Tag: critique

  • Critique Technique, Part 47 — Danglers

    Shoes hanging from a wire
    Photo by dhannte, via morgueFile.com

    When we think about dangling things—in writing, anyway—we usually think of dangling modifiers, the grammatical fumbles that lead to sentences like, “After spending weeks in the forest, the town was inviting.” So, the town spent weeks in the forest, eh?

    For this article, though, I’m thinking about a different kind of dangler: a story line, event, action, or character the author lavishes some attention on, then forgets. It’s never developed, it’s never finished, it’s just left—you guessed it—dangling.

    This is a continuity problem and it can be hard to catch, for both the author and the reviewer. Why? The author had some reason for putting that character, event, action, subplot, or story line in or she wouldn’t have done it. But then any one of these things happened:

    • She got wrapped up in moving the other characters, plots, and subplots forward and forgot about it.
    • She failed to follow up or follow through on the consequences of that event or action.
    • She had no idea how to finish the plot line or bring the character back in, and so never did, hoping the idea would finally come to her.
    • She thought she had finished that work, but hadn’t.
    • She cut the scene that completed or resolved the plot line, event, action, or character involvement during her editing for other reasons and didn’t realize how that affected earlier scenes.
    • The character or plot line was one of her “darlings” and she couldn’t bear to cut it as she should have.

    Whatever the reason, there the plot, event, action, or character dangles, twisting in the wind.

    It can be hard for a reviewer to spot danglers because, as with padding, he may not have enough material at one time to realize that a particular event or action, story line, or character’s role was never concluded. The reviewer doesn’t have many good ways to overcome this incompletion problem. He needs (a) a really good memory for the details of the story, (b) to have gotten enough of the story in a short enough time to have the chance to catch the dangler, or (c) that stroke of good luck—which usually comes at an inopportune time—in which he suddenly realizes, “Hey, what about…?”

    Catching that Dang Dangler

    So if catching and fixing danglers falls back on the author, what might she do? Probably the best way to do it is to lay out the story in some form so everything is visible. She can do this any number of ways.

    • Timelines or character lines drawn out on sheets of paper or in some electronic format. A character line tracks a particular character and what he or she does or has to deal with. Each character in the story has their own line, and they run parallel to each other. One form of this technique literally shows a solid line when the character is present in a scene, a dashed line when they’re mentioned but not present, and no line when they’re absent.
    • Sticky notes or index cards that track each plot or character line, neatly spread out wherever there’s enough space: on a cork board, wall, or floor… until the cat or 2-year-old finds them. Playtime! Scrivener has a cork board feature but it’s not flexible in the ways you can place each simulated card. It’s possible to color-code each card, which helps some, but it’s still not as helpful as it could be.
    • Get creative with the tools in your productivity software (Microsoft Office, OpenOffice, Libre Office, Apple iWork, etc.). I use an Excel spreadsheet that shows, scene by scene, who does what. Each scene gets its own row and each major character their own column. Sometimes I’ll even give the secondary characters their own columns. This technique is better for tracking character appearances and disappearances but it could be modified to track plot lines. You can also use the table function word processors have but Word’s doesn’t work well for me.
    • Use some other kind of project planning software, if you happen to already have it and know how to use it. These packages can be expensive, though, and they have a lot of other tools that may not apply to story development, so I don’t recommend buying one just for this.

    Questions for You

    These tools are fine for the author, but what about you, the reviewer? Let’s assume that you (a) have reached the end of the work, (b) have the right turn of mind for remembering these kinds of details, (c) were really taken by a character or story line and have kept them or it in mind, or (d) have been taking notes on the work throughout your review. Then you can ask questions like these.

    • Was there a character or story line that seemed important at the time but was never developed, was underdeveloped, or just disappeared from the story without explanation?
    • Was there an event or action in the story that seemed like it was going to be significant but never was, and there was no clear reason why it wasn’t?
    • Could the author combine two (or more) characters—or even story lines—to get rid of a dangler?

    If you can answer “yes” to any of these questions, discuss your discovery with the author. Landing the dangler may be as simple as adding a scene, or even less, at a strategic spot. On the other hand, the author may discover she needs to add or rewrite a lot of material, even remove large portions of the work to solve the problem. That’s not happy news but it’s far better to discover it while the work is still in draft than to have a sharp-eyed reader point it out after it’s published because the author, reviewer(s), and editor(s) didn’t catch it.

    How do you catch danglers? Don’t leave us hanging! Drop on down to the comments box below to share your suggestions.

  • Critique Technique, Part 46 — Padding

    A filled packing box
    Photo by slideshowmom via freeimages.com

    There are times when padding is acceptable, even desirable. When preparing something fragile for shipping, for example. Or filling out a Santa Claus suit. But in writing? Not so much. Not today, anyway.

    Back in the day, that is before Ernest Hemingway, padding was acceptable, even expected. Check out anything written by Henry James, for example. Since writers were paid by the word, “Never say in ten words what can be said in fifty” must have been their motto. No, sorry, more like, “Never say in a mere, miserly ten words, my good man, I exhort you, from the bottom of my soul, not to mention the bottom of my inkwell, what could be said, I have not the slightest doubt, with the greatest of sincerity, depth, and yet extravagance, in not less than fifty words, or indeed more.” There. Fifty-six words in place of eleven.

    Today, especially for the new writer, brevity, to quote Shakespeare’s character Polonius, is the soul of wit. Write tight.

    Sure, sure, the later work of writers like Tom Clancy were padded—filled with material that didn’t contribute to the work—but Clancy’s publisher knew that he had a fan base that would buy anything he wrote (or put his name on), no matter how bloated it was.

    You’re not Tom Clancy. Neither am I.

    Packing on the Pounds Words

    So why and how does a work get padded, how can you as a reviewer recognize padding, and what can an author do to get rid of it?

    Broadly speaking, padding is any material that adds length to a work without adding meaning or depth. A writer can pad her work in a number of ways. One of the most common is with backstory, that background material that explains why and how the hero got into his predicament in the first place; why the antagonist is the way she is, starting back in her deprived childhood; the histories of the remote monastery they now find themselves trapped in and the ascetic monks who first built it, and so on and so on. The reader needs to know all that, right?

    Um, no. That’s padding. (Part 25 discusses backstory in more detail.)

    Another form of padding is excessive description. Beautiful, detailed description is the thing in literary fiction (next to psychological navel-gazing—but I digress) and it can be wonderful. Until it gets in the way of the story. Remember, the more of those details the author provides, the less chance the reader has to be the co-creator of the story, so the less engaged they’ll be. I discussed having too much setting detail in Part 20.

    Speaking of digressions, they’re great examples of padding too. Digressions can be anything from a parenthetical phrase to a full story line that has only tangential connection or relevance to the main plot. They can also spring from secondary or even more minor characters, when the writer spends excessive amounts of time on them. I discussed tangents, which is another term for digressions, in Part 26.

    Travelogues are extensive descriptions of a place, its history, culture, food, people, atmosphere, geography, etc., or just getting a character from Point A to Point B where nothing but the travel happens. When these things aren’t key to the story, they’re padding. James Michener could get away with that. You and I aren’t Michener either.

    Older writers, and people who have worked for government agencies or even private corporations, may have been taught to write in “bureaucratese.” This is a special language that favors verbosity over conciseness, and big words over smaller, clearer ones. For example, rather than writing “to,” these writers will write “in order to” or “for the purpose of.” (I discussed putting too many words into the text in Part 30 and again in Part 42.) This kind of padding doesn’t reach the Henry James level but it was designed to hide meaning rather than reveal it. A motto for today’s writers should be “eschew obfuscation”—I mean, write clearly!

    Diet Time

    So how, as a reviewer, do you decide whether material is padding or not? Aye, there’s the rub. Sometimes it’s clear: Is the writer spending so much time on certain material that you lose track of the main characters and/or plot? Is the text just flat wordy? Do you find yourself getting bored? These are all signs of padding, and they’re places you need to flag for revision.

    If you’re reading only part of a piece, especially a small part, padding can be harder to spot. What seems like a digression now may turn out to be critical later. The only way around this problem, other than asking the author, may be to read larger pieces of the work.

    To help your writer trim the fat, discuss with her why you think the material in question doesn’t contribute to the overall work and how she could improve it by taking out the excess. You both have the same goal: to produce the best possible work. Removing padding is one of the best ways to achieve that.

    Questions for You

    Here are some things you can ask yourself as you review a piece.

    • Has the author provided too much backstory?
      • If so, what is excess, why, and how can he trim it down?
    • Is she spending too much time describing settings, people, or other scene details, or just moving characters from place to place?
      • If so, what did she spend too many words on?
      • Why do you think that was excessive?
      • How can she tighten up her descriptions without losing anything important?
    • Does the work contain material that doesn’t seem relevant to the story?
      • If so, why is it irrelevant? Might there be something you don’t know yet that will make it relevant?
    • Is the writing simply too wordy? Is he using multi-word phrases where a single word would do?
    • Is he using two-bit words where shorter, simpler ones would be better?

    How do you spot padding? How do you help your writers remove it and make their stories better? Set a good example: keep your suggestions short and to the point in the comments box below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 44 — Pop Goes the Reader!

    A toy jack-in-the-box
    By United States Consumer Product Safety Commission [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons

    This article starts a series on general story-telling problems and how to identify and critique them.

    One of the worst things a writer can do is to write something that “pops the reader out of the story,” in other words, write something that so distracts or surprises them that they fall out of the “fictive dream,” the world of the story, and think, Wait… what?

    Pop Starts

    This can happen in many different ways.

    The author can use an unusual term. As I discussed in Part 17, “unusual” can mean several different things.

    • A foreign or slang word or phrase, a jargon term, or writing in dialect, especially if such words have not been part of the story before.
    • A made-up word or phrase. Science fiction and fantasy are notorious for this.
    • A word or phrase that is too high-brow or low-brow for the story. For example, a friend of mine used the word “mephitic” in a mainstream story to describe the odor of a men’s restroom in a hotel. When I hit that word, I was popped out of the story because I did not know what it meant.
    • Any other word or phrase that stops the reader.

    The key characteristic of these unusual terms is that they make the reader stop, even if for just a second. Foreign, slang, jargon, or made-up words are fine if they’re introduced early in the story, their meaning is clear, they’re appropriate to the story or its genre, or if the character who uses them has the right kind of personality to use them. But if the reader gets surprised, they’re a kind of verbal landmine that blows the reader out of the story.

    A sudden and unexplained or unexplainable change in a character’s behavior will also pop the reader out. Behavior changes are fine, even expected, when the story demands them. But when a character suddenly does something out of character, there’d better be a believable explanation coming soon or the reader is going to become confused and suspicious. (See Part 14 for more on this topic.)

    Same for an event that happens for no apparent reason. As soon as the reader wonders, What’s going on here? she’s left the story. New writers will sometimes throw in an event like this because they think they’re adding to the tension and drama of the story with a “plot twist.” They’re not, they’re just sowing confusion.

    Similarly, a too-convenient event can be a reader-ejector. Writers may pull a rabbit out of a hat at the end of a story in order to solve a plot problem or save the hero. As soon as the reader says to himself, Oh, come on now, he’s out of the story.

    Not Surprises

    So it would seem like I could summarize the things that will pop a reader out of the story as surprises. That’s not quite true. Readers love surprises. They love surprises that keep them wondering what’s going to happen next, how the hero or heroine is going to get out of this new predicament, or how this new wrinkle is going to play out. All of these surprises move the story forward.

    What readers don’t love are surprises that don’t make sense within the context of the story. So whether it’s a word or phrase, a character’s behavior, or an event, if it makes them stop to try to understand it, they’re popped out, and that’s what we don’t want.

    Questions for You

    As a reviewer, then, if you get popped out of a story, it’s important to identify what did it and suggest ways the author can fix the problem.

    • Did a word or phrase confuse you?
      • If so, what’s a better alternative? It could be a more common word or one that’s more appropriate to the speaker.
    • Did a character suddenly behave in an unexpected way, and for which an explanation never showed up, or was not believable when it did? Perhaps there’s some information missing that the author needs to provide.
    • Was a plot event confusing?
      • Was it placed in the wrong spot or need some things to happen before it to prepare the reader?
      • Was the reason for it, when it did arrive, not believable?
      • In either case, what can the writer do to fix the problem?
    • Was a plot event too convenient?
      • If it was, why was it?
      • How can the author come up with a better solution to the problem the characters are facing?

    The kinds of corrections discussed here could require significant changes or additions earlier in the story to lay the groundwork for that solution, when it comes, or a rewrite for a totally different solution or outcome. The author may not be happy to hear that news, but a temporarily unhappy writer is better than a disbelieving or distracted reader.

    What kinds of things pop you out of a story? When you find them, how do you help the author fix them? Pop on down to the comments box below to add your suggestions.

  • Critique Technique, Part 42 — Too Many Notes

    Violin bow over music score
    Image courtesy of Luigi Diamanti / FreeDigitalPhotos.net

    Perhaps you remember this exchange from the movie Amadeus:

    Emperor Joseph II: “My dear, young man, don’t take it too hard. Your work is ingenious. It’s quality work. And there are simply too many notes, that’s all. Just cut a few and it will be perfect.”

    Mozart: “Which few did you have in mind, Majesty?”[1]

    Wow. Talk about a perfect response to an ignorant critic—never mind that the critic happened to be an Emperor! I guess that would qualify as a 3-star review. (It’s worth noting that a few lines earlier, the orchestra’s conductor had set the Emperor up by feeding him that criticism. Talk about helping throw someone under the bus! But I digress….)

    The truth is, it is possible to have too much of a good thing. In writing, that “good thing” can be descriptive details. Last time I wrote about the expository lump (a.k.a. the data- or info-dump), in which a truckload of details is dumped on the reader all at once, simultaneously overwhelming him and killing the forward motion of the story.

    Another way to drown the reader in detail is to provide so much information about each person or object, each action a character takes, the factors contributing to a scene’s mood or atmosphere, etc., that the story becomes the needle in the haystack of details.

    It isn’t necessary to create mini-info-dumps to do this either. Writers can do it just by providing a single detail about everything in the scene. Let’s take an example:

    Louis ran his left hand through his wavy black hair while he perched on the right arm of the paisley-patterned sofa. Soft yellow light from the brass torchiere lamp warmed the rectangular library, casting an even glow across the six-high shelves filled with leather-bound books on his right and the wall against the long hall that led from the comfortable family room to the ornate bedrooms at the east end of the house.

    Selena oozed into the room. A string of black pearls, centered on one fully an inch across, glowed against her creamy skin, just enough of which was bared by the modest neckline of her black brocaded dress….

    Whew. That’s enough. Did you feel the piece bogging down?

    What’s the Problem?

    As I suggested earlier, physical descriptions are not the only place where this can happen. Any time the author has some degree of expertise in or passion about a topic that’s a part of the story, or has done a lot of research on it, this trap lays in wait. Every detail of every move a pair of combatants make, for example, whether they’re people in hand-to-hand combat, maneuvering fighter aircraft or spacecraft, armies, or ships at sea can do this. So can moves in any sort of game or sport, animal behaviors, how a structure is being or was constructed, any scientific or technical venture, preparing a meal or making a piece of clothing or work of art. The list of possibilities is pretty much infinite.

    In each case, the writer is denying the reader any role in the story. Remember, the reader is the writer’s partner in creating the story. The writer provides the framework on which the reader builds the image of the story in her mind. When a writer provides so much detail that there’s little or no room left for the reader to provide her own, she’s going to disengage from it.

    This is one of the crucial differences between a book and a movie, play, or TV show: in the visual media, the viewer plays little or no part in imagining the setting and the characters, whereas in a book, the reader is the co-creator.

    Now, how much detail constitutes “too much” varies by genre. A Victorian Romance wants more detail than a science fiction shoot-’em-up space opera. Each also wants different details. The key, as always, is to pick the right details—the evocative ones or the ones that provide information the reader must be told—while leaving him the space to fill in the rest.

    Questions for You

    So as a reviewer, how do you determine whether the author has written “too many notes?” Ask questions like these.

    • Is there so much description that the story bogs down?
    • Did I find myself losing track of the story, the plot, or even the characters because there were so many details?
    • Which details were the ones I had to be given, and which could I have supplied on my own?

    The answers to these questions will help you guide the author toward a stronger, cleaner, and tighter manuscript.

    How do you determine whether an author is providing too much detail throughout a story? Once again, don’t worry about how many details you provide when you add your suggestions in the comments box below.


    [1] From http://www.dailyscript.com/scripts/amadeus.html.

  • Critique Technique, Part 41 — The Dreaded Expository Lump

    Old car stuck in the mud
    photo credit: Toronto History via photopin cc

    Ah, the dreaded expository lump, that moldering mass of minutiae, that exhausting example of authorial excreta, that soggy swamp of supercilious sentences that sends the reader straight into the Slough of Despond. (Yeesh, enough with the purple prose, already!)

    You know what the expository lump is, of course: that paragraph or page—or worse yet, pages—in which the author stops the story to tell you everything he knows about a particular character, setting, situation, etc. His intent is good—there are things the reader needs to know—but not all of them, not right now. And not all at once.

    Unfortunately, this lump, also known as an info- or data-dump, isn’t the exclusive province of the novice writer. We all risk writing it. As we get better, perhaps our lumps and dumps are shorter and a little less obvious because we’re better at slipping in backstory and key details. But we can still slip into that swamp without meaning to.

    New writers make two mistakes. First, they haven’t learned to trust the reader to figure things out. Second, they haven’t learned that the reader is their partner in creating the story, filling in what the writer does leave out. As a result, the new writer takes it upon herself to describe and explain everything.

    Stuck in the Mud

    Driving a story into an expository lump is like driving a car into a deep puddle of thick, gooey mud. First there’s the sudden loss of momentum, then that sinking feeling as the mire swallows the story car. The drive wheels may still be throwing around lots of mud words and making a mess but the story’s going nowhere. When the writer driver takes his foot off the gas, even for a moment, the mud words flow back into the story tailpipe and the engine vapor locks and dies. The passenger reader is left stranded, wondering how she’s going to get out of the mud, never mind looking forward to dinner at Grandma’s.

    As a critiquer, you play the role of the friendly tow truck driver, come to pull the hapless writer motorist out of his self-made morass. Unfortunately, you’re going to have to wade down into that muck yourself to find where to place the hook so you can pull the story car out without ripping the bumper off.

    The first thing to do is assess the situation: What happened here? As I noted above, the author’s intentions were good. He wanted the reader to know important stuff! But alas, he misjudged what was important and what wasn’t, like misjudging the depth of the puddle.  Or maybe he didn’t know what was important.

    Sometimes pulling our hapless writer out of the fine mess he’s gotten himself into is easy. The puddle isn’t very deep and just pulling the car straight out—that is, deleting the lump altogether—is all that’s needed. At other times, though…

    Oh, no! The word mud was too deep and thick. The winch cable snapped! Everyone’s okay, but now what? It’s time for some serious mucking to shovel out all those mud words that are stalling the story.

    But here’s the thing: not all mud words are bad. The story needs some of them. The key is figuring out which ones need to stay, which need to be gotten rid of, and which need to be put in a bucket in the trunk to make mud pies with the grandkids later.

    Should It Stay or Should It Go?

    Deciding when the piece you’re reading is getting stuck in the mud is easy enough. But you may have to get to the other side of the puddle, if not all the way to Grandma’s house—that is, to the end of the scene, chapter, or piece—to be able to recommend what needs to be taken out for good, and what needs to be taken out for now.

    Even then, it may not be possible for you to decide or suggest what belongs in either of those categories. That ultimately is the author’s decision, but you can help her decide.

    The mud words that need to stay are the ones that give traction (in other words, color, life, and depth) to the story at that moment. Which are they? That’s a tough question. In part it depends on the nature of the story; some genres expect more description and backstory, and hence a slower pace, than others do.

    Another part of the answer depends on the needs of the story at that moment. For example, when introducing a character for the first time, it may be important to reveal not just some of his physical characteristics but some of his surface intentions, let’s say, or his perceptions of his surroundings.

    Take a look, as I noted in Part 20, at whether a particular fact or detail adds something important to the story. Just as a little bit of salt sprinkled into a dish (although probably not a mud pie) adds to or brings out the flavor, a small, revealing detail or two, sprinkled into the story at just the right moment adds to its piquancy.

    The rest of it? Well, there’s no rule that everything a writer knows about a character, location, situation, etc., has to be put in. Just the opposite, in fact. The reader needs to know some of that information—maybe a lot of it—but not all of it, and not all in one big lump.

    If the author starts arguing with you about whether a detail needs to be included, find out why she feels that way. That conversation can tell both of you a lot.

    Let’s sum up, then. The expository lump or info-dump has two main problems. First, it delivers too much information at one time, most of which doesn’t contribute to the needs of the story at that moment. Second, it slows the story’s momentum, even bringing it to a dead stop. As a critiquer, your job is to identify when that’s happened. Then you can recommend which details should stay and which might be sprinkled in later so they add to the story, and why they should stay or go. Be sure you fit your suggestions to the genre and style of the story. With your help, the author will turn story-strangling mud into a fine, rich loam from which the flower of the story will bloom.

    Questions For You

    Here are some questions you can ask when you find yourself slogging through the swamp of an expository lump.

    • Has the author stopped the flow of the story, or seriously slowed it down, just to explain something or provide background information?
    • Do I really need that information or explanation right now? Is it vital to the story? If not, why not?
    • Are there any parts of this information that are useful right now? If so, which are they?
    • Have I come across other places in the story where some of this information would fit better?
    • Has the story so far suggested that there are other places coming up where that information could be used?
    • What seems to be the author’s purpose or intention for providing all of this information now? Does he think he has to provide everything about this character, situation, etc., to the reader, rather than letting the reader create some of it herself?

    Discuss your findings with the author. Tightening up a piece by removing blobs of unneeded exposition is an easy way to significantly improve it.

    How do you tell when you’ve hit an expository lump? How do you help the author fix it? It’s OK to provide all the information you want in the comments box below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 40 — What Was That Again?

    Cartoon confused man

    Ever had one of those moments when you’re reading through a story or article and the author’s description of a place, event, or person makes you stop and say to yourself, “Wait, did I miss something?” Sure you have. We all have.

    It’s OK for an author to confuse a reader if he’s doing it intentionally and in a way that makes them want—no, need—to read more. But confusing descriptions that stop the reader and interrupt the flow of the story are another matter.

    When these kinds of problems show up, it’s a good bet the author either knew what she meant but didn’t realize it hadn’t come out that way on the page, or she didn’t know how to say what she was trying to express. As a reviewer, you’re likely to be the first person to pick these problems up, so it’s your job to identify them and help the author fix them.

    Confusing descriptions can come in at least these four forms:

    • Vague or insufficient detail;
    • Contradictory or inconsistent information;
    • Inappropriate or irrelevant information; or
    • Details the narrator or POV character shouldn’t know.

    Let’s look at each.

    Vague or Insufficient Detail

    I covered vague descriptions in Part 39. Insufficient detail is related. Here there’s simply not enough information for the reader to build a mental picture of the character, object, or setting of the current moment of the story at all. An easy example is when the writer doesn’t identify the time or place when a scene begins. Another might be when he places a scene in a hotel room but give no other sense of what kind of hotel it is: a Motel 6 or the Ritz Carlton. (This is called “white room syndrome.”) Or, to continue the image of the river valley from Part 39, it might be wide and shallow or narrow and deep, lush and verdant or barren and dry, but the author never tells the reader.

    If these details are important to the story, whether they’re setting mood, placing the piece, or revealing something about a character, and if there aren’t enough or clear enough details to do the job, they need to be added or fixed.

    Contradictory or Inconsistent

    Contradictory or inconsistent details can cause the reader to laugh when the author didn’t mean for her to. Contradictory details can be useful for revealing character—the muscular he-man who’s afraid of germs, for example—or to signal some kind of change, but if the contradiction shows up without a clear purpose, that’s a problem.

    What often happens is that one detail shows up in one place, and then the contradictory or inconsistent detail shows up some time, maybe even chapters, later. In my first novel, I had a character who in one chapter stood 5 feet 11 inches tall. Several chapters later, she was 6-foot-2, and no, she hadn’t put on heels. Oops! These kinds of physical description contradictions trip up a lot of writers, especially if they haven’t done a separate, detailed character study.

    These kinds of problems can also be hard for you as a reviewer to catch, especially if you’re reading a work a chapter at a time with weeks between chapters. There’s no easy fix for this. If you have the kind of mind that will retain those details, that helps, but even that’s not a guarantee. Copy editors often make lists of these kinds of details so they can check them, but even they can’t know in advance which details might get contradicted. It’s a lot to ask you to do the same thing, so catch them if you can.

    If the problem is a contradiction, and you catch it, make sure you discuss it with the author to determine whether it was intentional or not. If it was intentional, then he may need to make the purpose of the contradiction clearer.

    Inappropriate or Irrelevant

    Inappropriate or irrelevant details show up when the author isn’t clear in her own mind about what she’s trying to describe or what she means to do with these details. In this case, she may throw lots of things at the wall to see what sticks, or have no idea that what she’s doing isn’t working.

    For example, I once read part of a first draft of a memoir by a member of my writers’ group. She spent several pages describing things she and a friend had done. Her intent was to illustrate aspects of this important character’s personality, but the collection of vignettes was a tangent at that moment in the story, and that much of that kind of detail was out of place. It wasn’t entirely irrelevant but it certainly was inappropriate.

    The good news is that these kinds of details do a great imitation of a sore thumb. As soon as you find yourself asking the author, “Why are you telling me this?” you’ve found something you need to flag. Be sure, though, that you also explain why the details in question aren’t appropriate or relevant and, if possible, suggest where he might use them instead.

    Details the Narrator or POV Character Shouldn’t Know

    Details the narrator or POV character can’t or shouldn’t know can be very tricky. Let’s say the work you’re reading is a murder mystery and a character (who you’ll learn later is the killer) comes into a detective’s office, looking to hire her to “solve” the case by framing someone else for the crime. Let’s say the detective is also the narrator and reports noticing that the potential client had a hole in the sole of his left shoe. So far, so good, except the author never showed you that the client stood, sat, or walked so the detective would have seen that sole! Even if that’s the sole problem with the scene (ahem), it does put a hole in the author’s credibility.

    Like some of the other problems I discussed above, these details are likely to show up when the author hasn’t thought through the scene well enough, or hasn’t realized what he’s done. After all, he knows what he intended!

    Questions For You

    Let’s sum up, then, with a few questions to keep in mind as you’re reading.

    • Do I have enough information here to give me a clear mental image of the person, place, mood, or thing I’m supposed to be sensing? (Remember, sensory details aren’t just visual but can engage several senses.)
    • Do any of the details contradict each other in ways that confuse me rather than revealing something important?
    • Are any of the details here inconsistent with what I was told earlier in ways that are not meant to reveal a change or some new aspect of the character, location, or situation?
    • Do the details I’m seeing here distract me from the main story?
    • Do I wonder why I’m being given this information now?
    • Is the narrator or POV character revealing something he shouldn’t or can’t know at this moment in the story?

    If the answer to any of these questions is yes, identify the nature of the problem and how the author can fix it. Next time around, the writing should be much better.

    Have I given you enough of the right kinds of details about details to help you help other authors? If not, go ahead and add what I left out, or clarify what I wrote, in the comments box below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 39 — The Gray Haze

    Fog over a village

    Painters have a lot of different tools at their disposal to create an image: oils, watercolors, acrylics, computer graphics. Photographers have light, composition, angle, framing, the capabilities of their camera and film or electronics, and of course Photoshop® and its cousins. Sculptors have stone, wood, found objects, metal, even sand.

    We writers have words—hundreds of thousands of them in the English language alone—so there should never be a problem with creating a clear image, right?

    Alas, we know that’s not true. It’s not how many or how few tools we have at our disposal, it’s how we use them that matters. The next five articles are going to deal with how writers use words poorly to describe what they want the reader to see, hear, feel (emotionally and physically), smell, taste, sense psychologically, and so on, and how critiquers can help them do it better.

    What Matters

    When we talk about vague or inadequate descriptions, there’s a tendency to ask how much description is the right amount. That’s the wrong question, for at least a couple of reasons. First, every genre has its own standards. Literary fiction often spends a great deal of time and effort on description in order to place the reader fully in the physical and/or psychological setting of the story. So can other genres, but still others spend far less. And quantity is not the most important factor anyway.

    For another thing, the descriptive needs of a work—fiction or non-fiction—change from moment to moment. For example, let’s say the characters in a story take several drives through a river valley. It might be appropriate in one scene to spend a lot of time describing the valley but say almost nothing about the car or its passengers. In another scene, the car may be more important than the valley and so should get more attention.

    In a third scene, it may be the experience of the road and drive itself—whether the road is straight or curved, flat or hilly, the drive is leisurely or panicked, and so on—and how that is presented to the reader.

    In a fourth scene, the experience of that and previous drives might matter most, so the factual details may be less important than the peoples’ memories of the drives and their responses to them.

    Lack of Focus

    One of the causes of inadequate or vague description is the author not knowing what she wants the reader to focus on or why. When this happens, the author’s mental senses will skim so lightly across the sensory field that she picks up little or nothing and as a result, describes little or nothing. Let’s say the characters of the example are driving through a valley on a hazy day. The lack of description can reveal a number of things.

    • The people in the car can see the fields and trees and river around them but the author doesn’t know if the sights and the haze have any meaning or import.
    • Maybe the passengers can hear the engine, the air rushing around the car, or the tires rolling over the pavement, maybe they can’t, or maybe those sounds don’t matter.
    • The author doesn’t know if there are any scents coming off the fields, the forest, or the river, or if they matter.
    • The road must be straight, smooth, and flat because there’s no sensation of movement, and so on.

    The result is that the scene is bland at best and maybe even unnecessary.

    Another cause of poor description is the author knowing he needs to describe things, but not knowing how. This can show up as anything from excessive description to none at all, or descriptions of things that don’t matter. Perhaps the most common error here is simply using bland, generic, or uninformative terms. In a work I once reviewed, the author described a character’s voice as “upper-tier baritone.” OK, baritone I understood but what did “upper-tier” mean? As it turned out, this adjective was unnecessary because he showed what he meant through the way the character spoke.

    Clear the Haze

    So how can you help a writer clear away the gray haze and give the reader a meaningful sensory experience? The first step is to know the general conventions of the genre, even the sub-genre, of the piece you’re reviewing.

    The second is to determine, if possible, whether the author intended to work within those conventions or outside of them. With this background information in place, you can get to the words themselves.

    The next step is to determine what’s necessary and appropriate to the story. The writer doesn’t want or need to engage all of the reader’s senses in every scene, but certain ones, especially beyond sight and sound, will draw the reader in. Identify those. Don’t forget, this includes things like mood too, which can be created by what is described in physical terms. Edgar Allan Poe was a master of this. Tell the writer which senses you believe should be engaged, or engaged better, why, and how the story or scene would be stronger if she did so.

    Now determine which objects, sensations, impressions, etc., need to be described in special detail. In one story, a glass on a windowsill may be a minor object; in another it could be key. The first glass needs little more than a mention; for the second one, whether it’s clean or dirty, full, half-full, or empty, what’s in it, how it looks in the light, etc., may matter for many different reasons. As a reviewer, you can help the author home in on those characteristics.

    The last key is to pick the most evocative descriptive terms. Remember how Mark Twain described the difference between the right word and the almost-right word as the difference between the lightning and the lightning bug? You’re looking for the right word or phrase, the one that reveals something important, that puts the reader inside the scene with the characters, rather than watching it from the outside. The right word or phrase sharpens the image; the vague and generic word or phrase dims or diminishes it.

    Questions For You

    Let’s consolidate what I’ve discussed so far into a few questions you can ask as you review a piece.

    • What are this genre’s or sub-genre’s conventions regarding the amount and kind of description writers should use?
    • Does the author intend to work within them, is she intentionally avoiding them, or does it seem that she may not know what they are?
      • If she’s avoiding them, what’s her intent for doing so? What is she trying to achieve?
      • If she does not appear to know what they are, this is something you can discuss.
    • Is the author giving you the kind and amount of description that draws you into the scene, or is his work suffering from “white room syndrome,” where there’s little or no description?
      • If there’s too little, or it’s too vague, what specifically can he add or change to bring the scene to life, as much as it needs to be? How can he capture the lightning rather than just the lightning bug?
      • Are the needed details physical, sensory, psychological, or emotional?

    Unintended vague description is a writer’s bane. It’s a particular problem for the new writer, but not just for them. Early drafts can often lack this kind of detail. As a reviewer, you can help the author pick out what needs to be described, come up with the best words to clear away the haze, and make her story sparkle.

    How have you helped writers overcome vague descriptions? Keep your answers clear and sharp in the comments box below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 38 — Pace: Speed It Up, Whoa It Up, or Change It Up

    Racing horses
    photo credit: dawvon via photopin cc

    In the last article, I identified the general questions critiquers want to ask about scene and story pace—does it vary, is it appropriate, and if not, what needs to change—and eight factors that affect pace: sentence and paragraph length, active or passive voice, dialogue versus narrative, tone, language, description, complexity, and what’s happening.

    Now let’s apply the factors to the questions.

    Does the Pace Vary?

    As I noted last time, even the shortest piece may have a varying pace but once you get beyond the flash-fiction story or filler article, the pace has to change. Readers need changes of pace to keep their interest. If the pace doesn’t change, either nothing’s happening or the author doesn’t know how to present the changes that are happening.

    Changing pace is one way the author tells the reader something different is happening in the story, something is changing. For example:

    • A scene of frenetic action, written in short, simple, highly active, and dialogue-free sentences wraps up. It is followed by a scene of quiet conversation that uses tone, language, and longer sentences to slow the pace down while maintaining a degree of tension.
    • A languid description of an apparently idyllic river valley (long narrative sentences, quiet tone, lots of descriptive details) suddenly shifts when a spaceship screams down to a landing and disgorges a company of storm troopers (short sentences, active language, dialogue among the troopers, different and fewer descriptive details).

    Is the Pace Appropriate to This Moment in the Story?

    Musicians sometimes mix music in a minor key, which usually indicates a sad emotion, with an up-beat tempo, creating a cognitive dissonance. Some of the best examples from classic rock are Santana’s “Black Magic Woman” and the Beatles’ “Eleanor Rigby,” but there are many others. It’s possible, although rarely easy, to do something similar in writing: write a fast-paced scene for a situation that would normally require a slow pace, or vice versa. In a situation like this, there needs to be a clear reason for doing it. That cognitive dissonance has to serve a purpose.

    While a skilled writer may be able to do that, more likely you’ll find a dragging scene that would be better at a faster pace, or one that goes too fast and needs to be slowed down.

    When a scene drags, it’s a good bet the author is providing too much information, has selected an inappropriate tone or style, or has let the scene go on longer than necessary to achieve its goals.

    On the other hand, if a scene goes by too fast, the author probably hasn’t developed the elements of the scene enough: it skips from one incident to the next without taking any time for character reaction, setting or plot development, etc.

    Is the Pace Appropriate for the Entire Piece?

    Whether the pace of an entire piece is appropriate can be much harder to answer, particularly if the work is book length, because you may not see the entire piece at once. The more time that passes between chapter reviews, the harder it will be to make a judgment.

    If you can see the entire story, you need to have a sense of what the author was trying to convey. Pace and tone will be closely connected here.

    The author’s going to have a lot of work to do if a long piece’s pace isn’t appropriate for its topic or message. If this happens, be sure to give him or her that feedback: it may be essential for the work to succeed.

    What Needs to Change, and How?

    What needs to change and how will be much easier to deal with at the scene level. Here are questions you can ask yourself as you review a piece.

    • If sentences and/or paragraphs are too long, how can the author shorten them to pick up the pace? If they’re too short, what can she do to slow things down? Would simply changing the mix of long and short sentences or paragraphs be enough?
    • If sentences are written by the author in the passive voice (as this clause is), how could he convert them to active voice (like that)? There will be very few situations where you’ll want him to convert an active sentence to passive voice. An example might be a brief bit of bureaucratic writing to show an organization blocking the protagonist.
    • Is the author using narrative to describe what a character is feeling, rather than having her show her feelings by saying or doing something? Conversely, is she having a character explain something where a one-sentence summary in narrative would be more effective? Offer suggestions about what would work better, and why.
    • Are the characters using language that’s appropriate to their personalities and to the situation they find themselves in? Is the language the author uses in the narrative appropriate for the situation? If not, suggest more apt words.
    • Tone is more likely to be not quite right than completely wrong. So, would a slight change in tone change the scene’s pace enough to fit better? Talk with the author to get a sense of what she intended before you make your recommendations.
    • Every descriptive detail should matter to the story. Do they, or are they bogging the story down? If the latter, suggest what the author could cut and explain why.
    • Conversely, is the reader having trouble creating an image of the scene and setting because there’s too little description, or it’s unhelpful? If so, ask the author to describe the setting to you out loud so he can capture the important details.
    • Is the author presenting so much information—not just setting or other details, but linguistic asides, secondary plot lines or activities, unnecessary characters and conversations, etc.—that the pace grinds to a halt? Then, as with descriptive details, suggest what could be moved or deleted to refocus the scene on its central elements.
    • Are a scene’s events essential to its goal and purpose? Show the author how she can remove unnecessary events to move the scene along. On the other hand, if the scene is too sketchy, show her how she could expand the scene to both slow it down and deepen it.

    As you’ve seen, pace is a complex thing to evaluate and critique, with many subtle and interrelated parts. How do you help an author adjust the pacing of his or her work to make it more effective? Quick! Add your suggestions in the comments box below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 36 — “As You Know, Bob…”

    Two people talking
    Photo by Ambro, courtesy FreeDigitalPhotos.net

    Whenever characters speak, they’re transmitting information, to one or more other characters and/or to the reader. That information can be truth, lies, or something in-between; it can be emotional (a state of being or feeling) rather than factual; it can be directive (an order or warning) or informational; it can be direct or indirect; it can be any combination of these. This is nowhere near a complete list.

    It can also be boring as hell.

    What happens is that sometimes, with the best of intentions (or maybe just not knowing any better), an author will use a character to dump information on the reader, rather than doing it himself through narrative. No matter how it’s done, info-dumping isn’t a good technique.

    This problem usually happens in one of two ways:

    • Characters make speeches or give lectures;
    • Characters tell each other things they already know, which is called the “as you know, Bob” problem.

    Speech-Making

    Now, to be clear, sometimes a character making a speech is fine. In one of my books, that happens three times. To make sure I didn’t put the reader to sleep, I broke up each speech repeatedly with one or more of these techniques:

    • Interruptions by a disruptive audience member, or simply audience reaction;
    • Weather or some other kind of external event interrupting the speaker; or
    • The behavior of the speaker, including meaningful gestures or movement around the location.

    In each case, I took what could have been long blocks of sleep-inducing monologue and turned them into active, action- and tension-filled events.

    “As you know, Bob…”

    Sometimes, too, it’s just fine for one character to remind another of some detail:

    Alice: “Wait, didn’t Jackson have a history of going off his meds?”

    Bob: “Right! How could I have forgotten that?”

    Boom! Done!

    But what if the conversation had started this way?

    Alice: “As you know, Bob, our files contain a series of cases, from January 1982, October 1994, August 2000, and March 2004, in which Jackson went off his medications, particularly his Prozac, properly known as fluoxetine, for extended periods of time. As you further know, failure to maintain a prescribed regiment of Prozac at an appropriate dosage can result in a wide range of adverse events, including….”

    Bob (and the reader): “Zzzzzzz.”

    The good news, at least for you as a reviewer, is that both of these problems are easy to spot. When it comes to speeches, you’ll find long, uninterrupted blocks of monologue. I’ve seen them go on for pages. Ugh. Even if the speaker is telling a story, this isn’t the best way to do it because the story is being told second-hand. That creates an emotional distance that blunts the story’s impact.

    “As you know, Bob” incidents will often involve just that phrase (unless the character’s name isn’t Bob, of course), or one much like it: “Let me tell you, Bob, in infinite and excruciating detail everything there is to know about this situation” (or piece of equipment, or whatever). That’s a nice big red flag for you.

    Helping the author fix the problem may not be quite so straight-forward but is still very doable. You can:

    • Ask him whether the information is really necessary right now. His first reaction is likely to be that it is, which should then lead to the discussion of how much the reader truly needs to know at that moment. The answer, 999 times out of 1,000, is a lot less. You can then discuss how he can spread out the key details and drop them into the story at the points where they’ll have the most impact.
    • Discuss with her other ways to present the information.
      • In the case of the character telling a story, for example, she could shift into a flashback, so the story becomes the immediate scene.
      • In the case of Jackson going off his meds, Alice and Bob could quickly call up his data file and refresh their memories with actions and snappy back-and-forth conversation about how Jackson did something worse each time.

    Note that in both of these examples, a key element of the fix is to get all of the characters in the scene active. When monologue turns into dialogue, when characters’ statements are interrupted by their revealing, contradictory, or reinforcing actions, or when the speaker’s words have an effect on his listeners, and vice versa—in other words, when the characters themselves are engaged in the story—the pace and tension will pick up and the reader will be engaged too.

    When a character makes a speech or one character tells another something she already knows, it’s a good bet the author means well but just isn’t clear on the best way to present that information. You have a great chance to help make the story—and the writer—significantly better.

    Questions For You

    Here are some questions you can ask yourself when you run across situations like these.

    • If a character is making a speech.
      • Are they doing it where making a speech, giving a sermon or lecture, etc., is natural?
        • If so, suggest how the author could break it up with actions, audience reactions, external events, etc.
        • Consider whether the speech is really necessary, or if the effect the author is trying to achieve could be accomplished in other ways. If it could, suggest them.
      • Are they doing it where it’s not natural?
        • Explain why speechifying is ineffective in that situation and suggest other ways the author could achieve the effect she wants, or why the speech might not be necessary at all.
    • If a character gives an “as you know, Bob” info-dump.
      • How much of that information does the reader really need to know at that point in the story?
      • How else might Bob and that character deliver the information that is needed, and where?
      • Suggest to the author how he could pare the information down to just what’s needed, what he could do with the rest of it, and how he and his characters could keep the story moving forward.

    As you know, Dear Reader, any kind of verbal info-dump, delivered by a character, runs a real risk of killing the pace of a story and causing the reader to skip ahead, or worse, stop reading. Have you seen these kinds of problems in other writers’ work? How did you help them overcome them? Go ahead: say as much as you need to in the comments box below.

  • Critique Technique, Part 1A — The Critiquer’s Mind

    Before we get to the specific tasks and techniques this series will cover, I want to talk about something that is central to your success as a reviewer: your mind. To an extent, this means your memory, but it also has to do with your attitude about and approach to critiquing, and your level of commitment to the task.

    Memory

    Pages of book shaped like a heart
    Image courtesy of Gualberto107 / FreeDigitalPhotos.net

    It’s important that you have a good but specialized memory. You can’t let the words just flow in one eye and out the other, the way someone who’s reading for pleasure can. The words have to stop and make your acquaintance. Or, to put the focus in the right place, you have to make theirs.

    It’s very helpful if you can recall specific kinds of details—about what a character did or said before, for example, or how the author described something—even if it’s been weeks or months since you last read a part of a work.

    That’s not a skill everyone has. I believe some, perhaps most, who don’t can develop it, but it takes conscious attention to the requirement on your part, a determination to learn the skill.

    If you’re a member of a critique group, you’re potentially in an ideal place to learn how to do this. I say “potentially” because not all groups are created equal. For your group to be the right kind of learning environment, there needs to be at least one person who already has the working memory to track the kinds of details this whole series is about, and has the ability to communicate clearly and effectively what they find, so you can learn from them.

    Improving your memory for these details is an active process on your part! First, you have to read a work as closely as you can, actively trying to spot the good and bad in it yourself, then actively listen to the other reviewers, and then actively reread the piece, looking for what they found.

    If you don’t currently possess this kind of memory, it can be tempting to sit back and let the other person do all the work. This is a mistake. It’s also—to be blunt—lazy.

    The better you learn how to critique someone else’s work, the better you’ll be able to evaluate and edit your own. And that means, when it’s time for the group to review your work, they’ll have a better work to review.

    Learning how to do this really isn’t any different from learning to read a text for its symbolism, theme, or deeper meaning—those things your high school English teacher tried to get you to write about in your term papers.

    OK, maybe that’s a bad memory. Sorry! J (But you remembered it! That’s a start.)

    And remember, this time, more than a mere letter grade is at stake.

    The more you practice this skill, the better your powers of observation and your memory for these kinds of details will become. But trust me, you’re not going to get it by osmosis. If it’s not already a part of your skill set or you don’t have that turn of mind, it’s going to take effort on your part to achieve.

    Attitude

    Woman reading a book
    Image courtesy of Marin / FreeDigitalPhotos.net

    “Attitude” means a lot of things in this context. One meaning is having the willingness to learn new skills, like the ability to remember details within and across chapters. Another is how you treat the other writers in your group: how you respect their efforts, no matter their current level of skill; how you present your critique to them, especially regarding the parts that need improving; etc.

    Those are important but I want to address two different aspects of attitude. The first is your view about how much critique you provide and when. In my own group, I have a member who will not thoroughly review a writer’s early drafts. Her rationale is that the writer will be making changes anyway, so a detailed critique isn’t necessary.

    This view assumes the author already knows how to edit their own work, an assumption I have seen proven wrong time after time. Think about it: if they already knew, wouldn’t they have submitted a better work to the group?

    In a situation like this, the critiquer’s role is especially important because they are—or should be—providing insights and suggestions to the author that he or she would not have had otherwise. The reviewer is teaching the writer how to write and edit.

    The second attitude is “paying it forward”: giving first in order to receive later. In a moment I’ll discuss how critiquing others’ work will improve your own but here I want to emphasize how much you have to give. No matter how experienced you are—or aren’t—by doing the best you can to honestly and fairly critique a work, to try to help your fellow writer do better, you establish a relationship of trust and respect that will encourage them to do the same for you.

    Commitment

    Woman with too much to do
    Image courtesy of Gualberto107 / FreeDigitalPhotos.net

    The last thing I want to discuss is the critiquer’s level of commitment. Being an effective, helpful reviewer means reading a piece much more carefully than an ordinary reader does. The fact that this series has nearly 60 articles on specific things to look for illustrates how much there is to do.

    Reading a piece once and then telling the author, “Well, I liked it…,” isn’t effective or useful critique. Neither is reading the piece once and telling the author, “Well, it sucks.” Both fail because they neither tell the author why you liked or hated the piece nor how it could be made better.

    It’s also important to understand that you’re no longer reading for entertainment. That means it doesn’t matter whether you like a piece or not.

    Surprised? It’s true. The purpose of critique, and your role in a critique group, is to look at a piece and identify what worked, what didn’t, and why. If you happened to enjoy the piece, that’s a bonus. It’s also possible to dislike a piece but still see that it was well-written, and what made it so.

    When I critique a piece, I read it twice. The first time I simply read it through without writing anything on the manuscript, just to get a sense of the story and its flow. After I’m done, I write about my overall impressions.

    The second time is when I get down to the nitty-gritty, looking for the good and the not-so-good in everything from spelling and punctuation to plot, characterization, flow, pace, dialogue, and so on.

    Make no mistake: this takes time. Sometimes it takes a lot of time.

    But I treat this work as part of my job of continuing to learn my writer’s craft. Whenever I suggest a way to improve someone else’s work, I’m teaching myself how to find and fix the same kind of problem in my own. To me, this is time invested, not time wasted or lost. It’s part of my commitment to my craft.

    In conclusion, then, a carefully tuned and focused memory, specific attitudes about critiquing, and a commitment to the task are key elements of the mind of an effective and valuable critiquer. A thorough critique benefits both the author and the person giving the critique. Do it well and you’ll be a better writer for it.

    What qualities do you think a person needs to be an effective critiquer? You can add your thoughts and suggestions in the comments box below.