situation that we hadn’t known before or which had changed enough to warrant the stronger language.

    Time and Place

    Swearing also needs to be consistent with the time and culture of the story. If one 17th century pirate calls another a scurvy dog, readers will accept that. If Edna calls Millicent that at their weekly tea, however, it’s going to make the reader wonder. Swearing always calls attention to itself, which is why the writer needs to make sure it’s drawing the right kind of attention.

    Along those lines, some think the fine art of scatology has lost its verve over the decades. Today’s vocabulary of swearage seems puny and limited compared to that of 150 or 200 years ago. When was the last time you heard someone called a lily-livered, yellow-bellied scalawag, for example? Today, different forms of “fuck” serve as almost every part of speech except conjunctions and most of the other obscenities and vulgarities in English have to do with sexual or excretory functions. Not much variety or creativity there.

    Trying to overcome that poverty can have its own problems, however.

    Writers sometimes make up words to take the place of current swear words. Most often in science fiction and fantasy, they’ll do it to introduce what they want the reader to believe are the swear words of the story’s time or place. These words almost always fail. They stand out just because they’re made up, rather than part of the reader’s regular vernacular.

    Writers who don’t want to use real swear words in work they expect teens and younger kids to read may make up swear words too. Unfortunately that response to a perceived taboo has become outdated, and there are better ways of setting a better example. Writers are no longer protecting kids from words they don’t already know: just visit any junior high school or middle school playground.

    Swearing can appear in narrative as well as dialog. It can be used in an indirect quote, such as, “Bob had been heard to refer to Ted as a fucking idiot.” This reveals something about Bob, Ted, and their relationship.

    Particularly in non-fiction, the attitude being expressed can be the author’s rather than a character’s, when an author is trying to make a piece “edgy,” for example, or appealing to a certain audience: young and macho, say, or angry or rebellious. As in dialog, though, when swearing for attitude is used too much, it becomes annoying and hurts the author’s credibility. Once the attitude is established, there’s little need for the swearing to continue.

    And of course, it can also be used in direct quotes from someone being interviewed or profiled.

    A Caution for Reviewers

    When you’re reviewing a work, and the author or her characters are using language you don’t—and maybe don’t approve of—it can be hard to evaluate the work objectively. Swearing, as an emotional action, naturally draws an emotional reaction too. If that happens to you, try to take a step back from the piece and remind yourself what you’re trying to do: to determine if the piece “works” for its intended audience. Just as a writer needs to “put on the clothes” of his characters, you may need to exchange your usual “wardrobe” for that of the piece’s target audience.

    Questions for You

    So as a reviewer, how do you determine whether the swearing—or the lack of it—in a work is necessary, appropriate, and effective? Here are some tests you can use.

    • Is the language the character is using appropriate to his or her personality, culture, era, and situation? If not, what doesn’t fit? What can the author do to fix that?
    • Does it:
      • Add relevant information about the speaker or another character that can’t or shouldn’t be presented some other way?
      • Reveal something new and unexpected about the character?
      • Demonstrate a character’s extreme emotion or physical pain?
      • Help the speaker express irony or sarcasm?
      • Illustrate or create an attitude, in the character or the piece?

    If the answer to any of these questions is no, and that seems to have been the author’s intent, what can she do to fix it?

    • Does the language call inappropriate attention to itself through overuse, underuse (does the author seem afraid to use it), or artificiality (that is, made-up words)? If so, what needs to change?

    For better or worse, obscenities, vulgarities, and swearing in general are parts of the language of every culture. As a result, they have a legitimate place in literature. Proper, purposeful use can, as with any other form of speech, add to a work’s effectiveness and power—or detract from it.

    When you’re reviewing a piece, how do you evaluate the author’s use of swearing? If you’ve got some suggestions, don’t keep them a damn secret! Share them in the comments box below.


    [1] Doctors have shown swearing really does help ease pain!

  • Critique Technique, Part 31 — The Wrong Words

    Authors can and do go wrong with their word choices, or use words the wrong way. This isn’t just a case of not understanding Mark Twain’s definition of the difference between the right word and the almost-right word: the lightning versus the lightning bug. It is that, but it’s much more.

    Pencil eraser erasing "wrong word"
    Photo by ningmilo via FreeDigitalPhotos.net

    There are at least half a dozen ways an author can mess things up for herself and her readers when it comes to word choice. They are: using words that are wrong for

    • The story, usually in narrative;
    • The character, usually in dialogue; or
    • The reader, in either one.

    Authors can also simply use the wrong word when they don’t know the difference between two or more words or what a word actually means. And then there’s the trap of trying to be too clever. We’ll save obscenities and vulgarities for next time but let’s take a look at the rest in more detail.

    Wrong for the Narrative

    Narrative words that are wrong for the story are ones that don’t match what the story is meant to be. For example, the sometimes-flowery, sophisticated, or psychologically dense language of “literary” fiction would be out of place in a western, say, or a thriller. Conversely, the taut, gritty language of that thriller would be jarring—in the wrong way—in a story examining the ins and outs of a couple’s troubled relationship.

    That’s not to say, of course, that there couldn’t be a couple with a troubled relationship in a western or thriller, but the way that relationship would be depicted—the words the author would use—would be very different.

    Writing above or below the level of the story, that is, using words that don’t match the target audience and the personalities of the characters makes the reader aware of the writing. Once that happens, that magical bubble we call a story pops and it’s hard to surround the reader with a new one.

    Wrong for the Dialogue

    Words in dialogue that are wrong for the characters can have these same problems, plus a few more. For starters, we expect a longshoreman’s conversations to be very different from those of a college professor: brief, basic, and profanity-laced on the one hand, elongated, erudite, and perhaps elliptical on the other. What they talk about will be different, too.

    When the content and style of a character’s speech don’t match what the reader expects, there’d better be a good reason for it. Maybe the professor used to be a longshoreman and in the scene in question he’s visiting his former buds at a bar near the docks. It would make sense if he used rough language there. If, however, he talks like a longshoreman while teaching electrical engineering, that’s a problem.

    Another problem in dialogue is when a character reveals knowledge she has no reason to have. To take an extreme example, the reader’s going to be surprised if a manicurist at a nail salon in rural South Dakota uses the language of the branch of physics called string theory, say, and uses it correctly, while talking with her customers. If the reason why she understands things like M-theory and branes hasn’t been established, it better be, and quickly, or it needs to be replaced with something more appropriate.

    A third problem in dialogue comes up when a character expresses attitudes or beliefs that are contrary to what the reader knows, or thinks he knows, about that character. The Bubba who uses the language of the LGBTQ community—without irony or disrespect—or the shoe salesman who speaks like an investment banker is, in the immortal words of Ricky Ricardo, going to have “some ‘splainin’ to do.”

    Wrong for the Audience

    Words that are wrong for the reader include technical jargon, slang, local idiom, dialect, or foreign or obscure words, especially when the words’ meanings aren’t made clear through the dialogue, narrative, or context. It’s okay to withhold information from the reader to build suspense or tension, but not to confuse or distract the reader. When that happens, the words throw the reader out of the story, whether it’s because he puts it down to go find a dictionary, or he hesitates, trying to puzzle the meaning out, and then struggles on (or worse, stops reading).

    A former member of my writers’ group loved to show off his extensive vocabulary by using unusual words. For example, he used “mephitic” to describe the smell of a men’s room in his autobiography about his time as an enlisted soldier. Not only is mephitic an uncommon word, it didn’t fit the story or his primary target audience. (It, and other words like it, did emphasize how out of place he was in that world, but that was already clear from the story itself.)

    Misunderstood Words

    Homonyms and homophones are the landmines of the English language. Homonyms are words that share the same spelling but have different meanings, such as quail and bear. Both can refer to animals, but quail also means to cower in fear, and it’s a curdling agent too! Bear also means to carry, to endure, or to uncover or be uncovered! YourDictionary.com has a short list of homonyms, but there are many others.

    Homophones are words that sound alike when spoken but are spelled differently and have different meanings. Some of the best known are to, too, and two; their, they’re, and there; and affect and effect. 7ESL.com has an illustrated list of over 300 homonyms and homophones.

    People who pun use homonyms and homophones all the time. It’s how we role—I mean, roll.

    Humor writers use words called malapropisms intentionally because the word substitutions can be hilarious: “he’s the suppository of all knowledge around here” (suppository, not repository). Unfortunately, these substitutions can show up in new writers’ work unintentionally if they have mis-heard or misunderstood a word in the past.

    Trying Too Hard

    My earlier example of my friend using mephitic instead of sulfurous is an example of trying too hard. Other times it happens when a writer gets bored (with using “said” over and over, for example) or wants to stand out somehow. One of the most infamous—and giggle-inducing—examples is using “ejaculated” instead of “exclaimed.” Yes, technically, ejaculated could be used to describe words bursting forth from a character, but we all know the word isn’t typically used to refer to words these days.

    On the Other Hand…

    Of course, there will always be cases where any of these kinds of supposedly wrong words will be both necessary and appropriate. The author may be setting up a contrast between the scene and the story’s tone or between a character’s past and her present. She may be using dialect, jargon, or incorrect or inappropriate words to establish something about a character. As a reviewer, you need to be aware of the possibility the writer is doing something “wrong” to achieve a certain effect.

    Questions for You

    What questions could you ask when you review a work for these kinds of problems? Try these.

    • Did the author use language that felt out of place—too sophisticated, too simple, or otherwise inappropriate—for the story?
    • Did I have to stop reading to figure out what a word meant?
    • Did the author apparently not understand what a word meant?
    • Did it feel like the author was trying to show off by using fancy words?
    • Did a character use words that didn’t fit with what I know about him or her?
    • Is the author consistently but unintentionally making homonym or homophone substitutions?
    • On the other hand, was there a purpose to what the author was doing with her word choices? If so, how effective was it? If not, why was it not effective?

    If the answer to any of these questions but the last set is yes, mark where the problem occurs and discuss alternatives with the author.

    What do you look for when it comes to inappropriate words in a story? Please be careful to avoid spreading contusions 😉 when you provide your answers in the comments box below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 30 — Too Many Words, or Too Few

    In the movie My Fair Lady, Eliza Doolittle, the Cockney flower girl turned high-society woman of charm and mystery, sings to her would-be boyfriend, “Words, words, words, I’m so sick of words….”

    For some writers, that’s not a problem. In fact, they’re too in love with words, and think the more of them there are on the page or screen, the better. Then there are the others who, Eliza-like, want no more of them. Or at least darn few of them.

    The days of padding a piece with any and every extraneous available word, á la Henry James, are over. (Well, for new or getting-established writers, they’re over. For über-successful authors like Stephen King, Tom Clancy, or George R. R. Martin, padding may not be intentional, but it’s not edited out, either.)

    At the other end of the spectrum, writers who take tight, Ernest Hemingway-like writing to the Clint Eastwood man-with-no-name extreme may not see print, either, at least not with a traditional publisher.

    Style Versus Substance

    Why? Because both writing styles hide meaning. Wordy writing buries it under a pile of needless verbiage, while too-spare writing fails to provide enough information for the meaning to come through.

    Both styles can also reveal a lack of confidence on the writer’s part.

    • Wordy writing may reveal the author’s fear that the reader won’t understand what he’s written.
    • In cryptic writing, the author:
      • Doesn’t know how to convey onto the page what she’s seeing in her mind’s eye, or
      • Assumes the reader knows everything she knows, or
      • Is perhaps afraid to say too much.

    Different genres of fiction and different non-fiction markets have different preferred styles. “Literary” and mainstream fiction tend to be wordier than some other forms because they value and expect more depth of description, greater use of simile and metaphor for comparison, more exploration of psychological and emotional states, and so on. Thrillers, westerns, and some science fiction, on the other hand, get right to the point and the action.

    The same is true in non-fiction: a magazine like Atlantic Monthly expects a different—wordier—style than, say, Outside.

    So, before making a judgment on whether a piece is too wordy or too cryptic, it helps to know its genre or target market.

    What to Look For

    With that in mind, you can start testing for faults. Too spare writing is easier to deal with, if not necessarily easier to detect. If a piece is too spare, you’ll find yourself wanting to know more. It may be drawing your curiosity but it also has holes. They might be details about a character, setting, or situation that you feel you need to know right now but don’t, or the story might fly by, flashing from event to event without explanation or development. In cases like these, flag the places where the problems happen and identify what you need to know, how the plot, characterization, or setting can be developed more, or the pace slowed.

    Overly wordy writing can take many forms. Here are some examples.

    • Using phrases like “in order to” or “in expectation of” rather than the shorter and cleaner “to” or “expecting”;
    • Using the passive voice;
    •  Piling on excess descriptive phrases, adjectives, or adverbs;
    • Data-dumping: pouring in more information than the reader needs at that moment in the piece; or
    • Trying to be “literary” by writing long, winding, complicated sentences.

    Like the wordy writer, this list could go on and on.

    The best ways to tell when writing is too wordy are:

    • You feel like you’re wading through the piece, rather than flowing through it;
    • You become conscious of the fact that you’re reading rather than being engaged in the story;
    • You find yourself losing interest, your mind wandering off to ponder what you’re going to have for dinner, whether your daughter’s newest boyfriend can be trusted farther than you can throw him, etc.

    Of course, there can be other reasons for being distracted, but in cases like these, when you drag your concentration back to the work, you’ll know you need to get out your verbosity meter and take a reading (pun intended).

    Questions for You

    Here are some questions you can ask yourself as you review a writer’s work.

    • Do I find myself struggling to understand what the author is trying to say, or picture what he’s trying to describe?
      • Is that because he’s buried the meaning or description in too many words? Is he trying to be “literary” in a piece that is not meant for that market? If so, show him how he can clean out the excess.
      • Is it because there’s too little information or description? If so, what needs to be added, and where?
    • Is she using empty words that don’t add anything meaningful to the piece?
    • Is he using the passive voice? Show him how the active voice saves words and is more engaging.
    • Is she providing explanations you think readers don’t need?
      • Did she provide that information before? If so, all you may need to do is remind her of that and encourage her to believe that her readers really will remember it from last time.
      • Is there so much information that it bogs the story down? If so, show her how she can trim out the material that is not contributing. Maybe it can be used elsewhere. Or maybe it is not needed at all.
    • Conversely, does it seem that he’s left important information out because he assumed the reader knows things they don’t? Show him why that information needs to be added, and where a good place to do it would be.

    Speaking of getting wordy, it’s time to cut this piece off. What do you look for to identify when writing is too wordy or too cryptic? And what do you do to help such writing get better? Feel free to put your brief—but not too brief—suggestions in the comments box below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 1B — Life on the Other Side of the Critique

    In addition to taking care to develop your own skills as a critiquer, some of which I discussed in Part 1A, there’s one other person you need to always be mindful of: the person whose work you’re reviewing.

    Think about how you react when your work is being critiqued. In 2012, Becky Levine wrote a blog post called Critique Comments: Remembering to Give Them Time. She advised letting a critique you receive sit and percolate, or ferment, or something (my words, her concept) before responding to it. Of course, there’s going to be the natural, defensive first response, even if the comments aren’t negative. Any suggestion to do things a different way is going to get that. That’s a reaction that needs to be put aside, taken off the hot stove and allowed to cool, as it were. It might be wrong.

    Or it might not.

    But in the heat of that first reactive moment, it can be hard to tell.

    I’ve been there. One of my writers’ group members didn’t read the kind of fiction I write (science fiction), so some of the techniques of the genre confused her. Sometimes she’d forget something that was explained a half page or two pages before. Sometimes context eluded her. So she’d comment on whatever confused her, and my first reaction was often frustration. But then… sometimes… I’d take another look and… well, yeah, I could have written that better.

    That’s a Person Over There!

    Woman with a headache

    That’s a good lesson. And it leads to this reminder: when you’re a critiquer, it’s important to remember that the work you’re reading was written by a human being. If you’re going to deliver that critique in person, you’ll see their initial reaction up close and personal. If you’re delivering it online, you may not, in which case it’s even more important to remember the humanity of the person on the receiving side of that critique. The anonymity, or at least physical separation, of the internet is no excuse for being a jerk.

    Or worse.

    Think about how you’d feel—or have felt—when you got a critique like that.

    I’ve read many first drafts of new writers’ first novels. They’re rough. Of course they are, they’re first drafts! The fact that they can often be rough for hundreds of pages is still no excuse for me to be hard on the author. It’s a first draft. If the writer’s gotten that far into the piece, they’ve got the talent to string together a complete novel. And for the first time in their life, they’re trying to do it. Yes, there will be a lot of work yet to do: drafts 2 and 3 and 4 and…. This is just the first one.

    But if I do my job wrong, if I’m too hard on that new author, maybe there won’t be a draft 2 and a draft 3 and so on until it’s done. Maybe they’ll decide it isn’t worth the continued abuse (their thought, not my intent!) to go on to draft 2 and draft 3 and….

    Which would be an absolute shame.

    Dif’rent Strokes for Dif’rent Folks

    There’s one other thing to think about. Different people learn and absorb information differently. Some do best reading new information. Others need to see it demonstrated. Still others need to hear it. And yet others learn best by doing a particular task. In-person and online critique group reviews tend to be written, with an oral summary at the group meeting. Critiques provided via a critique web site are almost always exclusively written.

    But what happens if that doesn’t connect with the way the author learns best? I currently have a critique group member who does a lot better if he hears the individual comments. Written comments and guides tend to go in one eye and out the other with him. One-on-one, step-by-step reviews with him doing the editing in real time takes time, but if the time spent turns out to make a big different in the areas he’s having trouble with, it’ll be time well spent.

    Our Responsibility

    As critiquers, we have to remember that we hold something very fragile in our hands—a new (or not so new) writer’s ego, their hopes, their dreams—and if we’re needlessly harsh, if we only criticize without offering suggestions for ways to get better results, we not only do no good, we may do harm.

    That isn’t to say we can’t or shouldn’t point out what isn’t working, or isn’t working as well as it could. It’s not to say we need to sugarcoat everything, or be so namby-pamby or vague that what we say is as good as useless.

    Writers do need to develop a thick skin. Once their work is published, they’re going to get feedback, and those one- and two-star reviews can sting. The internet’s trolls can be especially cruel.

    But that does not mean we critiquers should be.

    It does mean that we should always remember what it’s like to be on the receiving end of a critique and do our work accordingly.

    What are your thoughts about how to put yourself in the place of that other author when you’re critiquing their work? How do you approach presenting your critique, especially when the author has a lot of work to do? Please share your thoughts, suggestions, and ideas in the comments box below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 29 — Writers’ Tics

    Woman writing notes
    Image courtesy of Graur Codrin / FreeDigitalPhotos.net

    Writers’ tics—those sneaky, dastardly things that slip into our writing when we’re not looking and make it go CLANK! They’re insidious and terribly hard to recognize: our eyes glide right over them when we’re editing.

    And it doesn’t matter how experienced we are, we’re still vulnerable to them.

    What are they? Here’s a nowhere-near-complete list:

    • Incessantly using unnecessarily intrusive adverbs excessively.
    • Clichés we’ve read a million times before.
    • The words or phrases we really like to use over and over because they really do a really great job of really capturing what we’re really trying to say.
    • Those, like, popular, y’know, empty words or phrases that are nothing but noise. I know: seriously?
    • Repeated word patterns:
      • Short, choppy sentences. Strings of them. One after the other. Like that. And this.
      •  Whenever you’re writing, beginning sentences with independent or dependent clauses.
    • Making repeated parenthetical comments, perhaps set off between commas, or other ways (within parentheses)—or between dashes—to call attention to them.
    • Putting words or phrases in quotation marks to “set them off” from the others, so readers know they’re “special.”
    • Using italics or ALL CAPITALS when a character’s being very emotional. Even when they’re NOT.
    • Using exclamation points!! A lot!!!
    • Having one or more characters use the same gesture, facial expression, or other behavior over and over.

    The list goes on. And on.

    The good news is that this is a case where being a critiquer can benefit you as well as the author you’re reading. When you’ve learned to spot these problems in other people’s writing, you’ll catch more of them in your own work.

    Great! But what are you trying to do?

    Finding Writer’s Tics

    The good news is that finding writer’s tics uses a kind of working memory. Your subconscious keeps track of things in a story or article, counting each time they show up, and when it detects something, it whispers, “Hey, that’s the third time she’s used ‘really’ as an adjective in the last four paragraphs. Looks like there’s a pattern setting up.” Once you’ve developed this turn of mind to catch these problems, they’ll start jumping out at you.

    It’s like what happens after you’ve gotten a new car. Suddenly, you start seeing the same make and model on the street. You’ve become attuned to that thing—car or phrase—and now they seem to be everywhere. It’s not that they weren’t there before, you’re just more conscious of them now.

    So how do you learn how to do this?

    The good news is that there are at least a couple ways. First, if you know someone—a member of your writers’ group or a trusted reader—who already has the skill, watch them in action. Listen closely when they’re giving critique to another member of your group and then go back through that same piece, looking for what they found.

    If they reviewed some of your own work and were kind enough to mark those tics for you, go looking for the same problems in your other work.

    Or, take a piece of writing that you’ve been told has some kind of writer’s tic in it, but not what the specific problem is, and try to find it yourself.

    Like this one. I’ve planted a problem in it: a phrase that I’ve used repeatedly and in a very specific way. Can you find it?

    The good news is that if you can find it, you won’t have to look in this footnote[1] to find out what it is. (By the way, did you also notice that every bullet except the last one at the start of this article illustrated the problem it was describing?)

    Like all the other problems and techniques in this series, detecting writers’ tics is about being aware of more than just the chain of words that passes before your eyes. It’s about seeing the work in larger parts, as the sum of those parts, and as something more than the sum. It’s about reading like a writer, not merely like a reader.

    Once you’ve developed this skill, not only will you be able to help the writers you’re reviewing, you’ll be able to shock and dismay yourself when you discover how much you make these mistakes, too! But that’s OK, because after you get over the shock and fix the problems, your work will be better, and that’s what we’re all striving for.

    Questions for You

    Let’s go back through that list of potential tics and create some questions you can ask yourself as you review a work.

    • Does he use adverbs excessively?
    • Does she use clichéd descriptions?
    • Are there certain words or phrases that keep showing up in his work?
    • Does she use empty words that add nothing to the text? (Note that these can be acceptable in dialogue, at least for a while, to help demonstrate a character’s personality.)
    • Does he repeat sentence structures, like short or long sentences, or repeatedly beginning sentences with dependent or independent clauses?
    • Does she overuse commas, parentheses, em-dashes, italics, all capitals, or exclamation points?
    • Do his characters have only a limited repertoire of gestures, facial expressions, etc.?

    If the author does any of these things, or you notice any other kind of unintentional repetition, be sure to point it out to them and suggest what they can do to fix it.

    What other kinds of writer’s tics have you noticed in work you’ve reviewed? If you know any other techniques that writers and critiquers can use, please include them in the comments box below.


    [1] It’s starting paragraphs with the phrase “The good news is that…”

  • Critique Technique, Part 28 — Awkward Dialogue

    Woman talking on pay phone
    Image courtesy of Sira Anamwong / FreeDigitalPhotos.net

    Ah, dialogue. It’s hard for many writers to do well. When it works, it crackles, sings, inspires, enrages, chills, thrills. But when it doesn’t, it might do that too, but for the wrong reasons! It may be stiff and stilted, choppy or verbose, confused or confusing, or have other problems. Any or all of those characteristics can be acceptable, even necessary, when they reflect the character of the speaker. When they don’t, there’s trouble.

    Natural Dialogue vs. Written Dialogue

    There are many reasons for this. First off, dialogue in writing—all writing: fiction, memoir, and non-fiction—is not natural, but has to sound natural when read, especially out loud. Real dialogue includes pauses, repetitions, false starts, bad grammar, slang and jargon, incomplete sentences, and other problems.

    Fictional dialogue is “better” than natural speech without seeming to be constructed, even though it is. If any of the problems I listed above appear there, the author should have put them there intentionally.

    Perhaps even more than in narrative, every word must be the right word. Sentence structure must be just right to convey the proper degree of tension—from raving rage to the gentlest soothing. Every speaker must say just the right thing, especially when that’s just the wrong thing.

    The good news for you as a reviewer is that bad dialogue calls attention to itself. You feel the problem as you read it. You find yourself saying, “Huh?” or “Get on with it, will you?” or even throwing the story across the room in frustration.

    But let’s get a bit more specific about a few ways dialogue can be awkward. We’ll start with dialogue that is stiff or stilted.

    Stiff and Stilted

    First off, what do I mean by “stiff” and “stilted”? They’re very similar, so I need to be clear about how they’re different. Stiff dialogue has these characteristics.

    • It is often too grammatically correct. Sentences are complete, with an explicit subject, verb, and object. Real, and real-sounding, dialogue on the other hand is full of sentence fragments.
    • Sentences may be long and rambling (there’s an example below) or short and choppy, like this: “Bob went to the store. He bought a loaf of bread and a half-gallon of milk. He paid for them in cash.” Both kinds of sentences can be effective when they’re used properly. The problem occurs when the style does not match the character or the situation.
    • The speakers avoid using contractions, saying “I will” rather than “I’ll,” for example.
    • It’s emotionally flat, even when trying to express strong emotion, by avoiding the strong language that high emotion requires, or by using sentence structures that don’t match with or create the high emotion the author intended.
    • The pace never changes and often plods. The pace and flow of real, and real-sounding, dialogue ebbs and flows.

    In short, stiff dialogue sounds the way a robot in a bad science fiction movie from the 1950s would speak.

    Stilted dialogue is stiff, and then some. It adds extra degrees of formality, “expert” or erudite language (like that), and emotional distance between the speakers. Sentences in stilted dialogue or narrative tend to be longer and more complex than they need to be and to use many words where a few would do. The result can be something like this: “As you can see, madam, by virtue—or lack thereof—of your behavior, it shall be necessary for me to make inquiries into the nature and number of your previous liaisons with potential suitors in order that I may be better informed as to their, and your, morality and any potential indications of turpitude or depravity.”

    As opposed to, “So, Alice, who’ve you been screwing lately?”

    There are other ways writing can be awkward.

    • Unclear personal pronoun references can be a real problem. When there are two or more characters of the same gender in a sentence or paragraph, referring to them with pronouns (he/him/his, she/her/hers) can leave the reader confused over which pronoun refers to which character.
    • Similarly, using the characters’ names over and over can be just as awkward. There’s no confusion over who the author or speaker is referring to but repeating names does not reflect natural speech patterns.
    • “Talking around” a topic, that is, using euphemisms or indirect language rather than coming out and naming the person or thing can lead to real confusion for the reader, whether it’s the narrator or a character speaking.
    • Abnormal word order is a technique writers will use when they’re trying to make a character seem “foreign”—Yoda from the Star Wars movies, for example—or uneducated. Used sparingly and in character, this technique can be fine. If the author uses it too much, though, the reader will struggle.

    While I’ve concentrated on dialogue here, awkward narrative shares all of these faults. The only difference is that it’s the narrator “speaking” directly or indirectly to the reader, rather than the reader listening in on a character’s thoughts or to a conversation between characters.

    A Powerful Technique

    What can you do to help repair awkward dialogue or narrative? One of the best things you can do is encourage the author to read her work out loud before she submits it. Or, she can use the read-aloud capabilities that some word processors and document handling programs like Adobe Reader have. If she resists, read the unedited work out loud to her so she can hear just how awkward it is. In many cases, the awkwardness will speak for itself and you won’t have to exaggerate the problems. If she still doesn’t understand that there’s a problem, you may need to ask her to explain why she chose to write the dialogue the way she did. Maybe you’re the one who doesn’t understand.

     Reading a work out loud is such a powerful technique because we process the words we hear differently than when we read them with our eyes. Problems our eyes and brain glide right over will jump out to the listener when the work is read aloud. This technique works for narrative as well as dialogue.

    Questions for You

    Now here are some questions you can ask yourself as you review a work.

    • Is every sentence of the author’s dialogue grammatically correct?
    • Is every sentence complete, or does he use fragments?
    • Are her sentences consistently the same length, or do they vary?
    • Do her characters fail to use contractions?
    • Do his characters expresses emotion through their dialogue effectively?
    • Is his characters’ dialogue consistent or inconsistent with the kind of person they’re supposed to be?

    If you spot any of these problems, suggest ways the author could fix them.

    Awkward dialogue or narrative will undermine a reader’s confidence in a writer perhaps faster than just about anything else. It’s immediately obvious. It’s also generally easy to fix, and as a reviewer, you’ll do your writer-friend a huge favor by helping them do so.

    What kinds of things stand out to you as awkward dialogue? Be sure to be clear about it when you put your thoughts in the Comments box below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 27— Narrative and Dialog

     

    Two men talking
    Image by photostock, courtesy FreeDigitalPhotos.net

    This post begins a series on narrative and dialog. Stated most simply, narrative and dialog are the tools writers use to tell their stories. They take different forms and serve complementary functions, but with plenty of overlap.

    Writers use narrative to:

    • Describe—to show—action (“Bob ran down the street after Alice’s car”) or emotion;
    • Describe a person (“Alice’s hair was dyed souvenir-shop-coral red”), a place, or a thing;
    • Make connections between people, places, actions, emotions, or things; and
    • Provide the reader with whatever other information she might need.

    It is the words not placed inside quotation marks or used for internal monolog (sometimes shown in italics).

    While it’s true that dialog can do many of these same things, and often does, narrative is the better choice in many cases. Consider how awkward it would be to have characters discussing the details of every setting in order to present that information to the reader:

    “Oh, look, Alice. This room has windows through which the sun is shining on a round oak table with two chairs set opposite each other.”

    “Yes, Bob, and the far wall is nothing but bookcases filled with leather-bound volumes and the occasional knick-knack.”

    Oy.

    On the other hand, while it’s possible to write a story that contains little or no dialog—I published one that had only internal monolog; none of the characters ever said a word to each other—it’s rare and unless done well, hard for readers to stay engaged with.

    One reason is that we engage in dialog every day: we talk to each other. Characters need to do that, too. Dialog:

    • Allows characters to interact with each other: to support each other, provide information or direction, deceive each other, etc.
    • Illustrates character. What a character says reveals what he knows, how she’s feeling, what he thinks about a situation, how she perceives another character, and so on.
    • Can build or relieve tension and conflict.
    • Lubricates the plot and the narrative and keeps them moving forward.

    In short, dialog is all but essential to a story.

    Much of what I wrote about in earlier Critique Technique articles dealt with problems in narrative. This next series will, too, because many problems in dialog appear in narrative, too, and vice versa. But there are also some problems that are unique to dialog, so this is where I’ll address them. Specifically, we’ll be looking at:

    • Awkward, choppy, and stiff or stilted writing;
    • Overused words, phrases, or text patterns;
    • Writing that is verbose or cryptic;
    • Inappropriate language, including but not limited to obscenities and vulgarities;
    • Unintentionally contradictory language and statements;
    • Imbalance between narrative and dialog;
    • Name-calling within dialog; and
    • Using dialog to blatantly convey information to the reader, including the “As you know, Bob” problem.

    I may add other items to the list as we go along, but this is where we’ll start. What other problems would you like me to discuss in this section? Add your suggestions in the Comments below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 26 — Tangents

    Lines tangent to circles and ellipses
    Image courtesy Wikimedia

    If you look up “tangent” in the dictionary, it takes a while to get to a definition like this one from Webster’s Universal College Dictionary: “digressing suddenly from one course of action or thought and turning to another.”

    Tangents share a characteristic with excessive backstory and flashbacks: they start from the current story moment and then shift in time, place, point of view, or topic. As with a flashback, the author may mean to provide some kind of amplifying information, but then he forgets to stop after providing it and wanders not only off the beaten path, but off any path at all.

    Sometimes that can be intentional, for example if she’s trying to produce a piece of stream-of-consciousness writing. The sneaky truth, though, is that while stream-of-consciousness writing seems to be unstructured and uncontrolled, when done well it’s actually very tightly controlled. A tangent, on the other hand, if unplanned is a sign the author has lost control of her work.

    Back in Part 20, I put in a long and rambling monologue as an example of too much setting detail, but it overflows with tangents, too. I stopped counting at a dozen of them and I know there were more.

    Now, in the right context, a long sentence like that one could be just fine, a clear if exhausting illustration of a manic and scatter-brained personality. Even without a larger context, it’s easy to see how each tangent in that example splits off from the previous line of thought, only to have another tangent split off from it.

    Problems with Tangents

    The main problem with tangents is that their material has little to do with the story at the moment the tangent departed. If one of the lines in the diagram at the top of this article represents the main storyline, then when one of the circles, representing a tangent, touches it, the story loops of in a completely unrelated direction as it follows the edge of that circle. With luck, the loop will finally return to the original line.

    If not, each additional divergence takes the reader farther away from the original storyline, until, as with excess backstory, he loses track of it entirely. The circles in the diagram above are all on different planes, which illustrates that separation.

    Tangents also disrupt a story’s flow. Even when the events of a story are chaotic, a tangent can swirl the reader off into a whirlpool of confusion. At best, it may take a forced and awkward transition to bring her back to the main storyline.

    A tangent can be a clear sign that the author doesn’t know what’s important in his story. As with backstory or flashback, he may be trying to force in information. Or the tangent can be a sign that he’s losing control of the story: he doesn’t know where it’s supposed to be going.

    Uses for Tangents

    Not all tangents are bad, however, at least so long as the author has firm control on them. As I noted above, one positive use for a tangent is to illustrate a character’s personality. Tangents like these need to be used with caution, however, because in addition to the problems I listed above, too many of them can exhaust the reader as she tries to keep track of or make sense of the character’s personality.

    A tangent can also be used to plant a false lead or a false clue. Done with care and intention, this can really catch the reader’s attention and keep him wondering how that clue is going to matter. That false clue can be used to distract or misdirect a character too. “Red herrings” are a key tool for mystery writers, and tangents can be used to slip them into a story.

    In every case, however, tangents like these need to be used with care. The author needs to know exactly what she’s doing in order to maintain control of the tangent and her story.

    As a reviewer, then, a key problem you can face, especially when reading something for the first time, is determining the author’s intent. You might have to get through the entire piece and then look back on it before you can decide.

    Questions for You

    To wrap up, then, here are some questions you can ask yourself when you come across material that seems like a tangent.

    • If the author uses tangents repeatedly, is this a stylistic choice that supports the story? Does the tangential material do that in a clear and definable way?
      • If not, how is it failing?
    • Is the author illustrating something about a character or a chaotic situation?
      • If so, does he do it just enough to make the point? In other words, is he using the tangent in a controlled and purposeful way?
      • If not, what about it is not working?
    • Does the tangent begin and end cleanly, with clear transitions into and out of it?
      • If not, what’s wrong with the transitions and how could the author fix them?
      • Did the transition come back to the main storyline soon enough that I didn’t forget what the main story was?
    • Could the author use the material in the tangent somewhere else?
      • If so, where and how, or does it just need to be deleted?

    How do you identify tangents and how do you help authors avoid them? I know you’ll stick to the point in your suggestions in the comments box below.